|
On December 10 2016 09:51 aQuaSC wrote:Show nested quote +On December 10 2016 09:48 ossavi09 wrote: so some WCS players will get their travel expenses paid and all the others better hope they are on teamliquid? o.O TL is not a guarantee for everything now, they had to move some resources to their new Civilization department + Show Spoiler +Just kidding, don't hate on me I had already forgotten about the Civ team. I still don't understand that one at all
|
United States23455 Posts
On December 10 2016 09:51 lestye wrote:Show nested quote +On December 10 2016 09:37 Darkhorse wrote:On December 10 2016 09:02 Ansibled wrote:On December 10 2016 09:00 Darkhorse wrote:On December 10 2016 08:55 Ansibled wrote:On December 10 2016 08:52 Darkhorse wrote:On December 10 2016 08:41 Ansibled wrote:On December 10 2016 08:37 Darkhorse wrote:On December 10 2016 08:33 Ansibled wrote:On December 10 2016 08:22 Darkhorse wrote: [quote] Korea got fucked.
I know it probably took a lot of hard work to get this done and I appreciate that Incontrol highlights that and I'm happy there will be a WCS in 2017, but I'm still gonna call a spade a spade. Korea got fucked. In what way did Korea get fucked? Pro league is gone. S2SL is gone. Nothing done to offset this (ie allowing Koreans to enter DH, other weekend events again) so yay for oversaturation in GSL with far fewer established teams to pay players And by nothing done to offset this what you actually mean is 3 GSLs instead of 2, super tournaments, and money shifted from the foreign scene into global events (which Korea will take.) I mean is the only way Korea doesn't get fucked to you if Blizzard comes out and funds 6 teams and a teamleague? You have pretty unrealistic expectations. And of course this goes without mentioning the countless number of online tournaments we have. Super tournaments replace Kespa cup, something Korea lost that I didn't mention in my previous post (because I knew super tournaments offset them) also the IEM WC in Katowice has always been global unless I'm mistaken so it's not like Korea was "given something" there although I'll concede that the prize pool is higher this year. I'll concede that Blizzard shouldn't be expected to save PL on their own but Stork's recent interview seems to suggest they didn't even really try. That's most of my disappointment with Blizzard atm. Also I've never been a fan of splitting the global finals 50/50 (biggest prize pool of the year) when given an even playing field Koreans could easily qualify for more of those spots. But that last bit is all preference and I understand if you disagree Well there was 1 KeSPA cup and it was a global event not a WCS Korea event, so that's not strictly true. IEM Katowice season was a WCS Circuit event. http://wiki.teamliquid.net/starcraft2/2016_WCS_Winter_Circuit_ChampionshipI understand people not liking the way WCS final spots are allocated but I personally have no issues with it, and it's fairer than we see in most other games. True on Kespa cup. I will say that there is only one IEM circuit event available to Korea this season as opposed to last season (gyeonggi this year as opposed to Shenzhen, gamescon, and Taipei last year) The IEM and WCS seasons don't line up. There are only 2 events left on the IEM circuit this year, Gyeonggi and Katowice. We won't know more about IEM until they announce their plans for next season, it's possible they host more events though I don't know how likely this is. In any case I don't think Korea got fucked is a reasonable conclusion to draw from all of this. As an aside I hope people support online tournaments more this year, especially things like Olimoleague. You've turned me around to some extent here. I think Korea is getting slightly fucked and not all of it from Blizzard. Just the loss of PL really hurts them Which is ultimately not their fault. Blizzard didn't run or organize the Proleague, that what Kespa did. ... Obviously
I also pointed out that not all of Koreas woes were Blizzatds fault. PL falls under the "not Blizzards fault necessarily" umbrella
|
On December 10 2016 09:48 ossavi09 wrote: so some WCS players will get their travel expenses paid and all the others better hope they are on teamliquid? o.O $2 from each TL Winter Hat goes to pay for a fleet of TL private jets. a half dozen Boeing Business Jet 2s.
|
On December 10 2016 10:00 JimmyJRaynor wrote:Show nested quote +On December 10 2016 09:48 ossavi09 wrote: so some WCS players will get their travel expenses paid and all the others better hope they are on teamliquid? o.O $2 from each TL Winter Hat goes to pay for a fleet of TL private jets. a half dozen Boeing Business Jet 2s. We will build our own plane with Snute on it
|
On December 10 2016 09:55 SetGuitarsToKill wrote:Show nested quote +On December 10 2016 09:51 aQuaSC wrote:On December 10 2016 09:48 ossavi09 wrote: so some WCS players will get their travel expenses paid and all the others better hope they are on teamliquid? o.O TL is not a guarantee for everything now, they had to move some resources to their new Civilization department + Show Spoiler +Just kidding, don't hate on me I had already forgotten about the Civ team. I still don't understand that one at all It's ok TL forgot about it too.
|
The only qualm I have is looking at the schedule the first WCS Circuit event is in april-juli. That's 4 months+ from now, that's a very long break. Not sure how big/extensive the challenger events will be though, perhaps they can close the gap a bit.
