|
On November 01 2011 00:48 Empire.Beastyqt wrote:Show nested quote +On November 01 2011 00:47 RinconH wrote: If event organizers get a bad reputation TL should initiate boycotts of their tourneys Problem is that 90% of tournaments do it data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c81e3/c81e334f952fa6a3b77a0f55297a8c05972c04b5" alt="" Then they shouldn't be allowed to operate. Make sure tournaments have two-way contracts going in, so if they fail to pay the players have legal recourse. For example, if my employer decided not to pay me promptly, they would be in court tomorrow and I would receive my promised paycheck + some absurdly large settlement.
|
On November 01 2011 03:25 driftme wrote:Show nested quote +On November 01 2011 03:13 Teiwaz wrote:On November 01 2011 03:06 driftme wrote:On November 01 2011 02:53 Teiwaz wrote: 2.) Big tournaments have huge business behind them. Players have to understand the bureaucracy behind all that and that it actually takes some time for those companies to get the payment done.
Yes, big tourneys do have big business behind them. Yes, there is bureaucracy in any large business, but there is also still an accounting department that has to handle accounts payable, usually on a net-30 or 60 basis for something like this. [EDIT: Just to clarify im talking about a business submitting payment for advertisement or a sponsorship of an event, not paying tournament winners. When a business sponsors an event, the payment is usually expected from the sponsored entity on a net 30/60 basis, if not before the event. Granted, I've never run an esports sponsored event, but I've dealt with many different types of organizations, sponsorships, and events, and thats how it works in the non-esports world.] Its not like the tournament ends and then the tourney asks the sponsors to pay the players. The sponsorship costs go toward things like the advertising and signs you see around, and then the organizers use that money to pay the players. There is a paper trail and generally accepted accounting practice for this type of stuff. That's not a valid excuse for the organizer. Also, bigger tournaments are put on by organizations that DO have money.. they should be able to have the money in place to pay the players ahead of time, especially with the lead time for the larger tournaments. Its not a logistics problem, its an issue of the organizers not holding true to their word. Of course there are situations where a payment doesnt go through correctly or something, and mistakes DO happen in even the best accounting departments.. but those mistakes are generally caught before "closing the books". Things have to balance out =] I'm not saying that you should accept a ridiculously long waiting period. But up to 3 months is legit IMO. And even you stated that a waiting time of 30-60 days for the SPONSORS to pay their debts is nothing out of the ordinary. Yea, 30-60 is normal AP timeframe. BUT - for every event I've ever worked on (again, non-esports, but fundraisers and tournaments alike), the whole thing is planned way in advance, and when a company buys a sponsorship, the clock starts from when we start doing the printing etc for their ads/posters/whatever. NOT the day of the event. There's PLENTY of time for that money to be received and put into escrow.
Well, I guess that's something the "n00b" in all this business (eSports) has to learn before it gets to a "standard" tournament/fundraiser model. After all, eSports is a pretty new business.
|
Lesson learned: go to MLG peoples :=)
|
something needs to be done about this.Events should sign contracts with the players that give a timeframe for payment an allow the players to take legal action if they do not pay up within the timeframe.
Still, until that happens, us spectators should try to identify tournaments that are especially bad at paying out prizes and boycott their streams until they do.
|
Pretty bullshit. If you don't have the money or you aren't 100% sure you'll get the money from sponsors, dear tournament makers, don't freaking do it.
|
On November 01 2011 03:17 polarfluKe wrote:Show nested quote +On November 01 2011 01:53 DarKFoRcE wrote: I updated my list with approximate amounts of money owed, might be slighty off in some instances:
Dailymotion Cup 200$ or € EPS Season 17 ~450€ EPS Summer 2011 ~300€ Dreamhack Winter 2010 BYOC Qualifier (3000 SEK ~ 320€) Epiccup invite turnier 50$ Virus invite turnier (100 or 150)$ IPL Season 2 400$ WCG National Finals (Hardware prize) GeForce Pro Turnier 1575$ + hardware TheGreat Showmatch hardware Zotac Monthly Final September 500€ 16.10.2011 Polarfluke OPtoberfest ~340$ 19.10.2011 ESL Monthly Final September 500€
I did PM you regarding this, but I feel you have not played your part in the discussion and I have the right to say what I must say now. How exactly do you expect us to pay you? Did you bother to send me your payment details before I had to PM you earlier for them? Did you even read the tournament rules that are in place? Here is an excerpt from our Rules, updated on 13/10/2011: Payments (Added 13-10-2011) South African players must submit their banking details from their registered e-mail address Non South African players must submit their PayPal details from their registered e-mail address All prizes are paid in ZAR and thus the estimated USD value may be different to that stated on the tournament page due to currency fluctuations Players must submit their payment details within 2(two) weeks of the end of a tournament to receive their payment else the prize will be forfeit Once the 2(two) week period is over, all payments will be processed I did tell you after reading your OP that I would still make your payment even though you had failed to adhere to the rules of the tournament. This is absolutely ridiculous that you are including tournaments from 2 weeks ago; while I do support talking up about tournaments and hosts that have an extremely long wait time, you are causing damage to guys like me who do actually pay up. I work my ass off to host monthly tournaments with good prize pools. I spend hours upon hours in meetings, trying to get more money into my tournaments and with one or two posts you are able to wrongfully ruin a reputation my organization has earned. PolarfluKe has been running since May 2010 and we have run 18 tournaments for Starcraft II. Every tournament is paid up in full except for the tournament we hosted 2 weeks ago(15-16 October). If you had bothered to read the rules regarding payments (which I was forced to add because it takes players too long to send their payment details), I explicitly state how the payment structure works now. Do not lay blame on myself or my organization for payment not received when you can not adhere to simple rules. Did you bother to send your payment details to anyone in that list?
