|
NOTE: When providing a source, please provide a very brief summary on what it's about and what purpose it adds to the discussion. The supporting statement should clearly explain why the subject is relevant and needs to be discussed. Please follow this rule especially for tweets.
Your supporting statement should always come BEFORE you provide the source. |
On April 14 2026 23:22 Billyboy wrote:
None of what you say is remotely true.
If you don’t understand that Hezbollah being disarmed is a huge win for Lebanon and the Lebanese people you don’t understand remotely the conflict or reason. You are just down the rabbit hole of hate and are the ignorant hateful person you claim to hate. Even an evil tyrant might accidentally improve the conditions and lives around him by prosecuting wars against their authoritarian oppressors for purely selfish reasons. Netanyahu is less than that for wanting a non-terrorist regime to the north of his country with ample weapons and will to kill Israeli civilians in its north. He isn't doing it out of the goodness of his heart for the Lebanese people, nor is it anything but stupid to discount the results based on the intentions.
I think the anti-Israel blame, in some areas well-founded, has erased in the minds of the arguers just how terrible groups like Hezbollah and Hamas and the IRGC and the ayatollahs are for the innocents surrounding them. Israel gets more press simply because the western world has more influence on their actions. Any deal between Israel and Lebanon that creates peace and rids the Lebanese of Hezbollah control of their politics and southern territory is an unqualified victory for the Lebanese people. Anybody with a brain should be desiring that without whitewashing Israel's interests.
|
On April 15 2026 02:16 dyhb wrote:Show nested quote +On April 14 2026 23:22 Billyboy wrote:
None of what you say is remotely true.
If you don’t understand that Hezbollah being disarmed is a huge win for Lebanon and the Lebanese people you don’t understand remotely the conflict or reason. You are just down the rabbit hole of hate and are the ignorant hateful person you claim to hate. Even an evil tyrant might accidentally improve the conditions and lives around him by prosecuting wars against their authoritarian oppressors for purely selfish reasons. Netanyahu is less than that for wanting a non-terrorist regime to the north of his country with ample weapons and will to kill Israeli civilians in its north. He isn't doing it out of the goodness of his heart for the Lebanese people, nor is it anything but stupid to discount the results based on the intentions. I think the anti-Israel blame, in some areas well-founded, has erased in the minds of the arguers just how terrible groups like Hezbollah and Hamas and the IRGC and the ayatollahs are for the innocents surrounding them. Israel gets more press simply because the western world has more influence on their actions. Any deal between Israel and Lebanon that creates peace and rids the Lebanese of Hezbollah control of their politics and southern territory is an unqualified victory for the Lebanese people. Anybody with a brain should be desiring that without whitewashing Israel's interests.
What's your strategy to make sure that all of the Lebanese people who lose relatives and friends in this campaign to get rid of Hezbollah don't start feeling hatred toward Israel, hatred that will then be fueled by continued mistreatment of Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza and will motivate them to form another terrible group that is bad for the innocents surrounding them and that you will have to kill a bunch of Lebanese people to get rid of in 30 years?
|
On April 15 2026 02:16 dyhb wrote:Show nested quote +On April 14 2026 23:22 Billyboy wrote:
None of what you say is remotely true.
If you don’t understand that Hezbollah being disarmed is a huge win for Lebanon and the Lebanese people you don’t understand remotely the conflict or reason. You are just down the rabbit hole of hate and are the ignorant hateful person you claim to hate. Even an evil tyrant might accidentally improve the conditions and lives around him by prosecuting wars against their authoritarian oppressors for purely selfish reasons. Netanyahu is less than that for wanting a non-terrorist regime to the north of his country with ample weapons and will to kill Israeli civilians in its north. He isn't doing it out of the goodness of his heart for the Lebanese people, nor is it anything but stupid to discount the results based on the intentions. I think the anti-Israel blame, in some areas well-founded, has erased in the minds of the arguers just how terrible groups like Hezbollah and Hamas and the IRGC and the ayatollahs are for the innocents surrounding them. Israel gets more press simply because the western world has more influence on their actions. Any deal between Israel and Lebanon that creates peace and rids the Lebanese of Hezbollah control of their politics and southern territory is an unqualified victory for the Lebanese people. Anybody with a brain should be desiring that without whitewashing Israel's interests.
I agree with most of what you said and I don’t think you would be able to find a post from me that suggests Netanyahu’s interests are anything other than self.
What frustrates me is there are people in this thread that post as if groups like Hezbollah or Hamas are freedom fighters, which simply is not accurate. There are plenty of things to criticize Israel about that are real and proven.
Iran being only in Iran should be a goal that everyone shares. If you don’t share it, you are either uninformed, filled with hatred or both.
|
United Kingdom10014 Posts
On April 14 2026 22:49 Billyboy wrote:Show nested quote +On April 14 2026 22:19 Jockmcplop wrote:On April 14 2026 22:04 Billyboy wrote:
Israel and Lebanon are having their first direct talks in 40 years. Wild it’s been that long for neighbours.
They are wide apart in talks. Lebanon demands a ceasefire for legitimate talks, Netanyahu says they will continue until agreement made. Which makes it seem hard to ever get started.
Israel’s demands seem pretty reasonable from 10,000 feet, they are Hezbollah disarming and a conclusion of a historic peace agreement.
