[M][N] Medic Mafia
Forum Index > TL Mafia |
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On February 19 2018 17:21 prplhz wrote: what about making it a no flip game That'd become a shitfest. Good idea! (no sarcasm) | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
Will /in again probably next week if it hasn't started by then. But going to be busy for the next few days. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
but the hosty might be /out | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
I'm town so my posting rhythm should reach critical mass sometime soon I suppose. I'm moderately caught up and after reading a bunch of posts (of which I'm reading more as I write this up) I think that rsoultin and Moosy are town, and also the volumetric heroes of D1. For some reason I like the fact DF peaced in just to tell us he's going to read the OP tomorrow. Thanks DF. Tubesock/AMG/Noobking early interaction could yield scum. On March 06 2018 11:03 n00bKing wrote: Well let's not allow ourselves to become distracted by discussion that doesn't need to take place yet. We don't need to decide whether to mass claim on Day 2 until it's Day 2. On March 06 2018 11:36 Tubesock wrote: Didn't you just chastise me for talking about mass claiming strategy? And here you are talking about setup and strategy. Your hypocrisy is delicious. On March 06 2018 13:59 AMG wrote: He did not chastise you at all. Why are you so pricky? I can't decide if Tube overreacted here which I'm not sure he did cause choosing the path to conflict isn't really the mafias way. So leaning less towards tube mafia purely from this. Just seemed genuinely pissed that noobking shut him down about something and then started talking about that anyway. The AMG post initially looks like he wants to rectify the way Tubesock reacts. He drags out the prickly argumentation out for too long for my taste and transforms it into a full fledged scumread a few posts later. I can't really get behind AMGs reasons to scumread Tube as they are. He possibly went into the discussion with the mindset "I'll take safe sides in a TvT discussion and point at Tube making a mistake" , but since AMG also had to do something out of that to maintain the looks of doing something, he took the only thing he pointed out (prickly Tube) and made a case out of it. On March 06 2018 15:24 AMG wrote: Being prickly is scummy. You have to accept that people are going to ping you in this game. A prickly reaction usually comes from someone trying to hide something and reacting poorly. I don't have an opinion for or against people discussing strategy or mass claiming. I'll be spending my calories focusing on the psychology of players as opposed to trying to game mechanics. I don't find noobking scummy at all, I'm actually pretty certain he's town But he actually only votes Tube when Noobking does: On March 06 2018 20:45 AMG wrote: Basically, this. ##Vote: Tubesock Bottom line, i'm 1/13th of the game and you don't seem to care to engage me, I'd like to know why. And saying we disagree on one point is absolutely not an answer. I don't even know how his bottom line relates to anything he said before about being prickly. Hitting post, voting amg and resuming :> | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
Handing cookies to the wrong people? Why did he get a cookie? On March 06 2018 15:58 MoosyDoosy wrote: If I recall correctly this is exactly how the old n00bKing I knew of old was like. Always fussing with fine details I would just gloss over Is this a townread? Cause I just wrote up the same and it makes me townread him. I don't understand this whole thingy about tubesock calling HF medic. Seems like he's being misrepped since he also clarified it sufficiently in my opinion. It does make noobking come out as townie but why is tubesock mafia for any of this? The synopsis was that HF can fakeclaim mafia as town or medic where did tubesock mean it in any other way, poor wording excluded? | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
I don't see what would have required catching up in regards to his initial tubesock read however. It remains a read that is essentially based on Tube being prickly entirely, except that the actual vote happens only when Noobking votes. His initial impression that Tube is prickly goes from being an observation to an explanation for why it is scummy to a vote for other reasons. It looks like he reacts to his own posts to keep up a narrative in this case. I see it like this could have happened: Townie overreacts to other townie, AMG spots possible fault by TS, calls him prickly but doesn't go with it anywhere. So he needs to make a followup posts telling us that he thinks it's a mafia trait cause the previous post alone in the room would look bad. Only when Noobking attacks Tubesock AMG decides to vote for him, and he does it by rehashing/agreeing with what Noobking said. So AMG was kind of looking for reasons to get onto Tubesock purely for the reason he called him prickly already, and since his own reason didn't get enough pull, he only felt like he had the opportunity to do so when Noobking voted first. This is summed up what's not right with AMG in my opinion. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 06 2018 16:00 MoosyDoosy wrote: I thought Damdred was pretty town so far what makes you think he's scum? | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 08 2018 00:19 MoosyDoosy wrote: + Show Spoiler + On March 07 2018 17:34 MoosyDoosy wrote: no can do buddy sorry I do things my own way. The post was really light and jokey and metagamey and toney which are all things I see town Damdred doing. It's a tonal read so that's about as good as the description gets but I've actually played a fair amount of games with Damdred and this seems town Damdred. chaoser sounds exactly like me. When is this man entering the thread I need to meet him. Thanks. And you would stick to that read at this point? Cause besides you playing a fair amount of games with him and him seeming town to you, there really is no argument in the room for Damdred being town that anyone else could see except from your experienced point of view? For all I know, Damdred can still be mafia and what he's posted so far doesn't particularly sway me either way. On March 07 2018 02:56 Damdred wrote: It was more boring then I originally thought it would be, in that regard i'm slightly...disappointed. But Rsoultin is more than likely town, perhaps hard town in my mind at present. The way she read me seemed like a way she would do in town, and honestly even though I am not quite the player I was she would still like to interact with me then piling on early, also tone is pretty good and not pestering HF to get him to tilt is also a point in her favor. Never doubt this read my friends. Also AMG and Moosey are more than likely town in this situation. Both seem open, inquisitive and a good tone. Also Moosey I believe town read me early which I liked! (I like it when people come up with interesting reasons to townread someone as pro town ^_-, even if I could fake it as scum). I actually don't like FF at this point so far, his tone seemed a bit off earlier and sort of like he was just trying to post to post a bit? But it was still early and its just a lean. Tube I am not sure of, this slip I don't really buy and don't want to lynch him for that so far ehhhh. This post could come from mafia. 7 lines explaining his town reads, 3 explaining his scum reads. Easy to just get cred points by townreading people and spending as little as possible on his scumreads. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