Quoting this because too many people are simply jumping on the bandwagon without having both sides of the story.
|
NBA lockout, this issues...
All it's about F money... damnit
|
I am curious, blizzard does get a share from all prizepools above 5000 euro if I am not mistaken. Does it take all those organisations also more then 90 days to pay them. And how does Blizzard react on this?
|
On November 01 2011 01:34 Special Endrey wrote:I heard from quite a lot of players, that there where a lot of problems with paying out prize money too. I even helped some getting in contact with admins/sponsors esp when there are language barriers involved and tournament admins are not beeing able to proper communicate. Still, this is not always the tournament organizers beeing super greedy. Sometimes you as an organizer make a contract with a sponsor and they simply don't pay up in time. So this leaves the organizers in a hole of shit. Becasue they are blamed by the players and the general audience (/r/pitchfork anyone? hehe) for sponsors not holding on to signed contracts. I am not saying this is always the case, I don't even know if this is the majority or the minority. But I am saying that it is not always that simple. So beeing to fast on judging people/tournaments, might not always be the best idea data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c81e3/c81e334f952fa6a3b77a0f55297a8c05972c04b5" alt="" Still, this thread absolutly deserves attention, it is good that it is not that one sided. If organizers have a legal contract with their sponsors, and those sponsors fail to pay, the organizers should immediately take the matter to court. Stop making excuses if you have legal recourse.
If someone sets up a tournament, completes the proper documentation, and still fails to pay, of course they deserve to be judged and held accountable. Business is business and no one can consider themselves professional unless they do what all other professional organizations in every field do.
|
Unfortunately this has been the case in progaming since day one. Quake had the same problem, in some cases on a massive scale, one tournament organized owed $1 000 000, for example.
|
On November 01 2011 03:30 Celadan wrote: Lesson learned: go to MLG peoples :=) only problem with that is MLG has a lousy prize pool and absurd competition... (probably the second hardest tournaments in the world but they pay out like 1/100th of what the gsl pays
but yea this is totally unacceptable and I'm looking forward to sotg tomorrow so we can hear some more absurd stories
|
On November 01 2011 03:33 michielbrands wrote: I am curious, blizzard does get a share from all prizepools above 5000 euro if I am not mistaken. Does it take all those organisations also more then 90 days to pay them. And how does Blizzard react on this?
They don't get a share of the prizepool, they get a share of the ad revenue I think, slightly different.
|
im glad this thread exists. see as a tight community, and by singling out the tournaments that do this and dont pay, we can just boycott them. The next time i see a tournament going on that i know doesnt like to pay out, i just wont watch it, or ill post in the thread of the tourney asking about the plans to pay prize money.. making this thread is crucial for esports to truly flourish. and as a community we need to take this seriously.
|
Do people know how expensive it is to go to court? At least in the US it's REALLY freaking expensive. And you won't win if you're right, you'll win if you have more money and more lawyers. If there is indeed a problem we should really be looking to solve it outside the courtroom.
|
Pandemona
Charlie Sheens House51449 Posts
Would love NesTea or MVP to make a post..