Even if agreed, Lebanon hasn’t had any success (or the UN) in disarming Hezbollah. And Israel is likely going to demand a “buffer” zone for some length of time or even indefinitely.
Long way to peace, but good they are making the first actual step. I wonder what it is about Israel that makes them absolutely refuse to stop killing people for any reason at all. What a low content hateful post. Do better.
Still at it I see. Excellent work.
|
On April 15 2026 03:18 Jockmcplop wrote:Show nested quote +On April 14 2026 22:49 Billyboy wrote:On April 14 2026 22:19 Jockmcplop wrote:On April 14 2026 22:04 Billyboy wrote:
Israel and Lebanon are having their first direct talks in 40 years. Wild it’s been that long for neighbours.
They are wide apart in talks. Lebanon demands a ceasefire for legitimate talks, Netanyahu says they will continue until agreement made. Which makes it seem hard to ever get started.
Israel’s demands seem pretty reasonable from 10,000 feet, they are Hezbollah disarming and a conclusion of a historic peace agreement.
Even if agreed, Lebanon hasn’t had any success (or the UN) in disarming Hezbollah. And Israel is likely going to demand a “buffer” zone for some length of time or even indefinitely.
Long way to peace, but good they are making the first actual step. I wonder what it is about Israel that makes them absolutely refuse to stop killing people for any reason at all. What a low content hateful post. Do better. Still at it I see. Excellent work.
Just calling a spade a spade.
|
On April 15 2026 02:51 Nebuchad wrote:Show nested quote +On April 15 2026 02:16 dyhb wrote:On April 14 2026 23:22 Billyboy wrote:
None of what you say is remotely true.
If you don’t understand that Hezbollah being disarmed is a huge win for Lebanon and the Lebanese people you don’t understand remotely the conflict or reason. You are just down the rabbit hole of hate and are the ignorant hateful person you claim to hate. Even an evil tyrant might accidentally improve the conditions and lives around him by prosecuting wars against their authoritarian oppressors for purely selfish reasons. Netanyahu is less than that for wanting a non-terrorist regime to the north of his country with ample weapons and will to kill Israeli civilians in its north. He isn't doing it out of the goodness of his heart for the Lebanese people, nor is it anything but stupid to discount the results based on the intentions. I think the anti-Israel blame, in some areas well-founded, has erased in the minds of the arguers just how terrible groups like Hezbollah and Hamas and the IRGC and the ayatollahs are for the innocents surrounding them. Israel gets more press simply because the western world has more influence on their actions. Any deal between Israel and Lebanon that creates peace and rids the Lebanese of Hezbollah control of their politics and southern territory is an unqualified victory for the Lebanese people. Anybody with a brain should be desiring that without whitewashing Israel's interests. What's your strategy to make sure that all of the Lebanese people who lose relatives and friends in this campaign to get rid of Hezbollah don't start feeling hatred toward Israel, hatred that will then be fueled by continued mistreatment of Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza and will motivate them to form another terrible group that is bad for the innocents surrounding them and that you will have to kill a bunch of Lebanese people to get rid of in 30 years? I think they'll do a much better job than you at judging Hezbollah's oppression and intentions regarding the Lebanese people. As much as you would dismiss and ignore Hezbollah's actions after the US-Israel war on Iran, they saw the rocket and missile fire from Hezbollah into Israel first-hand. I just have to reject your premise here that it requires a strategy and their local observations are outweighed by propaganda coming from 100 miles away.
On April 15 2026 03:02 Billyboy wrote:Show nested quote +On April 15 2026 02:16 dyhb wrote:On April 14 2026 23:22 Billyboy wrote:
None of what you say is remotely true.
If you don’t understand that Hezbollah being disarmed is a huge win for Lebanon and the Lebanese people you don’t understand remotely the conflict or reason. You are just down the rabbit hole of hate and are the ignorant hateful person you claim to hate. Even an evil tyrant might accidentally improve the conditions and lives around him by prosecuting wars against their authoritarian oppressors for purely selfish reasons. Netanyahu is less than that for wanting a non-terrorist regime to the north of his country with ample weapons and will to kill Israeli civilians in its north. He isn't doing it out of the goodness of his heart for the Lebanese people, nor is it anything but stupid to discount the results based on the intentions. I think the anti-Israel blame, in some areas well-founded, has erased in the minds of the arguers just how terrible groups like Hezbollah and Hamas and the IRGC and the ayatollahs are for the innocents surrounding them. Israel gets more press simply because the western world has more influence on their actions. Any deal between Israel and Lebanon that creates peace and rids the Lebanese of Hezbollah control of their politics and southern territory is an unqualified victory for the Lebanese people. Anybody with a brain should be desiring that without whitewashing Israel's interests. I agree with most of what you said and I don’t think you would be able to find a post from me that suggests Netanyahu’s interests are anything other than self. What frustrates me is there are people in this thread that post as if groups like Hezbollah or Hamas are freedom fighters, which simply is not accurate. There are plenty of things to criticize Israel about that are real and proven. Iran being only in Iran should be a goal that everyone shares. If you don’t share it, you are either uninformed, filled with hatred or both. I think they really truly believe that Iranian proxies are legitimately concerned with the well-being of non-combatants. It's some kind of remix of the old pan-Arab nationalism movement or something.
|
United Kingdom10014 Posts
On April 15 2026 03:58 Billyboy wrote:Show nested quote +On April 15 2026 03:18 Jockmcplop wrote:On April 14 2026 22:49 Billyboy wrote:On April 14 2026 22:19 Jockmcplop wrote:On April 14 2026 22:04 Billyboy wrote:
Israel and Lebanon are having their first direct talks in 40 years. Wild it’s been that long for neighbours.
