• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EDT 18:55
CEST 00:55
KST 07:55
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
[ASL20] Ro24 Preview Pt1: Runway132v2 & SC: Evo Complete: Weekend Double Feature3Team Liquid Map Contest #21 - Presented by Monster Energy9uThermal's 2v2 Tour: $15,000 Main Event18Serral wins EWC 202549
Community News
Maestros of The Game—$20k event w/ live finals in Paris18Weekly Cups (Aug 11-17): MaxPax triples again!13Weekly Cups (Aug 4-10): MaxPax wins a triple6SC2's Safe House 2 - October 18 & 195Weekly Cups (Jul 28-Aug 3): herO doubles up6
StarCraft 2
General
What mix of new and old maps do you want in the next 1v1 ladder pool? (SC2) : Geoff 'iNcontroL' Robinson has passed away The GOAT ranking of GOAT rankings RSL Revival patreon money discussion thread Weekly Cups (Aug 11-17): MaxPax triples again!
Tourneys
Maestros of The Game—$20k event w/ live finals in Paris Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament Monday Nights Weeklies Master Swan Open (Global Bronze-Master 2) $5,100+ SEL Season 2 Championship (SC: Evo)
Strategy
Custom Maps
External Content
Mutation # 487 Think Fast Mutation # 486 Watch the Skies Mutation # 485 Death from Below Mutation # 484 Magnetic Pull
Brood War
General
Flash Announces (and Retracts) Hiatus From ASL BW General Discussion BW AKA finder tool Maps with Neutral Command Centers Victoria gamers
Tourneys
[ASL20] Ro24 Group C [Megathread] Daily Proleagues [ASL20] Ro24 Group A [ASL20] Ro24 Group B
Strategy
Simple Questions, Simple Answers Fighting Spirit mining rates [G] Mineral Boosting Muta micro map competition
Other Games
General Games
General RTS Discussion Thread Dawn of War IV Path of Exile Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Nintendo Switch Thread
Dota 2
Official 'what is Dota anymore' discussion
League of Legends
Heroes of the Storm
Simple Questions, Simple Answers Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Heroes of StarCraft mini-set
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread Vanilla Mini Mafia
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine The year 2050 European Politico-economics QA Mega-thread
Fan Clubs
INnoVation Fan Club SKT1 Classic Fan Club!
Media & Entertainment
Anime Discussion Thread Movie Discussion! [Manga] One Piece [\m/] Heavy Metal Thread
Sports
2024 - 2026 Football Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023 Formula 1 Discussion
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
High temperatures on bridge(s) Gtx660 graphics card replacement Installation of Windows 10 suck at "just a moment"
TL Community
The Automated Ban List TeamLiquid Team Shirt On Sale
Blogs
Breaking the Meta: Non-Stand…
TrAiDoS
INDEPENDIENTE LA CTM
XenOsky
[Girl blog} My fema…
artosisisthebest
Sharpening the Filtration…
frozenclaw
ASL S20 English Commentary…
namkraft
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 3730 users

Philosophical Thoughts On Beliefs - Page 3

Blogs > Eywa-
Post a Reply
Prev 1 2 3 4 Next All
IgnE
Profile Joined November 2010
United States7681 Posts
Last Edited: 2012-02-01 12:46:24
February 01 2012 12:37 GMT
#41
On February 01 2012 21:25 deathly rat wrote:
Did YOU read your own post?


Yes, I did. You didn't offer me an example of such a belief. If you want an actual example of such a belief see the poster above you who actually did offer one. Your belief example makes truth claims and so relates to logic and reason.

To make it perfectly clear: claiming that there is a deistic god that is unreachable by science that does not interact with the world in anyway is unverifiable but is also a claim for which evidence cannot be offered, even in theory. It's a totally moot proposition.


Claiming certain acts are sinful is a truth claim that inherently requires evidence in order to be believed. If you assert a truth claim that has real consequences in the world, it requires evidence of some kind in order to compel belief.
The unrealistic sound of these propositions is indicative, not of their utopian character, but of the strength of the forces which prevent their realization.
deathly rat
Profile Blog Joined October 2010
United Kingdom911 Posts
February 01 2012 12:41 GMT
#42
On February 01 2012 21:28 IgnE wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 01 2012 21:25 deathly rat wrote:
On February 01 2012 21:07 IgnE wrote:
On February 01 2012 20:54 deathly rat wrote:
On February 01 2012 19:17 IgnE wrote:
Give me an example of the kind of beliefs that are unfalsifiable and unrelated to reason or logic but that someone might still want to hold with no negative repercussions.


Not my belief, but for example...In Christianity they believe that you will be judged on your sins after you die. This is as good a reason as I have heard for living a moral life and being kind to strangers.



