EPTGood commentators - Page 7
| Forum Index > BW General |
|
Hapahauli
United States9305 Posts
| ||
|
-StrifeX-
United States529 Posts
Artosis, Day[9], Tasteless. Chill is decent one to watch since he deals with forums and like B- i think, Don't think he's as active as he was in the past though unless he is sneaking games  . IMO anyone below B- or not close to it can be leading you towards incorrect information if your looking towards trying improve and focus on the wrong areas. | ||
|
Ideas
United States8173 Posts
But really IMO english commentary in general is pretty overrated. I just sorta prefer korean just because it can be really funny sometimes. I don't like most english commentary because I feel like I'm just being told what I already know most of the time or something slightly wrong. | ||
|
NukeTheStars
United States277 Posts
My approach to english commentary has always been just a way to watch a game with someone else. It's ok to watch a sport on TV by yourself, but it's a lot more fun to hear someone else talking with you about the game, even if you can't respond. Since pro Starcraft is such a niche kind of entertainment, it's hard to get 2 people in the same room who like it. I think that's where English commentary really shines, especially with dual or triple commentaries. It feels like you're experiencing the game with other guys. | ||
|
SwEEt[TearS]
Canada1575 Posts
I still like Husky, Artosis, Day[9] and Chill but I'd say maybe 5% of the SC I watch is commentated t_t | ||
|
FoBuLouS
United States570 Posts
ex. AND THE REAVER TAKES OUT 13 DRONES! vs. REAVERRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR!~~~~~~ WAHHHHHHHHHHHH | ||
|
Cube
Canada777 Posts
... i was told i had a sexy voice once... | ||
|
Ignorant prodigy
United States385 Posts
On October 07 2009 14:02 FoBuLouS wrote: This makes me wonder, are there any english commentators that commentate in the style of korean commentators? i.e not as much analyzing but like excited retelling of what's happening at the moment. ex. AND THE REAVER TAKES OUT 13 DRONES! vs. REAVERRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR!~~~~~~ WAHHHHHHHHHHHH it's like watching other countries do soccer... 'gooooaaaaaaalllllll' I like Husky because he's comical and he somtimes he puts himself inside the unit's point of view. That's just entertaining. | ||
|
Gretorp
United States586 Posts
| ||
|
Chanted
Norway1001 Posts
On that note, does anyone know commentators who do foreigner games on a regular basis (english) ? | ||
|
qrs
United States3637 Posts
Among the YouTube commentators, Cholera is the only one I can stand: the rest don't seem to know very much about the game. Commentary aside, NukeTheStars does some pretty cool stuff with music and hype videos and that sort of thing. In terms of teams, I actually liked Artosis + Gentho better than any other team I've heard. Gentho's knowledge of the game was all right (Artosis's was better, of course), and their casting really flowed when they were together. | ||
|
Holgerius
Sweden16951 Posts
On October 07 2009 14:02 FoBuLouS wrote: This makes me wonder, are there any english commentators that commentate in the style of korean commentators? i.e not as much analyzing but like excited retelling of what's happening at the moment. ex. AND THE REAVER TAKES OUT 13 DRONES! vs. REAVERRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR!~~~~~~ WAHHHHHHHHHHHH Dude, watch a VOD with subtitles and you'll see that Korean commentators do provide a great deal of analyzing. There's a good one between Iris and Jaedong on Python, go check it out. | ||
|
GoAudio
Sweden400 Posts
| ||
|
rockon1215
United States612 Posts
| ||
|
dekuschrub
United States2069 Posts
I watch everything those guys commentate. So entertaining and insightful i do enjoy the occasional Cholera commentary though, but its rare he does a game that I haven't seen anyway. I also got really tired of tasteless, and I always disliked moletrap to a maximum | ||
|
Husky
United States3362 Posts
On October 07 2009 14:02 FoBuLouS wrote: This makes me wonder, are there any english commentators that commentate in the style of korean commentators? i.e not as much analyzing but like excited retelling of what's happening at the moment. ex. AND THE REAVER TAKES OUT 13 DRONES! vs. REAVERRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR!~~~~~~ WAHHHHHHHHHHHH hahahaha, I try to do this sometimes. Thats just kind of how my personality is i suppose (yelling and screaming ftw?) A couple important things to keep in mind about this: 1) Most commentators go solo. Yes, there are a lot of dual/triple commentaries out there, but I would say a majority of them are individual. Its kind of hard to just yell AHHHHH PLAGUUUUUUUU PLAGUUUUUU PSIONIC STORMUHHHHHHHHH when you're by yourself as theres no actual content to the commentaries. 2) English is not a language that flows really well with that kind of commentating. I mean look at English sports commentaries vs Spanish ones, when we yell GOAAAAAAAAAALLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL it just doesnt work as well. I think English is a better language for saying multiple things in a stoked tone of voice instead of just one. 3) A lot of people are shy  Thats just from my experience though and I am slowly trying to work stuff like that into my videos. Dunno if it works with English though... Edit: Reduced the 'though' count... | ||
|
FusionCutter
Canada974 Posts
Klaz and Day[9] imo. | ||
|
himurakenshin
Canada1845 Posts
| ||
|
FoBuLouS
United States570 Posts
On October 08 2009 06:59 Holgerius wrote: Dude, watch a VOD with subtitles and you'll see that Korean commentators do provide a great deal of analyzing. There's a good one between Iris and Jaedong on Python, go check it out. Ok, maybe a balance then . I feel Cholera is close to getting to that point, but as Husky did say, Korean commentators do have 3 people cycling to talk so theres like always stuff to say. Now if only there were English versions of MBC commentators D: | ||
|
Tom Phoenix
1114 Posts
| ||
| ||