They are wide apart in talks. Lebanon demands a ceasefire for legitimate talks, Netanyahu says they will continue until agreement made. Which makes it seem hard to ever get started.
Israel’s demands seem pretty reasonable from 10,000 feet, they are Hezbollah disarming and a conclusion of a historic peace agreement.
Even if agreed, Lebanon hasn’t had any success (or the UN) in disarming Hezbollah. And Israel is likely going to demand a “buffer” zone for some length of time or even indefinitely.
Long way to peace, but good they are making the first actual step. I wonder what it is about Israel that makes them absolutely refuse to stop killing people for any reason at all. What a low content hateful post. Do better. Still at it I see. Excellent work. Just calling a spade a spade.
You missed the point of my post.
I haven't really been following the thread so I wanted to see if the new moral depths Israel has plummeted to recently has stopped you from cheering them on like a little fangirl.
Good to know nothing has changed.
|
On April 15 2026 04:12 dyhb wrote:Show nested quote +On April 15 2026 02:51 Nebuchad wrote:On April 15 2026 02:16 dyhb wrote:On April 14 2026 23:22 Billyboy wrote:
None of what you say is remotely true.
If you don’t understand that Hezbollah being disarmed is a huge win for Lebanon and the Lebanese people you don’t understand remotely the conflict or reason. You are just down the rabbit hole of hate and are the ignorant hateful person you claim to hate. Even an evil tyrant might accidentally improve the conditions and lives around him by prosecuting wars against their authoritarian oppressors for purely selfish reasons. Netanyahu is less than that for wanting a non-terrorist regime to the north of his country with ample weapons and will to kill Israeli civilians in its north. He isn't doing it out of the goodness of his heart for the Lebanese people, nor is it anything but stupid to discount the results based on the intentions. I think the anti-Israel blame, in some areas well-founded, has erased in the minds of the arguers just how terrible groups like Hezbollah and Hamas and the IRGC and the ayatollahs are for the innocents surrounding them. Israel gets more press simply because the western world has more influence on their actions. Any deal between Israel and Lebanon that creates peace and rids the Lebanese of Hezbollah control of their politics and southern territory is an unqualified victory for the Lebanese people. Anybody with a brain should be desiring that without whitewashing Israel's interests. What's your strategy to make sure that all of the Lebanese people who lose relatives and friends in this campaign to get rid of Hezbollah don't start feeling hatred toward Israel, hatred that will then be fueled by continued mistreatment of Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza and will motivate them to form another terrible group that is bad for the innocents surrounding them and that you will have to kill a bunch of Lebanese people to get rid of in 30 years? I think they'll do a much better job than you at judging Hezbollah's oppression and intentions regarding the Lebanese people. As much as you would dismiss and ignore Hezbollah's actions after the US-Israel war on Iran, they saw the rocket and missile fire from Hezbollah into Israel first-hand. I just have to reject your premise here that it requires a strategy and their local observations are outweighed by propaganda coming from 100 miles away. Show nested quote +On April 15 2026 03:02 Billyboy wrote:On April 15 2026 02:16 dyhb wrote:On April 14 2026 23:22 Billyboy wrote:
None of what you say is remotely true.
If you don’t understand that Hezbollah being disarmed is a huge win for Lebanon and the Lebanese people you don’t understand remotely the conflict or reason. You are just down the rabbit hole of hate and are the ignorant hateful person you claim to hate. Even an evil tyrant might accidentally improve the conditions and lives around him by prosecuting wars against their authoritarian oppressors for purely selfish reasons. Netanyahu is less than that for wanting a non-terrorist regime to the north of his country with ample weapons and will to kill Israeli civilians in its north. He isn't doing it out of the goodness of his heart for the Lebanese people, nor is it anything but stupid to discount the results based on the intentions. I think the anti-Israel blame, in some areas well-founded, has erased in the minds of the arguers just how terrible groups like Hezbollah and Hamas and the IRGC and the ayatollahs are for the innocents surrounding them. Israel gets more press simply because the western world has more influence on their actions. Any deal between Israel and Lebanon that creates peace and rids the Lebanese of Hezbollah control of their politics and southern territory is an unqualified victory for the Lebanese people. Anybody with a brain should be desiring that without whitewashing Israel's interests. I agree with most of what you said and I don’t think you would be able to find a post from me that suggests Netanyahu’s interests are anything other than self. What frustrates me is there are people in this thread that post as if groups like Hezbollah or Hamas are freedom fighters, which simply is not accurate. There are plenty of things to criticize Israel about that are real and proven. Iran being only in Iran should be a goal that everyone shares. If you don’t share it, you are either uninformed, filled with hatred or both. I think they really truly believe that Iranian proxies are legitimately concerned with the well-being of non-combatants. It's some kind of remix of the old pan-Arab nationalism movement or something.
Maybe, but that takes ignoring a whole bunch of what’s going on, both war time and non war time.
|
On April 15 2026 04:15 Jockmcplop wrote:Show nested quote +On April 15 2026 03:58 Billyboy wrote:On April 15 2026 03:18 Jockmcplop wrote:On April 14 2026 22:49 Billyboy wrote:On April 14 2026 22:19 Jockmcplop wrote:On April 14 2026 22:04 Billyboy wrote:
Israel and Lebanon are having their first direct talks in 40 years. Wild it’s been that long for neighbours.
