|
On November 07 2013 13:33 jmbthirteen wrote:Show nested quote +On November 07 2013 13:16 TLNerd wrote:On November 07 2013 10:44 jmbthirteen wrote:On November 07 2013 10:37 TLNerd wrote:On November 07 2013 10:32 Salient wrote:On November 07 2013 08:41 Sunfish wrote:On November 07 2013 08:38 Salient wrote: Wouldn't it be better to interview a woman who is an actual professional gamer instead of just team-house mom? Maybe interview someone like QueenE instead? I recommend you read the rest of the interview. She talks about exactly that perception and what her actual work involves. I'd love to speak with a female progamer. If there's enough interest, I'm hoping to someday moderate a discussion between women in eSports (a player, a host, a behind the scenes type, a developer, w/e). That will have to wait a while though. I honestly don't think our community can handle that discussion yet. I just think an interview with a female professional gamer would be infinitely more interesting than an interview with a non-gaming employee of EG who happens to be female. Of course, EG is not a team that has female players . . . although others do. What does listening/reading to the interview have to do with his opinion about the affiliation of a female to gaming and her validity to speak about the subject? Edit: Of course she has more inside experience than 99.9% of men and women that read this, but that is beside the point. This interview is about female gamers. She is not a female gamer. Yes she is. She's just not a female professional gamer. Professional gamers aren't the only people in esports either. Isn't your pitchfork better suited to move dirt than to defend random girl who plays games? One. Fantastic post Two. No pitchfork. Three. I'm not even defending Anna. I'm defending the journalist and his interview choice. Four. Hardly a random girl.
So you've gone full nerd for absolutely no reason. K.
User was temp banned for this post.
|
Great interview! God, Anna Prosser-Robinson is so damn articulate and insightful! She and Geoff are such badasses!
|
Let people wear what they want to wear. Who cares if some people have issues getting over the fact that there is a girl on the interwebz or playing a game (issues as in can't contain themselves at the site of something like this or issues as in upset that they get attention for being female and wearing different clothes.) The more women that get involved in these events the less attention it'll draw until all that remains is the love of the game. Yes, right now women get attention because, lets face it, most men like women so therefor men pay attention to women. Most of the community is male so most of the community will pay attention to women. When the split is closer to 50/50 men/women then only half the community will pay attention to women and half the community will pay attention to men (with the exception of homosexuals/bisexuals who will pay attention to whoever they prefer.)
Best thing you can do, treat people like people and move on with your life. Don't make a big deal about people doing what people do.
|
It was a great interview and gave some nice insights. Interesting read. People definitely get too caught up in things sometimes
|
Good interview, thanks.
I didn't realize people would complain about cocktail dresses, lol. It is clothing for females. I recommend checking out what the German Chancellor wears. + Show Spoiler +
|
On November 07 2013 21:26 nimbim wrote:Good interview, thanks. I didn't realize people would complain about cocktail dresses, lol. It is clothing for females. I recommend checking out what the German Chancellor wears. + Show Spoiler +
That could blind someone. What's up with the Germans, anyway? If you ever go to a resort, you can be sure that the fattest, oldest, most naked people will be old Krauts or maybe Brits. We Americans get a lot of grief for being obese, but at least we don't show it off like we're proud of it. :p
|
On November 07 2013 21:41 Salient wrote:Show nested quote +On November 07 2013 21:26 nimbim wrote:Good interview, thanks. I didn't realize people would complain about cocktail dresses, lol. It is clothing for females. I recommend checking out what the German Chancellor wears. + Show Spoiler + That could blind someone. What's up with the Germans, anyway? If you ever go to a resort, you can be sure that the fattest, oldest, most naked people will be old Krauts or maybe Brits. We Americans get a lot of grief for being obese, but at least we don't show it off like we're proud of it. :p
Not sure if I can speak for all Germans, but for me a resort is something that exist for old people in the first place. If more German people think like that, then it's no wonder why the German people in a resort are of much higher average age.
|
I've got no idea why any woman would willingly choose to get involved with the basketcase of misogyny that is ESPORTS but it's always a pleasure to hear from Mrs Prosser-Robinson. Besides she seems a damn sight smarter than most of her critics.
|
Anna, I don't know if you will read these comments, but I have a profound respect for you and your ability to both do your job and not sink in one way or another to the level of the ignorant, often-vitriolic feedback the Internet and gaming community gives women. Speaking for myself, I'm glad that EG and the industry in general has people like you and Seltzer (among others) who are unashamedly very feminine and very committed to the community. Kudos all around.
