|
On February 23 2014 03:06 Palmar wrote:Show nested quote +On February 23 2014 03:04 CuteFluffyPuppy wrote:
Prplhz:
In the early stages of the game he went after Rayn's plan like Toad did. It seems unlikely that both scum would go for it, but it's not unheard of. Prplhz's filter in Carnival Cruise as mafia was very short though (4 pages), and he lived all the way until endgame.
This game doesn't feel like Carnival Cruise at all and a lot more like Roulette. Meta says he's probably town. He's paranoid too whereas his accusations felt more certain during CC. In Roulette he was more uncertain which I feel parallels this game.
Lack of interaction with Toad I can explain from the fact that they had the same gut response to Rayn's plan so I can imagine pr giving Toad a blind eye for that. Yeah I think Prplhz is town. in other news, Palmar is still insufferable
|
I like puppies.
rly it's suko & Kush.
|
obligatorysmurfguess: yamato
also marv might bus sandro because sandro will sometimes literally afk out of scum games while he will not hard bus toad unless he has very good reason for it and he didn't this game
|
It could be suki but I don't want her to be scum because she's putting in so much effort 
|
|
|
well actually not really the same, i don't think suki is scum because she is putting in so much effort
|
like, i think suki is town because she is putting in a lot of effort. i imagine that after having your godfather lynched on d1 and then someone finds a scumslip, you'd be more like "fuck this game i'm going outside now" but she just turned activity up to 11.
not as in, i think she is town but not because of the effort she is putting into the game
|
is forced silence during resolution period?
|
maybe you should put that in bold green
|
On February 23 2014 03:05 Palmar wrote:
suko why didn't you instajoin the toad wagon which was good but you instajoined my shit wagon on kush
I didn't join your wagon on kush, I gave my thoughts and provided reasoning.
What are your thoughts on Balla, Palmar?
|
Also Koshi I'm just going to ignore everything you say for the rest of this game.
|
There should be no talking during the resolution period. If it isn't roles like vigis have an incredible advantage over mafia, as any mafia can't counterclaim if the vig claims during the resolution period, and they can't hit him either. Either mafia should be allowed to change their hit, or there should be silence during that period. It's straight up unfair for mafia to give town a free time to claim roles in.
Same goes with cops etc on day 2. A cop can claim his night 1 result on the resolution period of night 2, and still mafia doesn't have chance to shoot/roleblock him so he gets a free night 2 check
|
|
|
On February 23 2014 03:56 suki wrote:Show nested quote +On February 23 2014 03:05 Palmar wrote:
suko why didn't you instajoin the toad wagon which was good but you instajoined my shit wagon on kush I didn't join your wagon on kush, I gave my thoughts and provided reasoning. What are your thoughts on Balla, Palmar?
I'll totally lynch him if you flip town, or scum... I don't really care.
|
On February 23 2014 03:57 suki wrote:
Also Koshi I'm just going to ignore everything you say for the rest of this game.
He's been really useful and is one of the confirmed town group. No idea why you'd ignore him.
|
Resolution period should be named silent period when you cant talk. They are named the same and it is so confusing.
|
United Kingdom36156 Posts
|
United Kingdom36156 Posts
On February 23 2014 03:15 prplhz wrote:
obligatorysmurfguess: yamato
also marv might bus sandro because sandro will sometimes literally afk out of scum games while he will not hard bus toad unless he has very good reason for it and he didn't this game
suki was talking about Palmar, not me, she just used Shadow as a handy bussing example
|
On February 22 2014 20:41 marvellosity wrote:
Balla, how confident are you that suki is town? She has some unfortunate things in her filter, such as her case on Koshi + below it where it outlines how Toad is awful and has no redeeming features and might possibly vote for him later if gosh darnit, she didn't just have this swell case on Koshi. That sort of thing.
I still think she's pretty solidly town. I don't much like her thought process throughout this n1 especially in regards to kush and I, but I still think it's more likely for her to be town for doing so because as town she is very flip-floppy with her reads especially when people are defending themselves. What i'm referring to is this:
On February 23 2014 00:42 suki wrote:
Obviously I'm looking at Kush being mafia, for having such a shitty read on Balla.
But his responses are coherent and make sense.
Taking another look at Balla's filter some things really don't add up. Calling marv questionable is a really weird thing. His case on toad also bad. His case on you bad. Bussing Toad is definitely a plausible move for scum Balla.
I guess I just liked the fact that he was hard defending me :|
Kush looks more townie to me right now from this exchange. Balla looks worse.
I do think Oats is town so scum suspect was kush and slam. Add Balla to the list now.
Kush looks more townie from the exchange? Even though kush provided very little insight into the way I actually play and is actually quite contradictory:
On February 23 2014 00:33 VIVAX420 wrote:
because degree of activity has nothing to do with alignment most of the time? i dind't see anything scummy early game. And no i wouldn't describe him as a "timid" scum. He is quite capable, it;s just that he wasn't trying that hard those scum games.
and furthermore, ive since downgraded my opinion of his towngame from when I said those quotes.
now does my line of thought line up?
Somehow my scum game has been upgraded in his eyes and my towngame downgraded, when all he's played with ME have been really really really shit scum games from me and NO town games, and all i've played SINCE then have been really really great towngames. That really really really doesn't add up.
I still think she's town, but I won't be hard defending her anymore if she keeps coming up with a bad trains of thoughts like this.
|
Balla if suko is town you're scum.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
