• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 03:19
CET 09:19
KST 17:19
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Team Liquid Map Contest #2312[ASL22] Finals Preview: Sweet Victory!12[ASL22] Ro4 Preview: Mirror Mirror6[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: Within Reach5[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: In A Tizzy11
Community News
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over5Dark completes military service, returns to SC217[BSL23] RO16 Group Stage20Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?2Weekly Cups (Oct 26 - Nov 1): MaxPax, herO, Solar win0
StarCraft 2
General
Team Liquid Map Contest #23 StarCraft open world shooter announced at BlizzCon Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over No more SC2 streamers on team liquid? Dark completes military service, returns to SC2
Tourneys
soO & FanTaSy return! SC2 Kevin Scrim 4v4 (Nov 16) Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament RSL goes to London! 2026 Offline Finals Nov 21-22 Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) Dark returns! GSL CK #7 4v4 Team Battle (Nov 19)
Strategy
[H] ZvP Mid-Late Game: Stalkers Collossi HT
Custom Maps
[G] How to playtest arcade maps Starcraft 2 Advance [D] the control group Simple Questions/Answers
External Content
Mutation # 552 Secret Storm The PondCast: SC2 News & Results Mutation # 551 Robotic Revival Mutation # 550 Graveyard Shift
Brood War
General
Light introduces ShieldBattery on his YouTube List of top players active on ShieldBattery BW General Discussion BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/ NaDa's Body
Tourneys
SC1 Kevin Scrim hosted by SOOP (Nov 18-19) KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4 [Megathread] Daily Proleagues [BSL23] Ro16 Group D - Sunday 21:00 CET
Strategy
Pluto's TvP 5Marine 2Medic Push Simple Questions, Simple Answers Infested Terran strategies in 2026 Nuke strategy worked in K-League 2026-11-09
Other Games
General Games
Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread The PlayStation 5 Warcraft III: The Frozen Throne Nintendo Switch Thread Free Space RTS Game, optimised f. Phone/Tablet etc
Dota 2
League of Legends
[TL LoL EUW IHs] Teemo shall perish
Heroes of the Storm
Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Artificial Intelligence Thread The Big Programming Thread Trading/Investing Thread
Fan Clubs
Fan Club Resource Thread Reynor Fan Club The Flash Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
Football (Soccer) Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Recent Gifted Posts
Blogs
The time I organised my…
AssyrianKing
Why I built Repalyzer (1.1.…
BlueStar
Innovate or Game Over?
TrAiDoS
ShieldBattery on Mac
Kraekkling
Can Bots Beat Pros?? Starcr…
namkraft
James Bond movies ranking - pa…
Topin
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 23755 users

European Politico-economics QA Mega-thread - Page 292

Forum Index > General Forum
Post a Reply
Prev 1 290 291 292 293 294 1432 Next
Although this thread does not function under the same strict guidelines as the USPMT, it is still a general practice on TL to provide a source with an explanation on why it is relevant and what purpose it adds to the discussion. Failure to do so will result in a mod action.
dismiss
Profile Blog Joined March 2009
United Kingdom3341 Posts
September 16 2015 17:40 GMT
#5821
On September 17 2015 02:31 Nyxisto wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 17 2015 02:17 WhiteDog wrote:
In a place where there are already 25 million people unemployed (europe) saying that immigration will instantly have a positive economical impact for everybody is just dumb and hypocritical. They will most likely put pressure on lower wage - which is exactly what has been happening in europe in the schenghen area through the introduction of some of eastern countries (and what has happened historically in the US through immigration).


Many countries with absolutely atrocious economic situations in Europe have net emigration for years, it hasn't helped the labour market a bit. Is there any data at all that supports the claim that immigration drives wages down significantly? You're a big proponent of demand oriented policies and immigrants buy stuff and create jobs, too.

https://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/110th-congress-2007-2008/reports/12-6-immigration.pdf

Here's a meta-study from the US that details a negative impact on the economy by illegal immigrants. This one is probably more pertinent than the other ones stating that people who managed to get through a highly competitive selection process have a net positive impact on an economy.
Failure to improve posting standards will result in a lengthy ban. I <crms_> !dumb <GeoffAnderson> crmsdota <crms_> damnit
WhiteDog
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
France8650 Posts
September 16 2015 17:43 GMT
#5822
On September 17 2015 02:31 Nyxisto wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 17 2015 02:17 WhiteDog wrote:
In a place where there are already 25 million people unemployed (europe) saying that immigration will instantly have a positive economical impact for everybody is just dumb and hypocritical. They will most likely put pressure on lower wage - which is exactly what has been happening in europe in the schenghen area through the introduction of some of eastern countries (and what has happened historically in the US through immigration).