Not even his scumreads, he says FF is just a lean and Tube isn't a scumread, it's a null and he doesn't look at him particularly well aside from the slip that HF wanted to sell. Which takes me to that (a post on the backburner): On March 06 2018 16:24 Holyflare wrote: Tubesock has called me medic! Not just town or mafia. Medic. Let that sink in. ##vote tubesock On March 06 2018 16:30 Holyflare wrote: Yes and as noobking says someone said I can do that as either alignment or any role but you have specifically said I'm a medic. There's a big difference from saying what I said means nothing to saying what I said means I am medic but either alignment. It appears like you know I'm medic but then add a hedge on top as a "oh I don't know" to fit in. It's a weird thought process comparatively to hf can be anything. Why shouldn't he call you town or mafia medic after you claimed medic? Why would mafia be more prone to take your claim at face value? If you are not one of them and Tube is, none of his information should push him towards believing you more or less. Or can you explain why believing your claim is more likely to happen to mafia who should pay attention to not let slip that they know someone is town. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 07 2018 05:12 darthfoley wrote: Okay i've caught up. AMG and n00b are pretty townie ATM. I think Damdred is kinda townie right now actually, for once. Maybe rsoultin too, because I agree with her about Tubesock. He might be mafia, but not for the reasons HF is pushing. The medic thing is really NAI even if it's "strange" Lynch pool of prplhz, FF and Tubesock for the time being. I really didn't like how FF announced his first read, then felt the need to explain why he's scumreading prplhz in the next post. I think you either 1) do both in one post or 2) announce your scum read, then explain it if asked. Just felt a tad like he's trying to make sure everyone knows he has reasoning behind his scumread, if that makes sense. A loveless post. This dude and this dude are town atm. I think this dude is kinda townie right now actually, for once [are you sure you didn't forget to add anything, df] Maybe this dudess is is town too because I agree with her about that dude. Lynch these three dudes for the time being. Here's an explanation for one of them: I didn't like that he didn't post both read and reasons in one post [which could be said for AMG]. Peace out. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
For all I know he took a stance similar to mine in regards to the AMG tubesock discussion. His filter doesn't make me lean either way. Why you? | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
What makes him lazy mafia over lazy town here? | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
Reading through moosy I noticed he pointed out how you had DF on the radar for his entrance but I don't see much investigation into him afterwards even now that he's been in the spotlight for a while (hopefully I didn't miss anything). To answer your previous question regarding my reads on you and Moosy: I ruled you out based on tone and amount of content when I started playing and skimmed a bit. You bossing around the thread and Moosys general involvedness. Just some heuristic early townreads to get started and reduce the pool of peeps I'm looking into. Those are superficial reads so prone to change as the game goes on. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 08 2018 06:03 AMG wrote: You completely overlook the reason I take issue with tubesock which I've gone over two or three times now. His pricklyness catches my eye, as did him having a read that conflicted with mine, so I challenged his read. He refused to discuss anything with me at all, like he didn't give a shit about my alignment and had no drive to find out why I had a different opinion to him. Except all of this happened not at once but you went from prickly->didn't fight your read->disengaged in your argumentation where you placed your vote at the final one after noobking did. So I can see you as mafia just building on your previous posts reacting to what you wrote to create a tubesock scumread which was consistent with what you already wrote, especially cause of your decision on when to place the vote (when another one already did) _____ I am actually open to the idea I'm wrong on either of you atm and after reading a bit of tube (since he talks about himself instead of finding mafia most of the time, but could be cause he's been in the defensive). And cause I'm always hesitant to lynch possible assets D1 I'm checking if there might be other ones worth lynching over df. Since you are so hung up on tube though I'd expect you to bring forward something more than what you already have and your read on him hasn't evolved much from that point onwards. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
Since you are so hung up on tube though I'd expect you to bring forward something more than what you already have and your read on him hasn't evolved much from that point onwards. I just remembered you townread him afterwards for some reason. Kind of interesting that you type this though: You completely overlook the reason I take issue with tubesock Why take? I thought you changed him back to town? | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 08 2018 07:10 n00bKing wrote: Ok, I'm off. Didn't see any backup on this, but to my eyes, the DF lynch doesn't thrill me. The push on Tubesock has been going for a long time, without much result, so I guess it's not happening today. ##Unvote Would love to see this happen: ##Vote: KelsierSC Why him over prpl? On March 07 2018 15:13 n00bKing wrote: Re: What Tubesock liked about Prpl's filter So being wishy-washy is a Town trait now? There's nothing to like about Prpl's play, in my opinion. All he's done is claim Cop, be vague and non-committal about whether he thinks you should be pushed, be vague and non-committal about suspicions that AMG's reads feel forced, and talk about a SK role that we know isn't in the game. I never like it when people say something like "I'm interested in seeing where this goes though." Just means they have no plans of making it go somewhere themselves...so I think to myself....then what good are you? | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 08 2018 07:16 AMG wrote: I'm a single parent that works. Activity will not be consistent. And when I return to the thread with a point to make, only to see someone has already said it, I see no need to repeat what I'm saying. And if you can't follow along with my thought process on why I've stepped away from my tubesock read, and, i was being nice about it up until this point, I'll absolutely spell it out for you: he's playing too stupid for me to expect logical and sensible responses and play from and I've gleaned that from our most recent conversation. Therefore I wont be calling him scum for not living up to the expectations that I have of him, I'm going to call him dumb town and move on to discussing other players. Sorry if you have it rough with the responsibilities. I'm not confident about your alignment but I feel good about just leaving the topic for now. Not going to push further for your lynch today. Besides we made the respective points of view clear enough I think. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 08 2018 07:20 darthfoley wrote: I can't remember Tubesock actually pushing anyone. He's been on the defensive all game, and I also disagree with his town read on prplhz That'd be my issue with tube too. Reactive and self-centered filter, but you're also somewhere in that category for me. I'd feel a lot better about lynching you if HF wasn't trying so hard to keep you on the block as I'm not sure what he is yet. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
