|
Blazinghand
United States25550 Posts
On August 21 2012 07:04 imallinson wrote:
I think the problem with something like that is that scum gets an auto blue snipe which will always cancel out one of the roles. Either that or all the blue pickers would choose vet and scum would be hard pressed to actually kill anyone. Also if the town happened to vote for 3 scum to get the roles scum can't kill a blue and it basically gives town three huge scum reads. Of course scum could fake this to waste a lynch. It's a set up that would have to be really carefully balanced to work well.
Yeah, I thought about that thing with the roles, which is why I included Vet in the list. Given that the 3 blues could pick Vet, Jailer, and Cop, it suddenly becomes very hilarious and WIFOM-ey for scum to shoot anywhere. The danger/benefit of scum getting the blue roles is also huge. It's a chance to feed the town info and get cred, but it's also dangerous. It sounds like a very tense and fun scenario.
I'll check out Election Mafia.
|
United Kingdom3482 Posts
On August 21 2012 07:10 Blazinghand wrote:Show nested quote +On August 21 2012 07:04 imallinson wrote:
I think the problem with something like that is that scum gets an auto blue snipe which will always cancel out one of the roles. Either that or all the blue pickers would choose vet and scum would be hard pressed to actually kill anyone. Also if the town happened to vote for 3 scum to get the roles scum can't kill a blue and it basically gives town three huge scum reads. Of course scum could fake this to waste a lynch. It's a set up that would have to be really carefully balanced to work well. Yeah, I thought about that thing with the roles, which is why I included Vet in the list. Given that the 3 blues could pick Vet, Jailer, and Cop, it suddenly becomes very hilarious and WIFOM-ey for scum to shoot anywhere. The danger/benefit of scum getting the blue roles is also huge. It's a chance to feed the town info and get cred, but it's also dangerous. It sounds like a very tense and fun scenario. I'll check out Election Mafia.
Having a quick skim of the Election Mafia makes it look similar to your idea but with varying roles. Your set up would probably be pretty hilarious just because of the heaping piles of WIFOM that would occur from the night actions.
|
Blazinghand
United States25550 Posts
On August 21 2012 09:04 imallinson wrote:Show nested quote +On August 21 2012 07:10 Blazinghand wrote:On August 21 2012 07:04 imallinson wrote:
I think the problem with something like that is that scum gets an auto blue snipe which will always cancel out one of the roles. Either that or all the blue pickers would choose vet and scum would be hard pressed to actually kill anyone. Also if the town happened to vote for 3 scum to get the roles scum can't kill a blue and it basically gives town three huge scum reads. Of course scum could fake this to waste a lynch. It's a set up that would have to be really carefully balanced to work well. Yeah, I thought about that thing with the roles, which is why I included Vet in the list. Given that the 3 blues could pick Vet, Jailer, and Cop, it suddenly becomes very hilarious and WIFOM-ey for scum to shoot anywhere. The danger/benefit of scum getting the blue roles is also huge. It's a chance to feed the town info and get cred, but it's also dangerous. It sounds like a very tense and fun scenario. I'll check out Election Mafia. Having a quick skim of the Election Mafia makes it look similar to your idea but with varying roles. Your set up would probably be pretty hilarious just because of the heaping piles of WIFOM that would occur from the night actions.
I should call it Wine Tasting Mafia and have each blue power be named someting like "Cabernet" or "Sauvignon Blanc" etc etc so it's all different kinds of wine. VTs are Wine Tasters and Mafia are Vinegar makers.
|
Blazinghand
United States25550 Posts
OK, I'm looking for some comments on balance here. I've got scum roles, plus an allotment of blue roles, and how many blues each night as a function of living townies.
Witchraft Mafia
scum (the inquisition): Inquisitor, Priest, Witch Hunter
town (the coven): 10 acolytes (VTs)
Witchcraft:
Each day, in addition to the normal vote, there is a secret vote done via PM to elect Blues. Each townie (or scum) has X votes they can distribute as they want, but can't put more than one vote on a guy or vote for themselves. At the start of the night, the X top winners can choose from the following pool of roles:
Sane Cop 1x
Pasta Chef 1x (DT that gets Innocent on townies or scum, Guilty on Godfather)
JK 1x
RB 1x
Mason 2x (may select buddy, lasts until end of day)
Vet 3x
Calculating number of blues:
X = (T - 3) / 2 rounded up
T is townies, X is number of blues / blue votes per player
At LYLO-3 you have 3 blues, at LYLO-2 you have 2 blues, at LYLO-1 you have 1 blue, at LYLO you're just voting on who to lynch. If town lynches scum, they don't get penalized for this and get extra days with more blues.
+ Show Spoiler +10 / 3
9 / 3
8 / 3
7 / 2
6 / 2
5 / 1
4 / 1
3 / 0
2 / 0
Inquisitor (goon): Mafia Goon. Innocent to Pasta Chef checks, guilty to DT checks. Can deliver KP.
Priest (godfather) Innocent to DT checks, guilty to Pasta Chef checks. Can deliver KP.
Witch Hunter (one-shot blue vigi): This particular Inquisitor is gifted with a gun loaded with a single Silver Bullet. Once, at any point during the game, he can fire his Silver Bullet by PMing the mod. If he hits someone empowered with Witchcraft, they die on the spot, even if they are a Veteran. If he hits an unpowered townie, nothing happens. Can do this and deliver scum KP in the same night. Innocent to Pasta Chef checks, guilty to DT checks.
|
Witchcraft Mafia sounds fun. I really like the Witch Hunter role, makes voting and claiming trickier.
Q: What happens if a Scum gets a lot of votes? Is he simply ignored? This might be an issue after the Witch Hunter has allready shot and Town force a player they think should have gotten a role to claim.
|
Blazinghand
United States25550 Posts
Hm, that's a good question.
