|
And I scanned over 40 pages for this ;D
|
On November 01 2011 07:29 aTnClouD wrote:Show nested quote +On November 01 2011 07:27 Enhancer_ wrote:On November 01 2011 07:01 quakerix wrote:On November 01 2011 06:04 AndersR. wrote: Kinda feel like ESWC has been bashed a bit too much in this thread, the owners now are not the ones who were known for not paying out the money, that where the previous owners who went bankruptcy with the brand. I'm pretty sure that the current owners have done a fine job paying out, at least as far as i remember that was what Na'Vi.cs said last year after they won it. Thank you. I'm extremely surprised that aTnCloud already posted about ESWC not paying out just a few days after the event. We didn't even finish up logistically and this event is already listed in this topic. Ok, i can imagine that because of the previous company going bankrupt the brand had some damage. But posting this before even contacting us is a bit harsh towards the new owners. Last year they paid out just a few weeks after the event and now we didn't even had the chance. You could have contacted us in 100 ways, your management has direct contacts with us, you could have replied to your invite email you could have even gone to our website and look up contact information. Anyway; i messaged you privately and i also already replied to you in the ESWC topic a few days earlier. Give us a break and we'll contact you as soon as possible. On November 01 2011 01:48 Jcnorheim wrote: I am sorry that this happens.
Many community figures talk about how events compete with one another for viewers, and I think that this is definitely one of the factors that concerns at least some viewers.
On the other side of the coin though, ESWC probably didn't get nearly enough viewers due to having to compete with Blizzcon. So they already lost the competition for viewers. Maybe ESWC will use that as an excuse to disappear again. We had 100k simultaneous viewers as peak during our weekend and there were about 1500 people watching games at the stage. ![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/tu7Fa.jpg) ![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/E1UWs.jpg) ![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/0YlVL.jpg) Don't worry about the fact that ESWC wasn't a success. It was. Something is still wrong with the idea that you expect players to have to contact you to get an update on the money owed to them. If you owe someone money, the responsibility is on you to pay it it. Or at least that's how I think it should be. I think the same, but he thought it was wise to PM me saying I put ESWC in bad light for no reason and I might not get invited next year because of it. lol.
This here is the post that firmly establishes cloud as the guy you don't fuck with.
The thread is a great idea, the more progamers that speak up about unpaid winnings the less this kind of thing will happen. If word gets out that a specific organizer either doesn't pay or is notoriously delinquent people will be less inclined to watch their tournaments, as players will be less interested in playing games that they might or might not ever get paid for.
|
On November 01 2011 07:46 jorge_the_awesome wrote:Show nested quote +On November 01 2011 07:44 mYNDIG wrote:On November 01 2011 07:42 jorge_the_awesome wrote:On November 01 2011 07:39 mYNDIG wrote:On November 01 2011 07:37 jorge_the_awesome wrote: WORD TO ALL PLAYERS:
As far as I know (according to tax lawyer relatives) a check is any sort of instruction from the bank. Therefore, the large checks they give you on stage CAN be redeemed, if they contain sender/recipient/amount info. The big checks they give you are just for show and has no real effect. They're designed to be just for show. Legally, they can be cashed. The bank teller might not accept it, and nobody usually cashes them, but legally, the can be cashed. Similarly, any piece of paper that is signed and has payment info can be cashed. You'd probably have to get the bank manager, but the tournament tries to hold you up, you can legally (at least in the US) cash it. I only know in Norway, and there they won't work. But what the rest of the world does is not something I know xD Have you ever tried? I know nothing about law in Norway, though.
We tried (more as a joke though.) when we got a big check from a company sponsoring our school trip a few years back. We were told that we had to come back with the real check, that this was just for show, etc etc etc.
|
Guess this is part of being a Progamer. Think you will all have to deal with it. Its one of the bad sides of it.
