|
theres a difference between broad game knowledge which is like knowing why lane swaps are good and what makes x jungler good over y jungler, which most people seem to think is really important. Specific game knowledge which requires a deeper understanding of the game such as how do i play this lane, how do i play this teamfight, should i gank here etc are whats a lot more important.
similarly in bw most people think they have brilliant stratgies but dont know enough about when to build workers when to expand when to attack how many production buildings to build etc it doesnt matter if your army comp is better if they have 2x as much stuff. those things were listed as "mechanics" but it was 90% game knowledge and 10% moving faster by knowing exactly what you had to do and why
|
On October 25 2013 00:09 AsmodeusXI wrote:Show nested quote +On October 25 2013 00:03 Ketara wrote: I've never understood this argument that being in a high league in the game is a requirement of being somebody who understands the game / has a lot of game knowledge.
It is probably true that being really good at the game makes it easier to understand the game, but the idea that it is impossible to understand the game without being really good at the game is obviously and demonstrably false, and yet people still try to argue it.
What league is Yango I wonder? You guys all give Yango a ton of respect for game knowledge (not that he doesn't deserve it) but I wonder if he's Diamond league. He's not. I think that was mentioned earlier. "something something Gold league scrub"
And Montecristo doesn't even play League. GG I should quit playing so I can become a cerebral mastermind.
|
regardless of what division yango is, he always posts about broad knowledge matters and relates them to dota etc, you dont see him tlaking about how to play a lane or whatever
|
|
On October 24 2013 21:04 Alaric wrote:Show nested quote +On October 24 2013 11:33 Seuss wrote:On October 24 2013 08:58 Alaric wrote:Kill me now. (Paging Seuss and Yango for a laugh.) It sometimes baffles me how they can fine tune some balancing aspects that I wouldn't ever dare touch with a 10-foot pole because I've got no experience toward it, and yet they still fall for such crutches and ideas you can label as "do not want" at first sight. I won't laugh until I see all the changes in aggregate. It's pretty silly to try and evaluate individual changes outside of their greater context. As Yango said, it's not for the effects themselves, but the way Riot handles stuff + Show Spoiler +: when we discuss "how to give more gold to the junglers", we're mostly discussing means, often indirect, to affect their income by looking at the causes (like how a bunch of us thought "carry junglers" wouldn't work off of increasing camp value in s3 because you can't afford to afk farm). But when Riot talk about issues I (too) often get a nasty feeling that their "give more gld to the junglers" is to be taken at face value. They're speaking literally. Which suggests that they ignore (whether on purpose or not) the underlying causes.
Regarding the 4th camp, I remember TL mentioning it at least as far as 1v2 lanes popping up (after donating the blue stopped). Its positioning suggests several things to me: - easy access to one camp from a side lane (golems or the new one), potentially lets 1v2 laners take it to still get some gold/exp when zoned? - reduces the farm discrepancy between jungle sides (when purple side I won't be bot often unless I plan for it because there's only the wolves). - it's close to the lane so barring other changes, it makes you lose less farm camping the nearby lane instead of making it harder for you to gank/countergank by drawing you away from the lanes (when thinking "4th camp" behind inner tower, opposite from wolves instinctively came to me) - easy access also means that wherever the duo lane goes, if it shoves or 2v1 it'll have access to a camp to poach
The more I think about it, the more the map looks too tiny to me, or rather, the lanes too short. The waves reach towers so fast so 1v2 laners can barely leave it without immediatly losing cs to the tower, and when you're missing it can immediatly be assumed that you're roaming rather than still in lne, just out of view. Editing the map's size would have pretty huge consequences not limited to these topics, though.
Also, this whole "carry junglers get stronger because they have items that scale with camps", first sounds dumb: - instead of giving you the income/farm opportunities to buy carry items, you get items that give you more bonuses as you "kill camps" - we're again in a forced interaction over freedom and the player making a choice: "you want to carry? You'll have these stats by killing camps". Not item build customised by the gold you earn, no income from farm allocation or jungle's gold rewards: you kill monsters, not minions or other stuff, specifically monsters (so outside of laning you have to weight the value of stats gained by killing a camp over the gold earned by clearing a wave), to receive specific stats from specific items granted to you.
On the other hand maybe these are actually items like Seeker's Armguard, so that once they're stacked you don't have incentive to prioritise monsters, and they're balanced at low cost/low efficiency, so they're accessible early, and once stacked they're very cost-effective but only as slot-effective as standard laner items.
Curious about how the "per camp" thing is handled too, seeing possible incentive to counterjungle champs using these items: if it's given by the big monster, or a flat increase per monster (so you casually kill his little wraiths, not cost-effective for you but you reduce the camp's stack worth by 75%), or something else entirely.
I completely understand that, but it's a cop out. Arguing that Riot is approaching their fixes from the wrong angle/mindset is fine and largely isn't what's been happening in this thread.
Simply put, expressing concerns over Riot's philosophical/stated direction and targeting individual changes outside of their greater context are two very different things, and I don't plan on engaging in the latter.
|
|
On October 25 2013 00:16 JimmiC wrote:Show nested quote +On October 25 2013 00:06 jcarlsoniv wrote:On October 25 2013 00:02 Slayer91 wrote: and then they fixed his numbers just like any other champ? Well, they neutered him pretty hard, but I do think he's in a fine place right now. But that's not the argument I'm trying to present. I was referring to the fact that Riot directly contradicted themselves in a very short time frame. I love that Riot communicates with the community as much as they do. I'm generally happy with most of what Riot does and tries to accomplish. But that doesn't change the fact that there has been more than one instance where it's been blatantly apparent that there are likely some communication issues within the organization. My point is if what you said above is true then why can't the comments about changes be generally happy, with some concern. I'd like to see some posts about the changes that are ina positive light and not have a bunch of other posters tell that person they don't know anything about the game.