##Unvote ##Vote: Noobking Cause he still hasn't explained how the hell he goes from summing up reasons for voting prpl, then voting Kelsier instead when tubesock isn't happening. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 08 2018 07:30 Fecalfeast wrote: I'm not gonna be here to defend myself in the final minutes so I'm a good shenanigan target but you probably shouldn't kill me Totally not a medic claim? | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 08 2018 07:37 rsoultin wrote: Yeah, no. Not voting for him. Saying you have 'no reason' to townread someone does not read to me as more scummy than outright saying you think afkers this game are more likely to be scum because of the balance. I don't necessarily agree with his thoughts, but the vote makes sense in context to me. Well the explanation isn't coming today either, but in my opinion what he did is serious bs. Serious scummy BS. I find his filter pretty hard to follow and will probably reserve an hour or so tomorrow reading it as he wasn't spare with words. Currently just juggling the question: prplhz or df if noobking isn't happening for what he did. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
3 actually, and 2 who forgot about the game. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 08 2018 07:45 rsoultin wrote: I'll take prp over df. I really think df is town here, though I'm not going to pretend that he's someone that I'm sure I can read. But why not tube? Hard to find an answer to that within 10 minutes. Right off the bat there is no reason not to lynch tube that comes to mind. I'd have kept him over prpl for D1. But since prpl isn't voting, might as well vote TS. The vote doesn't sit too right with me after arguing lots of the day about all his qualms with AMG and noobking, but what alternative do I have? Literally the only reason I have is the lack of scumhunting, but it's hard to tell if it's cause he was pushed into the defensive or cause he's mafia. meh ##Unvote ##Vote: Tubesock | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
Your 4 k post reward. Put link to the post into your profile or riot | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 08 2018 08:03 darthfoley wrote: Meh I thought we got him considering he was lurking at deadline I think he said he wouldn't be around maybe. Any ideas on how to make use of your medic claim? | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 08 2018 08:06 Holyflare wrote: I'm healing df. What happened to your statement that df is n1 kill though | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
As for HFs claim, I'll assume it can be true but doesn't have to. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 08 2018 09:51 Holyflare wrote: Yeah, not saying it wasn't but this is mafia and when it goes against the collective thought for reasons other people struggle to see then it deserves to be looked into. That's quite literally the game. Do you know about the experiment where 2 dudes told another dude that three lines of same length were different and most of the subjects responded wrongly as a result. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
Unless AMG for some reason thinks (Knows?) that DF is mafia and they're going to roleblock someoneelse? This is mostly my fantasy speaking but the more I see from him the less I like him for town. I think he's the type of guy who can just blind you with post size. The promised dive of his filter is still due though. tl;dr: Why did Noobking vote Kelsier and not prpl. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 08 2018 23:52 Holyflare wrote: He explained it? He said he'd rather vote a guy who posts absolutely nothing than a guy that has posted something but could come back. Just used a lot more words. I missed that post. Not happy with the explanation. On March 08 2018 14:18 n00bKing wrote: ...huh? Because Kelsier was a no-show (in the game thread at least) and prpl wasn't. You act like one vs. the other is an equivalent choice. It's not. If people want to make a big deal over this, I can explain further. But I would have thought that the reasons why you lynch a literal no-show (like Kelsier or chaoser) over someone who makes a few posts and then bails for the rest of the Phase (like prpl or damdred) were fairly obvious. And further explained down here. Paragraph 1: Explains he doesn't care that he thought prpl was scummy cause he's lynching for information and KSC is better in that regard. Doesn't make the slightest sense but whatever. Basically it's banking on KSC never posting for the rest of the game and an overly worded afk policy lynch. Paragraph 2: Something about his subjective experience about what players do who don't participate D1 as further justification. Paragraph 3: The bolded stands for b as in bullshit cause we've had discussion revolving around tubesock, prpl to a lesser extent, df all day and Noob basically ignored all of that in his decision on who to put his vote on. And that's already an invalid premise to his entire paragraph since he's claiming there was no consensus anywhere when he was in the thread while df had 3 votes and was leading wagon if I recall correctly. On March 08 2018 15:28 n00bKing wrote: You can't get as much information from killing someone who is low-activity as you can get from seeing what they say if they aren't DEAD. In my experience, people who are low activity usually tend to come back. And if they're Town, they can still contribute (they did show SOME interest in participating in the game after it started, at least, and they have seen SOME of what happened, as it happened) and if they're Scum, their posts will give you more opportunities to catch them. As well as more opportunities to see who they end up tied to WHILE you catch them. Conversely, I've virtually never seen a total Day 1 no-show Town player come into the thread later, and then play like a rock star. Those players hadn't shown that interest in participating, and then by the time they come along, the thread is unwieldy, and reading filters doesn't yield context if you weren't following along at the time. Even reading the thread straight through may not yield proper context, if you aren't paying attention to timestamps the whole way too. The value to the Town of a Town player who no-showed Day 1 is LOW. But the value to the Mafia of a Mafia player who no-showed Day 1 is still HIGH. His value to his team erodes at a MUCH slower rate, and that doesn't even account for the possibility that the Mafia no-show has actually been participating in the scum thread while hiding from the game thread, in which case he's already adding utility for his team. If Day 1 discussion yields a reasonably strong consensus of who to scumread, you always lynch that player first. If not, and there's a player with ZERO posts, you fall back on lynching him, over players who are merely low-activity. That's the way the game was taught to me, and I feel like the logic is sound. My attempts to get votes onto Tubesock *lost* ground, and then stalled altogether, as he ceased to even be a topic anymore. I didn't like lynching the counterwagon, so I went to the no-shows and picking Kelsier over chaoser made good sense to me for reasons that I hopefully don't need to repeat to you. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 08 2018 06:05 n00bKing wrote: Alright HF, you've said that DF's filter is "all just filler posts and no actual want to solve anything" and followed up later by saying "No drive, probably mafia." But we have plenty of players in the game who have shown no drive, or have put in no effort to solve anything, or have been no help. Kelsier and chaoser have been no help. prpl has been no help. I feel like Tubesock has been no help. When we're 46 hours into the game, I think you'd have to categorize Damdred (and his mighty single-page filter) as having been little or no help. If I lump DF into that category, it means that fully half of the other 12 players in the game with me have been no help. So I don't think DF's lack of drive automatically makes him a good lynch, unless you feel like a Town DF *would* show an actual "want to solve anything" and *would* show "drive." Is that the case? Because again, unless there's reason for you to expect more than this from a Town DF, then I don't see anything that makes this particular mole the one that needs whacking. His posting style is pretty careless. The filter is filled with him either repeating something