Noir Mini Mafia: Chapter 4 - Page 52

Post a Reply

Prev 1 50 51 52 53 54 77 Next

Koshi

Belgium38797 Posts

March 14 2016 20:51 GMT

#1021

But I want to lynch today so I will vote w.e

Shapelog

United States5184 Posts

March 14 2016 20:56 GMT

#1022

On March 15 2016 05:50 Koshisus wrote:
I am 100% on shape is town.

Fixed.
Anyways, you know, you could, like make a case or something?

Koshi

Belgium38797 Posts

March 14 2016 21:01 GMT

#1023

I don't make cases on confirmed mafia.

Shapelog

United States5184 Posts

March 14 2016 21:03 GMT

#1024

On March 15 2016 05:51 Koshi wrote:
But I want to lynch today so I will vote w.e

Let me give you a hint Koshi on how to lynch me.
+ Show Spoiler +

Your Case:
[image loading]

my posts:

You need to get to:
[image loading]

Shapelog

United States5184 Posts

March 14 2016 21:05 GMT

#1025

On March 15 2016 06:01 Koshi wrote:
I don't make cases on confirmed mafia.

Then how are you going to....
You know what, never mind. Wasting time, and I am not going to convince you to actually make a case. So...
[image loading]

Till I get done with Tumble and vote and shit.

Koshi

Belgium38797 Posts

March 14 2016 21:17 GMT

#1026

nha mafia is not within slam or tumble

Rels

France13467 Posts

March 14 2016 21:36 GMT

#1027

Yeah and ve was confirmed town last game
Lynch slam

Shapelog

United States5184 Posts

March 14 2016 21:47 GMT

#1028

Koshisus is going to flame me so hard for this but...

On March 09 2016 01:53 Koshi wrote:

Show nested quote +

I really get bored by post like this. After last game in which marv made exactly this post, and I was so fucking stupid to do it and even then he got his trash buddy to flame me some more I decided I will not be bothered to show any forced activity.

And I just might not post at all the give all you fuckers a fucking reason to lynch me based on retarded shitty reasons.

On March 09 2016 02:01 Koshi wrote:

Show nested quote +

Because I explained how I would prefer to play this game and you feel like you can boss me around and tell me how I should play or get lynched. Therefore my answer is Fuck You.

On March 09 2016 22:38 Koshi wrote:

Show nested quote +

On March 09 2016 05:23 yamato77 wrote:

On March 09 2016 02:07 Koshi wrote:
Sadly I already made something and I don't want to delete it because it is pure brilliance. And because I was a bit mean to Rels last game and his VE read when I entered the thread. Therefore I will correct his yamato read and explain it.

+ Show Spoiler +

On March 08 2016 16:16 yamato77 wrote:
I want to lynch Vivax.

Unsurprisingly.

On March 08 2016 16:25 yamato77 wrote:
Also, I don't understand how geript wants to lynch slam for what he's posted, nor would I give Shapelog a pass for being a noob. Shapelog's posts aren't bad necessarily, but they don't give off a newb vibe. They seem comfortable.

Vivax is the much more notable poster in the first few pages IMO and it's odd that all geript has to say about it is that he's a dick. All of that said, I don't really have a scumread on geript, I just disagree with him, as I expected to.

Kush being overly aggressive is whatever. Mild townread.

Tumble's first post is creative at least. If he's a new player I wouldn't expect that sort of effort as mafia but that's a highly conditional read.

.
1) The geript read + how he involves alakaslam,shape and Vivax. It just doesn't do it for me. Why is geript mafia for wanting to lynch alakslam? Why is geript mafia for thinking shape is newb town? Why is geript mafia for saying Vivax is a dick? geript explained his Shape read pretty clearly. I don't understand where yamato his confusion comes from. I also don't understand why yamato adds his own opinion of Shape in his geript segment, but fails to explain why it makes geript mafia. The entire paragraph just doesn't make sense from town perspective who is figuring out geript. Because Yamato isn't figuring out geript at all, he is correcting/doubting things geript said and then implies geript is wrong and therefore mafia. Or at least that is how this entire segment feels like. Because he doesn't really conclude anything on geript in the end. It's an open ending that we can fill in.