I havent been paid for MLG Providence 2011 yet....I won first place aswell ^_^
|
On November 01 2011 03:26 Diamond wrote:Show nested quote +On November 01 2011 03:24 VPGeneralHans wrote:On November 01 2011 03:15 Diamond wrote:On November 01 2011 03:12 Dr_Jones wrote:On November 01 2011 03:05 ReachTheSky wrote:On November 01 2011 03:02 Dr_Jones wrote: Am I completely bonkers for thinking that this is a managerial issue, that should be dealt with by the team managers for the players involved? It just seems odd that it isnt a bit more professional than this :/ Yes you are completely bonkers data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c81e3/c81e334f952fa6a3b77a0f55297a8c05972c04b5" alt="" . I think what would be a bit more professional is organizations paying money out within reasonable timeframes. I obviously agree with that, but as Carmac had been saying they were providing a 3 month delay for most of their tournaments. I guess this is to allow enough time to deal with all the paperwork involved with moving money around internationally (as Joshy.IGN pointed out, some countries are quite restrictive about such thing *cough The US cough*) But, why doesn't the player talk to the team manager, who then talks to the tournament manager, and resolve the issue this way? Obviously doesn't work with every small daily online cups, but for the the big name organised ones this would seem a minimum requirement? Again, I might be bonkers for expecting it, but it just seem like this would be way more professional (than posting on TL.net). I hope we reach that stage at one point in eSports, because that's when it becomes truly credible in my view data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c81e3/c81e334f952fa6a3b77a0f55297a8c05972c04b5" alt="" Just throwing this out there, most Non-Korean team managers actually do very little managing. I think I have dealt with one foreign team manager ever (Naz with Liquid, who is awesome) in all my time doing foreign events. I know Scoots is active with EG but most other team managers never would get involved in something like this. Why? The hell if I know, but it seems to be an issue all in itself. In the case of tournament winnings etc I think team managers should support their players and assist to give advice KR apply pressure but I don't think they should be in charge of collecting players prize money. Seems a wee bit intrusive and if I was a player I'd rather want to handle it myself. The less layers of communication you have to go through from player to person in charge is better Why on earth should professional players be worrying about things like collecting money? There job is to play, it's the managers job to manage. Crazy shit I know...
You want me sending in private forms with your tax records and bank details o.o Imagine if you were a USA player, I'd need to know your social security number to do anything that deals with companies.
If a player asks me to help them, I will help them of course. It's just not at a stage with real sports were they have lawyers and accountants bound by law to be private with a clients details.
|
On November 01 2011 03:26 Diamond wrote:Show nested quote +On November 01 2011 03:24 VPGeneralHans wrote:On November 01 2011 03:15 Diamond wrote:On November 01 2011 03:12 Dr_Jones wrote:On November 01 2011 03:05 ReachTheSky wrote:On November 01 2011 03:02 Dr_Jones wrote: Am I completely bonkers for thinking that this is a managerial issue, that should be dealt with by the team managers for the players involved? It just seems odd that it isnt a bit more professional than this :/ Yes you are completely bonkers data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c81e3/c81e334f952fa6a3b77a0f55297a8c05972c04b5" alt="" . I think what would be a bit more professional is organizations paying money out within reasonable timeframes. I obviously agree with that, but as Carmac had been saying they were providing a 3 month delay for most of their tournaments. I guess this is to allow enough time to deal with all the paperwork involved with moving money around internationally (as Joshy.IGN pointed out, some countries are quite restrictive about such thing *cough The US cough*) But, why doesn't the player talk to the team manager, who then talks to the tournament manager, and resolve the issue this way? Obviously doesn't work with every small daily online cups, but for the the big name organised ones this would seem a minimum requirement? Again, I might be bonkers for expecting it, but it just seem like this would be way more professional (than posting on TL.net). I hope we reach that stage at one point in eSports, because that's when it becomes truly credible in my view data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c81e3/c81e334f952fa6a3b77a0f55297a8c05972c04b5" alt="" Just throwing this out there, most Non-Korean team managers actually do very little managing. I think I have dealt with one foreign team manager ever (Naz with Liquid, who is awesome) in all my time doing foreign events. I know Scoots is active with EG but most other team managers never would get involved in something like this. Why? The hell if I know, but it seems to be an issue all in itself. In the case of tournament winnings etc I think team managers should support their players and assist to give advice KR apply pressure but I don't think they should be in charge of collecting players prize money. Seems a wee bit intrusive and if I was a player I'd rather want to handle it myself. The less layers of communication you have to go through from player to person in charge is better Why on earth should professional players be worrying about things like collecting money? There job is to play, it's the managers job to manage. Crazy shit I know... This is what separates Korea from the world right now.
Westerners are starting to form pro-gaming houses which is a good start. But Koreans literally have nothing to worry about aside from practicing. They have maids to clean, chefs to cook and managers that deal with everything non-gaming related.