he already said, or repeating something someone else already said. An example of him repeating himself is this post: He'd already named all 4 of those players as townreads. No need for a new, distinct post that merely says the same thing. And an example of him repeating another player is this: That post might as well be a copy & paste of Moosy's "King of Wagons" thing. (By the way, I think "Wagon King" would sound way cooler than "King of Wagons." Calls to mind the Witch King. Good stuff.) DF also parroted my verbiage almost exactly, when talking about prpl's "wishy washyness." I'd expect a little more caution and a little more mindfulness than this, from most scum players. If a scum player wasn't going to pay any more attention than this, why bother even making the posts? Just be yet another afk dude instead. Not just that. This post at the time when df had 3 votes and Noob was still on TS basically reads like him starting to want to defend df by dividing players by usefulness then starts summing up reasons for him being scummy instead. But concludes with this: I'd expect a little more caution and a little more mindfulness than this, from most scum players. If a scum player wasn't going to pay any more attention than this, why bother even making the posts? Just be yet another afk dude instead. So he took the argumentation for DF being mafia and concluded the opposite cause according to him there were enough afks for df not to post anything. Too scummy to be scum while he could be afk. Disregarding that an afk DF has probably never occurred on TL mafia as either alignment. I don't even know if he's right on wrong on DF here but if I were say a town DF and I had someone use this type of reasoning to townread me, I'd probably scumread him. Either way, he mostly just delivered a summary of some things df said without analysis besides his arbitrary conclusion. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
Provided you are town and care enough. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
Let's start our own votecount or something? ##Vote prplhz (for getting vigidoctored) | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 09 2018 01:24 Holyflare wrote: Yes but where is Amg's excuse to join the prplhz wagon? I also think the plural of it is a lazy read and not a typo. Forgive my interdiction but prplhz was talking about AMG making excuses to join a wagon on tubesock, not prplhlz iirc. I also had that feeling when I saw the way AMG hooked himself between noobking and tubesock and then started piling reasons for tubesock to be mafia. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 09 2018 02:20 n00bKing wrote: How come absolutely nothing came of this? Couple of all-caps posts about how you're about to go berserk, and then this, and then...fizzle. Same could be said for you. Your lynch is on the table but your involvement seems less than D1 to me. Plenty of things to talk about, why just randomly point at moosy for an unfulfilled joke promise and then do nothing with it? | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
So I don't think DF's lack of drive automatically makes him a good lynch, unless you feel like a Town DF *would* show an actual "want to solve anything" and *would* show "drive." Is that the case? Because again, unless there's reason for you to expect more than this from a Town DF, then I don't see anything that makes this particular mole the one that needs whacking. Technically the reason is that he is a type of player who is held at a higher standard regarding activity and post quality. To illustrate one of the things I don't understand about your read on df. Me, HF and rsoultin all noticed something being off about him pretty quickly. Yet here you are asking a question that doesn't want an answer about whether he is lackluster compared to his other town games. That post mostly sounds like you throw in a bit of everything and then reach a conclusion that's comfortable for you. Not cause of the arguments you presented, but because it's comfortable. So either you are unbelievably stubborn and tend to think the opposite of the majority for no apparent reason, or you just make up your reads. Tending towards the latter but I'm also biased at this point :> Who would you vote to vig tonight? | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
I don't see a better play he could think of where he doesn't tell town who he's doccing. He needs to play with open cards now or explain why not. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 09 2018 03:59 AMG wrote: He keeps posting giant piles of words that I haven't had enough coffee to read. It's 5am here. Any preference for who should be vigged? Lynch ideas for tomorrow? | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 09 2018 04:05 Koshi wrote: Hi all. Haven't read anything. Wont read anything soon. Just read Damdred's filter and pretend you are Damdred for this game. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
What's the alternative though. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 09 2018 04:50 rsoultin wrote: Kelsier. I'm pretty okay with a Kelsier flip the later it gets. He should be here by the minute according to him. Without knowing medic time schedule though and how much they follow the thread or if they are playing at all there is no reason to switch at this point though. Let's just hope that they play and aren't bad ;> | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 09 2018 05:18 KelsierSC wrote: Can I just sneak a pass N1 and that way I can read and give you some good shit. The alternative is shitposting some bullshit after a quick read, which I will probably realise is bad , contradict myself and then become easy lynch bait. Disturbing amount of blank lines below your post. Why can't you just come chill with us or something. You are cramped as fuck right now. Don't care if you shitpost but as long as you post you will get a feel for the game. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
Or maybe that's just my town play in general but I'll let others be the judge :> | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
Before my probable NK, I'd like to post my last wish: If you are town this game and not HF or rsoultin, post more. As for moosy, he has been a tad too chill for my taste tonight when I'm pretty sure he was around most of the time. See ya. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
Really happy with that N1 outcome thank god medics weren't afk or stupid and followed consensus. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
Going through AMGs filter I don't really spot a reason for him to be the NK. Either mafia is really bad or they thought he was a medic. Sure his read on prplhz was a good hit but by N1 no one spoke out against his death. On another note, I'm giving Noobking better chances to be town given some of his posts during the night, notably his reply to AMG about prpl where nothing hints at him expecting a prpl scum flip, and his last will post which I liked. So I'm not going to push into him today. I'd say voting Kelsier is good here cause of awkwardness and him not delivering after he said he would. Slam was seemingly having fun shitposting with the occasional read in between. He can go to town pile temporarily with a 20% confidence degree cause this is still a shit read. Didn't pay much attention to today's rso HF exchange yet but I'm not interested into considering either of them for lynch today so probably still won't. Koshi may have some more time to do stuff. I'm guessing he's going to make his entrance starting on the weekend. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 09 2018 21:35 rsoultin wrote: I'm out too. Been vomiting off and on for almost an hour, and I think phone posting is making it worse. Everyone: Please take a stance on mass claiming today, and explain why you think it would be a bad idea if you don't want to. Please look at HF. I think he's scum or too tunneled on DF to think straight. May not be back for awhile if this keeps up blech @.@ We already have a doc claim by DF. His claim should be enough. Town can just keep vigging using the two undiscovered medics while df heals random person. My bold guess based on the assumption that HF and DF are town is that mafia roleblocked random person they had a blue read on while doccing DF and hoping he'd die from that. HF summed the effects of his claim up sufficiently and his fakeclaim makes him more likely town than mafia in my opinion as it was a very smart play. Also, mass claiming plans are bad with questionable activity by multiple participants. For all we know slam won't give a fuck or a serious answer, and Kelsier isn't really doing anything. I propose we get a wagon on Kelsier going for today. Get well soon anyways. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