2) I don't see the connection between his opening post about lynching Vivax and the follow up in the geript segment. It could be that yamato his opening post is stating/complaining about the fact Vivax is offtopic as fuck. He confronts Vivax about that later again but without trying to solve the game or do anything. It's so meek. What is this read? + Show Spoiler +

Vivax is the much more notable poster in the first few pages IMO and it's odd that all geript has to say about it is that he's a dick. All of that said, I don't really have a scumread on geript, I just disagree with him, as I expected to.

3) I get the feeling that the Kush read and the Tumble read are "correct" reads mafia gives. Simple structured reads based on TMI but throwaway. Mafia yamato knows these 2 are town and then finds a reason to call them town. It is the same for the Shape read within the geript read btw. These reads feel like coming from mafia. Or really good town being in the zone but then I wonder what the fuck the geript/vivax vomitting was all about.

I think town yamato would have approached this entirely different, a town yamato would be able to express and structure himself a lot clearer in his first read post. Figure out players individually and not inappropriate mix in geript in every read. Yamato his reads just don't seem to be coming from a townie trying to solve the game. I feel it is a mafia giving reads through discrediting somebody else his reads. I can't explain it. Just doesn't look town.

##vote Yamato

some tinfoil:
I was wondering why yamato is so focussed on geript. It doesn't feel natural yamato starts his read post by reading geript giving reads on 3 other people. Discrediting geript? Scumbuddies? Tilting geript? I don't know. Might have something to do with Slam but maybe completely not.

you imbecile. This post is horrid.

Basically how I now will answer each post.

On March 09 2016 22:59 Koshi wrote:

Show nested quote +

1) grtz on focusing on the buzzword, you imbecile, and ignore the line of reasoning I gave you before that. Trash. Learn to play. Horrid player.

2) I never complained about that. I don't see where you get this from, you blind fuck. I didn't answer because I don't know and need to check previous games to answer it, and I can't check filters at work. Terrible shit.

3) You have flamed me at least 5 times in the last hour, but have you already tried to explain once why yamato isn't mafia? Like on a normal way? Or was calling me town zero, or retarded because you and yamato can't be on the same scumteam the normal way?

On March 09 2016 23:00 Koshi wrote:
Anyway. I am sure I was on a pretty good behavior this game. Vivax can try to spin it how he wants. I can quote posts in which he is a cancerous piece of shit. He can only make up lies.

Trash will be trash.

Also I looked at tumble filter and there is nothing that makes me want to vote him over Slam. Full read will be out shortly after i finish up.

Shapelog

United States5184 Posts

March 14 2016 21:55 GMT

#1029

Wait Belgium, Not Be-lien.

Oops

Shapelog

United States5184 Posts

March 14 2016 21:56 GMT

#1030

How the fuck did i confused Berlin and Belgium?

Shapelog

United States5184 Posts

March 14 2016 22:02 GMT

#1031

Reads Con.Reads Con.

Rels:
I am still wishy washy on Rels. Therefore I will Just quote on things I think are scum/town indicative and go from there. Since it prob. be a lot, I am spoiling it.
+ Show Spoiler [The journey begins!] +

On March 09 2016 06:02 Rels wrote:

Show nested quote +

???
+ Show Spoiler +

On March 08 2016 15:15 Tumblewood wrote:
I feel like Shape's been kinda backed into a corner by kush, or at least he feels that way. How it went down:
Kush flashed his badge at Shapelog. It read, "Private Investigator: Kush Mountains". "What do you know about the mafia?" he inquired.
Shape didn't have much to say; he'd only been there twenty minutes, and he'd only seen three other people in his time. He thought of the most informative thing he had to say, which was

Show nested quote +

It wasn't much, and they both knew it. Kush followed up with some leading questions.

Show nested quote +

Of course, there was no other way for Shape to answer but in the affirmative. They both knew that anyone could be a killer, and there was no sense in thinking someone good-willed from just one clue.
Basically, Shape made an observation on virtually the only (little) information he had, and kush drew the conclusion from it and coerced him into making his own conclusion, which was "that's not enough" and labeled backtracking. It's not concerning to me.