Many countries with absolutely atrocious economic situations in Europe have net emigration for years, it hasn't helped the labour market a bit. Is there any data at all that supports the claim that immigration drives wages down significantly? You're a big proponent of demand oriented policies and immigrants buy stuff and create jobs, too.

Yeah people are not as mobile as the market needs them to be, this reinforce the fact that immigration in those countries is negative.
Migrants buy stuff with which money exactly ? Most of the money the migrants get will be given to them by cutting in other expense (for the government, I believe Schauble already said he would find 500 m of budgetary cuts ?) so the global demand does not change.
As for the fact that immigration bring down wage, I don't have datas for you - there are tons of study on the case but no clear answers (basically the idea is that immigration has positive impact on wage above a certain degree of qualification and for specific people - native more than migrants - but negative impact on lower wage, but most studies are based on models and thus the results vastly change from one model to another). But it's an old fact that anybody knows ; competition bring price down.
"every time WhiteDog overuses the word "seriously" in a comment I can make an observation on his fragile emotional state." MoltkeWarding
Plansix
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
United States60190 Posts
September 16 2015 17:47 GMT
#5823
On September 17 2015 02:40 dismiss wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 17 2015 02:31 Nyxisto wrote:
On September 17 2015 02:17 WhiteDog wrote:
In a place where there are already 25 million people unemployed (europe) saying that immigration will instantly have a positive economical impact for everybody is just dumb and hypocritical. They will most likely put pressure on lower wage - which is exactly what has been happening in europe in the schenghen area through the introduction of some of eastern countries (and what has happened historically in the US through immigration).


Many countries with absolutely atrocious economic situations in Europe have net emigration for years, it hasn't helped the labour market a bit. Is there any data at all that supports the claim that immigration drives wages down significantly? You're a big proponent of demand oriented policies and immigrants buy stuff and create jobs, too.

https://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/110th-congress-2007-2008/reports/12-6-immigration.pdf

Here's a meta-study from the US that details a negative impact on the economy by illegal immigrants. This one is probably more pertinent than the other ones stating that people who managed to get through a highly competitive selection process have a net positive impact on an economy.

That report doesn't' address wages being driven down or the economy. Only the drain on local government due to the US's total inability to have a realistic immigration police. Immigration isn't bad on its own, only that being an illegal immigrant is bad for the immigrant and the local government.
I have the Honor to be your Obedient Servant, P.6
TL+ Member
Nyxisto
Profile Joined August 2010
Germany6287 Posts
Last Edited: 2015-09-16 17:51:26
September 16 2015 17:50 GMT
#5824
On September 17 2015 02:43 WhiteDog wrote:
As for the fact that immigration bring down wage, I don't have datas for you - there are tons of study on the case but no clear answers (basically the idea is that immigration has positive impact on wage above a certain degree of qualification and for specific people - native more than migrants - but negative impact on lower wage, but most studies are based on models and thus the results vastly change from one model to another). But it's an old fact that anybody knows ; competition bring price down.

Is it really competition though? We have over a hundred thousand apprenticeship positions open every year(I figure other European countries have similar problems) and there's a notorious lack of people in less paying service sector jobs like nurses, elderly care, maintenance and so on. These jobs simply never get filled and it's definitely not like people are fighting over them and already now many people working in these areas are working class immigrants.
Banaora
Profile Joined May 2013
Germany234 Posts
September 16 2015 18:12 GMT
#5825
On September 17 2015 02:23 Toadesstern wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 17 2015 02:17 WhiteDog wrote:
On September 17 2015 01:56 Sermokala wrote:
Economically all of them are desirable. Look at America it only takes a generation or so for indoctrination to set in with the kids and then suddenly they're good working citizens. Poor people are going to work hard to feed their kids and take shitty jobs to support them. You can't look at them like they're people you have to look at them like cogs in your economic machine.

The point is that the men are trying to earn money to get somewhere were they can bring the rest of their family over. USAs illegals are treated like shit and we still get them paying way more in taxes then they take out in services. That's having your cake and eating it too.

The thing is that people, when they take that "economical" argument, put aside the fact that the society is divided by different interests and groups. Immigration profit certain people, that's it. In a place where there are already 25 million people unemployed (europe) saying that immigration will instantly have a positive economical impact for everybody is just dumb and hypocritical. They will most likely put pressure on lower wage - which is exactly what has been happening in europe in the schenghen area through the introduction of some of eastern countries (and what has happened historically in the US through immigration).