|
On November 01 2011 07:48 mYNDIG wrote:Show nested quote +On November 01 2011 07:46 jorge_the_awesome wrote:On November 01 2011 07:44 mYNDIG wrote:On November 01 2011 07:42 jorge_the_awesome wrote:On November 01 2011 07:39 mYNDIG wrote:On November 01 2011 07:37 jorge_the_awesome wrote: WORD TO ALL PLAYERS:
As far as I know (according to tax lawyer relatives) a check is any sort of instruction from the bank. Therefore, the large checks they give you on stage CAN be redeemed, if they contain sender/recipient/amount info. The big checks they give you are just for show and has no real effect. They're designed to be just for show. Legally, they can be cashed. The bank teller might not accept it, and nobody usually cashes them, but legally, the can be cashed. Similarly, any piece of paper that is signed and has payment info can be cashed. You'd probably have to get the bank manager, but the tournament tries to hold you up, you can legally (at least in the US) cash it. I only know in Norway, and there they won't work. But what the rest of the world does is not something I know xD Have you ever tried? I know nothing about law in Norway, though. We tried (more as a joke though.) when we got a big check from a company sponsoring our school trip a few years back. We were told that we had to come back with the real check, that this was just for show, etc etc etc.
Wait, you really tried! Wow. Too bad it didn't work.
|
On November 01 2011 07:01 quakerix wrote:Show nested quote +On November 01 2011 06:04 AndersR. wrote: Kinda feel like ESWC has been bashed a bit too much in this thread, the owners now are not the ones who were known for not paying out the money, that where the previous owners who went bankruptcy with the brand. I'm pretty sure that the current owners have done a fine job paying out, at least as far as i remember that was what Na'Vi.cs said last year after they won it. Thank you. I'm extremely surprised that aTnCloud already posted about ESWC not paying out just a few days after the event. We didn't even finish up logistically and this event is already listed in this topic. Ok, i can imagine that because of the previous company going bankrupt the brand had some damage. But posting this before even contacting us is a bit harsh towards the new owners. Last year they paid out just a few weeks after the event and now we didn't even had the chance. You could have contacted us in 100 ways, your management has direct contacts with us, you could have replied to your invite email you could have even gone to our website and look up contact information. Anyway; i messaged you privately and i also already replied to you in the ESWC topic a few days earlier. Give us a break and we'll contact you as soon as possible. Show nested quote +On November 01 2011 01:48 Jcnorheim wrote: I am sorry that this happens.
Many community figures talk about how events compete with one another for viewers, and I think that this is definitely one of the factors that concerns at least some viewers.
On the other side of the coin though, ESWC probably didn't get nearly enough viewers due to having to compete with Blizzcon. So they already lost the competition for viewers. Maybe ESWC will use that as an excuse to disappear again. We had 100k simultaneous viewers as peak during our weekend and there were about 1500 people watching games at the stage. + Show Spoiler +Don't worry about the fact that ESWC wasn't a success. It was.
If you take a brand, you take either EVERYTHING or NOTHING. So stop whining about people still combining ESWC with shitty tournament organisation
|
On November 01 2011 07:37 Iselian wrote: As the professional SC2 scene continues to grow at such an enormous rate, no doubt tournament organizers and sponsors are looking to keep what money they can, even from the pro players who "only are playing games" or some such. While I do think a governing body would be best, something that initiates contracts for players, leagues, teams and events, it's something that has to be done *very* carefully.
Players and teams would have to have all their contracts made legally binding over an international sense. EU players who sign up with NA teams, KR players on EU teams, etc, wouldn't want to be held back by multiple agencies for multiple regions and countries. The contracts of course go without saying to be not unlike any "mainstream" athletic sport contract we know of today. Specific rules may be required in each contract by the agency, but that might not be necessary.
Leagues and the agency would have to come to a set of legally binding rules based on payment, organization, and what exactly qualifies a league. The last part would be the largest, and I think the biggest obstacle for now. With the explosion of leagues and events this last year, there are too many smaller groups who compete for the grand coverage that MLG, GSL, IPL, etc receive. I think it would come down to a designation of large, "official" leagues and events that are bound to the agency's rules (both of organization and payment), and "unofficial" leagues and events that are self-run and participated in at a bit of risk.
Sponsors would have to treat the aforementioned "official" leagues and events with a great deal of respect and knowledge that you already see in "mainstream" athletic sports. The agency would have to be given the power to step in and legally pursue debts from the sponsors. This would likely lead to a requirement for a paper trail from the sponsors to the leagues and events, but all under the eye of the agency.
The hardest part, I think, would be having everyone agree on an agency's structure and powers, that would not favor any particular leagues or regions. It would be a very, very fine line to walk, and I'm not sure it could be done just yet. In time, however.