Also with there being fewer tournaments in WCS Circuit hopefully we'll see double elimination and/or big round robin groups so players can play a bit more matches. Actually didn't quite realize reading the first time that this will be ALL there is for WCS. Besides it being sparse for the players I can imagine the caster life will also be way harder like this as they'll likely all have to work parttime. Wonder if we'll see caster retirements too.
I still think them already committing to 2018 as well is one of the best things ever. All these years with overly late info and formats changing every year haven't helped at all so I'm very glad there's a clear plan ahead plus less uncertainty for all the players.
|
SC II prize pool is a joke.
|
On December 10 2016 10:18 Antonidas wrote: SC II prize pool is a joke. Feel free to chip in.
|
United States1798 Posts
I don't understand why people are hung up on tournaments when it comes to Korea. All that matters is team salary, the guaranteed money that allowed Koreans to hold off military service and forego a traditional education. It's fairly obvious that no Korean companies want to sponsor starcraft, so it's left to foreign teams to pick up the talented former kespa pros. Unfortunately, with the region lock, they have no impetus to. The super tournaments have miniscule prize pools, leaving 3 gsls for the entire scene to subsist upon. The region lock is what will drive players into retirement, not the number of tournaments. This is a 2 year plan, but it's hard to imagine many players sticking around that long.
|
J..just... nay. I'd remain silent.
|
On December 10 2016 10:23 mizenhauer wrote: I don't understand why people are hung up on tournaments when it comes to Korea. All that matters is team salary, the guaranteed money that allowed Koreans to hold off military service and forego a traditional education. It's fairly obvious that no Korean companies want to sponsor starcraft, so it's left to foreign teams to pick up the talented former kespa pros. Unfortunately, with the region lock, they have no impetus to. The super tournaments have miniscule prize pools, leaving 3 gsls for the entire scene to subsist upon. The region lock is what will drive players into retirement, not the number of tournaments. This is a 2 year plan, but it's hard to imagine many players sticking around that long. Yes, that makes perfect sense. The region lock is the problem because all of those Koreans who can't make enough money from the current system will fly out to foreign tournaments at their own expense (because they still won't have teams) where they will lose to the same Koreans they lose to in GSL. Right?
On December 10 2016 10:18 Antonidas wrote: SC II prize pool is a joke. I'm sure you have nothing meaningful to actually say, but StarCraft II awarded 3 million dollars to 385 players so far this year. How is that a joke? There is also the opportunity to increase the funding next year with the war chest.
|
On December 10 2016 10:43 Ansibled wrote:Show nested quote +On December 10 2016 10:23 mizenhauer wrote: I don't understand why people are hung up on tournaments when it comes to Korea. All that matters is team salary, the guaranteed money that allowed Koreans to hold off military service and forego a traditional education. It's fairly obvious that no Korean companies want to sponsor starcraft, so it's left to foreign teams to pick up the talented former kespa pros. Unfortunately, with the region lock, they have no impetus to. The super tournaments have miniscule prize pools, leaving 3 gsls for the entire scene to subsist upon. The region lock is what will drive players into retirement, not the number of tournaments. This is a 2 year plan, but it's hard to imagine many players sticking around that long. Yes, that makes perfect sense. The region lock is the problem because all of those Koreans who can't make enough money from the current system will fly out to foreign tournaments at their own expense (because they still won't have teams) where they will lose to the same Koreans they lose to in GSL. Right? I'm sure you have nothing meaningful to actually say, but StarCraft II awarded 3 million dollars to 385 players so far this year. How is that a joke? There is also the opportunity to increase the funding next year with the war chest. I think the logic behind the region lock complaints is that if it's that difficult for Koreans to travel to international tournaments there's even less impetus for a foreign team to pick them up, who, if they had the incentive to invest in Koreans to travel to tournaments, would likely cover travel expenses. Not saying it's necessarily the way it'd shake out but you didn't seem to understand the point (which I'd say is reasonable) others were making.
|
On December 10 2016 11:02 sparklyresidue wrote:Show nested quote +On December 10 2016 10:43 Ansibled wrote:On December 10 2016 10:23 mizenhauer wrote: I don't understand why people are hung up on tournaments when it comes to Korea. All that matters is team salary, the guaranteed money that allowed Koreans to hold off military service and forego a traditional education. It's fairly obvious that no Korean companies want to sponsor starcraft, so it's left to foreign teams to pick up the talented former kespa pros. Unfortunately, with the region lock, they have no impetus to. The super tournaments have miniscule prize pools, leaving 3 gsls for the entire scene to subsist upon. The region lock is what will drive players into retirement, not the number of tournaments. This is a 2 year plan, but it's hard to imagine many players sticking around that long. Yes, that makes perfect sense. The region lock is the problem because all of those Koreans who can't make enough money from the current system will fly out to foreign tournaments at their own expense (because they still won't have teams) where they will lose to the same Koreans they lose to in GSL. Right? On December 10 2016 10:18 Antonidas wrote: SC II prize pool is a joke. I'm sure you have nothing meaningful to actually say, but StarCraft II awarded 3 million dollars to 385 players so far this year. How is that a joke? There is also the opportunity to increase the funding next year with the war chest. I think the logic behind the region lock complaints is that if it's that difficult for Koreans to travel to international tournaments there's even less impetus for a foreign team to pick them up, who, if they had the incentive to invest in Koreans to travel to tournaments, would likely cover travel expenses. Not saying it's necessarily the way it'd shake out but you didn't seem to understand the point (which I'd say is reasonable) others were making. I don't believe foreign teams would pick up Koreans much more than they currently do if the region lock was lifted, and the Koreans who might get picked up because of this change are likely the ones who would have no trouble earning money in tournaments.