They are wide apart in talks. Lebanon demands a ceasefire for legitimate talks, Netanyahu says they will continue until agreement made. Which makes it seem hard to ever get started.
Israel’s demands seem pretty reasonable from 10,000 feet, they are Hezbollah disarming and a conclusion of a historic peace agreement.
Even if agreed, Lebanon hasn’t had any success (or the UN) in disarming Hezbollah. And Israel is likely going to demand a “buffer” zone for some length of time or even indefinitely.
Long way to peace, but good they are making the first actual step. I wonder what it is about Israel that makes them absolutely refuse to stop killing people for any reason at all. What a low content hateful post. Do better. Still at it I see. Excellent work. Just calling a spade a spade. You missed the point of my post. I haven't really been following the thread so I wanted to see if the new moral depths Israel has plummeted to recently has stopped you from cheering them on like a little fangirl. Good to know nothing has changed.
Feel free to find me cheering, as usual you won’t. Just stop putting low content hateful posts and I’ll stop pointing it out. Everyone gets mad at various people for not calling their side. But there is a reason they don’t, you just end up with everyone mad because being hateful is cool and being a critical thinker is not. You are capable of being better, and you should be.
|
United Kingdom10014 Posts
On April 15 2026 04:18 Billyboy wrote:Show nested quote +On April 15 2026 04:15 Jockmcplop wrote:On April 15 2026 03:58 Billyboy wrote:On April 15 2026 03:18 Jockmcplop wrote:On April 14 2026 22:49 Billyboy wrote:On April 14 2026 22:19 Jockmcplop wrote:On April 14 2026 22:04 Billyboy wrote:
Israel and Lebanon are having their first direct talks in 40 years. Wild it’s been that long for neighbours.
They are wide apart in talks. Lebanon demands a ceasefire for legitimate talks, Netanyahu says they will continue until agreement made. Which makes it seem hard to ever get started.
Israel’s demands seem pretty reasonable from 10,000 feet, they are Hezbollah disarming and a conclusion of a historic peace agreement.
Even if agreed, Lebanon hasn’t had any success (or the UN) in disarming Hezbollah. And Israel is likely going to demand a “buffer” zone for some length of time or even indefinitely.
Long way to peace, but good they are making the first actual step. I wonder what it is about Israel that makes them absolutely refuse to stop killing people for any reason at all. What a low content hateful post. Do better. Still at it I see. Excellent work. Just calling a spade a spade. You missed the point of my post. I haven't really been following the thread so I wanted to see if the new moral depths Israel has plummeted to recently has stopped you from cheering them on like a little fangirl. Good to know nothing has changed. Feel free to find me cheering, as usual you won’t. Just stop putting low content hateful posts and I’ll stop pointing it out. Everyone gets mad at various people for not calling their side. But there is a reason they don’t, you just end up with everyone mad because being hateful is cool and being a critical thinker is not. You are capable of being better, and you should be.
If all you can see in my post is hatred, when its actually motivated by despair that Israel cannot help itself but wipe villages off the map and killing as many people as possible, then that says alot more about you than it does about me.
|
On April 15 2026 04:12 dyhb wrote:
I think they'll do a much better job than you at judging Hezbollah's oppression and intentions regarding the Lebanese people. As much as you would dismiss and ignore Hezbollah's actions after the US-Israel war on Iran, they saw the rocket and missile fire from Hezbollah into Israel first-hand. I just have to reject your premise here that it requires a strategy and their local observations are outweighed by propaganda coming from 100 miles away.
That seems contradictory to me. You would think that their local observations are what caused the people who are currently part of Hezbollah, who are mainly Lebanese people, to join Hezbollah in the first place. I would agree that these observations have more capacity to move people than propaganda from 1000 miles away (in this case Iran). But then you don't come to the same conclusion as me, so that seems weird, doesn't it? Do you have a different theory as to why these people have joined Hezbollah?
|
On April 15 2026 04:26 Jockmcplop wrote:Show nested quote +On April 15 2026 04:18 Billyboy wrote:On April 15 2026 04:15 Jockmcplop wrote:On April 15 2026 03:58 Billyboy wrote:On April 15 2026 03:18 Jockmcplop wrote:On April 14 2026 22:49 Billyboy wrote:On April 14 2026 22:19 Jockmcplop wrote:On April 14 2026 22:04 Billyboy wrote:
Israel and Lebanon are having their first direct talks in 40 years. Wild it’s been that long for neighbours.
They are wide apart in talks. Lebanon demands a ceasefire for legitimate talks, Netanyahu says they will continue until agreement made. Which makes it seem hard to ever get started.
Israel’s demands seem pretty reasonable from 10,000 feet, they are Hezbollah disarming and a conclusion of a historic peace agreement.
Even if agreed, Lebanon hasn’t had any success (or the UN) in disarming Hezbollah. And Israel is likely going to demand a “buffer” zone for some length of time or even indefinitely.
