Who Wants to be a Millionaire Cell Mini Mafia - Page 105
Forum Index > TL Mafia |
Shapelog
United States5184 Posts
| ||
Damdred
15669 Posts
I guess the townread isn't bad in principle because I agree. I just don't think it should be that easy for you to tr obi without perfect information meh. | ||
Shapelog
United States5184 Posts
Like I was really sus. of OWS for not doing much during the 1st few days. But I looked at him and lately he made me think he is town. | ||
Shapelog
United States5184 Posts
| ||
Kuragari42
United States346 Posts
Shapelog - Post 290: Original reads.+ Show Spoiler + On February 23 2016 23:27 Shapelog wrote: Anyways. I skimmed the thread, (I might have tinfoil already btw ) It is a bit early in the game. But I rather have this written down. Going to be helpful this game So Cell A: We have Rik, SL, and Kura. Funny enough, I have played with each of these lovely people once. They also all died before D2 when I played with them. I really do not know a lot about them. Rik, Who I want to town read, but have this "tryhard scum" feel from him. Pardonidia is a bitch right? SL, Has a weird entrance but is just weird in general. So I need to watch him. And then Kura. Kura from what I know, is a low content poster (as town mind you). He got lynched in the Newbie due to "Scum slip." For those wanting a filter from him that game: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/502408-newbie-student-mafia-xix?user=Kuragari42 From what i can tell, he was much more Srsy. in that game than this one. This one he is joking and stuff like that. It is different from b/4 though to say the least. Maybe the Free posting from him is just him excited. Cell B: So I am with Damdred and Obi. And one of them is scum. Wow, ok, that is different. So we got Damdred who is campaigning for mayor VS. Obi who hasn't done anything other then state questions or post 1/2 liners. So we got a scum between Tryhard guy and underwhelming guy. Prob. read closely at Damdred posts after this. Since this is my cell, I really do not care for the record when we go. Doesn't matter to me (although you people might have meta things and stuff like.) I just really do not want Mayor to go to Damdred mainly just b/c of him being in my cell. Cell C: Darth/KubRels/LS Oh wow, talk about strong townies (except one isn't). Darth from what I have played with him (Newbie XIX, Blue) is a strong town player. KubRels, well I scum read him and push him heavily b/4 as town, so need to watch that. I prob. look at his filter from Nut just to get idea of him again. But Content from him needs to be judged And then LS, who is stated to be hard to read. Idk about tbh, a lot of times he seems easy to read. However I have never rolled scum with him. I really do not know where to start on this one. Prob. wait a bit (prob. start of D1) before filter diving and trying to read them. Cell D: FF/Breskhe/VA People who I have not really played with or played briefly with. Quick Filter dive feels: FF: Happy to be "Town", which IIRC, Kush stated that he would have a scum burnout. That prob. filters into that post a bit tbh. Then reinstates it which feels weird. Another thing that stands out: He does not seem to care about why Breshke is being scum read by his other cell mate VA. I find it strange that FF, knowing if he is town that 1 or the other is scum, does not care about why they scum read each other. It just feels like FF didn't care. Breskhe: Anti-Mayor, Most of his talk is about set up. Fine with Damdred or Rit as mayor. I like the fact that he did not want afk players last. I agree with him on that, I feel that strong townies can help the game progress and help overall with the cells. Other than that, he really has not done anything. Kinda just talked about set up and left. VA: Scum reads! Scum reads everywhere! Wow, this guy is very aggressive. He really has not stated why he is scum reading people. But that actually makes me feel like he might be town. I feel personally that scum would feel the need to explain their scum reads. His attention is weirdly focused on My cell (B) and his Cell (D). I feel out the 3, right now if i had to pick, I say FF is scum. Does not make sense IMO, that he would not care about his other cell mates (while being town) scum reading each other. Especially since he would know that 1 of them had to be scum. Is a bit early though. So who knows. Maybe FF will blow me away or something. Cell E: Kush/Vivax/BUM MY MAN KUSH! I have played many of town games with Kush (I actually think, that all my games, Nut, Newbies 1&2, etc.) I have played with him. So Kush should know me very well. On the other hand, I have never