No that's idiotic. Besides being quite net negative for individuals, resulting in massive guilt for performing normal human activities like sexual intercourse, eating well, and indulging in life, any belief that sets out what activities qualify as sinful makes truth claims that are unverifiable and therefore spurious.

Not to mention bogus and unverifiable claims about an afterlife. Did you follow the argument at all in this thread?


This thread is full of rambling personal beliefs and nonsense logic, but when you make a simple question as you did, it is actually possible to analyse a preposition without getting distracted by the typical side tracks (as you have tried to introduce).

My statement did not imply that sex, eating well or ""indulging in life" is sinful, (and out of interest neither would most Christians).

next

"any belief that sets out what activities qualify as sinful makes truth claims that are unverifiable" - My actions may or may not be benevolent, but they don't make truth claims. For example, it is sinful to murder and steal, and it is kind to give to charity and recycle your plastic. What truth claims am I making?




You claim that murdering and stealing are sinful. Sinful acts are associated with punishment in an afterlife. Setting aside your totally unsubstantiated belief in an afterlife, how do you know that there is punishment in the afterlife for such acts?

I'll answer for you. You don't know, you just believe it's so with no evidence or testable hypothesis for finding out. You are just as crazy as someone who believes he is going to hell for walking on sidewalk cracks. There's literally no logical difference in the two beliefs. But I'm sure you would agree that someone who thinks he's going to hell because walking on a crack in the sidewalk is sinful is crazy.

Sinful =/= Immoral. Claiming something is sinful is making a truth claim about the act.


I note you have stopped arguing the below point

On February 01 2012 19:17 IgnE wrote:
Give me an example of the kind of beliefs that are unfalsifiable and unrelated to reason or logic but that someone might still want to hold with no negative repercussions.


and moved onto trying to prove religious beliefs by testing evidence, of which I have no interest. I assume you retract the previous preposition. Have a good day, and chill out.

No logo (logo)
IgnE
Profile Joined November 2010
United States7681 Posts
Last Edited: 2012-02-01 12:50:59
February 01 2012 12:49 GMT
#43
On February 01 2012 21:41 deathly rat wrote:

Show nested quote +
On February 01 2012 19:17 IgnE wrote:
Give me an example of the kind of beliefs that are unfalsifiable and unrelated to reason or logic but that someone might still want to hold with no negative repercussions.


and moved onto trying to prove religious beliefs by testing evidence, of which I have no interest. I assume you retract the previous preposition. Have a good day, and chill out.




I responded in the post above this one. The post you are quoting of mine was directed at someone else and he understood what I meant and offered a moot claim that satisfied the criteria I was looking for. That is, a claim that didn't require evidence for it be believed. I retract the wording, but you haven't really made an argument other than to point out that my wording wasn't clear. The wording should have been: "Give me an example of the kind of beliefs that do not require evidence to be believed but that someone might still want to hold."
The unrealistic sound of these propositions is indicative, not of their utopian character, but of the strength of the forces which prevent their realization.
AMaidensWrath
Profile Blog Joined September 2009
Belgium206 Posts
February 01 2012 12:50 GMT
#44

Do you think if you had been born in Iran you would be a Christian?

If that question was directed towards me, I'd answer:
No, I surely wouldn't be Christian. But I'd still believe in the same god. I'd just use a different name for him and would use different means to pray to him. In the end, Christianity, Judaism and Islam are the same religion, just in.... different flavours. Jesus is a prophet in the Islam religion. Christianity is heavily based on Judaism. Islam is based on Judaism and Christianity. They are in many parts the same belief adjusted to different cultures.
IgnE
Profile Joined November 2010
United States7681 Posts
February 01 2012 12:54 GMT
#45
On February 01 2012 21:50 AMaidensWrath wrote:
Show nested quote +

Do you think if you had been born in Iran you would be a Christian?

If that question was directed towards me, I'd answer:
No, I surely wouldn't be Christian. But I'd still believe in the same god. I'd just use a different name for him and would use different means to pray to him. In the end, Christianity, Judaism and Islam are the same religion, just in.... different flavours. Jesus is a prophet in the Islam religion. Christianity is heavily based on Judaism. Islam is based on Judaism and Christianity. They are in many parts the same belief adjusted to different cultures.



And yet each of the religions and all of its practitioners hold conflicting beliefs about this "same god." Who is correct? If you think god doesn't care about who is correct how do you know that he doesn't care? Many people would disagree that he doesn't care. You believe it's so. Oh right.