On March 09 2016 00:22 Tumblewood wrote:

Show nested quote +

I liked how he drew a decent conclusion from Shape's observation. It shows that his question wasn't just a token "look at me participating" question.
It was, what, his first post? so I'm not putting him into either category yet.

On March 09 2016 00:26 Tumblewood wrote:
Also geript town for persistently pushing a read that wasn't gaining much traction.

Two townreads on kush + you and a non-scumread on Shape.
How the fuck do you townread him ?

Town, I like this because he is inquiring about something he is finding sus. I know that scum would prob. do the same. But I feel scum would be more generic.

On March 09 2016 06:29 Rels wrote:
##Vote Tumblewood
Around for a few more minutes then it's bed time for me.

Scum, I feel that this vote came to quickly (3 posts from tumble) from a townie PoV. He took the sus. and ran with it a bit while every else was sus (Kush was scum and voted. wonder if Scum Rels would so too. That close to a lynch (and need 2 people to join) mabye)

On March 10 2016 01:23 Rels wrote:
I don't have strong opinions apart from kush, Vivax, Shape town and Tumble scum.

A line on each player I have a hard time deciding.

yamato seemed implicated in his first batch of posts but he's been reactive since and kinda useless.

Koshi should be town by meta of being obnoxious + having short post with his flow of thoughts sometimes. My problem with that is that we just got fooled in cells mafia by LS and Damdred abusing their meta super easily. scum!Koshi might be doing the same, 'cause apart from this meta being town indicative, he's has reads that are either non-explained (Tumble, I) or bad (the yamato case).

Slam is not looking for scum. He's saying reasonnable things but it doesn't feel like he's trying to solve the game like he was in smurf.

geript is fixed on his Slam meta read + Vivax scum. Being obtus like that is generally town indicative but I showed him two games that were against his meta read and he disproved them.

townish (1/2 point to totaltowncount) I like some of Rels here, going after people (Koshi in particular because of meta and what happen last game (cell)) and stuff like that. A course, he also Towns kush (which everyone did) and vivax (a shared read.)
A part of me goes "he is keeping advures alive!!!!!" so that why this is not full town count

On March 10 2016 01:56 Rels wrote:
I can't understand anyone townreading Tumble. He should be a null at most in anyone's mind.
He has very few reads. All of his townreads are obvious. His scumread on Vivax is non-explained. He has minimal interactions with the thread.

Scumish, I do not understand why anyone would fucking lynch someone based off of 3 posts. (no offense Rels)

On March 10 2016 03:31 Rels wrote:

Show nested quote +

Even the structure of this post is scummy. In the first sentence he agrees with a scumread passively, then he has unrelated comments about two others things. It's a weird post to post for a town that found a scumread. It makes sense for a scum that needs different things to be in the thread and doesn't care about solving the game.

townish, could be scum pushing for lynch. But I believed the same At the time and he questioned it.

On March 10 2016 04:10 Rels wrote:
Tumble nothing you have listed makes Vivax scum. The first thing you list is how he found scum Damdred in cells. His treatment of Koshi is logical. I had the same sentinement regarding geript, the two things you've said there I've agreed with him: geript saying "Tumble is so town anybody scumreading him is scum" was unwarranted, geript being so fixed on his slam meta when several people are against it was weird.

Town IMO, I can't really explain why i feel like it is town. it just does

On March 10 2016 07:54 Rels wrote:
Tumble had a big post on vivax now he's voting slam ? Did he explain why or did he ninja it

I forgot this, but this was good. townish

Flip out about Gepirt unvoting

Felt like real anger. But feels a tad bit weird/off. Like I can see him posting that as either so null (i just wanted a excuse to use that gif)

On March 10 2016 22:48 Rels wrote:

Show nested quote +

On March 10 2016 09:34 yamato77 wrote:

On March 08 2016 19:43 Rels wrote:
I don't like this from Vivax:

On March 08 2016 08:34 Vivax wrote:

On March 08 2016 08:32 Shapelog wrote:

On March 08 2016 08:27 nnn_thekushmountains wrote:

On March 08 2016 08:26 Shapelog wrote:

On March 08 2016 08:25 nnn_thekushmountains wrote:

On March 08 2016 08:24 Shapelog wrote:

On March 08 2016 08:19 nnn_thekushmountains wrote:
[quote]

About vivax:
If he were scum why not use his perfectly valid pregame excuse to not show up until tomorrow?

