Slytherin Mini Mafia

On February 08 2015 05:24 raynpelikoneet wrote:

what if i said Onegu is pretty damn confirmed town aswell?

On February 08 2015 10:01 Keirathi wrote:

And I dropped the suspicion when you said you were amazeballs at reading him and that he was playing as town when I asked you why. Damdred asked me which reactions stood out the most to me, so I told him. Slam's definitely looked the worst at first glance to me without knowing how to read him.

On February 08 2015 13:05 sicklucker wrote:


?? How am I dodging anything, I cant read myself. I know you ment ls and I answered that by asking how you read him town which you actually dodged.... I dont read people off half a page filter but explain how you did plz.

Ive explained everyone of my reads I dont have no damn read on Ls and why are you putting scum on me for not having a read on a guy that posted like 3 times.

On February 08 2015 14:13 gobbledydook wrote:


if u say 60-70% is a strong town read then ok.

that 30%-40% is where the doubt comes in, seeing as everyone townreads rayn i thought it was good to raise the issue of 'is he sure to be town'?

On February 09 2015 01:38 Onegu wrote:



Can you elaborate on this also?

On February 09 2015 01:51 sicklucker wrote:


or recent games where he tried to lynch me as town because he was bumhurt I tricked him as mafia

On February 09 2015 06:36 liancourt wrote:


Is that really an argument though? I can just as well vote and unvote later so what's the point in my voting now?

I can just vote like this

##vote keira

On February 09 2015 10:54 gobbledydook wrote:
no bueno i wake up to a wagon on me
first that 'why are u not voting damdred' thing is wrong, i can always vote whenever so long as i do it before deadline, i could put my vote on him and that would be as noncommittal as putting it anywhere else or not putting it anywhere.
damdreds showed up since i went to sleep. hes started thinking which is good. im taking him off the scumlist.

obi is pretty useless, but hes always pretty useless with a few scattered gems of brilliance among the uselessness and i lost my last game scumreading his uselessness when he was town, so i dont know any more. how do u read him?

lonemeow needs to say more stuff

lightning strike is pretty interesting, so what hes been doing is:
1) make a pretty general and boring list of one-sentence reads of everyone, that it doesnt seem like hes thought much about it.
2) makes excuses for not posting
3) sheeps damdred
4) asking simple questions about what X thinks of Y

this betrays a lack of deep thinking, i think its likely he scum tryna get an easy mislynch without doing much

On February 09 2015 12:37 Keirathi wrote:

Hmm, not really sure I buy it.

I think scum geript could have/would have pushed my lynch rather than defend me. ESPECIALLY if rayn is town. If they are scum together, maybe not so much, but for now I'm still okay with rayn being town even though he hasn't posted in over 24 hours.

Anyways, my point is, with rayn on my wagon without any sign of stopping, scum geript could have pushed me pretty easily without much fear, and likely gotten the second most experienced player in the game lynched for free. Why would he pass up that opportunity?

What makes you think he is scum?

On February 09 2015 12:55 geript wrote:

So you're saying the fact that I'm posting less makes me scum. That's a really dumb argument when it's clear from the start that I wasn't going to post as much. It's also rather ironic coming from you.

On February 09 2015 13:02 geript wrote:

Except that it does. I can't follow up on things if I'm not posting as much or if, when I'm posting, I'm following up on other things which are actually more important at the time. Like OWS. I can't follow up on things if I'm playing D&D with my friends for idk 7-8 hours or if I'm sleeping. Like I could make a huge case about you posting less and shit, but it's NLA. I'd rather just let people do their thing while I do mine.

On February 09 2015 13:11 geript wrote:

I haven't dropped Obi. We're fucking lynching his ass. Like I also haven't dropped some of the earlier stuff, but the threads been pretty dead and when it's not it's been pretty worthless. Like there really isn't much more to say since I was in this after noon. Like Obi's read on me plus his non-read on Keir plus his complete batshit crazy but not really batshit cray cray is amazeballs scummy. How do you not get that? Like he literally glosses over great points that he should agree with and support, two things which he doesn't do in any way, to focus on the most peripheral bullshit ever. Like it's completely hilarious. Why don't you want to lynch the fuck out of OWScum?

On February 09 2015 13:13 ObiWanShinobi wrote:


Mostly.

On February 10 2015 03:21 raynpelikoneet wrote:
No fuck LS is town.

On February 10 2015 04:13 raynpelikoneet wrote:
I jsut said if i am wrong on someone then SL might be mafia. Just for that fucking terrible vote and Keirathi's non-reaction to it. Also that would make Gobble town because SL is voting for him which makes you .. again, look way more worse.

On February 10 2015 07:50 geript wrote:
Here's scum motivation Damdred. Gobble is his mafia partner, he wanted to save him then thought he'd be lynched because of my vote and switched back. OR perhaps gobble is town and he figured he'd catch less flak if gobble is lynched instead of Keir. Or maybe he wanted to make sure Keir got lynch. Maybe he did it because he's methodical and people would think he'd never do that as mafia. Maybe he did it because he's a bad player as both alignments.

Do you need more possible explanations?

OWS being mafia has no affect on Gobble being mafia. They can independently be mafia.

On February 10 2015 10:52 ObiWanShinobi wrote:


This is not a good point to make ftr. Feels don't make a case.

