EPTAlso bunnies, no coaching discussion t.t
So that's my take on the current lynch flavour of the day, conclusion, I don't think that's good enough to lynch. Would want to hear more from him.
Detention Mafia - Page 9
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
gobbledydook
Australia2593 Posts
Also bunnies, no coaching discussion t.t So that's my take on the current lynch flavour of the day, conclusion, I don't think that's good enough to lynch. Would want to hear more from him. | ||
|
fuba
United States663 Posts
...Though now that I think of it, unless the scumteam is the exact three people it was last time, then jabber would be incredibly unlikely to intentionally lie about who was on it, since at least one scum from last game would be town this game and would point out that he's lying. So either this was just a mistake on his part or I'm misunderstanding some part of the interaction. Either way, I'm pretty sure I've talked myself out of this... ##Unvote | ||
|
Amiko
United States1725 Posts
Slam’s posting is usually fun, but occasionally frustrating since it’s not always clear what he means, so it can be hard to draw a read from that. I don’t think it is inherently bad On Jabberwockzerg I felt jabber’s first post was a bit odd because he copied his post from the prior game (where he was scum) and I feel like he might have a different opening if he was town. I also think bunnies may be onto something, but I’m not sure if her post (http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/451317-detention-mafia?page=6#106) realizes the more damning point or not (it’s sorta weirdly written) so I’ll write it just in case. To me, what is suspicious about jabber’s post is that he suggested a player was mafia last game, but he knew that the player was not mafia last game. In other words, he offered a scenario as a counterpoint that he knew to be false. It’d be fine if he said he was just raising the point as a possibility, but his answer (that he didn’t know it was public information) doesn’t look so hot. I’m not convinced on him yet, but I want to pursue this. @Jabberwockzerg: 27ninjabunnies has raised a point regarding your play that she argues shows you are mafia. You also posted that she was doing a lot of finger pointing on day one. Do you think her point on you is good? Do you feel that her raising that point makes her more likely to be town or mafia? @fuba and @HaruRH: You joined the vote on jabberwockzerg. I understand that you agree with bunnies’ point on him – what do you think of jabberwockzerg’s responses after bunnies’ vote? Do they feel more town or scum to you? aside @HaruRH: This is not game-oriented, but I really like the “God Knows” song from Haruhi and love to sing it in karaoke :D | ||
|
Amiko
United States1725 Posts
| ||
|
HaruRH
Singapore2780 Posts
On May 27 2014 15:33 Amiko wrote: @slOosh re: Alakaslam style of posting Slam’s posting is usually fun, but occasionally frustrating since it’s not always clear what he means, so it can be hard to draw a read from that. I don’t think it is inherently bad On Jabberwockzerg I felt jabber’s first post was a bit odd because he copied his post from the prior game (where he was scum) and I feel like he might have a different opening if he was town. I also think bunnies may be onto something, but I’m not sure if her post (http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/451317-detention-mafia?page=6#106) realizes the more damning point or not (it’s sorta weirdly written) so I’ll write it just in case. To me, what is suspicious about jabber’s post is that he suggested a player was mafia last game, but he knew that the player was not mafia last game. In other words, he offered a scenario as a counterpoint that he knew to be false. It’d be fine if he said he was just raising the point as a possibility, but his answer (that he didn’t know it was public information) doesn’t look so hot. I’m not convinced on him yet, but I want to pursue this. @Jabberwockzerg: 27ninjabunnies has raised a point regarding your play that she argues shows you are mafia. You also posted that she was doing a lot of finger pointing on day one. Do you think her point on you is good? Do you feel that her raising that point makes her more likely to be town or mafia? @fuba and @HaruRH: You joined the vote on jabberwockzerg. I understand that you agree with bunnies’ point on him – what do you think of jabberwockzerg’s responses after bunnies’ vote? Do they feel more town or scum to you? aside @HaruRH: This is not game-oriented, but I really like the “God Knows” song from Haruhi and love to sing it in karaoke :D what I understood from all jabber's responses are either a high level of newbie play, or scum. I will provide examples later after I get on a computer. Will not unvote until jabber defends himself convincingly | ||
|
Alakaslam
United States17322 Posts
| ||
|
Palmar
Iceland22630 Posts
| ||
|
Palmar
Iceland22630 Posts
##Vote Ninjabunnies it's because he wrote "XD" | ||
|
gobbledydook
Australia2593 Posts
On May 27 2014 18:34 Palmar wrote: Ninjabunnies is mafia, I'm going to vote him. Then I'm going to read another page of the game. ##Vote Ninjabunnies it's because he wrote "XD" ??? Did you become crazy after getting ##Nuked in that other game? | ||
|
Palmar
Iceland22630 Posts
On May 27 2014 18:36 gobbledydook wrote: ??? Did you become crazy after getting ##Nuked in that other game? Do you not think this is a valid case? At least you have to explain to me why you disagree. I think it's a pretty strong case. I should add that I combine it with the "ugh" from his first post, oh and his plea that "can we now hunt some scum?". Seems pretty ironclad to me. | ||
|
gobbledydook
Australia2593 Posts
On May 27 2014 18:40 Palmar wrote: Do you not think this is a valid case? At least you have to explain to me why you disagree. I think it's a pretty strong case. I should add that I combine it with the "ugh" from his first post, oh and his plea that "can we now hunt some scum?". Seems pretty ironclad to me. No I don't think that's a valid case, I think you're trolling. | ||
|
Palmar
Iceland22630 Posts