Did you think I was implying him to be scum? I just saw that and just said something about it.

About this question, Most likely. half a day-day is not that much to miss.

Most likely what?

Most likely he would use the excuss

So Vivax is most likely town?

Yes totally kush, one situation is all that i look for as town to town read someone. Does he look townie in that situation, yes. Does that mean he is town? no. You know that that is not a reasonable town read reason.

whats the point of you mentioning me reporting in and not doing much then if its completely nai apparently

scum points for you and town points for kush

On March 08 2016 08:35 Vivax wrote:
i also give you 1 minute to tell me where the carotic sinus is

Serious post about Shape being potentially scum, immediately (it's 1 minute later and it's the next post in the thread) followed by a joke post. There is a disconnect in the way Vivax is playing the game there. He's serious and posting a scumread on a guy, and immediately after he's posting a joke to the guy he's scumreading.

This is along my line of thinking but there's definitely more to it than just the one question.

I don't understand his progression on Vivax, how he got from the post before to a strong townread here.

Notably, I also don't really care for his read on me as it shows a lack of investment in figuring out my motivations but nonetheless, it's there, I guess.

On March 10 2016 01:40 Rels wrote:
geript might be town 'cause he's invested in his reads and because he reread the game. Not lynching him today.
Would be OK with tumble, slam and yamato in that order of preferrence.

Fights geript's meta read of Slam, and then says he wants to lynch him? His justification seems weak in the above post "Slam isn't looking for scum."

Wanting to lynch me for...??? Has barely commented on any particular post of mine, and actually DISAGREED WITH KOSHI'S CASE

I strongly dislike the inconsistency of Rels' reads.

There is no fucking inconsistency.
My first batch of reads were my thoughts after reading the few pages there were at the time. Of course they are going to evolve.
Vivas has been pushing to game forward with his activity + questionning. He's very likely town.
I've been saying all game than Slam can be found as scum when he's not doing anything to advance it. I've fought geript's meta read 'cause I think it was wrong. When Slam continued to have no scumread, I scumread him.
You claimed to have read my filter but you have missed everything I've said about Slam all game ?

Scumish, feels more from a scum then a townie. I feel a townie would of been a bit more calm about it vs this. Though I am horrible about determine Rels anger authenticateness.

On March 10 2016 22:57 Rels wrote:

Show nested quote +

Disagreeing with your meta read is different from being against a slam lynch. I've been leaning on Slam scum more and more as time passed on, and I voted him after his post agreeing with you on Vivax which was nonsensical on several levels. You're reaching for explanation there.

Show nested quote +

Vivax is not a possible busser ? I thought you scumread him like a lot ?
Tumble is a possible busser ? I thought he was confirmed town ?

townish, I like his questioning here.

On March 10 2016 23:01 Rels wrote:

Show nested quote +

Koshi I'm not scum. Stop scumreading me for no reason. STOP. I'm tired. The only reason you've stated a long time ago was "Rels is not sure about some reads, saying X could be town but also scum" or something like that; It doesn't make sense. Fucking stop you're annoying.
I suppose you're talkinga bout this fucking post:

Show nested quote +

So. 4 people I'm not that sure on. Just after that I concludfe you are super likely town and geript is maybe town. This is not scummy and I'm tired of you being in my town games. You lynched me in nutcracker and melee. You townread me on crossfire and pyp. Stop being fuycking dumb and sotp saying I'm scummy.

scumish, do not like this. OMGUS basically (which is not a bad thing but w/e i do not like it and it is my read.)

On March 11 2016 00:37 Rels wrote:

Show nested quote +

This really feels like buddying.