##Vote Noobking I think I'd still lynch Kelsier first but this might make noob post. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
I think Kelsier is the best lynch among non claimers. ##Unvote ##Vote KelsierSC | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 10 2018 22:23 Koshi wrote: So 4 medic claims. Good stuff. This means we have 6 VTs versus 4 medics atm. We know there is 1 mafia within the VTs. Now we have 2 lynches and 2 medic shots during the night to get the 1 mafia within the VTs. If we figure him out today we auto win killing medics. If we figure him out during night we auto win killing medics. If we figure him out next day we end up with 4 real vts and 3 medics which contain a mafia. = autowin cuz medics kill each other during night. If we figure him out the second night we go into a 2 VT + 1 medic vs a fakeclaiming medic mafia. It's a 50/50 because we have to lynch. But seriously. If we lose that we missed 3 lynches and 2 vig shots. Then you just deserve to lose. Koshi I really like that you play through the scenarios but did you read people's filters yet? I don't think I can read you either way when you are going to be a setup cruncher as it's a very noncommittal way to play the game. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 11 2018 01:22 darthfoley wrote: Yes, a mafia Vivax makes some sense. It is flashing in front of my eyes. Except I was the only one of the medic claims trying to coordinate the others into doccing prpl during N1. Whereas your post about him not being mafia cause nobody was speaking against it could be seen as you being the first to actually speak against it. But yea I wasn't really counting on hitting mafia there since I have a post where I was expecting him to flip town. However you are implying I was trying to get my own teammate killed. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
He can switch metas. I've seen him play scum with clean posts and with lazy posts. No way to tell how much of what he says is true if he keeps it at a minimum like this game and seemingly doesn't take it seriously. There is no world where I don't lynch him unless he tries to be more analytical in his posts and has the potential to screw up somewhere if he's mafia. So far all we got are two correct reads for questionable reasons that might as well just be tmi. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
##Vote: Koshi | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 11 2018 19:45 rsoultin wrote: Dude, if you don't give me more than this N2, I'm going to scumread you forever. It feels like you're just content to skate by because you know we have to lynch your partner first. I want reads. Informed by new things in thread. Not some vig shot the least common denominator crap without at least explaining how you get there. There's enough crap in the thread to solve the game probably, but creating more crap isn't the way to solve it. I'm also hung over and dropped moist coffee powder all over my floor and I really cba to read much today. That gabalier dude played at my village yesterday. I even saw Brits run around. When I can get killed thanks to the mass claim already I see little reason to put in more effort. Mafia kills medics, medics kill non medics. When we are done with that I can be convinced to play more. This is the way the others chose to play and now I'm not going to get shit on for it since I was against mass claiming in the first place. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
I don't think any of his advice makes him town. He's still cold as ice and not very organic while he posts useful things. I'm going to be healing Koshi, if one medic claims to be backing me up the other can go for a save at his own discretion, with the roleblocker down. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
If Koshi flips scum that also clears me and FF and the next days one of Noobking or DF flips mafia, or one of them claims to have healed Koshi as well and we lynch him. I'm going to heal Koshi, now to wait what the other medic claims claim to be doing. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 11 2018 20:50 MoosyDoosy wrote: This is getting into really pointless details imo. But it went something like this: I tried to play mafia normally -> got hard scum read by geript -> feelsbadman -> played in a game with rayn -> got hard scumread by him and brutally tunneled -> feelsbadman -> saw either glowingbear or alakaslam play (i dont remember which) -> was like hey they're acting crazy to get reactions this looks fun -> played another game with rayn -> he scumreads me again -> hey this looks like a good time to troll -> trolls -> was a lot of fun actually -> get a game without rayn -> hey maybe i can try trolling this game from the start rather than as a reaction -> commence trolling d1 -> post game realize that mafia lined up on my wagon nicely -> hey this can be a legit strat -> in future games with rayn or someone I find equally obnoxious use trolling as a defense mechanism -> use trolling in games without rayn as a legitimate tactic -> fast forward 2 years -> feels bad that i made a lot of ppl hate playing the game becuz of me -> decide to not troll good read | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 12 2018 02:44 Fecalfeast wrote: DF i'll team up with you who are we giving the lethal injection Ah so killing Koshi now suddenly isn't as nice to you as you made yourself sound? Please explain. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
HF you agree on Koshi being the kill or do you have another idea? | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
He certainly wouldn't be as helpful as he is being right now. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 12 2018 05:19 n00bKing wrote: That's because it's nonsense. He can't seem to string together even 2 posts in a row that make sense from the mind of a Town player trying to win this game. I look forward to your nonexistent action outcome after tonight. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
Not going to lie I have been playing with the thought of trying a hero save on df while gambling that he's town. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 12 2018 05:26 Holyflare wrote: This is quite literally the most information giving night action list. I think we'd both be dead if we followed that. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
