TL Mafia XXXI

On October 10 2010 08:04 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
This is my analysis of SiNiquity, a player of whom I have been suspicious of since day 1 but is growing ever larger now on my radar.

His first posts are useless and I won't quote them for the sake of saving space. They concern the issue of protactiniums smurf.

He continues throughout the beginning posting a lot but making empty arguments others have already made. "Who is protacts smurf?"

This amused me:


Oh really? We lose if we lynch the VI? Thanks for the input SiN.



Says the same thing.



Same obvious argument. Of course we can not lynch the Village Idiot.



Worthless post about protacts smurf



Backseat modding, no reason to post this whatsoever.



Admits himself that it's not even his list, he just copy pasted it. Big waste of space. So far he has a lot of posts and ZERO content.



link to the voting thread, very helpful



more backseat modding. so far has added zero content or thought to this game



worthless post

starting on page 22 he spams relentlessly, except this post stands out to me



What is the point of this? It's obvious at this point that BB wasn't going to end a game. This is a convenient time for mafia to come out and say "oh but I hate my role as (town role), let's restart". Not overtly suspicious but this is when he became a blip on my radar as "possible red" instead of just "awful and useless town player"

now ALL THE WAY from page 22 to 39 he spams one-liners with NO information. Look at his post history in his profile. It's ridiculous. he goes out of his way to confirm himself as town during twilight and then just continues spamming the thread. word.

Here is his first "big and useful" post. Which was utterly useless. Let's look at it (I'll be posting my thoughts inside the quote in red)



Even though he interpreted BM's argument THE OPPOSITE of how BM interpreted it. He still accused bloodycobbler. It seems strange to me that there is nothing in common between their conclusions other than the fact that they both painted BC red (bill murray and SiNiquity)

what did we learn from this post?
1. there is a big possibility BM and SiN have communicated out of game
2. despite interpreting BM's argument very differently SiN still accused bloodycobbler and insisted BM is 100% town.

After two more useless posts SiN posts this



What is this post about? Protecting BM and explaining his late vote. Mafia like to vote late so that they make sure to have the least conspicous vote possible.

He says "I understand BM's plan" yet in his previous post he interpreted CLEARLY in the exact opposite way BM did. If that is the case there is no way he understood what BM was doing unless they communicated or unless SiN has really really bad reading comprehension.



Would you like to explain? Misder didn't end up being mafia, just a bad townie. But why even say this if you aren't going to provie a reason? Not only does he not back up his defense but he doesn't propose an alternative. He isn't scumhunting which is what town should be doing. Lynching mafia.

If SiNiquity is mafia, Bill Murray definitely is. SiNiquity you have some explaining to do. How did you "know" BM was using the word "town" to trick people and was actually looking for the word "townie". How did you understand BM's argument yet come to different conclusions?

Why the spam? The nonsense one-liners?