Newbie Student Mafia X - Page 92

How did is filter cocnfirm any of that? Its easily possible to bus in this setup.

It's honestly stupid, but it is easy.

dDidnt he call me mafia too?

So does that confirm me?

disformation

Germany8352 Posts

May 29 2015 17:40 GMT

#1823

On May 30 2015 02:27 boxerfred wrote:

Show nested quote +

Yes. You still did not answer my question. I was not asking how you came down to that list, I was asking how you said "There is a godfather" and "bunnies is greenchecked and thus a confirmed townie". I can get point one. I can get point two. If you say both at the same time, you create a paradox.

... FFS
Next try:

Make a pool of all people alive.
Remove people with claims and checks and so on
If we randomly lynch one of those people we have a 66% chance to hit mafia IF there is no GF
[*]IF there is a GF: this chance is 33% IF one of bunnies or barakos is the GF

This is not a paradox...
better?

@sicklucker:
Care to explain why you said BM might be scum in this post:

On May 26 2015 21:37 sicklucker wrote:
Well im pretty convinced. One scum is definitely [b##unvote ]##vote 21ninjabunnies

When she flips ill figure out which one of sulp/barak/boxerfred made up fake reasons to scum read. Could also be bm

Earlier D2 you had him cleared off all suspicion after reading through scott's filter and saying scott spewed him town.

sicklucker

Canada16986 Posts

May 29 2015 17:42 GMT

#1824

On May 30 2015 02:31 27ninjabunnies wrote:

Show nested quote +

How did is filter cocnfirm any of that? Its easily possible to bus in this setup.

It's honestly stupid, but it is easy.

dDidnt he call me mafia too?

So does that confirm me?

nope get mad about it. His first post was him trying to get on my good side. His second post was pushing plots.His third post was pushing bm.

3 towns spewed by a 3 post mafia.

sicklucker

Canada16986 Posts

May 29 2015 17:43 GMT

#1825

bm was at like the end of my poe list and I barely mentioned him at the end of my kill reads once. Im not gonna 100% clear him for what scott said but it did hold alot of weight.

boxerfred

Germany8360 Posts

May 29 2015 17:44 GMT

#1826

On May 30 2015 02:40 disformation wrote:

Show nested quote +

... FFS
Next try:

Make a pool of all people alive.
Remove people with claims and checks and so on
If we randomly lynch one of those people we have a 66% chance to hit mafia IF there is no GF
[*]IF there is a GF: this chance is 33% IF one of bunnies or barakos is the GF

This is not a paradox...
better?

@sicklucker:
Care to explain why you said BM might be scum in this post:

Show nested quote +

Earlier D2 you had him cleared off all suspicion after reading through scott's filter and saying scott spewed him town.

..much better. I like that explanation

. ##unvote

sicklucker

Canada16986 Posts

May 29 2015 17:44 GMT

#1827

The way bm unvoted me when I unvoted him made me a lil suspicious still

boxerfred

Germany8360 Posts

May 29 2015 17:44 GMT

#1828

Also I love how your posts starts with "FFS" and ends with "

" :D

disformation

Germany8352 Posts

May 29 2015 17:48 GMT

#1829

On May 30 2015 01:59 Sulfurus wrote:
@Tictock please please please don't vote on Plots today. Obviously Batsnacks dies tonight but on the next night Mafia has to kill him since at this point he is a superior medic (he can prevent a KP regardless of who it is on and he confirms a mafia) so there is no point in doing mafia's job for them. This is what I was trying to say with my previous post so hopefully this gets through to you this time.

Right now my POE list is NinjaBunnies, Sicklucker, BoxerFred, and Disformation (no offense to the town on the list, I just think Barakos is townier) so we should lynch one of those names, preferably Bunnies.

And yes if a VT ever gets NK before a blue feel free to go ham on Plots.

This post honestly looks like town getting town to stop doing stuff. Sound reasoning. PoE list looks reasonable. But I'd like to hear a few explanations about that.

27ninjabunnies starts to give me an annoyed/frustrated town vibe... and I kinda have a feeling that D2 was between two town wagons (yeah a feeling is probably not a really solid reasoning, but whatevs :p). I am also not really fond of the odds of lynching into a green check...

On May 30 2015 02:06 27ninjabunnies wrote:

Show nested quote +

Lol, i dont care about the scott flip. Scott did nthing to help us find the other two mafia. We have no reads based on that except for voting and probably high bussing. Im going off of what i know.