played with scum Kush. So idk what to look at him for. His involvement + his attitude makes me want to TL him. So that Leaves Vivax and BUM. Which prob. is going to need a PoE in the long run. + Show Spoiler [things for me to remember for later.] + Bum: Wants his cell to go second last. posted nothing. and kinda peaces. I find him not wanting his cell to go till near the end a bit sus. Though it does fall in line with other peoples logic (Making them go on D3.) Vivax interested in trying to find scum in his cell. He feels different than from Nut (which is not much, considering I expect any scum like that to change their play-style). His other post is a bit weak. One that stands out is "KubRel for Mayor post." Does not make sense really from a scum perspective to me. Even if they are a team. I agree that this cell should go D3 maybe, Just note that that is the weekend cell. Post 590: He stresses upon Damdred's bad (and we now know, false) thought.+ Show Spoiler + On February 24 2016 22:00 Shapelog wrote: I like that thought of yours too. Mafia would just push the 1v1 instead of trying to convince Breshke not to use it. Especially since there are some more useful cells to use that on. I am going to look into VA after i catch up. My reasoning to TR him doesn't feel good to me after sleeping. Post 593: Goes back on 590. + Show Spoiler + Post 625: Good post calling out Breshke. Though this may be just scums complete bus of him.+ Show Spoiler + On February 25 2016 00:27 Shapelog wrote: I do not like this post. So he has not reason to scum read anyone, but yet then scums VA. That in itself is a bit weird. But then says he is going to filter VA. 180 from Filter diving VA. This was right after he posted saying he was going to filter dive VA. It is strange that he does not follow up on his scum read and instead go after some who he think is town. If he thinks that FF is town, and if he is town, then he should be focusing hard on VA. But he does isn't Breshke is Scum! and I am sorry to FF for calling him scum Post 674: Says that VA may just have RL issues when VA was being way more active than Breshke.+ Show Spoiler + Eh like Man VA might just have RL stuff. Going to vote the person who I think is scum. ##Vote: Breshke Post 685: Responds to the above issue by saying he was talking to himself? I don’t get it and will be surprised if someone doesn't call him out. + Show Spoiler + On February 25 2016 03:43 Shapelog wrote: Was talking to myself. Post 879: Misrepresents darth by cutting a post short.+ Show Spoiler + On February 25 2016 22:16 Shapelog wrote: + = Confusion. Darth wants people to see that he is different from his scum game in unoriginal (which was Unthemed.) But when I pull up a another unthemed game (A Newbie but still) he says it is completely different. I would of been fine if he said "Shapelog, it is different because that is a Newbie." But instead he said "Shapelog it is different because this is themed." Post 886: He admits that he would bus his teammates were he scum. + Show Spoiler + On February 25 2016 22:37 Shapelog wrote: If I was scum, 9/10 I would bus. I am willing to bus team mates (see Newbie XIX) as needed. Though I am town, and came to a conclusion that breskhe was scum b/4 50/50. Post 900/895: Shape seems surprised that he cut off the Star Wars part of darth’s post despite mentioning it just 5 posts before. I like how he doesn't bold the part where darth pretty much says you can't compare the two because it was newbie (playing with much better and experienced players).+ Show Spoiler + On February 25 2016 22:57 Shapelog wrote: There was a bit about star wars!?! Post 922: He promises reads 2-3 hours later. Let's see if he fulfills.. Post 944: He did Cell A (the last cell to go) reads first? Maybe to make it appear as though he is being helpful without providing relevant info. + Show Spoiler + On February 26 2016 00:07 Shapelog wrote: Post 1016: He did post his reads! He makes decent cases on several people but I don't like his reads on me, noon, or Vivax. A lot of his points on those 3 feel forced.+ Show Spoiler + On February 26 2016 04:08 Shapelog wrote: Post 1104: Says he needs to recheck his PM to confirm that he is town. Never comes back with the answer. + Show Spoiler + On February 26 2016 06:54 Shapelog wrote: Post 1361: Scum slip. So Scum Darth [i]would be and Town Darth is ..