But you are right about god, those other people who say he sends non-believers to hell are incorrect. Those people who say its sinful not to fast during Ramadan are wrong. Those people who say its sinful to use condoms are wrong. But you are right. Because you believe and are "tolerant." And you know god is "tolerant" too.
The unrealistic sound of these propositions is indicative, not of their utopian character, but of the strength of the forces which prevent their realization.
Tyrran
Profile Blog Joined January 2010
France777 Posts
February 01 2012 12:56 GMT
#46
On February 01 2012 20:17 IgnE wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 01 2012 20:06 Tyrran wrote:
On February 01 2012 19:40 doubleupgradeobbies! wrote:

I agree from a purely scientific standpoint it is indeed fairly meaningless, you can't use it to model anything useful that the simpler, razor compliant, version would not. But if the more complicated theory is still perfectly consistent with reality AND makes you feel happy, it'd almost be irrational not to believe that one instead.



What really is meaningless is to approach religion from a scientific standpoint . The goal of religion is no longer to tell us how the world was created and/or to make so called 'truth claim', i dont even think it ever was its goal ( but i agree it is sometime used a such, which is wrong IMHO).

Religion nowadays is a way of life, a message on how you should live your life, a guide on what you should or should not do. You are free not to beleive in this message. You are free not to follow it. However, some people beleive in it, and act accordingly to it. They see God's hand where other people see coincidence and/or randomness. They see God influence when they see someone smile. They try they best to care about other people, they pardon, they share and they are happy to do it.

Sure you migth say that you dont need religion to do it. But dont blame religious people for doing it. ( You are however allowed to blame religious people for making retarded claim about how the world was created :p )

People should stop thinking religion is stupid because there is no scientific proof behind it. It only proove that they know nothing about what religion is today.



Show me a religion that doesn't make truth claims about the world.

Does it involve praying? Does it involve educated religious leaders saying what God wants? Does it involve God actually performing miracles in defiance of the laws of the physics? If it doesn't what is it?

Don't call a philosophical viewpoint about life a "religion." The two are very different and it doesn't help anyone to equate philosophy with spirituality/religion.


I do not intend to start a huge discussion about how I see and live religion. At least not in this blog ( sorry OP for derailing a bit your thread). However these are interesting questions that deserve an anwser. I'll try to be short.

Show me a religion that doesn't make truth claims about the world.

Ever since I was born, I dont remember going to a mess where a truth claim was made about the world. I know some people use religion to make truth claim ( e.g. creationnists). I'll stand my ground and say that it is not the goal of religion to do so. Sure you can find many 'truth claim' in the bible. But I have learned a long time ago that what is written in the bible is not to be taken litteraly.

Does it involve praying?

Yes it does. I do pray. I pray god to give me the strengh i need to help other, to forgive me for what I have done wrong and to help me not to do it again. I pray god to give other the strengh they need to overcome obstacle they meet in life.

Does it involve educated religious leaders saying what God wants?

Yes it does. However religious leader are not blessed with the "thruth". The goal of 'educated religious leader' (in my case, priest or pastor) is to explain how the philosophy preached by the bible apply to real life problems. In most case, it is interesting, sometimes enligthening. But i've heard bad priest, and I even sometimes disagreed with some.

Does it involve God actually performing miracles in defiance of the laws of the physics?

No. Once again, the bible is not to be taken litterally.

Don't call a philosophical viewpoint about life a "religion." The two are very different and it doesn't help anyone to equate philosophy with spirituality/religion.

Quite frankly, when i hear people talking about religion, I often wish they would see it as a philosophy rather than a Science. They are way more similarities between religion and philosophy than between religion and science.
Against stupidity the gods themselves contend in vain.
IgnE
Profile Joined November 2010
United States7681 Posts
Last Edited: 2012-02-01 13:03:46
February 01 2012 12:56 GMT
#47
On February 01 2012 21:41 deathly rat wrote:
My actions may or may not be benevolent, but they don't make truth claims. For example, it is sinful to murder and steal, and it is kind to give to charity and recycle your plastic. What truth claims am I making?


I noticed you stopped arguing that point though.
The unrealistic sound of these propositions is indicative, not of their utopian character, but of the strength of the forces which prevent their realization.
IgnE
Profile Joined November 2010
United States7681 Posts
Last Edited: 2012-02-01 13:06:49
February 01 2012 13:00 GMT
#48
On February 01 2012 21:56 Tyrran wrote:
+ Show Spoiler +
On February 01 2012 20:17 IgnE wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 01 2012 20:06 Tyrran wrote:
On February 01 2012 19:40 doubleupgradeobbies! wrote:

I agree from a purely scientific standpoint it is indeed fairly meaningless, you can't use it to model anything useful that the simpler, razor compliant, version would not. But if the more complicated theory is still perfectly consistent with reality AND makes you feel happy, it'd almost be irrational not to believe that one instead.