If Koshi isn't dead tomorrow, you know it was FF who didn't contribute as I'm not doing any hero plays against our agreement. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 12 2018 05:40 MoosyDoosy wrote: Okay so possible mafia in claimed medics is vivax and fecalfeast. Who are you healing atm? Other claimed medics @noobking, @fecalfeast, @vivax, who are you guys healing atm and who do you think is scum. I repeated that stuff at least twice in the last 10 pages or something. What are you doing Moosy? | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 12 2018 05:48 darthfoley wrote: @vivax and @FF I'm down to heal Koshi Just when I changed my mind. I kinda think he's town now. On the other hand I'm getting the feeling that Moosy is mafia. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 12 2018 05:40 MoosyDoosy wrote: Okay so possible mafia in claimed medics is vivax and fecalfeast. Who are you healing atm? Other claimed medics @noobking, @fecalfeast, @vivax, who are you guys healing atm and who do you think is scum. On March 11 2018 19:42 Vivax wrote: Kelsiers strategy of trying to skate on big puppy eyes didn't quite work. Good, good. ##Vote: Koshi On March 11 2018 20:01 Vivax wrote: But objectively Koshi is right this is the best way to play the game. I don't think any of his advice makes him town. He's still cold as ice and not very organic while he posts useful things. I'm going to be healing Koshi, if one medic claims to be backing me up the other can go for a save at his own discretion, with the roleblocker down. On March 11 2018 20:13 Vivax wrote: I think I like Koshi/DF for remaining mafia very much, a bit on a whim. Having taken issue with Damdreds and DFs D1 posts already I'd love to have been right about suspecting them at that point already. On March 11 2018 20:17 Vivax wrote: Why am I doing what only, I want? FF posted that he's cool with healing Koshi, I'm cool with healing Koshi as well. So we can healkill Koshi both and Noobking and df can claim to be doing whatever. If Koshi flips scum that also clears me and FF and the next days one of Noobking or DF flips mafia, or one of them claims to have healed Koshi as well and we lynch him. I'm going to heal Koshi, now to wait what the other medic claims claim to be doing. On March 12 2018 02:47 Vivax wrote: Ah so killing Koshi now suddenly isn't as nice to you as you made yourself sound? Please explain. On March 12 2018 03:23 Vivax wrote: So I post 3 minutes away from FFs last post and he still hasn't replied. HF you agree on Koshi being the kill or do you have another idea? On March 12 2018 03:49 Vivax wrote: Ok so me and ff on koshi. Not a fan of plans to kill HF, but it comes down to df/noobking. On March 12 2018 05:01 Vivax wrote: Why aren't df and noob in thread to coordinate? | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
You deserve to be killed for that post moosy. Who's on board? | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
I think the other medic claims should take a look at moosy or sell me another target that isn't HF since if we aren't doing Moosy tonight I'm going to flip a coin between two targets at my discretion. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 12 2018 06:02 MoosyDoosy wrote: + Show Spoiler + alright so one question. To which I responded with this: + Show Spoiler + On March 12 2018 05:45 MoosyDoosy wrote: Koshi/darthfoley if I am correct. I'm trying to get people to come to a consensus atm because currently I see a lot of argument and not a lot of attempting to work together. But fair enough, halfway through day phase I did kind of start to faze things after it started to become clear we were playing setup. I don't think asking people to make sure they didn't change their mind is necessarily a bad thing though. It just makes you look like you're trying excessively to look like you're contributing. I wouldn't have scumread you for a good ol' shitpost but that post clearly tries to sell the picture that you're trying to look helpful. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
But that means you were around and didn't take any of what we said into serious account. Cause you don't need to remember anything about what townies said when you're mafia and not under pressure. My action is on Moosy. Looking forward to which medic is going to contribute. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
If I die and Moosy isn't dead tomorrow, he's mafia. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 12 2018 06:21 darthfoley wrote: Well, HF is not going to happen so I guess you need to kill Moosy ??? If that's your attitude why not do it yourself? | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 12 2018 06:23 rsoultin wrote: FF not being here to at least get this nailed down is not giving me the warm fuzzies. Which is lovely because the last thing I need is more scumspects. I really hope FF is the mafia doc cause then the mafia doc can't kill Koshi while I'm on moosy. Which means that moosy is scum if I die and he lives. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 12 2018 06:27 rsoultin wrote: Your logic isn't foolproof, but it's the most likely scenario regarding moosy. That said, this would be true of anyone you decided to cowboy your medic save on if you're town. And that doesn't change that I don't like why you're doing it in the first place. You're going to like it when you see that flip tho. Granted that my confidence fluctuates pretty highly depending on day and time but right now it's pretty high for Moosy posting scumquestions. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 12 2018 06:31 MoosyDoosy wrote: Vivax where is your explanation. Looking back, Holyflare also called out medics for being a mess. What makes me doing it and attempting to organize medics particularly scummy? Cause someone who was genuinely interested into the situation would only be worried about DF and Noobking not trying to find a common ground when me and FF already did. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 12 2018 06:33 MoosyDoosy wrote: And you really think me wanting you to say you were on Koshi to prompt darth and noob to also vote him is a sign of red? That's not what you did. You literally asked all of us in the most generic way possible. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
If Noobking doesn't get on moosy after saying he's the preferred target after HF, then noob is confirmed mafia if moosy is. If I die and moosy doesn't, you can lynch him tomorrow. In my scenario mafia medic is going to kill Koshi tonight. If FF is the mafia medic, Koshi won't die and we can lynch FF. If FF is a town medic, Koshi will die and you lynch Moosy tomorrow. If he's red you lynch Noob. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
What happened to your moosy read bro | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
![]() | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
Really don't like how rsoultin and df try to quickly pull out the confirmed town card | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
moosy, rso, hf, slam are the remaining vt claims with 1 mafia and you better have a good reason to lynch into medics first. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 12 2018 08:23 Holyflare wrote: There are actually variables where vivax isn't mafia but his shenanigans at deadline heavily suggest otherwise. Shenanigans? I formed a scumread and tried to kill it. Explain what the shenanigans are. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 12 2018 08:27 Holyflare wrote: The fact we agreed to do a unanimous nk and you bailed at the last second to cause the most confusion on a terrible read. Much like d1 tbh. I didn't agree to anything I could bail out of. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
It's obviously Moosy cause FF obviously is mafia. Cause it's bullshit that FF pretends to not have been around during EoD when he was around during EoD 1. And with FFs assumption that I was healing moosy and Koshi was dead man walking, he chose to just kill Koshi when he could have killed Moosy on top of him, but they are teammates. If I and DF actually followed through with rsoultins plan to lump us all together, then we'd sit at zero information. Thanks rsoultin. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
Then again the AMG shot also made little sense. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 12 2018 08:41 rsoultin wrote: See the thing is, Viva sitting on Moosy as scum doesn't make much sense unless they're scum together. And the buss doesn't make much more sense, either. You don't know if I was sitting on Moosy though. I could have been doccing anyone while claiming to have been on moosy and given the blame to whoever else was claiming to heal him with me. I don't know where your town bias towards me is coming from here. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