+ Show Spoiler + On February 27 2016 09:36 Shapelog wrote: 1. I agree with Darth, I feel his read on Breshke at the time makes sense. Mainly because there was not a lot to go off of. And the votes count, while misleading, could just be a simple mistake on Darth's behalf. I do not understand how it would help scum to lie about VC when it is so easy to look at. 2. I can understand Darths defense and questioning about Rel's VA read. I do not think, however, Rels fabricated it in anyway to TR VA while bussing Breshke. Especially when FF or VA could of been pushed for lack of content Etc at that point. 3. Darth logics makes sense. 4. I agree with Rels, I personally feel like Darth is spending to much time defending himself. But What else is he going to do? Half the thread (if not all of it) is scum reading him. But He could be finding more holes etc. while proving his town stats. Darth did jump ahead however and answer 5 in his response to 4. (Meta reads help cause theses btw.) 5. He did read them. 6. I think Darth should I have a read at this point (maybe not on LS because not a whole lot for a newbie to go off of.) But it makes sense for Darth to point out scum things (just like I have been doing with my cell) 7. 2 ponts that are NAI are, guess what NAI! Darth could of cited the vote timing of rel btw.... Darth OMGUS on Rels: Really NAI, Scum Darth would be trying to ML Rels if he saw a opening. Town Darth Is prob. pissed at Rels. Rels not wanting to use the Obs power being Scummy:Could be tbh., It is a weak power. If we are going ot use it, Rik needs to use it now. Post 1830: 2 minutes logic is wrong. + Show Spoiler + On March 01 2016 03:08 Shapelog wrote: Post 2014: He says that Damdred is scummy because he was tunneling me, then he says Damdred is scummy for not caring about Cell A. That seems to be a direct contradiction.+ Show Spoiler + Ok I am barly able to see the screen anymore and I am just looking at my keyboard to type. My tinfoil theory (which i have not fully looked at btw) basically puts Damdred/Sl as scum together because of a few reasons. One, He seems tunneled on Kura, but rarely meations SL. even called SL useless and not caring (but yet that does not seem to send off red flags as of late.) however I soon as i say i thought Kura was town. Damdred jumped on me. Two, He does not even seem to really care about Cell A. He is like "wow your cell is hard." yet it was one of the easier cells in the game tbh. there is not really a lot to ponder other which of the 2 do you think is more lazy. There is more, But i need eyes really to fitler dive. Prob. worth doing a associative read for both OWS and Damdred with the 2 flipped scum (and maybe Darth as well, though, that might not be fair tbh). Post 2075: This case for Shape’s TR on Obi doesn't seem very strong to me.+ Show Spoiler + [QUOTE]On March 03 2016 01:37 Shapelog wrote: [QUOTE]On March 03 2016 01:12 Damdred wrote: Ows is generally a hard person to read even obi admits that. So will you e,plain your tr in depth? Well sure bob! Well 1st lets start here: this cycle. [QUOTE]On March 02 2016 23:38 ObiWanShinobi wrote: Damdred could you elaborate a bit on why you think Shape is mafia? Same goes for Shape, actually - I can't really follow why either of you think the other is mafia which is bugging me because I keep flipping my read every 10 seconds or so.[/QUOTE] [QUOTE]On March 02 2016 23:48 ObiWanShinobi wrote: [QUOTE]On March 02 2016 23:40 Shapelog wrote: [QUOTE]On March 02 2016 23:38 ObiWanShinobi wrote: Damdred could you elaborate a bit on why you think Shape is mafia? Same goes for Shape, actually - I can't really follow why either of you think the other is mafia which is bugging me because I keep flipping my read every 10 seconds or so.[/QUOTE] Did you see my post on damdred in the last page? Anyways, I think Damdred is scum because of PoE, and on a closer dive, stuff like a brought up about how he handle Breshke.[/QUOTE] I don't know if PoE really works for me tbh - I can't come up with concrete reasons for either of you being town. It might be easy for you but for me, not so much. I read your post. It seemed okay but I sort of understood how Damdred could get there as well.[/QUOTE] OWS can easily follow his read progression this game and just push my death. Instead he is considering both options instead of taking the easy bait. Scum could easily get a point here with my death and Etc. [QUOTE]On February 28 2016 05:42 ObiWanShinobi wrote: Damdred. Fucking do something.[/QUOTE] [QUOTE]On February 28 2016 05:47 ObiWanShinobi wrote: I have to head to work now. I will be watching as best I can. Damdred needs to vote - I don't know what he's doing now but I'm losing my mind over it.