dunno. I felt 25posts still produced a lot of useless junk.

im not a great player or anything, but i think a lot of stuff posted in this game didn't need to be posted at all. its not that the logic is fallacious, its just ppl here love to waste posts having digs at at one another typically before grasping the full context of the post they are trying to retort.

I dunno I find most ppl either fall into writing short one liners with no game relevance, or massive spawls of text painful to read and also not game relevant lol... guess mafia is like everything else and fits the 80/20 rule perfectly.

Ace

United States16096 Posts

August 05 2013 02:14 GMT

#1822

Maybe only keep around people like me that produce quality posts and actually try to win. Players like Vivax only exist to hurt the Town atmosphere

Mocsta

Australia9387 Posts

August 05 2013 02:19 GMT

#1823

unfortunately this game was difficult in regards to ppl like wigglesm who actually wrote saolid well constructed posts, however supported the wrong lynches.

how u suggest separating that type of play from someone subtely pushing scum agenda?

Mr. Wiggles

Canada5894 Posts

August 05 2013 02:33 GMT

#1824

GG, thanks for hosting.

I didn't get too emotionally invested in this game, and I think that contributed somewhat to my lynch. I got too focused on the checks, and that was bad, especially with layabout's check being wrong. That basically screwed me, haha, since I tunneled in on it, and then it was incorrect info anyways. Oh well, honest mistake from him. I got way too tunneled in on the check, that I started becoming paranoid about everything else in the game. I'd suspected s&b of being scum for quite some time, but started doubting myself when koshi was pushing him (someone I didn't feel good about then), and rayne was pushing him (who I doubted since korynne hadn't flipped, so there was still a leak in the layabout pms, and there was the unexplained sloosh pardon). I also made too many assumptions about the setup, which was bad, and led me down the wrong path.

I was wrong about some things though, and wasn't very active or invested in the game, so I ended up getting lynched. Day 2, I lost some of my interest with all the trolling going on, and the big fight between Dr.H/FT. The modkills and Dr.H rage-quitting also didn't help, so I mostly read the game, but didn't participate too actively, which probably didn't help too much.

RebirthOfLeGenD

USA5860 Posts

August 05 2013 03:08 GMT

#1825

On August 05 2013 10:21 strongandbig wrote:
It's true that modkilling town to death is not great, but then it's Adam losing the game for his team vs the hosts winning it for his team. So that probably should have happened. Not really the important point here though, although Adam should get a ban for it

In the end the town still didn't win. So it's wrong to say I handed them the game. It was basically giving the mafia the game versus making it a bit more difficult for the mafia to win. I wouldn't say a modkill is losing it for your team, losing a game is making bad plays and just sheeping along blatantly bad lynches. Getting modkilled is ruining the game for everyone, mafia gets unearned victory and it kind of shits on the integrity of the game.

And I said it before, as a host you are inevitably going to fuck up eventually, it's how you handle the fuckup that matters. You are faced with tough calls and have to make decisions that aren't going to make everyone happy. I'm sorry if you/kush find that unacceptable. However lets point out, it still wasn't enough to get the town a win. In the end the SK won

Also it was possible for the SK to die at night, it was just exceptionally difficult. He wasn't bullet proof he just had two night lives. No one ever actually attacked him. Alternatively, you could just lynch him if you are paying enough attention to catch him. However he did play pretty well, I think it took Ver until day 3 to figure him out.