Yeah okay, wifom plays aside this is where the town bias could be coming from. I also know why you aren't able to see why I thought going for moosy was good since you don't know my alignment. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
I know for sure scum didn't attempt to kill moosy tonight. I know Noobking gave in to town pressure to go Koshi instead of going for his claimed #2 moosy. I know that FF posted just to tell us he was on the target he was on to begin with. Do you think any of this would have come out without me being on Moosy? What you're calling confusion is more information. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
If you want to be incredibly stupid and prefer to lose town power roles over vanillas, then go ahead. But then don't expect me to put in a shred of effort if I know you are ready to throw the game by voting for me. It's also fucking pointless to defend myself or go read your wrong shit about me cause of the above reason and if I know you are dumb enough to lynch a medic today then you are also dumb enough that my defense wouldn't change anything. Yes I'm triggered. Yetserday we were deciding between 5 VTs, today we got it down to the same amount as we have medics and hence there is only one correct play and everyone is still arguing about medic lynches. So all this day should be between HF, Moosy, Slam fighting it out and you know where I stand. And yes I would lynch HF last. ##Vote Moosy | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 07 2018 05:44 Fecalfeast wrote: Man noobking if you're scum I'll be super impressed. Bleeding town on top of talking about host interactions in thread makes you lock green to me forever On March 10 2018 04:27 Fecalfeast wrote: I would lynch wall of text king On March 10 2018 04:29 Fecalfeast wrote: ##unvote ##vote noobking What happened/who were you sheeping at the time? | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
Once again, I might have to start considering that HF can be mafia. Hard times we live in. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
##Unvote | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
Cause I don't get at all how mafia attacks a VT and DF sees it coming. It all fits too well to be true. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 13 2018 21:54 Holyflare wrote: It's possible but not worth thinking about until tonight where you need to get all the medics to follow a set plan. I have also tinfoiled this but with slam just voting me now and moosy just posting meta and mechanics I can't really think about a rsoultin mafia world. I don't know why you've suddenly backtracked on moosy either. I want you to link the games you've read that made you change your mind and a short sentence from each game on why it's different. Alright chief. 4 scum games in total. Modkilled in 2, lynched day 1 in 1, survived in 1. From database so you know where to look. From his worst one: On June 25 2016 08:21 MoosyDoosy wrote: ![]() On June 25 2016 08:22 MoosyDoosy wrote: should i name the rest of the people that aren't on my team? On June 25 2016 08:48 MoosyDoosy wrote: neeeeveeer. But to be serious, we generally pass the BS stage when someone really presses an issue or like 6 hrs before deadline. On June 25 2016 08:53 MoosyDoosy wrote: oh g0d I really want shapelog to post some gifs about now. With his worst game he never took the game seriously and spent these posts and a whole bunch more just trolling and making jokes. With his arguably best game he racked up 36 pages of filter. He has his occasional trolly posts there as well. What he lacks are instead sensible posts and a good feeling for his own progression. It's hard for me to sum it up in words rn but also his way of posting arguments for people being scum looks different. But he is capable of making huge case posts as a side note. This might not be the best example but I hope it displays what I mean with feeling for his own progression. It is a handicap that I don't know the context of firefly, but in the case below you can at least see that in his mafia game, the only instance where he relates what someone else did to his own actions is "he didn't refute my points". In this game, he can sum up every instance that pushed his read towards a direction by a tick. Bolded it for you. Either way, it reads authentic compared to his mafia game. On September 10 2015 01:19 MoosyDoosy wrote: Nothing changed. I acknowledge that it's weird that CopCake would have pointed out GB that early although her points against him were very weak in the first place and might as well not be there. Things that I still dislike about this whole affair is that she hasn't refuted any points that I presented, dodges around questions aimed at her, solely spouts rayn sentiment, and is basically relying on rayn to stay alive at this point in time. Despite how she may have pointed out GB earlier, that's still just one weak point against a whole host of others. The only reason that she's probably not refuting any points and having thread presence is because doing so might just incriminate her more and she's relying on rayn anyway. On March 07 2018 12:36 MoosyDoosy wrote: Are you even reading the quotes I'm linking...? I asked that and I asked this: Because I wanted to see what you would do. And while I agree with what others have said in that your tone has gotten better, you look like you're effectively just throwing shit at the wall trying to see if it will stick instead of actually trying. Instead of actually searching for Mafia, it looks like you're trying to get on the same page with AMG to cater to him because he offered you a life rope. Instead of reading the quotes I linked you, you're asking me a question which I answer in said quotes where I specifically ask for feedback. Instead of not asking me the same question someone already has (n00bKing) and which I've addressed with someone else (Fecalfeast), you ask me it again. I doubt you're actually trying and while your posts entering were tonally good, it reads to me atm like you're just trying to get anything to stick. Summa summarum the post above looks to me like real thoughts and compared to his mafia game it looks to me like he is being less bureaucratic in explicating his scumread and relates it more to how he feels about the response. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 12 2018 20:11 darthfoley wrote: to be clear, I think Vivax is scum not just because of last night. Rather, because his defense today has seemed all over the place trying to throw theories at the wall to see what sticks. Plus my case against him regarding his interactions/read progression on prplhz D1 that only Koshi seemed to read and Vivax never even tried to defend himself against. I also agree with n00bking that today wasn't gonna be an auto lynch. I mean yesterday wasn't an auto lynch but you still had people like Vivax and Moosy who kept talking about how they have no interest in the game considering it's a mechanics based solution. Tbh this stuff on me feels a lot like the things moosy was saying about cop in his mafia game. I know meta, from different players on top of it isn't really an argument but the analogy caught my eye since "he didn't refute my points" is an argument df is using as well. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
Cause me presenting it to you is more work and more prone to not being able to convey my point sufficiently or correctly. Putting down a sum of impressions into a post using selected posts isn't that easy. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