What really is meaningless is to approach religion from a scientific standpoint . The goal of religion is no longer to tell us how the world was created and/or to make so called 'truth claim', i dont even think it ever was its goal ( but i agree it is sometime used a such, which is wrong IMHO).

Religion nowadays is a way of life, a message on how you should live your life, a guide on what you should or should not do. You are free not to beleive in this message. You are free not to follow it. However, some people beleive in it, and act accordingly to it. They see God's hand where other people see coincidence and/or randomness. They see God influence when they see someone smile. They try they best to care about other people, they pardon, they share and they are happy to do it.

Sure you migth say that you dont need religion to do it. But dont blame religious people for doing it. ( You are however allowed to blame religious people for making retarded claim about how the world was created :p )

People should stop thinking religion is stupid because there is no scientific proof behind it. It only proove that they know nothing about what religion is today.



Show me a religion that doesn't make truth claims about the world.

Does it involve praying? Does it involve educated religious leaders saying what God wants? Does it involve God actually performing miracles in defiance of the laws of the physics? If it doesn't what is it?

Don't call a philosophical viewpoint about life a "religion." The two are very different and it doesn't help anyone to equate philosophy with spirituality/religion.


I do not intend to start a huge discussion about how I see and live religion. At least not in this blog ( sorry OP for derailing a bit your thread). However these are interesting questions that deserve an anwser. I'll try to be short.

Show me a religion that doesn't make truth claims about the world.

Ever since I was born, I dont remember going to a mess where a truth claim was made about the world. I know some people use religion to make truth claim ( e.g. creationnists). I'll stand my ground and say that it is not the goal of religion to do so. Sure you can find many 'truth claim' in the bible. But I have learned a long time ago that what is written in the bible is not to be taken litteraly.

Does it involve praying?

Yes it does. I do pray. I pray god to give me the strengh i need to help other, to forgive me for what I have done wrong and to help me not to do it again. I pray god to give other the strengh they need to overcome obstacle they meet in life.

Does it involve educated religious leaders saying what God wants?

Yes it does. However religious leader are not blessed with the "thruth". The goal of 'educated religious leader' (in my case, priest or pastor) is to explain how the philosophy preached by the bible apply to real life problems. In most case, it is interesting, sometimes enligthening. But i've heard bad priest, and I even sometimes disagreed with some.

Does it involve God actually performing miracles in defiance of the laws of the physics?

No. Once again, the bible is not to be taken litterally.

Don't call a philosophical viewpoint about life a "religion." The two are very different and it doesn't help anyone to equate philosophy with spirituality/religion.

Quite frankly, when i hear people talking about religion, I often wish they would see it as a philosophy rather than a Science. They are way more similarities between religion and philosophy than between religion and science.


If you pray, you are making truth claims about the world. You believe that god directly intervenes in daily life to tell you things, breaking the laws of physics and directly communicating with you in your head. That's a truth claim.

Also implicit in all this are the truth claims that: you have a soul, you will enter into an afterlife when you die, that the bible was communicated to people by god similar to the way he communicates to you through prayer, that you can know what god wants for us, that god exists at all (perhaps the most common truth claim in any religion).

None of those are substantiated with a shred of evidence. So I think you are mistaken.
The unrealistic sound of these propositions is indicative, not of their utopian character, but of the strength of the forces which prevent their realization.
bITt.mAN
Profile Blog Joined March 2009
Switzerland3693 Posts
Last Edited: 2012-02-01 13:13:13
February 01 2012 13:10 GMT
#49
^
^ Well, that didn't happen. I have no evidence or information on my-life-had-I-been-born-in-Iran, so it is unreasonable to suggest I know anything about what I would be like, had that happened. However I do believe that God reveals himself to everyone in different ways throughout their lives, and while it's hard there are still Christian converts in Iran.

And ^ AMaidensWrath, I will respectfully disagree and say they are far more divergent than just different flavors. Albeit the same roots (Abraham and his descendants etc) there is little kingship between Judaism and what the Prophet Mohammed told people it was OK to do to Jews (kill 'em). The most important feature of any religion IMO is 'how you reach God', to me that's what defines if it's worth following or not. [justified = made just before God, that he accepts you as his own and no longer holds your sin against you]
Judaism you are justified by your obedience of the laws of Moses; since none can NEVER have fault and be utterly blameless, and follow the law perfectly, you're pretty screwed.
Christianity you are justified by your acceptance of the Gospel Message and the saving grace of Christ. It's free, but sure not easy.
Islam (I must learn more) is similar to Judaism in that you are justified by your conformity to the 5 pillars and obedience to the teachings of Mohammed.