Long way to peace, but good they are making the first actual step. I wonder what it is about Israel that makes them absolutely refuse to stop killing people for any reason at all. What a low content hateful post. Do better. Still at it I see. Excellent work. Just calling a spade a spade. You missed the point of my post. I haven't really been following the thread so I wanted to see if the new moral depths Israel has plummeted to recently has stopped you from cheering them on like a little fangirl. Good to know nothing has changed. Feel free to find me cheering, as usual you won’t. Just stop putting low content hateful posts and I’ll stop pointing it out. Everyone gets mad at various people for not calling their side. But there is a reason they don’t, you just end up with everyone mad because being hateful is cool and being a critical thinker is not. You are capable of being better, and you should be. If all you can see in my post is hatred, when its actually motivated by despair that Israel cannot help itself but wipe villages off the map and killing as many people as possible, then that says alot more about you than it does about me.
They are not wiping villages off the map or killing as people as possible. Where are you getting this information from? Please link your sources.
|
On April 15 2026 04:28 Billyboy wrote:
They are not wiping villages off the map or killing as people as possible. Where are you getting this information from? Please link your sources.
The Guardian
‘Everything is gone’: Israel destroys entire villages in Lebanon
"The Guardian reviewed three videos posted by the Israeli military and on social media, which showed Israel carrying out mass detonations in the villages of Taybeh, Naqoura and Deir Seryan along the Israel-Lebanon border. Lebanese media has reported more mass detonations in other border villages, but satellite imagery was not readily available to verify these claims."
|
United Kingdom10014 Posts
On April 15 2026 04:28 Billyboy wrote:Show nested quote +On April 15 2026 04:26 Jockmcplop wrote:On April 15 2026 04:18 Billyboy wrote:On April 15 2026 04:15 Jockmcplop wrote:On April 15 2026 03:58 Billyboy wrote:On April 15 2026 03:18 Jockmcplop wrote:On April 14 2026 22:49 Billyboy wrote:On April 14 2026 22:19 Jockmcplop wrote:On April 14 2026 22:04 Billyboy wrote:
Israel and Lebanon are having their first direct talks in 40 years. Wild it’s been that long for neighbours.
They are wide apart in talks. Lebanon demands a ceasefire for legitimate talks, Netanyahu says they will continue until agreement made. Which makes it seem hard to ever get started.
Israel’s demands seem pretty reasonable from 10,000 feet, they are Hezbollah disarming and a conclusion of a historic peace agreement.
Even if agreed, Lebanon hasn’t had any success (or the UN) in disarming Hezbollah. And Israel is likely going to demand a “buffer” zone for some length of time or even indefinitely.
Long way to peace, but good they are making the first actual step. I wonder what it is about Israel that makes them absolutely refuse to stop killing people for any reason at all. What a low content hateful post. Do better. Still at it I see. Excellent work. Just calling a spade a spade. You missed the point of my post. I haven't really been following the thread so I wanted to see if the new moral depths Israel has plummeted to recently has stopped you from cheering them on like a little fangirl. Good to know nothing has changed. Feel free to find me cheering, as usual you won’t. Just stop putting low content hateful posts and I’ll stop pointing it out. Everyone gets mad at various people for not calling their side. But there is a reason they don’t, you just end up with everyone mad because being hateful is cool and being a critical thinker is not. You are capable of being better, and you should be. If all you can see in my post is hatred, when its actually motivated by despair that Israel cannot help itself but wipe villages off the map and killing as many people as possible, then that says alot more about you than it does about me. They are not wiping villages off the map or killing as people as possible. Where are you getting this information from? Please link your sources.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c0j6d538l6qo
Over 1.2 million people have been displaced, or one in five of the population, most of them from Shia Muslim communities.
Villages near the border have been destroyed, as invading Israeli troops aim to create what the Israeli authorities call a security buffer zone, to destroy Hezbollah's infrastructure and push its fighters away.
This has raised concerns that some areas may be occupied even after the end of the war, and that many residents may never be able to return.
Israeli officials had indicated their intention to continue with their campaign in Lebanon even if there was a deal with Iran. But in recent days, military sources quoted by Israeli media suggested the army had no intention to advance further in their invasion, and acknowledged that they would not be able to disarm Hezbollah by force.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cvg07j6yeweo
The Israeli defence minister also said all houses in villages near the border in Lebanon will be destroyed "according to the model of Rafah and Beit Hanoun in Gaza".
But its nice to know you here denying it for them.
Almost as if you are motivated to see those villages destroyed the same way Israel are.
|
Nvm, I see multiple posts have beaten me to it.
|
Gaza, Lebanon... Israeli Jews are a growing population.They just need some Lebensraum.
|
Northern Ireland27464 Posts
On April 15 2026 04:12 dyhb wrote:Show nested quote +On April 15 2026 02:51 Nebuchad wrote:On April 15 2026 02:16 dyhb wrote:On April 14 2026 23:22 Billyboy wrote:
None of what you say is remotely true.
