EPTBut I ended up continuing to be lost so I just left it.
[T] MTG Mini Mafia - Page 83
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
But I ended up continuing to be lost so I just left it. | ||
|
Toadesstern
Germany16350 Posts
On July 10 2012 08:22 gonzaw wrote: But you said "I'll reread stuff and post my opinions later" or something (if I remember correctly), which implied you were in fact playing. he did exactly one post in this game. The one you are referring to :p | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
| ||
|
kitaman27
United States9245 Posts
On July 10 2012 08:24 marvellosity wrote: I did plan on playing, because I was hoping how heavy it was on Magic would die down just a little. But I ended up continuing to be lost so I just left it. gonzaw hadn't played a game of magic before, yet that didn't stop him from producing 17 pages of filter! Noob. | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
| ||
|
Mattchew
United States5684 Posts
On July 10 2012 07:27 strongandbig wrote: every game i've ever played or read with you where you were town try your "night kill trap" in LV for example lol, so mad | ||
|
Mattchew
United States5684 Posts
On July 10 2012 07:53 strongandbig wrote: (its okay.) And as for "the game came down to 1HP" It's worse than that. the game literally came down to the fact that I reloaded the page at 7:00 before your attack posted. I could have sacrificed something or just attacked Mattchew instead of sitting on my hands. posting while reading so this may have been answered but the game town down to townies killing townies, just like every time mafia wins | ||
|
Mattchew
United States5684 Posts
http://forums.mtgsalvation.com/showthread.php?t=414478 You can play these in multiple ways (draft or type 4) | ||
|
gonzaw
Uruguay4911 Posts
On July 10 2012 08:29 kitaman27 wrote: gonzaw hadn't played a game of magic before, yet that didn't stop him from producing 17 pages of filter! Noob. lol I felt so proud when I made the 2 8/8 beast plan! Like I knew shit about Magic so I felt like the underdog making an awesome play that would win the game :D .....which ended up killing 1 townie (Grey) and then being useless since both guys that had them died in 2 turns >_> Damn, in hindsight I wished I had given Grey another chance and attacked Mattchew instead in D3 (I was actually planning on doing that, but well Grey's actions and behaviour convinced me otherwise). Also when I was talking to kita I was toying with the idea of using Steal Artifact on WBG's Myr Enforcer (when I was talking to him how WBG could be scum). Stealing his own Enforcer and attacking him/Mattchew+using the 8/8 beast would have been a good choice >_> Also in hindsight I wish I had actually expressed all these thoughts I had with kita in the thread instead of being the wishy-washy mess that I was before dying (I think I FoSed everybody at one point or something >_> ) I tried all I could to get accurate reads, rereading the thread/filters and changing my mind if necessary.....but meh I failed again just like in iGrok's game  EDIT: In D3 I was kind of confused. I was toying with the WBG+Mattchew+S&B or Zealos scum team or something with kita, but I was actually expecting him to read the thread and tell me if that was a good idea or it was me spouting bullshit, but he didn't show up in the chat to talk about it I was also waiting for Nova, Zealos, Fulla, etc to post in the thread their thoughts about all the shit I was talking about (about Grey, Mattchew, etc). But nobody showed up. Nova didn't show up, neither did Zealos, etc; and kita didn't show up either, so it got very lonely in there not knowing what to do and not having anybody around to discuss shit; and those that are around are not playing at all (Grey/Mattchew) or just have tunnel vision on and won't consider anything else (S&B/WBG). | ||
|
Acrofales
Spain18135 Posts
 Given my position as a hydra with Artanis, we had quite a bit of discussion about this game as well. Honestly, the amount of work he put into this game is astounding. I really enjoyed reading it too as it had a unique setup. I didn't suspect Toad(+Marv) for a long time, so kudos there. I had my money on a Mattchew + Promethelax scumteam for a while (once I realized that Zealos was not scum) and was banging my head at town killing Greymist. If I had paid a bit more attention to who was the master of puppets behind that play I *might* have figured it out, but as is, I hadn't figured it out until endgame. Well played, WB-G! As for the voteswitching: S&B, you say you've never seen it happen, yet SSB mafia ended like 2 days ago and Risen last-minute vote switched there (although he was town). Mafia pull last-minute switches all the time at lylo when town bets on the wrong guy. I don't see how you can say that never happens in normal games. I think the setup has a lot of promise and enjoyed reading the game  | ||