The left in europe right now is constantly using that economical argument to support their desire to welcome refugees (E. Balibar even wrote a piece saying it will force europe into changing their economical policies ! who seriously believe that ?) shows very well how the current left is liberal to its core.

well from a german point of view, as the country that recently even "surpassed" Japan when it comes to having the lowest birthrate, you'd be pretty hard pressed to find negative things about it.

We just flat out won't have the people to pay for pensions for people who can't work anymore come 20 or 30 more years right now.

I personally think there is something wrong in our country that we as Germans have such a low birth rate especially compared to France and I would rather prefer we changed our policy in this regard than using the low birth rate as an "excuse" why we need immigration.

The current immigration of 1 Mio seekers of refugee status will in my opinion change our country in the long term and nobody was really asked if he wants that. Let's assume 50% get accepted, then they are allowed to take their family to Germany so I'm just guessing now we would have maybe 1 Mio new immigrants that can get residence status after some years or if they have to go later usually get tolerated to stay as most will not get deported if they are successfully integrated into our society. And this is just for 2015 and will probably continue.

Yes we are solving our ageing population problem this way but no one can know at what costs. Will the integration be a success?

There are resources bound to that that could have gone into other projects maybe to show solidarity with poor families in Germany or projects in southern Europe to create jobs.

Sure you can argue you are playing out refugees against other issues on the other side money can only be spent once and maybe it's a better idea not to advertise to everybody to come to Germany with their cultures to seek safety here.
Toadesstern
Profile Blog Joined October 2008
Germany16350 Posts
Last Edited: 2015-09-16 18:43:03
September 16 2015 18:21 GMT
#5826
On September 17 2015 03:12 Banaora wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 17 2015 02:23 Toadesstern wrote:
On September 17 2015 02:17 WhiteDog wrote:
On September 17 2015 01:56 Sermokala wrote:
Economically all of them are desirable. Look at America it only takes a generation or so for indoctrination to set in with the kids and then suddenly they're good working citizens. Poor people are going to work hard to feed their kids and take shitty jobs to support them. You can't look at them like they're people you have to look at them like cogs in your economic machine.

The point is that the men are trying to earn money to get somewhere were they can bring the rest of their family over. USAs illegals are treated like shit and we still get them paying way more in taxes then they take out in services. That's having your cake and eating it too.

The thing is that people, when they take that "economical" argument, put aside the fact that the society is divided by different interests and groups. Immigration profit certain people, that's it. In a place where there are already 25 million people unemployed (europe) saying that immigration will instantly have a positive economical impact for everybody is just dumb and hypocritical. They will most likely put pressure on lower wage - which is exactly what has been happening in europe in the schenghen area through the introduction of some of eastern countries (and what has happened historically in the US through immigration).

The left in europe right now is constantly using that economical argument to support their desire to welcome refugees (E. Balibar even wrote a piece saying it will force europe into changing their economical policies ! who seriously believe that ?) shows very well how the current left is liberal to its core.

well from a german point of view, as the country that recently even "surpassed" Japan when it comes to having the lowest birthrate, you'd be pretty hard pressed to find negative things about it.

We just flat out won't have the people to pay for pensions for people who can't work anymore come 20 or 30 more years right now.

I personally think there is something wrong in our country that we as Germans have such a low birth rate especially compared to France and I would rather prefer we changed our policy in this regard than using the low birth rate as an "excuse" why we need immigration.

The current immigration of 1 Mio seekers of refugee status will in my opinion change our country in the long term and nobody was really asked if he wants that. Let's assume 50% get accepted, then they are allowed to take their family to Germany so I'm just guessing now we would have maybe 1 Mio new immigrants that can get residence status after some years or if they have to go later usually get tolerated to stay as most will not get deported if they are successfully integrated into our society. And this is just for 2015 and will probably continue.

Yes we are solving our ageing population problem this way but no one can know at what costs. Will the integration be a success?

There are resources bound to that that could have gone into other projects maybe to show solidarity with poor families in Germany or projects in southern Europe to create jobs.

Sure you can argue you are playing out refugees against other issues on the other side money can only be spent once and maybe it's a better idea not to advertise to everybody to come to Germany with their cultures to seek safety here.