And to the OP: great interview, a very nice read. Thank you for posting.
|
On November 07 2013 09:38 Plansix wrote: It is an infuriating behavior that is prevalent across all of gaming and everyone tries to justify it by saying that there are "some girls that get involved with gaming for attention." Because that is somehow justification for being a dick.
I'm not disagreeing with the 'being a dick' part, but I happened to be chatting with my niece the other weekend and 'girls who get involved with gaming for attention', or 'gamer groupies' as she put it, is a real (and for her, enormously irritating) thing.
Girls at her school will talk about this or that big new release, but when she joins in it's soon clear they're bluffing, and either don't have the game or haven't played it. It's also apparent, when one reads between the lines of social media chatter about who did what and where with whom each evening or weekend, that most don't spend any significant time playing games. And it absolutely is all in order to get attention from boys, because 'gamer girl' is the in-thing to be.
On a personal note this is vexing because I appear to have been born twenty years too early, but moving on:
The simple truth - as I see it, anyway - is that girls and boys have always played separately. When a boy plays a game (particularly anything competitive or with a high score element) a significant part of the pay-off is real or imagined standing within a real or imagined group. And social standing for boys is related to perceived mating rights. Hitting GM may not actually get you laid, but as far as your hind-brain is concerned, it means you're the kind of guy who gets laid.
All this gets thrown into complete disarray when a girl steps up to the plate. Unless she's there to play along, to simper and demonstrate how bad she is, her presence is a direct challenge to that subconscious narrative. "You beat that guy? So what: I beat him. I am a girl and your achievements do not impress me. What else you got?"
Personally I can't think of a single game or sport where men play at a lower level than women - and I don't think that's because men are better at everything. I think it's because men won't compete, even with each other, in an event where women have a natural advantage. It's like entering a 'who's got the smallest dick' contest.
Obviously this is a generalisation; it won't be true of everyone to the same extent. But it's true enough of enough boys to make gaming a culture that's very uncomfortable with girls participating, especially since boys aren't necessarily at a natural advantage in that arena.
|
"attractively feminine "
I lol'd. Either way I feel like we should just let female gamers be female gamers and treat them like we'd treat any male gamer (though that'll never happen).
|
On November 07 2013 09:43 LongShot27 wrote: I don't really care about girls in gaming or hosting or whatever, gender is irrelevant, but saying the equivalent of a suit is a cocktail dress is just flat out dumb, the equivalent is a full dress not a miniskirt
you misread her answer.
she's saying the female equivalent of the MALE co-hosts casual (semi-formal) wear (t-shirts, blazers, jeans/pants) is a cocktail dress, which is probably true. she didn't say a suit = cocktail dress. reading comprehension.
|
On November 07 2013 09:50 bombsauce wrote:Show nested quote +On November 07 2013 09:43 LongShot27 wrote: I don't really care about girls in gaming or hosting or whatever, gender is irrelevant, but saying the equivalent of a suit is a cocktail dress is just flat out dumb, the equivalent is a full dress not a miniskirt I mean a "full dress" implies a formality that would pair with a tuxedo. Women have a lot more liberty is getting away with things like skirts and cocktail dresses etc. to go along with professional wear, especially in the business world. However, just like in the professional world, there is a sort of imaginary "decency line" tied to just how short that skirt or dress is.
Whoah, whoah, whoah.
Tuxedo =/= suit. To find the equivalent of a tuxedo, you'd have to wear a ball gown (and you don't want to wear one of those, they're a BITCH to get on).
Suits can be quite casual. I have a few hanging up in my closet which are widely considered to be for semi-formal wear, nothing more. A cocktail dress is actually a very good equivalent for a normal suit, because they are considered semi-formal. Cocktail dresses are not mini-skirts, they typically reach down just above the knee or even to the ankle, and are not mini-skirts at all.
With so many idiots trying to impose dress rules on women to make them look less slutty, it's incredible the amount of them that don't even understand what women's clothes are like. I'm not implying that you're one of them, but men like that are quite common.
I've never seen a pant suit on any woman in a semi-formal situation. Moreover, imagine how gross it would be if all the women at eSports tournaments started wearing pantsuits. Blech. 