How is that not original? I was reading Sulfurus town day 1. Many people have been calling me scummy for this, but i am reevaluating my read.

I gave what I have already. I said we dont lynch any of the claimed roles, and we dont lynch the greenchecks. The greencheck on the other person that was checked could very well be real, and i know the greencheck on me is real because i am town.

So I really need to look into my two remaining choices:
boxerfred and sicklucker...

disformation

Germany8352 Posts

May 29 2015 17:50 GMT

#1830

On May 30 2015 02:44 boxerfred wrote:
Also I love how your posts starts with "FFS" and ends with "

" :D

Yeah at first I was like "Ugh! This is not rocket science!" and then I was like "okay, this is much easier to understand than before."

boxerfred

Germany8360 Posts

May 29 2015 17:57 GMT

#1831

On May 30 2015 02:48 disformation wrote:

Show nested quote +

So I really need to look into my two remaining choices:
boxerfred and sicklucker...

Yeah, or you and sicklucker *rolls eyes*. You and me are so fucking interchangeable. Since I'm not maf, I'm re-picking up my vote on you. ##vote Disformation. Seriously you're not even trying to understand my reads regarding plots and 27nb, you just keep yolo'ing on people. I'm willing to bet money on you unvoting in a bit and follow the main train anyways. I said it before and I say it again, I do not like this play at all.

boxerfred

Germany8360 Posts

May 29 2015 18:01 GMT

#1832

I really wanna get RB'ed next night. That would imply two things: a) if I'm a scum member and decide to kill someone I'll be blocked b) if scum decides to not shoot someone to make townies feel like there was no NK due to me being blocked and make me look scum by that, cop survives another night.

boxerfred

Germany8360 Posts

May 29 2015 18:02 GMT

#1833

also that would strengthen the RB claim a lot - basically doing what batsnacks advised.

boxerfred

Germany8360 Posts

May 29 2015 18:04 GMT

#1834

also whoever gets roleblocked when a NK happens is basically confirmed town so yeah here we go. Just don't lynch the RB today.

disformation

Germany8352 Posts

May 29 2015 18:09 GMT

#1835

On May 30 2015 02:57 boxerfred wrote:
Yeah, or you and sicklucker *rolls eyes*. You and me are so fucking interchangeable. Since I'm not maf, I'm re-picking up my vote on you. ##vote Disformation. Seriously you're not even trying to understand my reads regarding plots and 27nb, you just keep yolo'ing on people. I'm willing to bet money on you unvoting in a bit and follow the main train anyways. I said it before and I say it again, I do not like this play at all.

You are awefully quick to pick up that vote after I mention your name.

And I think I already unvoted. (Vote count please?)

But stay with me:
Without the blue claims and myself who is left:
bunnies: who looks not good at all on D2 and D3, but has a green check. Not 100% comfortable to lynch a green check.
Sulfurus: who looked really good D1, did nothing D2, looks at bit better as of today.
boxerfred: Not really sold either way.
sicklucker: Looks pretty good D3, but there are some D2 plays that confuse me and he hasn't even bothered to explain. Also ridic hard to read overall.
disformation: yeah I am not the greatest, but in my mind it is obvious that I am at trying to solve this. I am also trying to show you WHY I am waffling that much. Also since sicklucker tried this already we know that I am not allowed to vote myself.

So. 3+ people on that list are town making the game a lot harder and I am having a hard time deciding who on that list is the scummiest person around.

27ninjabunnies

United States2486 Posts

May 29 2015 18:11 GMT

#1836

On May 30 2015 02:42 sicklucker wrote:

Show nested quote +

nope get mad about it. His first post was him trying to get on my good side. His second post was pushing plots.His third post was pushing bm.

3 towns spewed by a 3 post mafia.

We dont know you are town.

boxerfred

Germany8360 Posts

May 29 2015 18:12 GMT

#1837

On May 30 2015 03:09 disformation wrote:

Show nested quote +

You are awefully quick to pick up that vote after I mention your name.

So. 3+ people on that list are town making the game a lot harder and I am having a hard time deciding who on that list is the scummiest person around.

Yeah keep going at me. Oh you already did what I expected you to do. Now get on a train please. Your pattern switched so fucking hard since there was a coinflip on a scum member on D1. I pointed that out like every single day until now. "You're not the greatest"? More WIFOM please.