EPT[VOTE] SC2 Player quality limits in order to post - Page 2
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
Slakter
Sweden1947 Posts
| ||
|
SixTwo
Netherlands68 Posts
As for the discussion parts with only allowing diamond level players to post, in my opinion that won't work as many many people that are in diamond don't deserve to be there, I'm mostlly lurking on these forums and beeing denied access to a part of a forum just because I don't play sc2 enough to be 1200+ doesn't sound very good to me. QXC you've probablly heard of him, is a great great player and I'm sure if he makes a post about something he feels needs posting, people that post negative responses just for the sake of posting, without actually discussing the matter at hand again like I said won't stay here much longer. SOmme people that have been warned or banned for 2+ days have been banned for one line posts, trolling, or even just quoting the guy above, when they provide no feedback on the discussion they need to go. (TLDR): TL.net is great, please keep it as it is. | ||
|
Monokeros
United States2493 Posts
| ||
|
ryanAnger
United States838 Posts
This could also fix the issue that was mentioned by Saracen, where a lot of pros don't actually like to post here any more because there is always an abundance of noobs telling them that they are stupid, whenever they post something. | ||
|
Dekoth
United States527 Posts
How about a Forum where the quality of yours posting earns you the right to post, instead of some arbitrary number? It would make a great deal more sense to base it off what someone has proven they can bring to the table of discourse instead of some number that may or may not of been earned. | ||
|
Tenks
United States3104 Posts
| ||
|
Rakanishu2
United States475 Posts
But it probably won't. Sadly. | ||
|
Blix
Netherlands873 Posts
 | ||
|
Chaos
United States772 Posts
+ Show Spoiler + btw "I'm high rank plat, my games are usually vs. 500pt Diamonds. so.... whats that C or lower in ICCUP?" probably means you're D rank iccup  | ||
|
Marahumm
United States98 Posts
| ||
|
FantaFunL
Belgium71 Posts
On September 21 2010 04:10 SmoKim wrote: i always giggle when a thread starts with "hai gais im 800-9000 point diamond player, therefore my opinion matters" you come of as a huge elitist in my eyes, in the end its the staff of TL that decides stuff like that, and tbh i don't think they want it to be a regime like that Did you read the OP | ||
|
Rakanishu2
United States475 Posts
On September 21 2010 04:09 artanis2 wrote: I think you'll be surprised by how many immature "pro" players there are. I think I won't. Make this feature happen and we'll see how it works out. | ||
|
Humdrum
40 Posts
| ||
|
Karthane
United States1183 Posts
| ||
|
Tuneful
United States327 Posts
| ||
|
MoreFaSho
United States1427 Posts
On September 21 2010 04:17 Karthane wrote: I'd be up for having a sub forum that only "pros" can post in, just to have all their posts in one place and to be able to easily look at their strats/thoughts etc. But i think these people should not be just over 1200 rating. I think the TL staff should designate who they think should be able to post there. Hopefully people like IdrA, Huk, LzGaMeR, etc. Don't let IdrA find out you compared him to HuK and Lz, his head my explode with BM. | ||
|
rycho
United States360 Posts
Also, comparing anything to arenajunkies is pretty much a joke, I was a member of that site from the day it was created and i saw very few intelligent threads and mostly exactly what you guys are complaining about, people you don't think are intelligent or highly ranked enough to be posting making stupid threads or whatever. | ||
|
VonLego
United States519 Posts
The largest issue for setting the forum up would be how to allow privileges. Invite only would work for "pros only" but a 1300+ forum would need some automation likely requiring folks to link their TL accounts with their profiles. I don't know how much time or money would be required in setting that up. I second issue which could likely could be worked around with some ingenuity is that the "good players" have an ever moving point value. Perhaps time will show that eventually we know "1500+ is a very good player" but currently we just know that point values have been slowly going up since launch. Solution likely would involve a "Rating > 1000 + kTime" in place of "Rating > 1300" to account for this steady growth of rating as the season goes on. | ||
|
Gorguts
Canada254 Posts
On September 21 2010 04:01 Mantikor wrote: I'm high rank plat, my games are usually vs. 500pt Diamonds. so.... whats that C or lower in ICCUP? LOL? try D- | ||
|
NuKedUFirst
Canada3139 Posts
On September 21 2010 04:11 Sl4ktarN wrote: This is so elitistic. I disagree. The "lesser players" will still be able to read it, they just can't reply and fuck the thing up. I think it's an awesome idea. Right now the strategy forum is like bronze players OP with a diamond player response or diamond player with a bunch of bad bronze responses. | ||
| ||