+ Vote on vivax

Scum, He had weak reasons to vote on this wagon as i look at it. It feels like someone jumping on instead of lynching scum.

On March 14 2016 07:43 Rels wrote:

Show nested quote +

On March 10 2016 06:20 nnn_thekushmountains wrote:
I think ima vote alakaslam.
Rels makes a really good point here and makes me townread rels pretty hard.:

On March 10 2016 03:21 Rels wrote:

On March 10 2016 03:04 Alakaslam wrote:

On March 09 2016 15:02 geript wrote:

On March 08 2016 22:58 Vivax wrote:
geripts read on slam is too high for me to understand, or maybe just too contrived, but Ill sheep it if i dont nail a mafia myself before that, cuz it sounds like gerupt really believes dat stuff.

waiting for koshi to post from his uncomfortable last position

On March 09 2016 03:36 Vivax wrote:
i was hoping geript would take interest into my post about slam as that was the point where he could have gone "yes, yes! Lynch slam with me now" which would have been in line with the tryhard tone of the rest of his posts.

But let's see

I saw this in rereading and this is really, really fucking off. There's literally zero reason with Vivax's first post for me or anyone else to think that Vivax is happy about a Slam lynch. Hell, at best it's exceptionally limited and tacit approval of slam lynch.

On March 09 2016 03:33 Vivax wrote:
lol koshi is so town, cute

This also is bullshit. Koshi is more than capable of posting everything he has as scum.

On March 09 2016 03:38 Vivax wrote:
here's a vote with secret reasons (for now):

##Vote tumblewood

This is even more bullshit. There's not a single read or point or anything here.

Literally the only thing Vivax has done this whole game is dance outside of issues. He's posted a worthless reads post with no reasoning whatsoever. He prods people and gets them to focus on lots of little bullshit things which are irrelevant. He's asking questions of other people and somehow never gives a real opinion on anyone. It's working on 48 hours and literally all he's doing is leading people around by the nose.

If you guys aren't going to lynch SLam, then Vivax is clearly the next best option.

These are excellent points

Btw while I didn't mention it, TY shape I clearly did not look at OP :/

And am clearly confused hoodwinked whatever.

"geript is right, Vivax calling Koshi town is based on nothing".
But you have the exact same read on Koshi than Vivax ??

On March 09 2016 06:00 Alakaslam wrote:

On March 09 2016 05:58 Rels wrote:

On March 09 2016 05:43 yamato77 wrote:
Rels, what do you make of Koshi?

Maybe scum. He has excuses to not post a lot like he does as town +<script id="gpt-impl-0.9145947964961816" src="http://partner.googleadservices.com/gpt/pubads_impl_81.js"></script> I don't understand his case on you.

Koshi is quite clearly town in my mind.

Yeah that was the post I had in mind. Kush said he would vote Slam and didn't do it, when at the time Slam was 1 vote away from being hammered:

Show nested quote +

D3 he pushed and voted Slam though but not with a lot of strength. This added with Slam's play, I think he is the last scum.
##Vote Alakaslam

Townie, came to same conclusion i did. Like the post as well.

On March 14 2016 18:05 Rels wrote:

Show nested quote +

If Slam or Tumble don't claim now but claim at LYLO they should be lynched.
If one is blue it's good for us 'cause we don't have to use a lynch for him.

I can understand this since unlike normal games, this game has random roles and with 1 blue can always Cced a false claim.
Though mafia can do it either so meh.
Townie points as long as Rels does not claim anything.

On March 14 2016 23:32 Rels wrote:
Slam if you're blue claim now or rescind your right to do it forever.

Idk how not doing it in a hour would of change anything. As long as it is before 2 hours before deadline it should be fine.

Final count:
Town Level: 5
Scum Level: 3 1/2

Verdict: Town. I also agree with Yam point about partner, though did not consider it while looking at the posts.

Koshi:
I had a tinfoil theory on him, being lazy in such (as he said himself) and slacking + something else my mind thought of last night (i had a crazy night). Though this post from gerpit made me see light.