Until then, I really do wish there was a way that, in a simple form, players could sign a contract agreeing to participate and in return, that same contract could be used to guarantee earned payment via placement.
I think this is a little overboard. You don't need to control the formats of tournaments or such. Merely a standard which you can use to rate organizations. This doesn't need to be kespa. It just needs to be a group which looks out for the PLAYERS. Somone the teams can trust to certify tournaments validity and back them up in a courtroom if needed.
So let's call this organization the eSPA (e Sports Players Association). eSPA sets forth guidelines for tournaments to meet. For expample, these might include things such as: 1. Payments must be disbursed within 90 days of event completing. 2. All live events must pay 5% or $500 (whichever is greater) to winners on the day of event for travel concerns. 3. All tournament organizers must submit a list of sponsors, contracts, and accounting for prize money 30 days prior to the event.
etc. etc. etc.
Then set up a tier of certification:
eSPA Gold Standard - Meets all standards asked by eSPA eSPA Silver Standard - Legitimate tournament, but has not met all standards put forth by eSPA eSPA Trial - Tournament has promised to meet standard, signed contract saying they will, but has not proven yet. eSPA Suspended - Tournament has not met standards, but is making efforts to remedy in meantime. Re-entry involves one year trial period on Silver Standard upon payments before gold standard may be considered again. eSPA Blacklisted - Tournament has promised and failed to meet standards of eSPA.
I think this baseline, combined with legal abilities, would do wonder for players, fans, and organizers.
|
On November 01 2011 07:25 iNcontroL wrote:Show nested quote +On November 01 2011 07:11 FlyingDJ wrote: Well, this thread pretty much shows how most have not been around for a long time.
It's clear that most StarCraft 2 players have not been exposed the the delays in paying out prize money because they were rarely part of major esports tournaments before the release of that game. Ask someone who's been playing before 2009. That was when ESL was held in high regard because they paid out, even if it took a long time. Not a thing you could take for granted.
Now with money being thrown at SC2 like there's no tomorrow, everyone here is suddenly going crazy about how delays cannot be and how apparently players starve when they're not being paid on time. A couple of years ago you would have ended up with no tournaments at all had you decided to boycott those who had delayed payout in prizes. That's what this has always been like. Does it need to change? Probably, but it's not going to happen over night. ESL is one of the only tournaments that made it through the recession that followed 2008, and they don't get the amounts of venture capital that MLG carries around these days.
Instead of posting about it on a forum, the players might consider actually forming some kind of organisation to help in those matters. Doesn't seem too much work to me. And even if not, they could just boycott the tournaments they think do not pay out prize money on time. What's that, there are almost none left then? Oh well...
It's such a hypocrisy that everyone is always applauding insane prize pools and players tend to follow the sums instead of the reputation yet at the same time, any delay is totally unacceptable. Do you honestly believe most of the current tournaments have a sustainable business model that returns their investment? hmm kinda odd to call you out on this but the thread starter is ClouD.. formerly ToT)Cloud( from BW and various other top teams in that time. Tyler has chimed in.. a player from BW as well who has played for a decade. IdrA, myself.. the list kind of goes on. It seems unwise to write this entire thread off and basically call everyone SC2 newbs. To make matters worse you are kind of suggesting that people should be appreciative that ESL pays at all.. and that it used to be "held in high regard" as if that makes it ok to be late? The best and really the ONLY reply possible is "hey sorry, there is a lot of redtape and we are aware it isn't optimal but we are doing our best" or something along those lines. Not "shutup at least we pay you sc2 novices!"
