|
So the question is: When would the new contract take effect. Ganzi seems to believe immediately:
My contract still had five months left on it, and the contract did not have any clauses to modify the content of the contract, which made me unable to accept his demand Jason Lake says this:
We simply offered GanZi a lesser salary for 2013 (his contract expires in March) (So new contract taking effect in april 2013?)
Maybe someone could ask both parties to verify.
|
I think i'll side with complexity on this one. First of all please don't take your business negotiations out to the media and secondly it seems fair to me the due to a decline in popularity/health/performance over some time is reflected in the salary.
|
english korean understanding problems ? xD both sides has a version so we cant say whats true
|
I think coL was right. But anyway I hope Ganzi will recover soon, such a good player with great personality.
|
Two people who speak two different languages had a misunderstanding, big shocker. No need to blow anything up here, ganzi will find a new team and coL will sign someone else.
|
On December 16 2012 20:56 archonOOid wrote: I think i'll side with complexity on this one. First of all please don't take your business negotiations out to the media and secondly it seems fair to me the due to a decline in popularity/health/performance over some time is reflected in the salary.
Normally, I would agree. However, in the case of progamers, it is not like they have an association/union they can turn to when they feel they are getting treated unfairly. As for the change in salary, it depends on how the contract was drafted and the terms.
Could Taeja have asked TL for a immediate raise after this awesome summer run eventhough his contract still had ways to go? For the next contract, of course things like performance will be taken into consideration. But from Ganzi's perspective, they were asking him to change their existing contract, which he has a right to refuse. Of course, if is like Lake said and that it was for next years contract, then I would side with Complexity.
|
so it seems the discussion in this thread has boiled down to whether or not it was fair to cut ganzis salary mid contract? sounds a bit dodgy to me, and true or not ganzi doesn't stand to gain much by airing this, i doubt he's lying, he feels aggrieved and is warning others of a perceived threat.
|
Sad for Ganzi but tbh I wouldn't be surprised if the problem in this conflict would be on his side. Often, when reasonable contract negotations are brought forward by western teams (involving Koreans) the Koreans seem to be butthurt about them.
You're "deeply hurt" because your salary got cut in half? You take that shit personal? Come on...
|
As much as Jason Lake is passionate and hard-edged in ways, he's incredibly fair, and business savvy. If you can blame Jason for anything, it's that an injury-type clause wasn't present in the contract to begin with. Given the increasingly common occurrence regarding RSI and other issues with pro players, I imagine it'll become more commonplace to work out a solution that deals with injuries, their length and how it affects one's salary.
Now, in terms of professional players in other sports, most still get paid their full salary even while injured. Having a guaranteed contract in a professional sport is a lot different than in the area of eSports. eSports organizations simply aren't flush enough to absorb shelling out money to a player that's not streaming, attending tournaments, or anything else they're required to do according to their contract.
While it may seem like a negative and dispiriting thing to happen while a player still has many months remaining on his contract, Jason is simply looking to shore up his organization. And there seems to be some confusion regarding whether they were trying to change his immediate salary, or whether this applies to a new contract next year; I'd have to think it's the latter.
|
CoL did everything right from a business perspective. Sucks for Ganzi though getting injured
|
On December 16 2012 22:09 drooL wrote: Sad for Ganzi but tbh I wouldn't be surprised if the problem in this conflict would be on his side. Often, when reasonable contract negotations are brought forward by western teams (involving Koreans) the Koreans seem to be butthurt about them.
You're "deeply hurt" because your salary got cut in half? You take that shit personal? Come on... More likely he was hurt when they said they wanted to pick up a "more famous and skilled player" and as a result his next salary would be cut in half. I have to agree with Complexity on this one, Ganzi said he was "demanded" to sign a new contract which would be in accordance to what Lake stated.
|
On December 16 2012 22:09 drooL wrote: Sad for Ganzi but tbh I wouldn't be surprised if the problem in this conflict would be on his side. Often, when reasonable contract negotations are brought forward by western teams (involving Koreans) the Koreans seem to be butthurt about them.
You're "deeply hurt" because your salary got cut in half? You take that shit personal? Come on...
I agree with this 100%, it seems silly that players are upset because they're getting less salary, but it makes sense because they are performing worse.
|
Anyone that have a job would probably throw a hissy fit if they go into salary negotiations and your boss wants to cut your salary in half. I would probably quit on the spot if that happened. Naturally sometimes you have to compromise but since we don't really know how the conversation actually played out it's a bit hard to say whether or not Ganzi overreacted.
|
One side says one thing, the other says another. Was ganzi being asked to take a salary cut on his existing contract or future contract? Did complexity say anything that can be deemed "insulting" to a professional player?
|
This pretty much sounds like an unfortunate misunderstanding. :S
|
On December 16 2012 22:38 derpface wrote: CoL did everything right from a business perspective. Sucks for Ganzi though getting injured It depends. If the injury is the sole reason for cutting his salary and he are expected to recover from it (no idea if this is the case) then it could be a pretty douchy thing to do. It can be understandable considering the financial situation of many teams, but still pretty douchy. That doesn't necessarily apply in the case though since it's probably not that black and white.
|
Difficult issue. There are too many unknown things to take a stance reliably. I can understand both parties, judging from their own stories.
Btw, i assume ganzi was deeply hurt because they wanted a more skilled player as a reason to cut his salary, but not the salary cut itself? I'm not really sure on this part.
edit: Oooops, that was my 1000th post..
|
Surprise surprise...its all about Money. Cant tell who is right or wrong here. But i guess that e-sport is a though business. Any Dollar is needed...so dont tell things about loyalty etc...
|
On December 16 2012 19:55 Jinsho wrote:Show nested quote +On December 16 2012 19:53 Technique wrote:On December 16 2012 18:29 RenSC2 wrote: From the outside looking in, it seems like Jason Lake negotiates hard, but fairly, when it comes to contracts. It's very standard practice in the western world. Unfortunately for him, I don't think he understands Korean culture yet and the way they seem to negotiate contracts. Following western business practices with eastern players may burn more bridges for Complexity than they can afford when the best players are almost all Korean. He's going to have to learn how to bridge that gap somehow if he wants Complexity to be a force within SC2. No it's not... ''standard'' would be to wait out the contract and then offer him this contract (or none at all, if you ain't happy with him) This is, of course, nonsense. Contract renegotiation is something you do while the contract is still running, before it ends. Which is exactly what they did there. Sounds to me like they wanted him to sign a contract nullifying the one he had... so they could sign a ''better'' player...
|
As long as they didn't break his existing contract, who is Ganzi to say whether the new terms are fair or not? He had and exercised his option to walk away in search of a better deal.
|
|
|
|