If you don't believe me, take a look at this wikipedia page (emphasis on "semi-formal" and the ankle length comment )
|
On November 07 2013 09:43 LongShot27 wrote: I don't really care about girls in gaming or hosting or whatever, gender is irrelevant, but saying the equivalent of a suit is a cocktail dress is just flat out dumb, the equivalent is a full dress not a miniskirt
A cocktail dress and a miniskirt are not the same thing
|
I think I remember that dress. I think it was red with diamonds and shit to make it all sparkly. Basically people thought she was trying to hog the spotlight. Women have worn dresses before when they host without it being a big deal it was just that occasion.
Also im glad that Anna does behind the scenes stuff now because she wasnt a very good host. Well, to be fair I only like Redeye, the Korean guy and Day9 when he isnt being too corny.
|
Fascinating debate about arbitrary fashion(fuck I hate that word/concept) going on here. In order to avoid further controversy, I propose a dress code for Esports events, full body industrial fatigues with combat boots. Except for Apollo who has to wear a pink pyjamas.
I don't really like the whole idea of putting good looking women up there in skimpy clothing as a marketing tool, I just find it to be a source of irritation, but I clearly understand why it's being done. The show is being marketed to a crowd of 15-30 year old mostly male audience, the math is fairly straightforward.
|
On November 08 2013 02:17 Bowzar wrote: I think I remember that dress. I think it was red with diamonds and shit to make it all sparkly. Basically people thought she was trying to hog the spotlight. Women have worn dresses before when they host without it being a big deal it was just that occasion.
Also im glad that Anna does behind the scenes stuff now because she wasnt a very good host. Well, to be fair I only like Redeye, the Korean guy and Day9 when he isnt being too corny. I'm sorry, people had an issue with a sparkly red dress that IPL picked for them to wear? Because that is beyond stupid. I didn't know our community was so ADD that shiny objects on a woman's dress distracted them and made them unable to listen to interviews. I would understand she went full Mylie Cyrus, but wearing a sparkly red dress is not something we need to be debating.
|
On November 08 2013 02:30 Plansix wrote:Show nested quote +On November 08 2013 02:17 Bowzar wrote: I think I remember that dress. I think it was red with diamonds and shit to make it all sparkly. Basically people thought she was trying to hog the spotlight. Women have worn dresses before when they host without it being a big deal it was just that occasion.
Also im glad that Anna does behind the scenes stuff now because she wasnt a very good host. Well, to be fair I only like Redeye, the Korean guy and Day9 when he isnt being too corny. I'm sorry, people had an issue with a sparkly red dress that IPL picked for them to wear? Because that is beyond stupid. I didn't know our community was so ADD that shiny objects on a woman's dress distracted them and made them unable to listen to interviews. I would understand she went full Mylie Cyrus, but wearing a sparkly red dress is not something we need to be debating. Youre making it sound like there was an uproear. A couple of guys on reddit thought they were trying to hog the spotlight from the players, other people argued against them and the thread got big because of the whole womens role in esports debate. Sponsors didnt get contacted, no one had to apologize and no one got fired. The blonde chick wore a dress again at WCS EU, no one cared. End of story.
|
Sigh.
I'm so disappointed in how this entire thing has been handled.
Sjokz is the perfect role model for excellence.
It was a genius move to try and make Smix the "SC2 Sjokz" but terribly mishandled by ESL and in general too much pressure was put on her from the start. Sjokz had a chance to grow from the comfort of the small studio environment, Smix was expected to instantly be at Iron Squid level.
Disappointed in Anna for not recognizing female hosting in eSports done right when there's an active example of it out there already.
|
On November 08 2013 02:30 Plansix wrote:Show nested quote +On November 08 2013 02:17 Bowzar wrote: I think I remember that dress. I think it was red with diamonds and shit to make it all sparkly. Basically people thought she was trying to hog the spotlight. Women have worn dresses before when they host without it being a big deal it was just that occasion.
Also im glad that Anna does behind the scenes stuff now because she wasnt a very good host. Well, to be fair I only like Redeye, the Korean guy and Day9 when he isnt being too corny. I'm sorry, people had an issue with a sparkly red dress that IPL picked for them to wear? Because that is beyond stupid. I didn't know our community was so ADD that shiny objects on a woman's dress distracted them and made them unable to listen to interviews. I would understand she went full Mylie Cyrus, but wearing a sparkly red dress is not something we need to be debating.
Not to mention the fact that they are told what to wear by the organizers...
|
|
|
|