If you don’t understand that Hezbollah being disarmed is a huge win for Lebanon and the Lebanese people you don’t understand remotely the conflict or reason. You are just down the rabbit hole of hate and are the ignorant hateful person you claim to hate. Even an evil tyrant might accidentally improve the conditions and lives around him by prosecuting wars against their authoritarian oppressors for purely selfish reasons. Netanyahu is less than that for wanting a non-terrorist regime to the north of his country with ample weapons and will to kill Israeli civilians in its north. He isn't doing it out of the goodness of his heart for the Lebanese people, nor is it anything but stupid to discount the results based on the intentions. I think the anti-Israel blame, in some areas well-founded, has erased in the minds of the arguers just how terrible groups like Hezbollah and Hamas and the IRGC and the ayatollahs are for the innocents surrounding them. Israel gets more press simply because the western world has more influence on their actions. Any deal between Israel and Lebanon that creates peace and rids the Lebanese of Hezbollah control of their politics and southern territory is an unqualified victory for the Lebanese people. Anybody with a brain should be desiring that without whitewashing Israel's interests. What's your strategy to make sure that all of the Lebanese people who lose relatives and friends in this campaign to get rid of Hezbollah don't start feeling hatred toward Israel, hatred that will then be fueled by continued mistreatment of Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza and will motivate them to form another terrible group that is bad for the innocents surrounding them and that you will have to kill a bunch of Lebanese people to get rid of in 30 years? I think they'll do a much better job than you at judging Hezbollah's oppression and intentions regarding the Lebanese people. As much as you would dismiss and ignore Hezbollah's actions after the US-Israel war on Iran, they saw the rocket and missile fire from Hezbollah into Israel first-hand. I just have to reject your premise here that it requires a strategy and their local observations are outweighed by propaganda coming from 100 miles away. Show nested quote +On April 15 2026 03:02 Billyboy wrote:On April 15 2026 02:16 dyhb wrote:On April 14 2026 23:22 Billyboy wrote:
None of what you say is remotely true.
If you don’t understand that Hezbollah being disarmed is a huge win for Lebanon and the Lebanese people you don’t understand remotely the conflict or reason. You are just down the rabbit hole of hate and are the ignorant hateful person you claim to hate. Even an evil tyrant might accidentally improve the conditions and lives around him by prosecuting wars against their authoritarian oppressors for purely selfish reasons. Netanyahu is less than that for wanting a non-terrorist regime to the north of his country with ample weapons and will to kill Israeli civilians in its north. He isn't doing it out of the goodness of his heart for the Lebanese people, nor is it anything but stupid to discount the results based on the intentions. I think the anti-Israel blame, in some areas well-founded, has erased in the minds of the arguers just how terrible groups like Hezbollah and Hamas and the IRGC and the ayatollahs are for the innocents surrounding them. Israel gets more press simply because the western world has more influence on their actions. Any deal between Israel and Lebanon that creates peace and rids the Lebanese of Hezbollah control of their politics and southern territory is an unqualified victory for the Lebanese people. Anybody with a brain should be desiring that without whitewashing Israel's interests. I agree with most of what you said and I don’t think you would be able to find a post from me that suggests Netanyahu’s interests are anything other than self. What frustrates me is there are people in this thread that post as if groups like Hezbollah or Hamas are freedom fighters, which simply is not accurate. There are plenty of things to criticize Israel about that are real and proven. Iran being only in Iran should be a goal that everyone shares. If you don’t share it, you are either uninformed, filled with hatred or both. I think they really truly believe that Iranian proxies are legitimately concerned with the well-being of non-combatants. It's some kind of remix of the old pan-Arab nationalism movement or something.
I don’t think thread denizens view Hezbollah, Hamas as honourable freedom fighters at all.
The quibble is mostly if Israel should kill mostly civilians to eradicate those organisations in lieu of other potential avenues.
Israel at this stage is just as hardline as an Iran, increasingly virulently nationalistic emboldened by the US and just bombs folks as they want.
Polling, increasingly reflects this as well. The idea that a Netanyahu was doing certain things to deflect from unpopularity, and it didn’t reflect general Israeli sentiment and there was sizeable opposition used to have some legs, increasingly it appears it doesn’t.
|
On April 15 2026 04:43 Jockmcplop wrote:Show nested quote +On April 15 2026 04:28 Billyboy wrote:On April 15 2026 04:26 Jockmcplop wrote:On April 15 2026 04:18 Billyboy wrote:On April 15 2026 04:15 Jockmcplop wrote:On April 15 2026 03:58 Billyboy wrote:On April 15 2026 03:18 Jockmcplop wrote:On April 14 2026 22:49 Billyboy wrote:On April 14 2026 22:19 Jockmcplop wrote:On April 14 2026 22:04 Billyboy wrote:
Israel and Lebanon are having their first direct talks in 40 years. Wild it’s been that long for neighbours.
They are wide apart in talks. Lebanon demands a ceasefire for legitimate talks, Netanyahu says they will continue until agreement made. Which makes it seem hard to ever get started.
Israel’s demands seem pretty reasonable from 10,000 feet, they are Hezbollah disarming and a conclusion of a historic peace agreement.
Even if agreed, Lebanon hasn’t had any success (or the UN) in disarming Hezbollah. And Israel is likely going to demand a “buffer” zone for some length of time or even indefinitely.
Long way to peace, but good they are making the first actual step. I wonder what it is about Israel that makes them absolutely refuse to stop killing people for any reason at all. What a low content hateful post. Do better. Still at it I see. Excellent work. Just calling a spade a spade. You missed the point of my post. I haven't really been following the thread so I wanted to see if the new moral depths Israel has plummeted to recently has stopped you from cheering them on like a little fangirl. Good to know nothing has changed. Feel free to find me cheering, as usual you won’t. Just stop putting low content hateful posts and I’ll stop pointing it out. Everyone gets mad at various people for not calling their side. But there is a reason they don’t, you just end up with everyone mad because being hateful is cool and being a critical thinker is not. You are capable of being better, and you should be. If all you can see in my post is hatred, when its actually motivated by despair that Israel cannot help itself but wipe villages off the map and killing as many people as possible, then that says alot more about you than it does about me. They are not wiping villages off the map or killing as people as possible. Where are you getting this information from? Please link your sources. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c0j6d538l6qoShow nested quote +Over 1.2 million people have been displaced, or one in five of the population, most of them from Shia Muslim communities.
