On September 12 2013 16:28 Koshi wrote:
I can wait a bit on the other Europeans to wake up.

SnB can be town obviously. But meh. Could lynch.
Pandain pretty bad entry.

OP pretty cool guy. Not going to lynch.

Hey Koshi, since you're here what do you think of my case on Pandain? Can you expand upon your read beyond bad entrance.

Koshi

Belgium38797 Posts

September 12 2013 07:52 GMT

#242

On September 12 2013 16:49 Grackaroni wrote:

Show nested quote +

Hey Koshi, since you're here what do you think of my case on Pandain? Can you expand upon your read beyond bad entrance.

I totally agree with what you said and with what PS said.

The Zealous part is not scummy for me though. He first said Zealous was probably town because his rolename it the main character in the series. But then he says we should be wary of lurkers and Zalous is a lurker. I am ok with that.

Not impressed with that entire post from Pandain. The part about him saying that he doesn't know that he is allowed to reason like he did about the rolename setup made my conspiracy/Wifom senses tingle. I didn't like that part.

Koshi

Belgium38797 Posts

September 12 2013 07:54 GMT

#243

The part where Pandain tries to put some suspicion on OP is pretty bad as well. Not impressed!

But the day is still long.

I am waiting on rayn and the Snowman to show up.

raynpelikoneet

Finland43188 Posts

September 12 2013 08:44 GMT

#244

Old_Partner what's your read on Papa_Smurf?

Koshi

Belgium38797 Posts

September 12 2013 08:53 GMT

#245

Hi rayn!!!

raynpelikoneet

Finland43188 Posts

September 12 2013 09:10 GMT

#246

Hi Koshi! Why do you exactly think OP is a cool guy?

Koshi

Belgium38797 Posts

September 12 2013 09:29 GMT

#247

On September 12 2013 18:10 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Hi Koshi! Why do you exactly think OP is a cool guy?

Because he plays like nobody else does. Hopefully he can keep that up.
Imagine 14 people reading the thread like that and asking direct and good questions. I like it.

raynpelikoneet

Finland43188 Posts

September 12 2013 09:31 GMT

#248

Really, what i see is two big posts that say:
1) "This happened then that happened"
2) "These guys could be scum or they could be town"
3) "I wanna policy lynch kush in case i can't find a lynch target on D1. I however do not know kush's meta"

Koshi

Belgium38797 Posts

September 12 2013 09:32 GMT

#249

Well, nobody answered to poor guy so he can't follow up yet.

Koshi

Belgium38797 Posts

September 12 2013 09:32 GMT

#250

to the*

Obviously OP will need to make conclusions and follow up on his questions. But I think he will and it will be epic.

raynpelikoneet

Finland43188 Posts

September 12 2013 09:39 GMT

#251

We'll see about that. I already find a couple of suspicious things in his posts. I can't see the point of summarizing the game happenings so far, anyone who has read the thread knows what has happened. Most of his questions are useless, some of them are weird. Like why do you ask "what do you think of Koshi's policy of lynching scum"? What conclusions can you possibly draw from whatever the answer is?

raynpelikoneet

Finland43188 Posts

September 12 2013 09:47 GMT

#252

Actually Koshi tell me what of OP's questions are good in your opinion?

Koshi

Belgium38797 Posts

September 12 2013 09:56 GMT

#253

On September 12 2013 12:31 Old Partner wrote:

4. This is @vayneauthority: despite the fact that you have interacted obliquely with Koshi, you do not mention him ever. Do you think he is town, or he is scum? What do you think of his initial vote on SnB for questioning his "policy" of lynching scum? What do you think of his "policy"? Why haven't you weighed in on him yet?

5. this is @SnB: you think koshi is "uncomfortable" and "projecting"... and you also say he is "silly". do you have a scumread on him or not?
5.b this is @SnB: what do you think of VA, in light of my notes on him? Would you say your perception of him is colored by his defense of you? taking that into account, do you see why he is viewed as scummy?

6. this is @papa_smurf: why did you smurf into this game? Are you really BH? After you unvote SnB you don't mention him again. Do you still have a scumread on him, or do you think he is town because VA is scum?

4) VA doesn't comment on my allignement. nowhere. Love the question + how he asked it.

5a) Asking for clarification on SnB his read on me.
5b) Demanding participation in scumhunting on VA.

6) First questions are Meh. Last question is pushing PS to do transparant scumhunting.

I love OP. I think he is a really cool guy. I am going to let him do his thing. He pushes and advocates good and transparant posting/scumhunting.

raynpelikoneet

Finland43188 Posts

September 12 2013 10:06 GMT

#254

4) As i said earlier, dumb questions. The last one is fair.

5a) HE misses the fact that you were the one who called SnB uncomfortable first. Why does he want to know about that from SnB? From reading the thread he seems to be having a townread on SnB, i don't know his read on you. Why ask a townread why he calls another guy uncomfortable, why does he not want to know whay YOU think his townread is uncomfortable instead?

5b) VA's read on SnB is completely fine. For me this question reads as "SnB you are not allowed to think VA is town, because in case you guys think each other is town that removes two suspects from the pool". That's casting doubt on VA for his read on SnB and telling SnB to not trust VA (for what reason?).

6) See (5b). He is doing the same thing here, "guys, do not have a town read on VA". "Do you still have a scumread on SnB, as you unvoted him". Yeah, people usually unvote their scumreads, question makes totally sense!

Koshi

Belgium38797 Posts

September 12 2013 10:11 GMT

#255

Well, what you say might be true. But questions like OP asked are good, and should be answered more quickly for better effect. Now they seem to be bad, but if answered instantly they could have produced good conversation.

I still like the questions.

Koshi

Belgium38797 Posts

September 12 2013 10:13 GMT

#256

It's a bit unlucky that VA signed off 4 minutes before OP asked those questions.

raynpelikoneet

Finland43188 Posts

September 12 2013 10:13 GMT

#257

TLDR; His tone screams the motivation of breaking up townies plans on finding other townies to reduce the suspect pool. He does not accuse anyone, he is trying to break the good atmosphere town is trying to achieve (mainly SnB and VA).

Vayne is totally town, he is shutting down bad cases and arguments. SnB is most likely town too for what vayne said.