Tournament Promoters: SHUT UP AND TAKE MY MONEY! + Show Spoiler +
|
On November 01 2011 07:47 Nizzy wrote:Show nested quote +On November 01 2011 06:36 svefnleysi wrote:On November 01 2011 06:24 Lolli92 wrote: I think this should be a topic for a Day9 Daily or a F*** Slasher episode !! This should be called out on SotG, Inside the Game, Fuck Slasher, and basically every SC2 media outlet. The organizations responsible need to get the bad publicity they deserve.IGN: If you think it's not a big deal because it's "not even been 90 days" then that just makes you sound retarded.Not even paying the winner of IPL season 1 yet? Any and all respect I had for IPL was just flushed down the toilet. Your post is very ignorant and I will prove that with facts. Your post in my opinion is very stupid and IPL doesn't deserve those comments. First off if you had any idea of the scene in SC2 and all the events IPL is a top 3 if not the best overall. Number 1 in production. In a recent interview they lost a shit ton of money (6 figs range) and didn't think anything of it because it was simply for the fucking good of eSports. You're obviously going off of IdrA's situation, so lets talk about it. They probably have on their books right now that a check was written/issued out to him. He just never got it and they are looking into it as in tracing it as we speak. They might have already just issued another one as IGN.Joshy already touched upon this. Do you have any idea or understanding of how large organizations work? This isn't 1998. IGN isn't your little cheat website for nintendo 64 anymore. They're multi million dollar organization. They can't just throw money at something and not account for it. All the production value they put into these events takes time to set up, even the winning prize money. They seem to do things right, so maybe one of the things they will address is paying players on winning day. Like they also said, there isn't just some guy in a room with XXXXXX money ready to pay out. IPL comes from IGN. They must get things approved. As a pro gamer in this thread already stated 90 days for such a big prize pool is reasonable. Nobody cares if you don't decide to not turn on IPL again, however I guarantee you the large majority of the community loves IPL as they continually improve and host the best events. I don't see how the average SC2 fan can agree with your post.
IPL 3 live event... all of their live crew, payment to the casino, and any other equipment/services they needed for the event got paid for BEFORE SERVICES WERE RENDERED guaranteed. So why can't players expect to be paid at the same fking time? It's not like they didn't know the amount of money they were giving out before hand... "$100,000 to first place!" ok so set aside $100k BEFORE the event.
|
On November 01 2011 06:32 ProBot wrote: John i understand where your coming from and what your point of view is, however it is NO EXCUSE for having to wait up to even 3 months for prizes. You run a business ... great then you should know what budgeting is. If a tournament ( especially ones that are aware of tardiness from certain sponsors ) know they will be getting sponsorship money late then they should have theprize money as part of their overall production budget, especially larger lan tournaments.
There's no excuse for them not to, the tournament organizers are the ones in contract with the sponsorships for the money ... not the players, so even if the tournament pays out of pocket to the players and the sponsors bail, at least the tournament themselves can get the money eventually via legal measures.
It's common sense and should be common practice, especially for the high profile tournaments. You shouldn't be advertising X amount of dollars for a prize when in reality your just praying the sponsors to come through with it. It's just shitty business practice, you seem to think it's the norm and in some situations it is, but in the end it doesn't have to be, it's just laziness.
You are right.. you should not have to wait 90 days..but if the contract calls for those terms..then you must accept them. You can not whine and cry that they are not 'fair'. Might as well start "Occupy eSports".. and waste everyone's time crying about something that is just part of life (I expect flame for that remark ). The point is though.. the stage in the process that requires professional communication between the players and those ultimately responsible for paying them is just as important as the terms put in place. I think people misunderstand me.. I strongly dislike it that there are large organizations in this industry that can continue to get away with not meeting those terms and players continue to support them because they put on a good 'show'.. while companies like mine (CSN) continue to work hard to get sponsorship money and work hard to make sure every player is paid in a timely manner. Shit.. I have paid out of my own pocket (not with CSN).. just to make sure a player is paid and happy. For us (my organization and others like it)..the players (not the stream #'s...lol) are the most important commodity.