Villages near the border have been destroyed, as invading Israeli troops aim to create what the Israeli authorities call a security buffer zone, to destroy Hezbollah's infrastructure and push its fighters away.
This has raised concerns that some areas may be occupied even after the end of the war, and that many residents may never be able to return.
Israeli officials had indicated their intention to continue with their campaign in Lebanon even if there was a deal with Iran. But in recent days, military sources quoted by Israeli media suggested the army had no intention to advance further in their invasion, and acknowledged that they would not be able to disarm Hezbollah by force. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cvg07j6yeweoShow nested quote +
The Israeli defence minister also said all houses in villages near the border in Lebanon will be destroyed "according to the model of Rafah and Beit Hanoun in Gaza".
But its nice to know you here denying it for them. Almost as if you are motivated to see those villages destroyed the same way Israel are.
I didn’t know about the villages. I was wrong. Hence the reason why small effort posts, with sources are better than low effort posts with none.
I notice no sources on the killing as many people as possible. Can I see those, and I’ll happily admit I was wrong.
|
On April 15 2026 05:43 WombaT wrote:Show nested quote +On April 15 2026 04:12 dyhb wrote:On April 15 2026 02:51 Nebuchad wrote:On April 15 2026 02:16 dyhb wrote:On April 14 2026 23:22 Billyboy wrote:
None of what you say is remotely true.
If you don’t understand that Hezbollah being disarmed is a huge win for Lebanon and the Lebanese people you don’t understand remotely the conflict or reason. You are just down the rabbit hole of hate and are the ignorant hateful person you claim to hate. Even an evil tyrant might accidentally improve the conditions and lives around him by prosecuting wars against their authoritarian oppressors for purely selfish reasons. Netanyahu is less than that for wanting a non-terrorist regime to the north of his country with ample weapons and will to kill Israeli civilians in its north. He isn't doing it out of the goodness of his heart for the Lebanese people, nor is it anything but stupid to discount the results based on the intentions. I think the anti-Israel blame, in some areas well-founded, has erased in the minds of the arguers just how terrible groups like Hezbollah and Hamas and the IRGC and the ayatollahs are for the innocents surrounding them. Israel gets more press simply because the western world has more influence on their actions. Any deal between Israel and Lebanon that creates peace and rids the Lebanese of Hezbollah control of their politics and southern territory is an unqualified victory for the Lebanese people. Anybody with a brain should be desiring that without whitewashing Israel's interests. What's your strategy to make sure that all of the Lebanese people who lose relatives and friends in this campaign to get rid of Hezbollah don't start feeling hatred toward Israel, hatred that will then be fueled by continued mistreatment of Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza and will motivate them to form another terrible group that is bad for the innocents surrounding them and that you will have to kill a bunch of Lebanese people to get rid of in 30 years? I think they'll do a much better job than you at judging Hezbollah's oppression and intentions regarding the Lebanese people. As much as you would dismiss and ignore Hezbollah's actions after the US-Israel war on Iran, they saw the rocket and missile fire from Hezbollah into Israel first-hand. I just have to reject your premise here that it requires a strategy and their local observations are outweighed by propaganda coming from 100 miles away. On April 15 2026 03:02 Billyboy wrote:On April 15 2026 02:16 dyhb wrote:On April 14 2026 23:22 Billyboy wrote:
None of what you say is remotely true.
If you don’t understand that Hezbollah being disarmed is a huge win for Lebanon and the Lebanese people you don’t understand remotely the conflict or reason. You are just down the rabbit hole of hate and are the ignorant hateful person you claim to hate. Even an evil tyrant might accidentally improve the conditions and lives around him by prosecuting wars against their authoritarian oppressors for purely selfish reasons. Netanyahu is less than that for wanting a non-terrorist regime to the north of his country with ample weapons and will to kill Israeli civilians in its north. He isn't doing it out of the goodness of his heart for the Lebanese people, nor is it anything but stupid to discount the results based on the intentions. I think the anti-Israel blame, in some areas well-founded, has erased in the minds of the arguers just how terrible groups like Hezbollah and Hamas and the IRGC and the ayatollahs are for the innocents surrounding them. Israel gets more press simply because the western world has more influence on their actions. Any deal between Israel and Lebanon that creates peace and rids the Lebanese of Hezbollah control of their politics and southern territory is an unqualified victory for the Lebanese people. Anybody with a brain should be desiring that without whitewashing Israel's interests. I agree with most of what you said and I don’t think you would be able to find a post from me that suggests Netanyahu’s interests are anything other than self. What frustrates me is there are people in this thread that post as if groups like Hezbollah or Hamas are freedom fighters, which simply is not accurate. There are plenty of things to criticize Israel about that are real and proven. Iran being only in Iran should be a goal that everyone shares. If you don’t share it, you are either uninformed, filled with hatred or both. I think they really truly believe that Iranian proxies are legitimately concerned with the well-being of non-combatants. It's some kind of remix of the old pan-Arab nationalism movement or something. I don’t think thread denizens view Hezbollah, Hamas as honourable freedom fighters at all. The quibble is mostly if Israel should kill mostly civilians to eradicate those organisations in lieu of other potential avenues. Israel at this stage is just as hardline as an Iran, increasingly virulently nationalistic emboldened by the US and just bombs folks as they want. Polling, increasingly reflects this as well. The idea that a Netanyahu was doing certain things to deflect from unpopularity, and it didn’t reflect general Israeli sentiment and there was sizeable opposition used to have some legs, increasingly it appears it doesn’t.