It must be rough being a player when you have to do all 3 of those + be expected to practice 8+ hrs a day and compete with the Koreans/rest of the world.
|
On November 01 2011 03:33 hmunkey wrote:Show nested quote +On November 01 2011 01:34 Special Endrey wrote:I heard from quite a lot of players, that there where a lot of problems with paying out prize money too. I even helped some getting in contact with admins/sponsors esp when there are language barriers involved and tournament admins are not beeing able to proper communicate. Still, this is not always the tournament organizers beeing super greedy. Sometimes you as an organizer make a contract with a sponsor and they simply don't pay up in time. So this leaves the organizers in a hole of shit. Becasue they are blamed by the players and the general audience (/r/pitchfork anyone? hehe) for sponsors not holding on to signed contracts. I am not saying this is always the case, I don't even know if this is the majority or the minority. But I am saying that it is not always that simple. So beeing to fast on judging people/tournaments, might not always be the best idea data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c81e3/c81e334f952fa6a3b77a0f55297a8c05972c04b5" alt="" Still, this thread absolutly deserves attention, it is good that it is not that one sided. If organizers have a legal contract with their sponsors, and those sponsors fail to pay, the organizers should immediately take the matter to court. Stop making excuses if you have legal recourse. If someone sets up a tournament, completes the proper documentation, and still fails to pay, of course they deserve to be judged and held accountable. Business is business and no one can consider themselves professional unless they do what all other professional organizations in every field do.
That's how US law works and tries to force itself on every other fucking country. Doesn't work so on every other part of the world. European tournament + US sponsor? Going to court? Not so easy.
But I'm no lawyer...
|
On November 01 2011 03:37 VPGeneralHans wrote:Show nested quote +On November 01 2011 03:26 Diamond wrote:On November 01 2011 03:24 VPGeneralHans wrote:On November 01 2011 03:15 Diamond wrote:On November 01 2011 03:12 Dr_Jones wrote:On November 01 2011 03:05 ReachTheSky wrote:On November 01 2011 03:02 Dr_Jones wrote: Am I completely bonkers for thinking that this is a managerial issue, that should be dealt with by the team managers for the players involved? It just seems odd that it isnt a bit more professional than this :/ Yes you are completely bonkers data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c81e3/c81e334f952fa6a3b77a0f55297a8c05972c04b5" alt="" . I think what would be a bit more professional is organizations paying money out within reasonable timeframes. I obviously agree with that, but as Carmac had been saying they were providing a 3 month delay for most of their tournaments. I guess this is to allow enough time to deal with all the paperwork involved with moving money around internationally (as Joshy.IGN pointed out, some countries are quite restrictive about such thing *cough The US cough*) But, why doesn't the player talk to the team manager, who then talks to the tournament manager, and resolve the issue this way? Obviously doesn't work with every small daily online cups, but for the the big name organised ones this would seem a minimum requirement? Again, I might be bonkers for expecting it, but it just seem like this would be way more professional (than posting on TL.net). I hope we reach that stage at one point in eSports, because that's when it becomes truly credible in my view data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c81e3/c81e334f952fa6a3b77a0f55297a8c05972c04b5" alt="" Just throwing this out there, most Non-Korean team managers actually do very little managing. I think I have dealt with one foreign team manager ever (Naz with Liquid, who is awesome) in all my time doing foreign events. I know Scoots is active with EG but most other team managers never would get involved in something like this. Why? The hell if I know, but it seems to be an issue all in itself. In the case of tournament winnings etc I think team managers should support their players and assist to give advice KR apply pressure but I don't think they should be in charge of collecting players prize money. Seems a wee bit intrusive and if I was a player I'd rather want to handle it myself. The less layers of communication you have to go through from player to person in charge is better Why on earth should professional players be worrying about things like collecting money? There job is to play, it's the managers job to manage. Crazy shit I know... You want me sending in private forms with your tax records and bank details o.o Imagine if you were a USA player, I'd need to know your social security number to do anything that deals with companies. If a player asks me to help them, I will help them of course. It's just not at a stage with real sports were they have lawyers and accountants bound by law to be private with a clients details. I'm fairly certain he meant things like hassling organizers for money. Contacting them and demanding to know what the situation is. Submitting relevant paperwork will obviously be up to the player still. But they shouldn't have to spend their time trying to contact organizers and find out why they aren't being paid.
|
On November 01 2011 03:34 Carush wrote:Show nested quote +On November 01 2011 03:30 Celadan wrote: Lesson learned: go to MLG peoples :=) only problem with that is MLG has a lousy prize pool and absurd competition... (probably the second hardest tournaments in the world but they pay out like 1/100th of what the gsl pays
Before you jump to that, you should know that they are increasing it for next year and they couldn't increase it mid-season this year. And they also will be organizing one of the biggest tournament this year with massive prize pool. (Providence)
But yes, i agree with the rest.
|
|
|
|