They are radically different, albeit similar roots. I don't actually know the history of what religious group became the first Muslims (i.e. Mohammed's original religion). Christian's have a fulfilled and complete understanding of the God of the Old Testament (Judaism) whereas Jews are still waiting for the messiah, the completion of the Old Testament's prophecies of a deliverer, who's already come (Jesus).
BW4LYF . . . . . . PM me, I LOVE PMs. . . . . . Long live "NaDa's Body" . . . . . . Fantasy | Bisu/Best | Jaedong . . . . .
IgnE
Profile Joined November 2010
United States7681 Posts
February 01 2012 13:14 GMT
#50
On February 01 2012 22:10 bITt.mAN wrote:
^
^ Well, that didn't happen. I have no evidence or information on my-life-had-I-been-born-in-Iran, so it is unreasonable to suggest I know anything about what I would be like, had that happened. However I do believe that God reveals himself to everyone in different ways throughout their lives, and while it's hard there are still Christian converts in Iran.


You actually have a lot of evidence. The overwhelming majority of people in Iran are not Christian, despite whatever belief you have that god is revealing himself to them. You are not that different from other people. Are they just all that thickheaded over in Iran or is god not doing a good enough job revealing himself?

In fact the overwhelming majority of the world is not Christian at all. What's up with that?
The unrealistic sound of these propositions is indicative, not of their utopian character, but of the strength of the forces which prevent their realization.
ShadeR
Profile Blog Joined December 2009
Australia7535 Posts
February 01 2012 13:15 GMT
#51
There is a fairly strong statistical argument to be made that IF you were indeed to have been born in Iran you would likely not be a christian but rather a muslim. And as you've so aptly pointed out that changes everything =P
bITt.mAN
Profile Blog Joined March 2009
Switzerland3693 Posts
February 01 2012 13:26 GMT
#52
Bro regardless of where I was born I'd still have the same parents, otherwise it's not me (my genes) {: I was born in Japan, haven't lived there since I was three. No biggie really.

Ok, and once we start going down life-stories that never happened there's just as much evidence (i.e. none, as it didn't happen) that right about now in my life I'd be going to school in the West (white parents with US passports usually cause that to happen) and have been exposed to the Gospel Message. Hypothetically if I was Muslim, I'd then start to have serious issues with it, because who's gonna believe you can be 'good enough' to appease a wholly just and holy God by your works alone. By faith in God's grace we are saved, he's the only one who can bridge the gap we create whenever we turn away from him. That's Christianity.
BW4LYF . . . . . . PM me, I LOVE PMs. . . . . . Long live "NaDa's Body" . . . . . . Fantasy | Bisu/Best | Jaedong . . . . .
ShadeR
Profile Blog Joined December 2009
Australia7535 Posts
February 01 2012 13:29 GMT
#53
Well then gosh i wish i was indoctrinated by my elders from an young age too!
IgnE
Profile Joined November 2010
United States7681 Posts
February 01 2012 13:29 GMT
#54
Yeah it is difficult to imagine inhabiting the subjective conscious experience of a person with entirely different genes/parents/culture isn't it?

So are they all just that thickheaded over in Iran or is god not doing a good enough job revealing himself?

The unrealistic sound of these propositions is indicative, not of their utopian character, but of the strength of the forces which prevent their realization.
IgnE
Profile Joined November 2010
United States7681 Posts
Last Edited: 2012-02-01 14:05:33
February 01 2012 13:32 GMT
#55
On February 01 2012 22:26 bITt.mAN wrote:
Hypothetically if I was Muslim, I'd then start to have serious issues with it, because who's gonna believe you can be 'good enough' to appease a wholly just and holy God by your works alone. By faith in God's grace we are saved, he's the only one who can bridge the gap we create whenever we turn away from him. That's Christianity.


I mean, who is gonna believe in a god that saves you for merely saying you believe in him rather than doing what he asks of you?

BTW the saved by faith thing is only some versions of Protestant Christianity. So you are putting yourself in an increasingly minority position that thinks it alone has the official word on what god thinks or does. Protestant Christianity isn't even directly descended from Jesus. You'd have to go Orthodox or Catholic for some historical connection to a possibly fictitious man.
The unrealistic sound of these propositions is indicative, not of their utopian character, but of the strength of the forces which prevent their realization.
Tyrran
Profile Blog Joined January 2010
France777 Posts
February 01 2012 14:32 GMT
#56
On February 01 2012 22:00 IgnE wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 01 2012 21:56 Tyrran wrote:
+ Show Spoiler +
On February 01 2012 20:17 IgnE wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 01 2012 20:06 Tyrran wrote:
On February 01 2012 19:40 doubleupgradeobbies! wrote:

I agree from a purely scientific standpoint it is indeed fairly meaningless, you can't use it to model anything useful that the simpler, razor compliant, version would not. But if the more complicated theory is still perfectly consistent with reality AND makes you feel happy, it'd almost be irrational not to believe that one instead.



