|
This is a thread that is dedicated to discussing One Piece. Do not read this thread if you are not currently caught up as there are spoilers in here.
If an episode or a chapter has already been officially released, then it is not necessary to post using spoilers.
If you have knowledge on a chapter that has not been officially released yet, do NOT post it in this thread. Ignoring this public note will result in a mod action. |
On May 28 2016 09:00 Sentenal wrote: You only think that because you don't think Oda ever plans for things or foreshadows or sets up anything in advance. And look what happened last time.
im actually blanking on what last time was
and i only think that because i think violet and robin look as similar as 3 eyed chick and pudding
|
|
honestly they dont seem that similar, hair style, nose, breasts all are similar but still noticeably different imo
plus the way the cop guy talked to her makes it seem likes shes a more permament resident, he acted respectfully but not what youd expect from (presumably) one of Big Moms top execs, plus if she was going to be a mole shed act in some way mysterious instead she seems straightforward and innocent shes acting more like mermaid princess then violet
|
They look different in the way a person could change their hair style and change their clothes would be different. The bangs to hide her forehead seems very deliberate for a later reveal to the SH members and Sanji.
Even if Pudding is not the three eyed girl she still should get a lot of respect because she is the daughter of Big Mom and is going to be married into an important political alliance so I don't see how the cop point makes sense. It makes more sense that the whole town is just very joyful on the outside so all residents are casual to each other. Pudding doesn't need to know she is talking to Luffy, individual characters can be quirky so she could genuinely be flattered by what Luffy said.
|
They look different in the way a person could change their hair style and change their clothes would be different. The bangs to hide her forehead seems very deliberate for a later reveal to the SH members and Sanji.
the way her hair and nose are drawn look different to me (and im not just talking about the ponytails) 3 eyed chick hair is wavier and the nose is drawn differently
and yes i get she could be like Mr.2 and genuinely befriend them but i just cant see it being likely they are the same person
though im sure if they are ill get tons of shit for having an incorrect opinion -.-
|
Are you guys being serious? Look at the eye shape, nose shape, hairstyle.This is definitively the same person. The only other possibility is that they're twins. Yet why would one twin (who has the same genes) have a third eye and the other wouldn't? Also a dead goddamn giveaway is that we can't see Pudding's forehead in the second image. The hair is there for only one reason: to block the eye.
|
She's really a perfect match for Sanji. He too knows a thing or two about hiding an eye with his hair.
|
she has the eye of the providence, she can see everything everywhere whenever she wants, that's why she's hiding it when the power isn't needed
|
On May 28 2016 12:40 ZigguratOfUr wrote: She's really a perfect match for Sanji. He too knows a thing or two about hiding an eye with his hair. Oh yeah that's kinda clever if that's intended.
|
There's even that slimy thing on her shoulder in both examples you brought up...
|
On May 28 2016 12:32 Hyperbola wrote:Are you guys being serious? Look at the eye shape, nose shape, hairstyle.This is definitively the same person. The only other possibility is that they're twins. Yet why would one twin (who has the same genes) have a third eye and the other wouldn't? Also a dead goddamn giveaway is that we can't see Pudding's forehead in the second image. The hair is there for only one reason: to block the eye. because OPverse totally doesnt have magic fruit that alters peoples apearence
assuming it is third eye, why is she wearing a disguise against people who have never seen her before?
|
On May 28 2016 18:14 Forikorder wrote:Show nested quote +On May 28 2016 12:32 Hyperbola wrote:Are you guys being serious? Look at the eye shape, nose shape, hairstyle.This is definitively the same person. The only other possibility is that they're twins. Yet why would one twin (who has the same genes) have a third eye and the other wouldn't? Also a dead goddamn giveaway is that we can't see Pudding's forehead in the second image. The hair is there for only one reason: to block the eye. because OPverse totally doesnt have magic fruit that alters peoples apearence assuming it is third eye, why is she wearing a disguise against people who have never seen her before?
quoted for reference later.
|
On May 28 2016 18:00 Talron wrote: There's even that slimy thing on her shoulder in both examples you brought up... Oh I feel dumb for not even noticing the slime in the first one.
assuming it is third eye, why is she wearing a disguise against people who have never seen her before? Oda is disguising Pudding's third eye for plot purposes, but does it really qualify as disguise from her point of view to simply put her bangs down? Even if it does count as a disguise why would hiding something different about yourself be odd? Cover the eye with bangs and she becomes just a normal human girl.
|
|
well i mean, if one thing is consistent in the manga (excluding the chapter cover), the characters stay the same with their clothing. look at their dresses. and also, i doubt mama would let her to stay outside like that without guards etc.
+ Show Spoiler +that jelly thing though + Show Spoiler +i am kidding, the dude says it is her wedding....it would be too much of coincidence if they are not the same girl wouldnt it lol
|
How can they not be the same person? They look exactly the same. Unless the idea is to trick people in thinking it's the same person for lazy plot reasons.
|
I think that Forik knows this thread thrives off him saying unfounded and outrageous things, so hes just doing his civic duty to feed the thread.
|
Intentional or not it's true that forik brings a lot of discussion to the thread and I enjoy reading it. There will always be users that go against the thread and are called trolls which gives everyone an excuse to rehash or reread the material to prove the other person wrong. The slime thing with Pudding for example made me go from "she is probably Pudding" to "she is almost certainly Pudding."
|
On May 28 2016 18:37 evanthebouncy! wrote:Show nested quote +On May 28 2016 18:14 Forikorder wrote:On May 28 2016 12:32 Hyperbola wrote:Are you guys being serious? Look at the eye shape, nose shape, hairstyle.This is definitively the same person. The only other possibility is that they're twins. Yet why would one twin (who has the same genes) have a third eye and the other wouldn't? Also a dead goddamn giveaway is that we can't see Pudding's forehead in the second image. The hair is there for only one reason: to block the eye. because OPverse totally doesnt have magic fruit that alters peoples apearence assuming it is third eye, why is she wearing a disguise against people who have never seen her before? quoted for reference later. okay im just gonna nip this one in the bud
quite frankly, i do not care AT ALL if pudding has a third eye, it literally does not interest me in any way, she could she could not as far as im concerned the odds are EXACTLY 50/50 and whichever way it goes, i probably wont react unless its like SUPER cliffhanger/climactic reveal
so once again I DO NOT CARE
all i have a problem with, literally the only singular thing, is that people are simply assuming its 100% certain so, literally, all i am doing in this specific argument is playing devils advocate to try to stop people from assuming its definently 100%
|
It's not about being 100% certain it's about finding compelling evidence for whatever fan theory. Could fans be 100% certain Sabo was alive before the reveal? No, but there was a lot of things that led fans to believe he was alive like Sabo's death never being confirmed, his interaction with Dragon followed by Dragon saving someone, coy answers from Oda about Sabo's death and the sake cup on Ace's grave. The Pudding thing is not 100% either and not thinking it's 100% is fine, but it's just odd that you don't consider her appearance and other circumstances strong evidence and are playing devil's advocate for something you don't care about.
|
|
|
|