On May 27 2014 18:41 gobbledydook wrote: No I don't think that's a valid case, I think you're trolling. I'm not, why do you think I'm trolling. Granted, I'm only about 2 pages or so into the game as we speak, + skimming Ninja's filter. But I feel pretty good about this. Could you elaborate on why you think I'm trolling? Or at least if there is something you don't understand in my case, ask for an explanation? | ||
|
gobbledydook
Australia2593 Posts
On May 27 2014 18:43 Palmar wrote: I'm not, why do you think I'm trolling. Granted, I'm only about 2 pages or so into the game as we speak, + skimming Ninja's filter. But I feel pretty good about this. Could you elaborate on why you think I'm trolling? Or at least if there is something you don't understand in my case, ask for an explanation? Because I reject your assumption that XD, ugh and 'can we now hunt some scum' as pointing to any alignment. I'm done arguing with you on this. | ||
|
27ninjabunnies
United States2486 Posts
On May 27 2014 15:12 gobbledydook wrote: Hm, bunnies' case against jabberwockzerg is interesting, but I'm not sure that logic necessarily stands. Specifically, bunnies discounts the possibility that jabber really didn't know who was mafia in the game he looked at and was just plain guessing, not knowing that everyone else knows the answer already. So I would be hesitant to read too deeply into that one lead. Also bunnies, no coaching discussion t.t So that's my take on the current lynch flavour of the day, conclusion, I don't think that's good enough to lynch. Would want to hear more from him. I never talked about coaches. I talked about haru- who is a player in this game- was coaching jabber to change the subject. Also, jabber was corrupting the cherry snake last game, so he wasnt just plain guessing. | ||
|
27ninjabunnies
United States2486 Posts
On May 27 2014 18:34 Palmar wrote: Ninjabunnies is mafia, I'm going to vote him. Then I'm going to read another page of the game. ##Vote Ninjabunnies it's because he wrote "XD" This is the best case on me in forum I have seen to date. Wow. Congrats. | ||
|
27ninjabunnies
United States2486 Posts
On May 27 2014 15:33 Amiko wrote: @slOosh re: Alakaslam style of posting Slam’s posting is usually fun, but occasionally frustrating since it’s not always clear what he means, so it can be hard to draw a read from that. I don’t think it is inherently bad On Jabberwockzerg I felt jabber’s first post was a bit odd because he copied his post from the prior game (where he was scum) and I feel like he might have a different opening if he was town. I also think bunnies may be onto something, but I’m not sure if her post (http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/451317-detention-mafia?page=6#106) realizes the more damning point or not (it’s sorta weirdly written) so I’ll write it just in case. To me, what is suspicious about jabber’s post is that he suggested a player was mafia last game, but he knew that the player was not mafia last game. In other words, he offered a scenario as a counterpoint that he knew to be false. It’d be fine if he said he was just raising the point as a possibility, but his answer (that he didn’t know it was public information) doesn’t look so hot. I’m not convinced on him yet, but I want to pursue this. @Jabberwockzerg: 27ninjabunnies has raised a point regarding your play that she argues shows you are mafia. You also posted that she was doing a lot of finger pointing on day one. Do you think her point on you is good? Do you feel that her raising that point makes her more likely to be town or mafia? @fuba and @HaruRH: You joined the vote on jabberwockzerg. I understand that you agree with bunnies’ point on him – what do you think of jabberwockzerg’s responses after bunnies’ vote? Do they feel more town or scum to you? aside @HaruRH: This is not game-oriented, but I really like the “God Knows” song from Haruhi and love to sing it in karaoke :D Your bolded point here is exactly the point I brought up in my case, though it might have been difficult to tell with all my euphemisms. The fact that he was the one who was worshipping the volvo last game, and he says that chrom was/ might have been the one last game, raises some high suspicion. Also, the team last game was epi, amiko, and jabber, yes? Epi isnt even in this game, and amiko didn't show up until just now, so who exactly was around to point that case out on jabber? Hmmm. Me. Who is actually paying attention to the game. | ||
|
27ninjabunnies
United States2486 Posts
On May 27 2014 18:40 Palmar wrote: Do you not think this is a valid case? At least you have to explain to me why you disagree. I think it's a pretty strong case. I should add that I combine it with the "ugh" from his first post, oh and his plea that "can we now hunt some scum?". Seems pretty ironclad to me. Also, her, not him. Prob something mundane to comment on, but i hate seeing his.... Bleh | ||
|
jabberwockzerg
United States294 Posts
On May 27 2014 15:51 HaruRH wrote: what I understood from all jabber's responses are either a high level of newbie play, or scum. I will provide examples later after I get on a computer. Will not unvote until jabber defends himself convincingly I don't think the case against me is solid, but obviously since I know I'm town that'll influence my judgment of the case. As for whether bunny's town, I don't know. Strong campaigning doesn't make her mafia, but she's really the only one making plays and that stands out. | ||
|
HaruRH
Singapore2780 Posts
On May 27 2014 12:15 jabberwockzerg wrote: If we're both mafia, wouldn't he have told me that in the QT? wait what? scum or newbie mistakes? | ||
|
HaruRH
Singapore2780 Posts
On May 27 2014 11:24 jabberwockzerg wrote: Didn't realize that was public information My bad This may have been used as evidence for the past 5 pages, but it still raises eyebrows. Why would you accuse someone of being mafia last game when you clearly know who is mafia last game? On May 27 2014 11:50 jabberwockzerg wrote: Clearing this up, I didn't mean mafia specifically, just non vanilla. Was this bad wording? Yes. Stupid of me? Yes. Learning experience, definitely Didn't mean mafia, but meant non-vanilla... wait, he said he could have been super into last game because he was mafia. On May 27 2014 11:56 jabberwockzerg wrote: Essentially, at that point in the game I was just spitballing. Then, he defends his claim by saying he was crapping. | ||
| ||