On February 10 2015 10:59 ObiWanShinobi wrote:


I know they can.

The issue is that what you're saying can be interpreted multiple ways and saying that "it feels gloaty" isn't enough to warrant a lynch. I think you might be letting confirmation bias affect you atm.

On February 10 2015 09:45 gobbledydook wrote:
wat the hell was obi thinking when he voted keir
apparently the best reason offered so far about obi being scum is he wouldnt do that vote switch as town, and hes useless?
what about this, i played with him last time in championship belt, he was fucking useless and does weird ass things and we scumread him at lylo and lost? that switching vote thingy can happen often esp when ppl get confused by last-minute switches by other ppl and the ten million reasons why X is or is not mafia that they throw out and expect ppl to understand in five minutes?
i dont think rayns '100% mafia' read is right in fact i think at most its a coinflip on ows here

ls i have a bad timezone and things to do sorry i couldnt be on after that last post i made?

On February 11 2015 13:43 Alakaslam wrote:

It has been long that I waited this game




Come! Tell me truly, why am I so scummy?

Indeed this is the first time when that is said referring to people's actual sentiment 0.O

On February 11 2015 13:45 Alakaslam wrote:
oh & Damdred u r scum because you vote gobble and rayn said he is probably town because he was gone and yet you still push him and me today

Now I await your counter

+ Show Spoiler +

On February 12 2015 06:24 raynpelikoneet wrote:

DO YOU WANT OT CONTEST MY CLAIM?

On February 09 2015 18:24 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Keirathi
Geript
Gobblydobbly

are mafia.

On February 12 2015 13:42 Onegu wrote:



Who the fuck would be stupid enough to give him a gun?

On February 13 2015 00:31 OnceKing wrote:
Vote count

sicklucker (10) : raynpelikoneet, FecalFeast, Alakaslam, gobbledydook, Damdred, ObiWanShinobi, Onegu, LightningStrike, geript, LoneMeow
Alakaslam (1): sicklucker

Currently, sicklucker is set to be lynched. Day 2 ends in at 20:00 GMT (+00:00).

Reminders: Votes are done in the voting thread (link). Make sure to unvote if you want to vote someone new. Voting is mandatory-- you may not abstain.

On February 10 2015 03:12 LoneMeow wrote:
I don't quite agree that Keirathi has done nothing to contribute in scum hunting, he has asked some relevant questions. Followup and conclusions on those seems to be lacking though so meh, maybe he is scum.

I'll just sheep raynpelikoneet for now.

##Vote: Keirathi

On February 13 2015 03:45 LoneMeow wrote:


Some day you'll learn the difference between "odd" and "scum".

I trust the reads of some of the players in this game more than my own; then the question simply becomes do I trust my read on them when I think they're town and push for a totally different lynch than what I'd want.

On February 15 2015 02:31 LoneMeow wrote:


Two questions:

How exactly do you know there's a godfather in the game?

What makes you think gobbledydook has a red check on LightningStrike?

On February 15 2015 03:25 LoneMeow wrote:


My biggest scum read is pretty clearly in the case I just posted.

And I'm not scum because I know the role PM I received? Not sure if you want me to analyze myself or what?

For the record I'm not sold in the slightest about LightningStrike being scum. I also don't think Damdred is scum despite that weird red check thing which I don't quite buy at the moment.

On February 15 2015 03:33 LoneMeow wrote:


I'd think goon, RB, GF vs mason pair and cop would be a bit over the top, but I must admit I'm not super familiar with balancing the games.

What I wanted to know is what in gobbledydook's filter makes you think he has a red check on LightningStrike, duh.

Also since you make a big point about him explicitly a cop, I wouldn't mind if you explained why you're so sure about that, too. But far more interested in the first point.

On February 12 2015 11:01 gobbledydook wrote:
sicklucker has to be scum
i can't imagine any town reacting in such a way to rayns claim, fake or no.
I'm not going to say anything regarding the mason or cop claim because it's 100% fake but rayn is 100% town.

the logical fallacy in sicklucker is real and hes spent 20 pages being useless and shouting ur the cop no im not ur the cop no im not and generally occupying space. this is probably the least productive night ive slept through because of that and sicklucker deserves the praise.

On February 15 2015 04:09 LoneMeow wrote:


You're the only one on the list who is not "confirmed" in some way.

Fecalfeast is not really 100% confirmed to me.

There's a tiny chance that scum was planning on switching from gobbledydook to Keirathi at the last second but town made the switch before they could do it so (barring any other confirmation) gobbledydook is not 100% confirmed either.


Based on play alone and nothing else, I'd say gobbledydook is most likely of those to be scum, but honestly the way the wagons went on day 1... I'd rather think I'm wrong about LightningStrike I guess.

On February 15 2015 06:23 Alakaslam wrote:

PAAAAAAHHHHHH

this wifom.

Can someone rehash why onegu is confirmed?

On February 15 2015 06:36 Damdred wrote:
Final Vote Count

Keirathi (6): raynpelikoneet, liancourt, Alakaslam, LoneMeow, Onegu, FecalFeast
gobbledydook (6): Damdred, LightningStrike, Keirathi, sicklucker, geript, ObiWanShinobi
LightningStrike (1): gobbledydook

This is an interesting eod vote.