|
wow......... thats kinda messed up
|
On November 01 2011 07:50 aike wrote:Show nested quote +On November 01 2011 07:47 Nizzy wrote:On November 01 2011 06:36 svefnleysi wrote:On November 01 2011 06:24 Lolli92 wrote: I think this should be a topic for a Day9 Daily or a F*** Slasher episode !! This should be called out on SotG, Inside the Game, Fuck Slasher, and basically every SC2 media outlet. The organizations responsible need to get the bad publicity they deserve.IGN: If you think it's not a big deal because it's "not even been 90 days" then that just makes you sound retarded.Not even paying the winner of IPL season 1 yet? Any and all respect I had for IPL was just flushed down the toilet. Your post is very ignorant and I will prove that with facts. Your post in my opinion is very stupid and IPL doesn't deserve those comments. First off if you had any idea of the scene in SC2 and all the events IPL is a top 3 if not the best overall. Number 1 in production. In a recent interview they lost a shit ton of money (6 figs range) and didn't think anything of it because it was simply for the fucking good of eSports. You're obviously going off of IdrA's situation, so lets talk about it. They probably have on their books right now that a check was written/issued out to him. He just never got it and they are looking into it as in tracing it as we speak. They might have already just issued another one as IGN.Joshy already touched upon this. Do you have any idea or understanding of how large organizations work? This isn't 1998. IGN isn't your little cheat website for nintendo 64 anymore. They're multi million dollar organization. They can't just throw money at something and not account for it. All the production value they put into these events takes time to set up, even the winning prize money. They seem to do things right, so maybe one of the things they will address is paying players on winning day. Like they also said, there isn't just some guy in a room with XXXXXX money ready to pay out. IPL comes from IGN. They must get things approved. As a pro gamer in this thread already stated 90 days for such a big prize pool is reasonable. Nobody cares if you don't decide to not turn on IPL again, however I guarantee you the large majority of the community loves IPL as they continually improve and host the best events. I don't see how the average SC2 fan can agree with your post. IPL 3 live event... all of their live crew, payment to the casino, and any other equipment/services they needed for the event got paid for BEFORE SERVICES WERE RENDERED guaranteed. So why can't players expect to be paid at the same fking time? It's not like they didn't know the amount of money they were giving out before hand... "$100,000 to first place!" ok so set aside $100k BEFORE the event.
I think the major problem is that they don't know who will win etc. They know who should be paid for the other work, because that is settled already.
|
Better call Saul!
jkjk.
I really feel that something has to be done about this, especially if we want eSport to get invited into the mainstream. I also think there's alot of things like these that people don't know about, even with teams, for example Spawn and HeatoN have openly said that SK didn't pay them the money they should've and that they still owe them quite a sum of money. Can't put it better then Naniwa, teams and tournaments, pay up or gtfo.
|
Damn. this sucks.
Can't players perform some sort of legal action? I mean this is not on, claiming that you have prize money you don't have.
|
On November 01 2011 07:53 mYNDIG wrote:Show nested quote +On November 01 2011 07:50 aike wrote:On November 01 2011 07:47 Nizzy wrote:On November 01 2011 06:36 svefnleysi wrote:On November 01 2011 06:24 Lolli92 wrote: I think this should be a topic for a Day9 Daily or a F*** Slasher episode !! This should be called out on SotG, Inside the Game, Fuck Slasher, and basically every SC2 media outlet. The organizations responsible need to get the bad publicity they deserve.IGN: If you think it's not a big deal because it's "not even been 90 days" then that just makes you sound retarded.Not even paying the winner of IPL season 1 yet? Any and all respect I had for IPL was just flushed down the toilet. Your post is very ignorant and I will prove that with facts. Your post in my opinion is very stupid and IPL doesn't deserve those comments. First off if you had any idea of the scene in SC2 and all the events IPL is a top 3 if not the best overall. Number 1 in production. In a recent interview they lost a shit ton of money (6 figs range) and didn't think anything of it because it was simply for the fucking good of eSports. You're obviously going off of IdrA's situation, so lets talk about it. They probably have on their books right now that a check was written/issued out to him. He just never got it and they are looking into it as in tracing it as we speak. They might have already just issued another one as IGN.Joshy already touched upon this. Do you have any idea or understanding of how large organizations work? This isn't 1998. IGN isn't your little cheat website for nintendo 64 anymore. They're multi million dollar organization. They can't just throw money at something and not account for it. All the production value they put into these events takes time to set up, even the winning prize money. They seem to do things right, so maybe one of the things they will address is paying players on winning day. Like they also said, there isn't just some guy in a room with XXXXXX money ready to pay out. IPL comes from IGN. They must get things approved. As a pro gamer in this thread already stated 90 days for such a big prize pool is reasonable. Nobody cares if you don't decide to not turn on IPL again, however I guarantee you the large majority of the community loves IPL as they continually improve and host the best events. I don't see how the average SC2 fan can agree with your post. IPL 3 live event... all of their live crew, payment to the casino, and any other equipment/services they needed for the event got paid for BEFORE SERVICES WERE RENDERED guaranteed. So why can't players expect to be paid at the same fking time? It's not like they didn't know the amount of money they were giving out before hand... "$100,000 to first place!" ok so set aside $100k BEFORE the event. I think the major problem is that they don't know who will win etc. They know who should be paid for the other work, because that is settled already.