|
gonzaw
Uruguay4911 Posts
On July 10 2012 16:15 Acrofales wrote: I had my money on a Mattchew + Promethelax scumteam for a while (once I realized that Zealos was not scum) and was banging my head at town killing Greymist. Surely you mean Nova there? | ||
|
Acrofales
Spain18135 Posts
Killing Nova before the attack phase was also a rather bad idea, but with hindsight that might've worked out pretty well, because Toad could've had a pretty heavy hand in directing that 8/8 trampler away from himself or Matt, which could have been worse for town. | ||
|
gonzaw
Uruguay4911 Posts
On July 10 2012 16:52 Acrofales wrote: Nova too, but all your earlygame hostility at greymist was based on.. well.. basically nothing. Someone said all he was doing was talking about the setup. He was, but so was everybody else at that point. He made it rather easy to be pushed around, but I really didn't see why you went all "he's scum, lynch him!" Killing Nova before the attack phase was also a rather bad idea, but with hindsight that might've worked out pretty well, because Toad could've had a pretty heavy hand in directing that 8/8 trampler away from himself or Matt, which could have been worse for town. My hostility was mostly based on Grey doing no scumhunting, then going for the easy target (Zealos), and then doing nothing at all afterwards (but still going against Zealos without stating reasoning behind it). Not counting the "scummy" posts he made once in a while (like his brother being all aggressive all of a sudden against my plan, and Grey accusing me later, and stuff) Up to the point where I started to have a "change of heart" Grey received 3-4 damage only so it wasn't that bad. If you mean me+WBG killing him with our 8/8 and 5/3 creatures...then you still think it was such a facepalm? I tried all I could to give Grey a 2nd chance and kill Mattchew instead but he didn't even try. I'd say Nova's death was 10 times worse, since he didn't even have the time to properly defend himself or anything. but with hindsight that might've worked out pretty well, because Toad could've had a pretty heavy hand in directing that 8/8 trampler away from himself or Matt From what I recall Nova was 100% set in attacking Mattchew, so I don't think that would have worked | ||
|
Nova_Terra
Switzerland1190 Posts
On July 10 2012 16:52 Acrofales wrote: Nova too, but all your earlygame hostility at greymist was based on.. well.. basically nothing. Someone said all he was doing was talking about the setup. He was, but so was everybody else at that point. He made it rather easy to be pushed around, but I really didn't see why you went all "he's scum, lynch him!" Killing Nova before the attack phase was also a rather bad idea, but with hindsight that might've worked out pretty well, because Toad could've had a pretty heavy hand in directing that 8/8 trampler away from himself or Matt, which could have been worse for town. U kidding? theres no way in hell i was directing any attention away from him or matt, i hate listening to people whose logic seems terribad. Now to vent my frustration, : + Show Spoiler + On July 01 2012 19:14 Nova_Terra wrote: I feel uncomfortable with mattchew on that list On July 01 2012 20:32 Nova_Terra wrote: Also I oppose any plan that banks on wbg being town On July 01 2012 21:34 Nova_Terra wrote: Would prefer to kill mattchew first On July 02 2012 03:24 Nova_Terra wrote: Mattchew He keeps pushing along things passively while chilling back and doing nothing himself On July 04 2012 09:17 Nova_Terra wrote: look into mattchew/wbg or mattchew/sb connections On July 04 2012 09:20 Nova_Terra wrote: I fail to understand how experienced players such as those playing as "wbg" can be town and think their logic makes any sense, more like scum trying to make everything seem obvious to a newbie audience On July 05 2012 00:40 Nova_Terra wrote: Let me summarize this game for everybody 1: What's this? 4 out of 9 players in the game CAN'T be town because I read mafia planted wifom perfectly!! 2: Oh what sound logic! Let me use all of my possible abilitIes immediately to kill him! All assembled: yayyyyyyy!!!111! On July 05 2012 00:42 Nova_Terra wrote: Wbg cause i still dont see how an experienced player like toad could be so utterly illogical as town On July 05 2012 07:22 Nova_Terra wrote: I've said again and again that I think Mattchew and [WBG] or Matthew and sb are scum and that's what I fucking mean. I really hope ur [WBG] scum cause if not I have officially lost faith in "veteran" players I am disappointed in SB and Fulla, both of whom made no effort to read into the logic (AKA the lack of it) that caused your most valuable town asset in the game, and i am particularly disappointed in Zealos for sheeping logic that it appears wasnt even thought about whatsoever and not only killing me, also making himself pretty much worthless for the rest of the game, like a free 2 town players dead but one can still talk. Can someone (Fulla) explain to me why Prom was suddenly scum? Thank you to Artanis for hosting the game, It must have taken a ton of time and effort and i definitely want to participate in another in the future. It was really cool | ||