Noobkings obstinacy on you shifted me towards him being town as of late. FF stays at roughly the same spot cause I can't tell if he's being lazy cause irl like he claims or cause of the shitty start mafia had. I think I'd be crazy enough to want to flip rsoultin today. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
By shooting you it's like they wanted us to get closer to the mafia claiming VT which doesn't make sense so that only leaves cred shot as scenario. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 14 2018 00:37 rsoultin wrote: Viva, real talk, if I were the vt scum among the vts and the literal only person in the game people weren't scumreading, why would I NEED some stupid strat to get 'confirmed' over three kills last night including moosy that would all but win us the game. We'd mislynch slam or something today then shoot hf over me cause noob wham bam thank you maam thats game. Your tinfoil is pure paranoia if you're even town here. And part of me thinks that scum don't come up with something this ludicrous in the first place so you probably are barring acta of pure desperation Let's say we lynch moosy, we vig HF and one doc dies. We lynch slam. Now it's two docs vs you and DF. Mafia wins. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
rso, hf, slam vs 3 medics. Lynch hf. Slam gets vigged, medic dies. 1 vt 1 mafia vs 1 doc 1 mafia. Mafia wins if rsoultin makes it through the scrutiny. So if rso and df actually did this play it takes away scrutiny from rso without really changing what happens next at the cost of 1 extra cycle to play if I'm not mistaken. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
Why is he accepting it just like that when rsoultin is the night target (moosy unlikely if mafia believed me). Are we actually dealing with an HF + DF team? | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
##Vote: HF | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 14 2018 01:15 rsoultin wrote: It's wifom but this is just not something id do right off the back of another scum game, and a shit one at that. Probably not ever. I dont actually enjoy playing scum nearly enough to want to extend the game, especially needlessly. I was under no pressure and we weren't lynching medics until the mafia in the vts was found anyway. Yeah. This is the last post I'll make about this. I'll address any genuine reasons to scumread me I suppose, should you or anyone else produce any. But I don't see how I can fight suboptimal hypotheticals that you seem determined to believe in despite how little sense they'd make for me as scum. I don't think you're scum, and I don't think you're bad. So all I can call it is paranoid viva going down the rabbit hole. And frankly, I'm trying hard not to be offended that you think it's so impossible mafia would try to shoot me. That you're basing it off setup makes it a little better, but still...that's cold lol >< Do you think the odds are that bad that mafia DF protects you from mafia HF when it really doesn't matter? I give a team of prplhz, FF, Slam a 0 % chance of existing and then not killing into df, rsoultin, HF | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 14 2018 01:20 rsoultin wrote: Not to be a wet blanket, but how does this make sense to you either? Now you think df is going to confirm me town rather than just kill me? Doesn't that make it more rather than less likely to get it lynched, especially with my reading him scum at the end of n2 over the other vt claims? Are you just super convinced df is scum or what's going on here? Well if you are town he pockets you, associates himself with you and if he actually killed you it wouldn't have made things easier for mafia. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
If HF flips mafia there isn't a traceback to df. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
If we wind up lynching HF and he flips town, then we are boned cause I don't see myself capable of pushing for a df, then rsoultin lynch. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
I don't have any townreads. I kinda thought I had one on moosy but then I question my own reasoning. Nothing sheepable around either. It's pretty much just down to the simple question of whether to lynch Hf cause of the amg kill or to lynch FF cause he's playing afk mafia. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 14 2018 04:42 Holyflare wrote: Why the fuck would I kill AMG when all the medics are on prplhz OR I've somehow convinced one to go to df. Why Vivax? That's a free you kill, a free Rsoultin kill. Why do I kill AMG? That's such bull shit to come from you and you know it. Who do I kill if it isn't you or moosy HF? | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 14 2018 04:45 Holyflare wrote: what the hell are you saying? There's confirmed mafia in the rsoul/slam/moosy trio and confirmed mafia in the vivax/ff/nk/df group. If df and rsoul are taken out, which any sensible person should do since they haven't said anything egregious, have been town read and didn't need to make any play when they could have shot moosy then you're left with slam/moosy and ff/nk. That's two 50/50s you can lynch into. We've been sticking to some lynch VT plan so you have to theorise which one of Moosy and Slam is mafia. If you think Moosy is too happy then just read my bit on slam above and how he's just randomly lynching me today. If Slam does not respond I don't know what I am going to do. When does mafia ever say anything egregious they just try to say whatever anyone wants to hear. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
Now they are supposed to be confirmed town and I feel like they're leaving the rest of us to fend for ourselves sinking teeth into each other when we are all town anyway. If I had one argument for rsoultin to be mafia it would be that she's too docile. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
I'll just be optimistic, assume I'm wrong on everything and murder moosy disregarding my second thoughts. Maybe he flips scum, then we kill FF and maybe win the game. This weirdo change of mind comes from the fact that regardless of the nightkills making not the slightest sense to me, I'd take a mafia HF over a town afk any day to make the game bearable. ##Unvote ##Vote Moosy | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 14 2018 05:07 Holyflare wrote: Moosy and df still voting vivax? Poor show. Got em boys | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
On March 14 2018 06:49 MoosyDoosy wrote: darthfoley's behavior at end of night leads me to believe he's town because he was pretty frantic about who to vote for and organizing people. Also his initial reaction to things like vivax's push so I doubt he's mafia. I will say that rsoultin's drop off is pretty bad once she was confirmed town but honestly don't think it's uncharacteristic because she's also playing setup. Sorry fam, mafia is you and vivax. Honestly if you actually read the night you'd have seen I was just as frantic even before getting that scumread on you that also stems from you not reading something. You can't expect to do stuff only at EoD, read people by what they do at EoD exclusively and be taken seriously. Even now you are just reading EoD. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
This day was crucial cause it's the day we decide whether to lynch on tinfoil or on "sensible" terms like HF called it. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
| ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
Impressed by Slam this game he was pleasant to have around but still wouldn't have been able to tell how he was town. Don't expect the last mafia to do anything but concede. Healing NK tonight. | ||
Vivax
21857 Posts
It must be so intimidating for the n1 action what to pick against three medics, so amg kill makes some sense from that perspective, even though his reads were good he can't really be considered a thread pusher like HF/rsoul from whom you can have feedback almost whenever you like. Kudos to df for guessing the N2 target. Too bad the paranoia didn't allow me to appreciate it during the game :> | ||
| ||