They are not nearly as hard line. For example, in Israel no protesters have been killed. In Iran 10s of thousands have.
|
On April 15 2026 05:43 WombaT wrote:Show nested quote +On April 15 2026 04:12 dyhb wrote:On April 15 2026 02:51 Nebuchad wrote:On April 15 2026 02:16 dyhb wrote:On April 14 2026 23:22 Billyboy wrote:
None of what you say is remotely true.
If you don’t understand that Hezbollah being disarmed is a huge win for Lebanon and the Lebanese people you don’t understand remotely the conflict or reason. You are just down the rabbit hole of hate and are the ignorant hateful person you claim to hate. Even an evil tyrant might accidentally improve the conditions and lives around him by prosecuting wars against their authoritarian oppressors for purely selfish reasons. Netanyahu is less than that for wanting a non-terrorist regime to the north of his country with ample weapons and will to kill Israeli civilians in its north. He isn't doing it out of the goodness of his heart for the Lebanese people, nor is it anything but stupid to discount the results based on the intentions. I think the anti-Israel blame, in some areas well-founded, has erased in the minds of the arguers just how terrible groups like Hezbollah and Hamas and the IRGC and the ayatollahs are for the innocents surrounding them. Israel gets more press simply because the western world has more influence on their actions. Any deal between Israel and Lebanon that creates peace and rids the Lebanese of Hezbollah control of their politics and southern territory is an unqualified victory for the Lebanese people. Anybody with a brain should be desiring that without whitewashing Israel's interests. What's your strategy to make sure that all of the Lebanese people who lose relatives and friends in this campaign to get rid of Hezbollah don't start feeling hatred toward Israel, hatred that will then be fueled by continued mistreatment of Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza and will motivate them to form another terrible group that is bad for the innocents surrounding them and that you will have to kill a bunch of Lebanese people to get rid of in 30 years? I think they'll do a much better job than you at judging Hezbollah's oppression and intentions regarding the Lebanese people. As much as you would dismiss and ignore Hezbollah's actions after the US-Israel war on Iran, they saw the rocket and missile fire from Hezbollah into Israel first-hand. I just have to reject your premise here that it requires a strategy and their local observations are outweighed by propaganda coming from 100 miles away. On April 15 2026 03:02 Billyboy wrote:On April 15 2026 02:16 dyhb wrote:On April 14 2026 23:22 Billyboy wrote:
None of what you say is remotely true.
If you don’t understand that Hezbollah being disarmed is a huge win for Lebanon and the Lebanese people you don’t understand remotely the conflict or reason. You are just down the rabbit hole of hate and are the ignorant hateful person you claim to hate. Even an evil tyrant might accidentally improve the conditions and lives around him by prosecuting wars against their authoritarian oppressors for purely selfish reasons. Netanyahu is less than that for wanting a non-terrorist regime to the north of his country with ample weapons and will to kill Israeli civilians in its north. He isn't doing it out of the goodness of his heart for the Lebanese people, nor is it anything but stupid to discount the results based on the intentions. I think the anti-Israel blame, in some areas well-founded, has erased in the minds of the arguers just how terrible groups like Hezbollah and Hamas and the IRGC and the ayatollahs are for the innocents surrounding them. Israel gets more press simply because the western world has more influence on their actions. Any deal between Israel and Lebanon that creates peace and rids the Lebanese of Hezbollah control of their politics and southern territory is an unqualified victory for the Lebanese people. Anybody with a brain should be desiring that without whitewashing Israel's interests. I agree with most of what you said and I don’t think you would be able to find a post from me that suggests Netanyahu’s interests are anything other than self. What frustrates me is there are people in this thread that post as if groups like Hezbollah or Hamas are freedom fighters, which simply is not accurate. There are plenty of things to criticize Israel about that are real and proven. Iran being only in Iran should be a goal that everyone shares. If you don’t share it, you are either uninformed, filled with hatred or both. I think they really truly believe that Iranian proxies are legitimately concerned with the well-being of non-combatants. It's some kind of remix of the old pan-Arab nationalism movement or something. I don’t think thread denizens view Hezbollah, Hamas as honourable freedom fighters at all. The quibble is mostly if Israel should kill mostly civilians to eradicate those organisations in lieu of other potential avenues. Israel at this stage is just as hardline as an Iran, increasingly virulently nationalistic emboldened by the US and just bombs folks as they want. Polling, increasingly reflects this as well. The idea that a Netanyahu was doing certain things to deflect from unpopularity, and it didn’t reflect general Israeli sentiment and there was sizeable opposition used to have some legs, increasingly it appears it doesn’t.
My christian friend born at tyr views hezbollah as such. Until 2023, the fpm was associated to the 8 march movement and distanced from hezbollah only after 2024.
Lebanon is more complex than supremacists like billyboy who claim criticism toward ethnic cleansing is hateful portrays it.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