[/QUOTE] [QUOTE]On February 28 2016 05:52 ObiWanShinobi wrote: [QUOTE]On February 28 2016 05:51 Damdred wrote: Obi shut the fuck up I'll do things as I get time to do them. I got called into work after I ate because I take they are passed at me for giving a two weeks notice but that's beside the point. @Ritoky, here's the issue I have. Darth feels a bit town in some of his later postings and it sorta feels to me like Rels is trying to zero in on the lynch. And I'm not sure which way to go a small bit. I do think Darth is a little to defense oriented but his reads list give us a lot of information if he is scum at the same time. And I see that coming from town more than scum in this situation[/QUOTE] Sorry, forgot about your interview and junk.[/QUOTE] Something about this rubs me as town. Like he is interested in your vote, but yet aren't pushing your voting logic were I feel scum who do the opposite. He also did not just vote bum and peace. He was interested in our cell [QUOTE]On February 28 2016 10:49 ObiWanShinobi wrote: Fair enough. So, talk to me a bit about Damdred?[/QUOTE] [QUOTE]On February 28 2016 10:50 ObiWanShinobi wrote: Normally I'm really comfortable reading him one way or the other but I at least want to pick at him a bit before our cell is on the block.[/QUOTE] [QUOTE]On February 28 2016 10:39 ObiWanShinobi wrote: I think now is the time we take a serious look at Damdred at this point. Why do you think he's town?[/QUOTE] I can go on if i want, which i am going to. He also does not have a sense of "I GOT TO DO SOMETHING" I feel scum in this situation, even if the heat is not on them, would be doing what me and damdred are doing and posting things to try to convince people they are not scum. [/QUOTE] With just reading Shape's filter, I'd say he is scum . | ||
Kuragari42
United States346 Posts
On March 03 2016 02:00 Shapelog wrote: wheres your amazing shapelog read Kura? Epic, not amazing. | ||
Shapelog
United States5184 Posts
Also even If I was to come back with and say it was town, that would make you think i was town? | ||
Kuragari42
United States346 Posts
On March 03 2016 02:00 Shapelog wrote: Damage to the brain from interruption of its blood supply. -google Becauselly your brain cannot get enough blood. Wow. You didn't even catch it the second time.. stoke.. | ||
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
Vote Count Shapelog (1): sicklucker Not Voted (5): Kuragari42, Shapelog, ritoky, ObiWanShinobi, Damdred Currently, Shapelog is slated to be lynched. Also, everyone not voting is slated to be modkilled. You have to place your vote here. Voting is mandatory. You may not abstain. | ||
Kuragari42
United States346 Posts
On March 03 2016 02:15 Shapelog wrote: Lol You think i was srs. with the PM check? Also even If I was to come back with and say it was town, that would make you think i was town? I was sort of joking with that part lol. If you had come back and said you were town it would not have been remarkable. | ||
Shapelog
United States5184 Posts
| ||
Kuragari42
United States346 Posts
@Everyone Is LS known for playing a lot of LOL? | ||
Shapelog
United States5184 Posts
Yeah if he cares about Cell A he wouldn't be so focused on you and not really on SL. He is not even really focused on SL, but when i called you townie yesterday he instantly asked why. | ||
ObiWanShinobi
United States8089 Posts
| ||
Shapelog
United States5184 Posts
| ||
Kuragari42
United States346 Posts
On March 03 2016 02:23 Shapelog wrote: And me saying 2 mins is why I think Damdred was NAI off of those post is also Scum? Poor logic is what makes that post scummy. | ||
Shapelog
United States5184 Posts
On March 03 2016 02:29 Kuragari42 wrote: Poor logic is what makes that post scummy. Can you electorate on why my logic was poor? | ||
Shapelog
United States5184 Posts
Donald Drumpf has gotten into my head. | ||
Kuragari42
United States346 Posts
On March 03 2016 02:27 Shapelog wrote: Post 2014: He says that Damdred is scummy because he was tunneling me, then he says Damdred is scummy for not caring about Cell A. That seems to be a direct contradiction. Yeah if he cares about Cell A he wouldn't be so focused on you and not really on SL. He is not even really focused on SL, but when i called you townie yesterday he instantly asked why. I don't understand the bolded. "He wouldn't be so focused on you and not really on SL." So he already has who he think is scum in Cell A, he therefore doesn't care about Cell A? "But when I called you townie yesterday he instantly asked why." He asks you about your town read on his scum read. What about that makes him scummy?? | ||
Damdred
15669 Posts
On March 03 2016 02:27 ObiWanShinobi wrote: Both of my suspects in the final cell are voting shape... Maybe they are putting their eggs into one of them winning the last cell. Whcih one do you think is more likely scum out of SL and kor? | ||
| ||