Because what you bolded might not be true for everyone? That's my opinion, I don't speak for everyone.
And I think you're being incredibly doomsday-y. Yes, people on this forum are critical of the game (sometimes to a fault). But it's because they are passionate about it and care about the direction of the game.
Speculation drives discussion. Sometimes it's useless, but if we didn't speculate about upcoming changes, we'd be sitting here talking about whether Galio is bad or not still.
Also, if you keep your expectations low (what you're calling pessimism), then there is less disappointment if things go poorly. If things go well and change for the better, then you are pleasantly surprised.
|
On October 25 2013 00:18 JimmiC wrote:Show nested quote +On October 25 2013 00:14 Slayer91 wrote: regardless of what division yango is, he always posts about broad knowledge matters and relates them to dota etc, you dont see him tlaking about how to play a lane or whatever I think the purpose was to use Yango as a example of some one in a lower league with lots of knowledge, that most people on this forum will agree has lots of game knowledge. Showing that high league placement isn't 100% nessecary to knowldege.
you just completely ignored the distinction i made between broad knowledge and specific knowledge
like ur dad shouting at football players on tv but he doenst know anything about the specifics of movement and how to kick the ball in such a way or sprinting technique etc
skiesarered used to think i just was really good mechanically or something because when he'd be in inhouses talking about comps and picks id always say like doesnt matter just pick what you're good at comps dont matter. When I was on vent with him when i finally got a mic he said he "changed his opinion" because i was talking about how people shoulda got certain items and making wrong plays and such absentmindedly
in solo q knowing about how pro players play and such and team comps is pretty much all useless since you have to play just 1 specific champion as well as you cna and you have little influence except for making calls on the rest of the team
|
Yango also doesn't play the game like ever. He's been in the same spot division wise for like the entire season. You don't need to be diamond to think about the game.
|
if you dont play you wont learn Hundreds of thousands watch pro play and they all still suck
|
You can also learn from watching.
|
only if you analyzing in a very focused way and not watching riving and phreak pan around the map to look for puns
|
here is my opinion on the matter.
I suck at gaming (and most sports). i just dont have the real time / quick decision making, confidence, or whatever it is to be instantly good at these things. I have no game talent.
But I still played competitively, and still can be diamond 1 when trolling solo Q, etc. etc.. This is a lot because of just playing the game a TON last year, but also comes down to knowledge.
And this is why i think its bull shit when people say "oh im silver, but i watch streams and understand the game so well!". there isnt that much execution in LoL that if you understand you cant get at least diamond. I suck dick at execution, as previously stated, yet im there.
so, dont say your understanding is way higher than you are ranked and its execution holding you back. its either your understanding is much worse than you think (probably the answer), or you dont play enough games (rarely the case).
(note: esports understanding and GAME-solo Q understanding are two different things, as the context is strategically very different).
|
On October 24 2013 21:28 TheLink wrote: I've been wondering, how many of you guys sell Dorans items for wards when your inventory is full? be honest and not the usual "I always get 2 wards every back" that the mids always lie about. Isn't that what ward bitches are for?
|
On October 25 2013 00:24 Nos- wrote: Yango also doesn't play the game like ever. He's been in the same spot division wise for like the entire season. You don't need to be diamond to think about the game.
You forgot the part where he´s a rather talented Dota player. He might not be diamond in LoL, but my guess would be, he is at that level in dota.
Kinda the same with me. I used to be a rather good raid leader in World of Warcraft and that "talent" surely affected my playstyle/calls in League of Legends and made me the player i am today.
|
How much potential do you think CLG has with the roster changes and the korean influence?
|
|
It will only be potential. ;;
Well we'll see who they bring on.
|
On October 25 2013 00:40 JimmiC wrote:Show nested quote +On October 25 2013 00:21 Slayer91 wrote:On October 25 2013 00:18 JimmiC wrote:On October 25 2013 00:14 Slayer91 wrote: regardless of what division yango is, he always posts about broad knowledge matters and relates them to dota etc, you dont see him tlaking about how to play a lane or whatever I think the purpose was to use Yango as a example of some one in a lower league with lots of knowledge, that most people on this forum will agree has lots of game knowledge. Showing that high league placement isn't 100% nessecary to knowldege. you just completely ignored the distinction i made between broad knowledge and specific knowledge like ur dad shouting at football players on tv but he doenst know anything about the specifics of movement and how to kick the ball in such a way or sprinting technique etc skiesarered used to think i just was really good mechanically or something because when he'd be in inhouses talking about comps and picks id always say like doesnt matter just pick what you're good at comps dont matter. When I was on vent with him when i finally got a mic he said he "changed his opinion" because i was talking about how people shoulda got certain items and making wrong plays and such absentmindedly in solo q knowing about how pro players play and such and team comps is pretty much all useless since you have to play just 1 specific champion as well as you cna and you have little influence except for making calls on the rest of the team I understand your point. But are you saying Yango is like a dad yelling at tv screen? If not I think the orignal posters point stands.
clearly you dont if thats all you understand dad yelling at tv screen is the average viewer (clg fan lolol) maybe yango would hope to be at he level of the panel commentators
|
|
|
|
|