You're right: the issue I potentially see would be if Mafia couldn't choose to reproduce a town power, town might say "ok all blues pick mason or RB and target who we the town decide and claim it."-- and if mafia can't do this, town will know who they are.
Mafia should probably get a reward for looking townie enough to earn a blue power.
How does this sound: any member of the inquisition that gets a blue power draws it from the pool of town powers as normal, and can use it. But if it's a DT or Veteran power he instead gets the ability to RB (in addition to whatever powers he might have had) for the night.
|
What about this one?
If a scum is voted, he is informed that he got a lot of votes but he doesn´t get a power, but knows he should prepare a fakeclaim. If that´s not enough, the roleblock and mason abilities are the only ones scum can´t fake, so give scum one use of each during the game. They might use it to counter situations where they are about to be outed, or offensively to roleblock or talk in private with a townie.
|
Blazinghand
United States25550 Posts
That's interesting! Inquisitor's tools, yes. That would fit well.
I'll go with: the scum faction has 1-shot masonry and 1-shot RB that they can use, and it can be sent by any scum player.
They'll likely save it to fakeclaim in case town does some sort of mass Blue thing. That sounds perfect.
|
Not really sure where this should go, but I didn't think I needed to open a separate thread, so I'll just talk about it here.
I was bored today, and was talking with marv on irc as Rockband Mini Mafia was ending, and decided to write a setup generator for c9++ games. It's just a simple little GUI program that could potentially make rolling a c9++ setup quicker. And hey, even if no one is interested in it, at least I had fun making it and learning C# in the process 
+ Show Spoiler [Screenshots] +
Edit: It requires .NET framework, which most people should have. But if not, I can direct you where to grab it if you're still interested.
Edit 2: Download Can provide source code if anyone is interested (beware, its messy )
If someone downloads it and tries it out, please let me know. I'd like to make sure it actually runs for other people (AKA I need beta testers!)
|
that's really nifty.
i've been doing a filtergathering votecounting editchecking webbased (pretty much a website from user perspective) tool for my upcoming newbie game (because i'm lazy and i don't want to count votes and that). i wanted to test it out on the newbie game first but it seems like it's working for now and i think maybe i have somewhere i can host it to make it available for other people at all times and not just for me. i want to post a screenshot but it's on my other computer and i have to leave in 5 mins and either way it's not visually impressive, it's just nice not to have to do tedious work like that.
anyway, it's kind of a webpage where you just put in information about your game and then it does filterlist/votecount/editcheck and outputs it formatted for a post on teamliquid.
i wanted to do some setup generating tool too but i'm horrible with setups.
|
kitaman27
United States9244 Posts
Awesome Keirathi 
|
Hey so I am running a RL mafia game and just wanted some advice on the balance of my current setup. I didn't want to start a whole new thread for this and I couldn't get an answer on the TLmafia IRC.
The game should have between 9-12 people.
I was thinking of having 2 mafia (one godfather(detects as town)), a serial killer(unkillable at night, 1 KP), a detective, a doctor, a 1-shot vigilante and the rest vanilla townies.
The group of players experience level goes from none to weak and I wanted to get a decent amount of special roles in their to keep everyones interest up and still make for some interesting games.
I appreciate any help someone can give me. Like if this game would be too hard for the town or mafia to win and if by some miracle this is fine, when I would add another mafia if I get more people to play.
|
For 9 people, 3 blues, 2 reds and an SK seems like way too many special roles. I think for a smaller group, I would drop the GF and either the cop or the doc. For 12 people, that seems not terribly unbalanced. If you're having trouble trying to find a good setup, I would refer you to the F11 setup (9 people) or the C9++ setup (13 people). The setups are meant for online mafia, but I'm sure they would work just as well in real life.
|
RL mafia players complain a lot with too many special roles.
[9 players]
1 Cop, 1 Veteran, 5 VT, 2 Mafia
[10 Players]
1 Cop, 1 Medic, 6 VT, 2 Mafia
[11 Players]
1 Cop, 1 Vigilante, 7 VT, 2 Mafia
[12 Players]
2 Cop, 7 VT, 3 Mafia OR 1 Cop, 1 Medic, 8 VT, 2 Mafia (Make sure you tell them either one is possible)
|
Blazinghand
United States25550 Posts
iGrok is correct. RL Mafia is more about reading body language and stuff than it is about weird roles. Long night phases are lame
|
I like having mayors when I play RL mafia. But it really only works when you have like 20 people. Or like I guess you could have a mayor in a small game, except he can't decide the first lynch, he just like picks candidates to vote on.
|
hey in connection with cohosting forumite's resistance mafia i wrote a script to count votes and stuff like that
i wanted to use it some time later for other games but i forgot how the hell it worked and then i thought i'd just do a small and robust web interface on my local web server
and then i thought i might just as well put that online for everybody to use if they feel like it
link
it should be pretty self explanatory how it works, i used an old newbie game of mine to test it out and the test data is still in there. it takes about 1-5 seconds for every 20 posts the script has to go through (mostly 2 seconds i should think). takes about 30 seconds for the filters example and about 20 seconds for the votes example. this is 99% network delay. it's important that you type the list of players out correctly but it's not important that they vote in the correct format or vote for exact player names. people can vote "kita" instead of "kitaman27" and stuff like that. if someone decides to use it then any feedback is welcome. this has just been a fun hobby project combining my interest in computers with my interest in mafia to make something i actually find useful
all of the source code is also there if anybody else wants to host it too.
i only tested it in chrome and firefox because i don't really have ie  but hopefully it works in ie too.
also to catch a vote you have to type in both the voter and the votee in the players textarea
|
kitaman27
United States9244 Posts
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/lwDeY.png)
![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/ydyxl.png)