|
Fulla
United Kingdom519 Posts
You just seemed to sheepishly go 'oh woops nevermind'. I'm disappointed that you don't concede this as a mistake. This is what led to your downfall. From my perspective at the time it was a pure fluke that Zealos happened to be holding a deathbomb in his hands that almost near 1shot killed you. I finished the job I accept that killing you was probably a mistake, but even with hindsight now, you're play made no sense to me as town. | ||
|
Fulla
United Kingdom519 Posts
My main gripes/recommendations for improvement: - Put a limit on what cards from editions you can use. Example only last 10 editions or say from Mirrodin onwards. Sol ring is old and too overpowered. - NO banned cards! Skullclamp, wtf? How many cards did Were draw because of that? - Zealos's deck has already been spoken about but yeah imbalanced shit! - Attack Phase, this is a bit silly, in normal mafia you can only switch 1 vote last minute. In this you can wipe out 3 people. - There is no easy work around this. Off the top of my head the only solution would be everyone declares there attacks, then everyone states 'accept' or if they wish ti make changes. This however could lead to an endless unending attack phase. But anyways I think more discussion on this would be good. - Perhaps this could lead | ||
|
Fulla
United Kingdom519 Posts
Prom kept going afk, appearing, doing his filters, declaring anyone could be scum, everything is up in the air, best not to attack anyone etc. etc. It just seemed like he stalling and stalling, trying to promote inaction just long enough to kill us with the mafia beast. He put forward no plan only right right towards the end. Were very cleverly bussed Matt instantly at the right time and started putting forward a town plan to win. I thought he was town. I was stupid not to see how he stitched up Nova then quickly when silent after Nova's death. But considering how I was already highly suspicious of Nova I didn't see it :/ I thought Prom would simply kill strong with his Flyer and let Matt kill me. In other words the game was already over. That's why I wasn't around. | ||
|
Fulla
United Kingdom519 Posts
| ||
|
Toadesstern
Germany16350 Posts
On July 10 2012 21:28 Fulla wrote: Why Prom not Were? Prom kept going afk, appearing, doing his filters, declaring anyone could be scum, everything is up in the air, best not to attack anyone etc. etc. It just seemed like he stalling and stalling, trying to promote inaction just long enough to kill us with the mafia beast. He put forward no plan only right right towards the end. . Oh btw. What I said the last couple of days were no lies at all. Surely the assumption that prom has to be mafia was a lie and had to be wrong but what Fulla said here is correct. We didn't get people lynch Greymist, Nova and away from me onto Prom for nothing. We found things that really were strange from a town point of view and what I said about Prom the last couple of days really was something that should be considered scummy in games, just not as scummy as I made it sound. I felt like I had a good point to attack all those guys. Grey and Prom because they screwed up and posted weird when they didn't have to and nova because of wifom. On July 10 2012 21:18 Fulla wrote: - NO banned cards! Skullclamp, wtf? How many cards did Were draw because of that? I only killed one creature with it, so just 2 cards in total. | ||
|
Nova_Terra
Switzerland1190 Posts
On July 10 2012 21:01 Fulla wrote: Well Nova you got us all to pool you mana, let you summon a big beast. then go AFK. WTF? If you couldn't be available once during the entire 24 hours attack phase why ask for the mana? You just seemed to sheepishly go 'oh woops nevermind'. I'm disappointed that you don't concede this as a mistake. This is what led to your downfall. From my perspective at the time it was a pure fluke that Zealos happened to be holding a deathbomb in his hands that almost near 1shot killed you. I finished the job I accept that killing you was probably a mistake, but even with hindsight now, you're play made no sense to me as town. Case in point, did you actually read what I said? ![[image loading]](http://i47.tinypic.com/j8zbbr.jpg) | ||
| ||