If foreign teams were dedicated to picking up Korean players, they are allowed to compete in the WCS circuit like Polt and TRUE did. Region locking is a poor excuse, and removing it will cause more damage than it will solve problems.
|
On December 10 2016 10:43 Ansibled wrote:Show nested quote +On December 10 2016 10:23 mizenhauer wrote: I don't understand why people are hung up on tournaments when it comes to Korea. All that matters is team salary, the guaranteed money that allowed Koreans to hold off military service and forego a traditional education. It's fairly obvious that no Korean companies want to sponsor starcraft, so it's left to foreign teams to pick up the talented former kespa pros. Unfortunately, with the region lock, they have no impetus to. The super tournaments have miniscule prize pools, leaving 3 gsls for the entire scene to subsist upon. The region lock is what will drive players into retirement, not the number of tournaments. This is a 2 year plan, but it's hard to imagine many players sticking around that long. Yes, that makes perfect sense. The region lock is the problem because all of those Koreans who can't make enough money from the current system will fly out to foreign tournaments at their own expense (because they still won't have teams) where they will lose to the same Koreans they lose to in GSL. Right? I'm sure you have nothing meaningful to actually say, but StarCraft II awarded 3 million dollars to 385 players so far this year. How is that a joke? There is also the opportunity to increase the funding next year with the war chest.
not every Korean is willing to flight oversea. More than that, many Koreans who already joined foreign teams like Byun, Solar or some are also looking for team like Soo, those amazing guys will not be able to play in foreign tournaments even though they would love to.
|
On December 10 2016 11:18 ParksonVN wrote:Show nested quote +On December 10 2016 10:43 Ansibled wrote:On December 10 2016 10:23 mizenhauer wrote: I don't understand why people are hung up on tournaments when it comes to Korea. All that matters is team salary, the guaranteed money that allowed Koreans to hold off military service and forego a traditional education. It's fairly obvious that no Korean companies want to sponsor starcraft, so it's left to foreign teams to pick up the talented former kespa pros. Unfortunately, with the region lock, they have no impetus to. The super tournaments have miniscule prize pools, leaving 3 gsls for the entire scene to subsist upon. The region lock is what will drive players into retirement, not the number of tournaments. This is a 2 year plan, but it's hard to imagine many players sticking around that long. Yes, that makes perfect sense. The region lock is the problem because all of those Koreans who can't make enough money from the current system will fly out to foreign tournaments at their own expense (because they still won't have teams) where they will lose to the same Koreans they lose to in GSL. Right? On December 10 2016 10:18 Antonidas wrote: SC II prize pool is a joke. I'm sure you have nothing meaningful to actually say, but StarCraft II awarded 3 million dollars to 385 players so far this year. How is that a joke? There is also the opportunity to increase the funding next year with the war chest. not every Korean is willing to flight oversea. More than that, many Koreans who already joined foreign teams like Byun, Solar or some are also looking for team like Soo, those amazing guys will not be able to play in foreign tournaments even though they would love to. ByuN, Solar, and soO are not the ones who will struggle to place well in tournaments in Korea. They won't be forced into retirement from this system.
They might want to play in foreign tournaments, and they can with Katowice and whatever other global tournaments we might have, but what does that have to do with anything? Allowing them won't change that low tier Korean players will struggle, it will make most foreigners struggle with them. It's better to have a deep scene than to let a few players fly around until no one is left to play against.
StarCraft doesn't need to be more top heavy than it already is.
I mean it doesn't really matter what people think region lock is here to stay. It won't be the death of Korean StarCraft but if you need an excuse feel free to use it I guess.
|
well it s good that there is a WCS system in 2017, we ll see how it goes.
|
In my opinion this looks pretty good. I am surprised by the all the criticism.
|
Happy about this! I don't think there was more to ask. Happy that people try to be optimistic and realistic. Maby TL can finally be a place where some discussions can take place instead of the endless whining and blizzard bashing.
|
whilst dh is correct in that Korea got fucked, the fact that korea is getting anything at all is a complete shock to me
|
This is really great news and I'm glad Blizzard and Afreeca will keep GSL running, SC2 wouldn't be the same without the top Korean talent.
|
|
|
|