What really is meaningless is to approach religion from a scientific standpoint . The goal of religion is no longer to tell us how the world was created and/or to make so called 'truth claim', i dont even think it ever was its goal ( but i agree it is sometime used a such, which is wrong IMHO).

Religion nowadays is a way of life, a message on how you should live your life, a guide on what you should or should not do. You are free not to beleive in this message. You are free not to follow it. However, some people beleive in it, and act accordingly to it. They see God's hand where other people see coincidence and/or randomness. They see God influence when they see someone smile. They try they best to care about other people, they pardon, they share and they are happy to do it.

Sure you migth say that you dont need religion to do it. But dont blame religious people for doing it. ( You are however allowed to blame religious people for making retarded claim about how the world was created :p )

People should stop thinking religion is stupid because there is no scientific proof behind it. It only proove that they know nothing about what religion is today.



Show me a religion that doesn't make truth claims about the world.

Does it involve praying? Does it involve educated religious leaders saying what God wants? Does it involve God actually performing miracles in defiance of the laws of the physics? If it doesn't what is it?

Don't call a philosophical viewpoint about life a "religion." The two are very different and it doesn't help anyone to equate philosophy with spirituality/religion.


I do not intend to start a huge discussion about how I see and live religion. At least not in this blog ( sorry OP for derailing a bit your thread). However these are interesting questions that deserve an anwser. I'll try to be short.

Show me a religion that doesn't make truth claims about the world.

Ever since I was born, I dont remember going to a mess where a truth claim was made about the world. I know some people use religion to make truth claim ( e.g. creationnists). I'll stand my ground and say that it is not the goal of religion to do so. Sure you can find many 'truth claim' in the bible. But I have learned a long time ago that what is written in the bible is not to be taken litteraly.

Does it involve praying?

Yes it does. I do pray. I pray god to give me the strengh i need to help other, to forgive me for what I have done wrong and to help me not to do it again. I pray god to give other the strengh they need to overcome obstacle they meet in life.

Does it involve educated religious leaders saying what God wants?

Yes it does. However religious leader are not blessed with the "thruth". The goal of 'educated religious leader' (in my case, priest or pastor) is to explain how the philosophy preached by the bible apply to real life problems. In most case, it is interesting, sometimes enligthening. But i've heard bad priest, and I even sometimes disagreed with some.

Does it involve God actually performing miracles in defiance of the laws of the physics?

No. Once again, the bible is not to be taken litterally.

Don't call a philosophical viewpoint about life a "religion." The two are very different and it doesn't help anyone to equate philosophy with spirituality/religion.

Quite frankly, when i hear people talking about religion, I often wish they would see it as a philosophy rather than a Science. They are way more similarities between religion and philosophy than between religion and science.


If you pray, you are making truth claims about the world. You believe that god directly intervenes in daily life to tell you things, breaking the laws of physics and directly communicating with you in your head. That's a truth claim.

Also implicit in all this are the truth claims that: you have a soul, you will enter into an afterlife when you die, that the bible was communicated to people by god similar to the way he communicates to you through prayer, that you can know what god wants for us, that god exists at all (perhaps the most common truth claim in any religion).

None of those are substantiated with a shred of evidence. So I think you are mistaken.


And once again you are trying to find scientific foundation to religion when I am trying to explain that you should not. I'm not christian because I think my soul will be saved. I am christian because I believe in the message/guide/philosophy delivered by Jesus in the bible.

Yes I do believe God exist. I also believe He does not have a physical existence. I beleive He is within each one of us , and I see His action when i look at people dedicating their life to figth poverty. This is not something rational, driven by physical law. This is not a scientific truth claim. This is what I believe, this is my faith.

I'm a scientist, conducting a applied Mathematic PhD at the moment. Beleive me, if i ever found something that did not work accordingly to the physical law i know, I'd immediatly write a paper on it and become famous :D
Against stupidity the gods themselves contend in vain.
PEEFSMASH
Profile Joined March 2011
108 Posts
Last Edited: 2012-02-01 14:36:31
February 01 2012 14:34 GMT
#57
I want to know how you go about creating your own beliefs. It seems that creating your own belief would require you to create your own ideas, but ideas do not work that way. Ideas simply pop into your head, they are not forged. On reflection this is the only way it could be. Your beliefs are going to be based on your ideas, ideas that are gathered from sense experience/reasoning, and cannot be divorced from the real world.