The problem isn't the who though, their excuse keeps being "sponsors haven't paid us yet" blah blah blah.... that is such horse shit.
|
On November 01 2011 07:50 aike wrote: IPL 3 live event... all of their live crew, payment to the casino, and any other equipment/services they needed for the event got paid for BEFORE SERVICES WERE RENDERED guaranteed. So why can't players expect to be paid at the same fking time? It's not like they didn't know the amount of money they were giving out before hand... "$100,000 to first place!" ok so set aside $100k BEFORE the event.
I don't know all the details but personally if I won a 25k tournament I wouldn't just want to walk out of the building with a real 25k check. I would want this to be done after the tournament, probably sent to me securely after the event.
IPL isn't just going to punch in bank account numbers as the 1st/2nd/3rd placements come down. I'm not sure how it works and how MLG does it. However right now I get paid as per a contracted position and it doesn't bother me that I work now and I might get paid for it 1-2 months in the future.
I can see the problems, however 90 days for such high $$$ isn't the worst thing ever. Anything over 3 months I will agree is the cut off and is pushing it. Like I already said in my response, surely IPL/IGN might be able to make some changes in the future to make it better for the players.
However that guy literally took his pants off and shit on IPL which just isn't acceptable. I've been nothing but beyond pleased with their events and I think they're a top 3 organization/ in the WORLD in terms of SC2 Tournaments, with GSL/MLG.
|
On November 01 2011 07:49 Teiwaz wrote:If you take a brand, you take either EVERYTHING or NOTHING. So stop whining about people still combining ESWC with shitty tournament organisation data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/41f32/41f32ccbf9c308e87a90fa896d4fd874e9b79ee6" alt=""
couldn't agree more. that's why i think the new owners of ESWC should take responsibility and pay out the prize money that was never paid out in 2008. and since their tournament apparently is such a "success" this should imo be a high priority.
|
blizzard should be helping out here
|
On November 01 2011 07:56 Nizzy wrote:Show nested quote +On November 01 2011 07:50 aike wrote: IPL 3 live event... all of their live crew, payment to the casino, and any other equipment/services they needed for the event got paid for BEFORE SERVICES WERE RENDERED guaranteed. So why can't players expect to be paid at the same fking time? It's not like they didn't know the amount of money they were giving out before hand... "$100,000 to first place!" ok so set aside $100k BEFORE the event. I don't know all the details but personally if I won a 25k tournament I wouldn't just want to walk out of the building with a real 25k check. I would want this to be done after the tournament, probably sent to me securely after the event. IPL isn't just going to punch in bank account numbers as the 1st/2nd/3rd placements come down. I'm not sure how it works and how MLG does it. However right now I get paid as per a contracted position and it doesn't bother me that I work now and I might get paid for it 1-2 months in the future. I can see the problems, however 90 days for such high $$$ isn't the worst thing ever. Anything over 3 months I will agree is the cut off and is pushing it. Like I already said in my response, surely IPL/IGN might be able to make some changes in the future to make it better for the players. However that guy literally took his pants off and shit on IPL which just isn't acceptable. I've been nothing but beyond pleased with their events and I think they're a top 3 organization/ in the WORLD in terms of SC2 Tournaments, with GSL/MLG.
Nobody is saying that IPL is a bad tournament from a spectators point of view. And nobody is saying hand them $25k to walk out the door with. What I'm saying is that any tournament should have the prize money on hand before running a tournament. They shouldn't have to wait to collect money from sponsors AFTER the event to pay players. In the NFL for the superbowl do you think the TV station plays all those adds and then collects the money from advertisers after the fact? No. They charge millions of dollars well before the event even takes place, which allows them to apply those funds to the event itself.
And really, i do love IPL. The only tournaments I watch are IPL and MLG. I will still watch NASL finals, and maybe some of the euro events, but nobody puts on a show as good as MLG. IPL definitely 2nd, because they fail hard at hype.
|
United States5162 Posts
On November 01 2011 07:58 hytonight wrote: blizzard should be helping out here Blizzard isn't involved in this, nor should they be. They don't represent the players' or the tournaments' interest and have no basis to make any decision.
|
|
|
|