To say one last word to the setup discussion, I think blues should only claim when they are being lynched or if they think outing themselves will help town.
Now, as we need to pressure someone, Drazerk, why do you bring the focus away from freeloader immediately and try to incriminate 3 people who haven't posted hours after the game started. Trying to protect your scumbuddy?
On June 18 2011 19:10 Xedat wrote: Generic post not to be modkilled.....
To say one last word to the setup discussion, I think blues should only claim when they are being lynched or if they think outing themselves will help town.
Now, as we need to pressure someone, Drazerk, why do you bring the focus away from freeloader immediately and try to incriminate 3 people who haven't posted hours after the game started. Trying to protect your scumbuddy?
Focusing on freeloader?
What was we focusing on he made one worthless post which was more than the three I had listed had done who had more than enough time to post something by the time I posted the list.
If I had not pointed the three out they will continue to lurk which is just bad all round
Yeah, I am not actually suspecting you, just tried to get someone talking. We will see if someone slips something stupid, otherwise it will be a random lynch tomorrow I think.
On June 18 2011 23:00 Xedat wrote: Yeah, I am not actually suspecting you, just tried to get someone talking. We will see if someone slips something stupid, otherwise it will be a random lynch tomorrow I think.
You might not be, but I most certainly am. What is particularly suspicious about Drazek is how much his posting behavior has changed between last game and this one. Last game Drazek said almost nothing all game long. However, he's been perhaps the biggest talker this game. I suppose one could attribute this to being "more comfortable" with the smaller setting, but it's not like he increased his posted more at the end of the last game. This strikes me as very suspicious.
On June 18 2011 23:00 Xedat wrote: Yeah, I am not actually suspecting you, just tried to get someone talking. We will see if someone slips something stupid, otherwise it will be a random lynch tomorrow I think.
You might not be, but I most certainly am. What is particularly suspicious about Drazek is how much his posting behavior has changed between last game and this one. Last game Drazek said almost nothing all game long. However, he's been perhaps the biggest talker this game. I suppose one could attribute this to being "more comfortable" with the smaller setting, but it's not like he increased his posted more at the end of the last game. This strikes me as very suspicious.
##Vote: Drazek
It was more the fact every time I posted in that thread people ended up voting for me and as it ws the first game i just wanted to keep my head down and survive as long as possible
It wouldn't be bad at all. DT is good because they let us know where the mafia is. If they aren't doing that then they are useless. We don't score points at the end for how many blues are alive or something.
DT claiming as soon as they hit red helps us by a. giving us a verified lynch (either the person accused or the person who claimed DT must be mafia with no miller/framer/whatever) and killing 1/3 of the mafia b. preventing a possible mislynch (any lynch based on posting is less accurate then one based on DT check) c. it also gives us information to find the other mafia members from the vote list, posting, etc.
I 100% dissagree UNLESS the DT is about to get lynched. If you're playing optimally it is best for the DT to hold on for as long as possible, while succesfully convincing the town to lynch who they red confirmed without outing themselves. In a game with only 12 people, having a DT get as many checks as possible is key, and outing themselves
On June 18 2011 23:23 Drazerk wrote: 5. Lord Vatti 6. Alderan
Speak up now, being silent only helps Mafia
Keep in mind guys we're less than 24 hours in, I mean, I just woke up. Just like last game (I think almost all of us were in), a list of people who are posting very generic fluff and not helping the town is much more helpful than an inactive list.
i'll vote for treadmill for putting up such an aweful plan for our DTs. i'll be back in about 24 hours. until then i'll spend my time on the german Autobahn ;-)
placeholder vote til he speaks i'm leaning to someone else but no need to *not* vote for the lurker at this point in case i can't get on later ##vote: Lord Vatti
On June 19 2011 06:30 aprudds wrote: Hey Drazerk, inactives will get modkilled. I'm sure you learned that from last game. You also seem a bit too eager to change focus from freeloader.
I still have no idea what the case on freeloader is despite passing by the last game and then making an Awful post in this one
The Vaati vote is purely there until a case is built on someone else
I don't think there is a case against freeloader. The problem is he's being just as useless as he was last game. Hear that, freeloader? Please be less useless.
Drazerk is posting a lot but not contributing, which is worse. I'm gonna back up Pyo and ##Vote: Drazerk
but mostly just to pressure him into actually saying something.
If Vatti gets himself modkilled I'm gonna be so depressed.
On June 19 2011 02:37 supersoft wrote: i'll vote for treadmill for putting up such an aweful plan for our DTs. i'll be back in about 24 hours. until then i'll spend my time on the german Autobahn ;-)
Bad plan =/= scum. After re-reading the last few pages I doubt that Treadmill had a scum agenda. The whole reason he made that first post was due to the fact he thought that mafia had 2 KP, in which case claiming asap to instantly cut scum down to 1 KP wouldn't be such a bad idea.
Drazerk and Lord Vatti have been gathering the most attention at the moment, so I'm wondering why you put a vote on Treadmill? He's trying to contribute ideas and get the discussion moving, which is more than most people in the thread so far. You state your reason in about 10 words, then tell us you won't be around for 24 hours. Why? To give you justification for not responding to any pressure that's put on you or your decision to vote treadmill?
##vote: supersoft. Let's see if you are back within 24 hours.