To the above poster who claims that God is visible when people do charity, I cannot respect such a belief without any evidence. And you don't appear to even care to give any. The faith you are describing is nothing more than an assertion without evidence, and should not be given any more respect than the suicide bomber who kills people to please his God.
IgnE
Profile Joined November 2010
United States7681 Posts
February 01 2012 14:42 GMT
#58
On February 01 2012 23:32 Tyrran wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 01 2012 22:00 IgnE wrote:
On February 01 2012 21:56 Tyrran wrote:
+ Show Spoiler +
On February 01 2012 20:17 IgnE wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 01 2012 20:06 Tyrran wrote:
On February 01 2012 19:40 doubleupgradeobbies! wrote:

I agree from a purely scientific standpoint it is indeed fairly meaningless, you can't use it to model anything useful that the simpler, razor compliant, version would not. But if the more complicated theory is still perfectly consistent with reality AND makes you feel happy, it'd almost be irrational not to believe that one instead.



What really is meaningless is to approach religion from a scientific standpoint . The goal of religion is no longer to tell us how the world was created and/or to make so called 'truth claim', i dont even think it ever was its goal ( but i agree it is sometime used a such, which is wrong IMHO).

Religion nowadays is a way of life, a message on how you should live your life, a guide on what you should or should not do. You are free not to beleive in this message. You are free not to follow it. However, some people beleive in it, and act accordingly to it. They see God's hand where other people see coincidence and/or randomness. They see God influence when they see someone smile. They try they best to care about other people, they pardon, they share and they are happy to do it.

Sure you migth say that you dont need religion to do it. But dont blame religious people for doing it. ( You are however allowed to blame religious people for making retarded claim about how the world was created :p )

People should stop thinking religion is stupid because there is no scientific proof behind it. It only proove that they know nothing about what religion is today.



Show me a religion that doesn't make truth claims about the world.

Does it involve praying? Does it involve educated religious leaders saying what God wants? Does it involve God actually performing miracles in defiance of the laws of the physics? If it doesn't what is it?

Don't call a philosophical viewpoint about life a "religion." The two are very different and it doesn't help anyone to equate philosophy with spirituality/religion.


I do not intend to start a huge discussion about how I see and live religion. At least not in this blog ( sorry OP for derailing a bit your thread). However these are interesting questions that deserve an anwser. I'll try to be short.

Show me a religion that doesn't make truth claims about the world.

Ever since I was born, I dont remember going to a mess where a truth claim was made about the world. I know some people use religion to make truth claim ( e.g. creationnists). I'll stand my ground and say that it is not the goal of religion to do so. Sure you can find many 'truth claim' in the bible. But I have learned a long time ago that what is written in the bible is not to be taken litteraly.

Does it involve praying?

Yes it does. I do pray. I pray god to give me the strengh i need to help other, to forgive me for what I have done wrong and to help me not to do it again. I pray god to give other the strengh they need to overcome obstacle they meet in life.

Does it involve educated religious leaders saying what God wants?

Yes it does. However religious leader are not blessed with the "thruth". The goal of 'educated religious leader' (in my case, priest or pastor) is to explain how the philosophy preached by the bible apply to real life problems. In most case, it is interesting, sometimes enligthening. But i've heard bad priest, and I even sometimes disagreed with some.

Does it involve God actually performing miracles in defiance of the laws of the physics?

No. Once again, the bible is not to be taken litterally.

Don't call a philosophical viewpoint about life a "religion." The two are very different and it doesn't help anyone to equate philosophy with spirituality/religion.

Quite frankly, when i hear people talking about religion, I often wish they would see it as a philosophy rather than a Science. They are way more similarities between religion and philosophy than between religion and science.


If you pray, you are making truth claims about the world. You believe that god directly intervenes in daily life to tell you things, breaking the laws of physics and directly communicating with you in your head. That's a truth claim.

Also implicit in all this are the truth claims that: you have a soul, you will enter into an afterlife when you die, that the bible was communicated to people by god similar to the way he communicates to you through prayer, that you can know what god wants for us, that god exists at all (perhaps the most common truth claim in any religion).

None of those are substantiated with a shred of evidence. So I think you are mistaken.


And once again you are trying to find scientific foundation to religion when I am trying to explain that you should not. I'm not christian because I think my soul will be saved. I am christian because I believe in the message/guide/philosophy delivered by Jesus in the bible.

Yes I do believe God exist. I also believe He does not have a physical existence. I beleive He is within each one of us , and I see His action when i look at people dedicating their life to figth poverty. This is not something rational, driven by physical law. This is not a scientific truth claim. This is what I believe, this is my faith.