On March 14 2016 14:53 geript wrote:

Show nested quote +

This is the most interesting Kush post so far. Koshi and Vivax had been getting into it and Kush is a little 'chill out'-y. It's interesting to me because the Vivax Koshi spat was relatively tame by TL standards for dick contests. So far Kush has been interjecting to push and prod people towards conclusions or towards forcing them into a stance of some kind that he can jump on, but here he doesn't. Koshi's worth a specific read.

On March 14 2016 14:55 geript wrote:
I'd also add the Kush post doesn't really prod Koshi or Vivax on more really which seems a bit more typical if town-town action.

Plus I really can't find anything to scum read the guy heavily that I believe in.

Gerpit:
I was sus. about him at 1st (D1) but now after a bit he seems more townie. His recent postings made me think more of him being town too.

On March 14 2016 14:53 geript wrote:

Show nested quote +

On March 14 2016 15:53 geript wrote:
The more I see Tumble posts the more bullied his posts look. Less original thought and more plagiarizing others reads. I kinda want to lynch Rels because he I think gives the most info. But I like Yams reasons for him being a less likely partner. Koshi's going to call me bad, but I think Koshi isn't a bad lynch. I'm going to go to bed and reread myself and tumble when I get up. Like, I think I want to lynch tumble to keep him out of lylo.

Town.

Tumble:
Reasons to scum: weak ideas over all. typically followed the feel of the thread for the most part. Vivax read progression (Vivax is top scum -> Vote Vivax -> Vote Slam -> Vote vivax)
Reasons to town: Kush push on him. post:

On March 11 2016 04:09 Tumblewood wrote:
Vivax's Shape comment is weird coming from scum; they'd just put it in their QT.
Of course, that's also weird coming from town, but less so.

Does not rub me as a scum trying to get cred from being on a opposing wagon as scum. Scum would most likely post the 1st line and that is it (or expand on it).
Fact that tumble is striking me as Scum!Tumble

I have a gut read that tumble is town here. Mainly just because it feels right to me, about him being town. I can understand how people are sus. of him. But to me he is town. What I would need to think he is scum, is a huge fuck (IMO) or someone who can convince me.

Still need to technically Dive Yammty (I think he is town but won't hurt to check) and look more closely at Rels and Kush filter as a whole.
I am asking @everyone (minus Koshi b/c talk to the hand gf) did I miss something in tumble or anything else that I should know about?

Shapelog

United States5184 Posts

March 14 2016 22:08 GMT

#1032

Like I am in a block here because I really only find Slam Scummy and, while I think Tumble and Rels could be scum. I am trusting my gut on tumble and after reviewing, Rels came to town.

Shapelog

United States5184 Posts

March 14 2016 22:11 GMT

#1033

Well Slam is 91% mafia in my eyes so we win in 48 mins

Shapelog

United States5184 Posts

March 14 2016 22:15 GMT

#1034

I mean Hapa is still scum in my eyes but you people do not even consider him a threat!
I even made a case, but no one listen

Half the Sky

Germany9029 Posts

March 14 2016 22:16 GMT

#1035

Vote Count - Day 2

Alakaslam (4): geript, Tumblewood, Rels, ~~Koshi~~, Shapelog
Tumblewood (2): Alakaslam, yamato77
Shapelog (1): ~~Alakaslam~~, ~~Koshi~~, Koshi
Rels (0): ~~Koshi~~

Not Voting (0):

At this time, Alakaslam is slated to be lynched. With 7 players, 4 are needed to lynch.
The next check will occur on 23:00 GMT (+00:00).
Town must find the mafia before on 23:00 GMT (+00:00)

The voting thread is here.
Only votes there will be counted.

Shapelog

United States5184 Posts

March 14 2016 22:21 GMT

#1036

On March 15 2016 07:16 Half the Sky wrote:

Vote Count - Day 2

Other than Koshi not changing vote to make a lynch (which we do not even know if he was serious or not).
OMG LOOK! HAPA CAN'T EVEN BE ASKED TO VOTE COUNTZZBABJSBAIDBASDBKASBDKAJSBDKJASDKABDJ! SCUMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM!!!!!!!!!