|
Like i'm most sure about these people being town
Damdred Rayn Geript Lightning Strike
Probably town Liancourt Onegu
SL, LM, Obi could potentially be scum. But I still think obi does this stuff as town all of the time, LM has some ok posts and some things he just drops for no reason and him wanting to sheep a case because of a stronger town read is a bit weird to me especially when they were liking the case earlier. SL idk some of his votes were weird but his filter looks okish, hes a bit strange.
|
lunch post stuff to bounce ideas off of before deadline
|
All of SL's votes look like he's just trying not to get modkilled. He came back and took a stance when he was back in the thread.
What's the problem?
|
On February 11 2015 01:24 ObiWanShinobi wrote: All of SL's votes look like he's just trying not to get modkilled. He came back and took a stance when he was back in the thread.
What's the problem?
Specifically all of the "weird votes" people are talking about are things I don't necessarily have an issue with.
Also I don't like FF's case on LS.
|
OWS I asked this yesterday and you told me you give me the answer today in case you forgot:
On February 10 2015 12:43 LightningStrike wrote: So OWS what are your reads atm and can you explain to me why your reads are the way there are please?
|
I didn't really forget. I'm working on them right now.
|
On February 11 2015 01:28 ObiWanShinobi wrote: I didn't really forget. I'm working on them right now. Ok was just reminding you that's all.
|
So here's where I stand at the moment:
LM: Townlean. I kind of already explained this. His activity usually makes it really hard to gauge his alignment but I do like the few posts that he has. My biggest issue with him in Carol was that he was posting like he wanted other people to scumhunt for him and he gave off this really weird aura of wanting to "hide." I'm not getting any of that here, so I think he's mostly okay for the moment.
Geript: Null. I'm in kind of a weird position with geript. I didn't like his list post earlier on but I was inclined to leave him alone for his "I'm obviously town" lunacy and whatnot, especially since it was so similar to the time we hydra'd together and he started throwing around the same phrase and such.
Then there's the fact that he's using whatever he can get a hold of as ammo (specifically, he's using my not posting reads for a day against me, I mean lol are you serious) to go after me. I don't know. I'm probably a bit more "wait-and-see" with geript.
I do get the feeling that he wouldn't want to lynch me if he were mafia but I don't know how much that's going to matter if he keeps tunneling me over bullshit.
Slam: Scumlean. His start was okay but then he posted a giant wall of nothing, where he came to no conclusion about pretty much anything. Then he decided that he was going to sheep geript despite geript having him as a scumread and then being totally fine with not being townread by geript for it.
Sicklucker: Town. A bunch of his thought processes are very similar to mine (the commentary on the two wagons from yesterday specifically, plus his thoughts on the voteswap being accurate without being overly precise) which means he's probably town.
Damdred: Town. Could be jumping on me but isn't, and combined with the fact that he's being towny outside of that (taking a bunch of solid stances that he's going to be held accountable for later as well as actively scumhunting and pushing lynches) makes this slot an easy townread.
LS/Liancourt: Town. I have absolutely nothing wrong with these slots and I don't understand why other people do.
Rayn is obviously town for obvious reasons.
That's what I've got so far. I know I've missed a few but I've given opinions on almost everyone at this point.
|
|
Obi so that's FF and Gobble as scum then along with slam? Also you seem to have missed onegu?
|
He said he know missed a few but he already gave a opinion on them up to now. Learn to read Damdred
|
Well the thing is before you interrupted LS is he was rocking back and forth on gobble as of last night because of that post, and I was wondering what his stance on gobble was now and since he left him out of the list post its a bit of a head scratcher.
Also he has no real FF read in his filter LS, he agrees with his list post but didn't mention him at all. He also draws a bit of a shadow onto onegu talking about his voting, but its really unclear what his read on is at that point, but other than that you can't tell what his read is.
So no it has nothing to do with learning to read but actually covering everyone which he hasn't done. In his filter or in this post.
|
On February 11 2015 02:38 Damdred wrote: Well the thing is before you interrupted LS is he was rocking back and forth on gobble as of last night because of that post, and I was wondering what his stance on gobble was now and since he left him out of the list post its a bit of a head scratcher.
Also he has no real FF read in his filter LS, he agrees with his list post but didn't mention him at all. He also draws a bit of a shadow onto onegu talking about his voting, but its really unclear what his read on is at that point, but other than that you can't tell what his read is.
So no it has nothing to do with learning to read but actually covering everyone which he hasn't done. In his filter or in this post. You are right about the FF thing because the only thing I seen him about FF was he didn't like his case on me and that's it. You are right about his onegu stuff too it's not a clear read for him too.
|
I've already covered GD and my opinion hasn't changed. I want to see how he handles tomorrow. If you put a gun to my head, I'd probably lynch him but I wouldn't be super confident on that.
I mostly took rayn's word that Onegu is town but /shrug. I don't know what to do with that slot.
I haven't put the time in to read FF. I do know that I didn't like his LS case so I'm probably going to head back and take a look at it again when I get a chance to see if he was cherry picking mistakes or actually trying to find mafia.
I think Slam might be the best lynch tomorrow, though.
|
I might be back for deadline to see if I get vigi'd but maybe not. Idk.
I'll be around intermittently.
|
Here's a quick update on where I stand:
Upgraded LightningStrike to null-ish, looks better now that he's trying to do something to solve the game.
Downgraded Alakaslam to leaning scum for not doing anything at all and that post on his "reads".
It bothers me that I can't seem to find more scum reads, makes me think there's a possibility that there's scum in raynpelikoneet/Damdred/geript who I think are good enough that I don't stand much of a chance figuring them out (this early at least), but I'll worry about that later.
|
Any other reactions to reads posted in the thread etc., LM?
|
On February 11 2015 03:34 Damdred wrote: Any other reactions to reads posted in the thread etc., LM?
I haven't had the time to think properly, so I'll leave that until morning. Doubt I'll be shot anyway.
|
On February 11 2015 01:24 ObiWanShinobi wrote: All of SL's votes look like he's just trying not to get modkilled. He came back and took a stance when he was back in the thread.
What's the problem?
I tried to hammer. I would have if you guys didnt go rapid change on your votes.
|
On February 11 2015 04:02 sicklucker wrote:Show nested quote +On February 11 2015 01:24 ObiWanShinobi wrote: All of SL's votes look like he's just trying not to get modkilled. He came back and took a stance when he was back in the thread.
What's the problem? I tried to hammer. I would have if you guys didnt go rapid change on your votes.
I have no issue with any of your votes, to be clear.
|
|
|
|