I'm a scientist, conducting a applied Mathematic PhD at the moment. Beleive me, if i ever found something that did not work accordingly to the physical law i know, I'd immediatly write a paper on it and become famous :D


As long as you freely admit you believe in stuff for which there is no evidence and for which you have no rational support, then keep doing what you are doing. More power to you if you want to believe in crazy shit, as long as you keep your distance.
The unrealistic sound of these propositions is indicative, not of their utopian character, but of the strength of the forces which prevent their realization.
FractalsOnFire
Profile Blog Joined August 2010
Australia1756 Posts
February 01 2012 15:05 GMT
#59
On February 01 2012 21:56 Tyrran wrote:

Does it involve God actually performing miracles in defiance of the laws of the physics?

No. Once again, the bible is not to be taken litterally.


So uh everything it says is metaphorical? Therefore Jesus is not the son of god, savior, died to save our sins etc etc?
IgnE
Profile Joined November 2010
United States7681 Posts
February 01 2012 15:07 GMT
#60
It always amazes me how many people are willing to believe something is true just because they "want to."
The unrealistic sound of these propositions is indicative, not of their utopian character, but of the strength of the forces which prevent their realization.
Prev 1 2 3 4 Next All
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
The PiG Daily
21:00
Best Games of EWC
Serral vs Cure
Classic vs Solar
PiGStarcraft487
LiquipediaDiscussion
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
PiGStarcraft487
Nathanias 136
StarCraft: Brood War
ggaemo 111
Dota 2
monkeys_forever944
NeuroSwarm67
Counter-Strike
Stewie2K649
Heroes of the Storm
Grubby2761
Trikslyr65
Other Games
tarik_tv28617
gofns13675
summit1g5999
FrodaN1856
shahzam451
ToD215
C9.Mang0134
RotterdaM106
Organizations
StarCraft 2
angryscii 26
Other Games
BasetradeTV23
gamesdonequick20
StarCraft 2
Blizzard YouTube
StarCraft: Brood War
BSLTrovo
sctven
[ Show 15 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• davetesta34
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• LaughNgamezSOOP
• Migwel
• sooper7s
StarCraft: Brood War
• Pr0nogo 9
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Dota 2
• masondota22363
League of Legends
• Doublelift3794
Other Games
• imaqtpie1638
Upcoming Events
Korean StarCraft League
4h 5m
CranKy Ducklings
11h 5m
SC Evo League
13h 5m
WardiTV Summer Champion…
14h 5m
Classic vs Percival
Spirit vs NightMare
CSO Cup
17h 5m
[BSL 2025] Weekly
19h 5m
Sparkling Tuna Cup
1d 11h
SC Evo League
1d 13h
Replay Cast
2 days
Afreeca Starleague
2 days
Queen vs HyuN
EffOrt vs Calm
[ Show More ]
Wardi Open
2 days
RotterdaM Event
2 days
Replay Cast
3 days
Afreeca Starleague
3 days
Rush vs TBD
Jaedong vs Mong
Afreeca Starleague
4 days
herO vs TBD
Royal vs Barracks
Replay Cast
5 days
The PondCast
5 days
Replay Cast
6 days
LiuLi Cup
6 days
Cosmonarchy
6 days
OyAji vs Sziky
Sziky vs WolFix
WolFix vs OyAji
BSL Team Wars
6 days
Team Hawk vs Team Dewalt
BSL Team Wars
6 days
Team Hawk vs Team Bonyth
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Jiahua Invitational
uThermal 2v2 Main Event
HCC Europe

Ongoing

Copa Latinoamericana 4
BSL 20 Team Wars
KCM Race Survival 2025 Season 3
BSL 21 Qualifiers
ASL Season 20
CSL Season 18: Qualifier 1
SEL Season 2 Championship
WardiTV Summer 2025
Esports World Cup 2025
BLAST Bounty Fall 2025
BLAST Bounty Fall Qual
IEM Cologne 2025
FISSURE Playground #1
BLAST.tv Austin Major 2025

Upcoming

Acropolis #4 - TS1
CSLAN 3
CSL Season 18: Qualifier 2
CSL 2025 AUTUMN (S18)
LASL Season 20
BSL Season 21
BSL 21 Team A
Chzzk MurlocKing SC1 vs SC2 Cup #2
RSL Revival: Season 2
Maestros of the Game
EC S1
Sisters' Call Cup
IEM Chengdu 2025
PGL Masters Bucharest 2025
Thunderpick World Champ.
MESA Nomadic Masters Fall
CS Asia Championships 2025
Roobet Cup 2025
ESL Pro League S22
StarSeries Fall 2025
FISSURE Playground #2
BLAST Open Fall 2025
BLAST Open Fall Qual
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2025 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.