Do you want to force people to have babies? Because I'm pretty sure there are efforts to make germans want more babies... it's just that they don't seem to work. If you want it or not, we need more young people if we want to keep our pension system alive

In the end it's a problem people brought upon themselves, so I really couldn't care less about people whining about that sort of thing.

People don't want to have babies, people don't want to have immigrants, people don't want to have cuts in pensions... Maybe we should have invested more money into cloning research rather than anything else.
+ Show Spoiler +
I might not be 100% serious with my last paragraph
<Elem> >toad in charge of judging lewdness <Elem> how bad can it be <Elem> also wew, that is actually p lewd.
dismiss
Profile Blog Joined March 2009
United Kingdom3341 Posts
September 16 2015 18:32 GMT
#5827
On September 17 2015 02:47 Plansix wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 17 2015 02:40 dismiss wrote:
On September 17 2015 02:31 Nyxisto wrote:
On September 17 2015 02:17 WhiteDog wrote:
In a place where there are already 25 million people unemployed (europe) saying that immigration will instantly have a positive economical impact for everybody is just dumb and hypocritical. They will most likely put pressure on lower wage - which is exactly what has been happening in europe in the schenghen area through the introduction of some of eastern countries (and what has happened historically in the US through immigration).


Many countries with absolutely atrocious economic situations in Europe have net emigration for years, it hasn't helped the labour market a bit. Is there any data at all that supports the claim that immigration drives wages down significantly? You're a big proponent of demand oriented policies and immigrants buy stuff and create jobs, too.

https://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/110th-congress-2007-2008/reports/12-6-immigration.pdf

Here's a meta-study from the US that details a negative impact on the economy by illegal immigrants. This one is probably more pertinent than the other ones stating that people who managed to get through a highly competitive selection process have a net positive impact on an economy.

That report doesn't' address wages being driven down or the economy. Only the drain on local government due to the US's total inability to have a realistic immigration police. Immigration isn't bad on its own, only that being an illegal immigrant is bad for the immigrant and the local government.

There's a direct correlation between how much income tax you pay and your economic impact. z_z
Failure to improve posting standards will result in a lengthy ban. I <crms_> !dumb <GeoffAnderson> crmsdota <crms_> damnit
Plansix
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
United States60190 Posts
Last Edited: 2015-09-16 18:45:44
September 16 2015 18:36 GMT
#5828
On September 17 2015 03:32 dismiss wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 17 2015 02:47 Plansix wrote:
On September 17 2015 02:40 dismiss wrote:
On September 17 2015 02:31 Nyxisto wrote:
On September 17 2015 02:17 WhiteDog wrote:
In a place where there are already 25 million people unemployed (europe) saying that immigration will instantly have a positive economical impact for everybody is just dumb and hypocritical. They will most likely put pressure on lower wage - which is exactly what has been happening in europe in the schenghen area through the introduction of some of eastern countries (and what has happened historically in the US through immigration).


Many countries with absolutely atrocious economic situations in Europe have net emigration for years, it hasn't helped the labour market a bit. Is there any data at all that supports the claim that immigration drives wages down significantly? You're a big proponent of demand oriented policies and immigrants buy stuff and create jobs, too.

https://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/110th-congress-2007-2008/reports/12-6-immigration.pdf

Here's a meta-study from the US that details a negative impact on the economy by illegal immigrants. This one is probably more pertinent than the other ones stating that people who managed to get through a highly competitive selection process have a net positive impact on an economy.

That report doesn't' address wages being driven down or the economy. Only the drain on local government due to the US's total inability to have a realistic immigration police. Immigration isn't bad on its own, only that being an illegal immigrant is bad for the immigrant and the local government.

There's a direct correlation between how much income tax you pay and your economic impact. z_z

Yes, but that all related to the immigrants being illegal, not always paying taxes and not being paid as much because they were illegal. And that it was bad for local governments because of those issues. It doesn’t address legal immigration, which is what the poster above was asking about.
I have the Honor to be your Obedient Servant, P.6
TL+ Member
dismiss
Profile Blog Joined March 2009
United Kingdom3341 Posts
Last Edited: 2015-09-16 18:45:56
September 16 2015 18:45 GMT
#5829
On September 17 2015 03:36 Plansix wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 17 2015 03:32 dismiss wrote:
On September 17 2015 02:47 Plansix wrote:
On September 17 2015 02:40 dismiss wrote:
On September 17 2015 02:31 Nyxisto wrote:
On September 17 2015 02:17 WhiteDog wrote:
In a place where there are already 25 million people unemployed (europe) saying that immigration will instantly have a positive economical impact for everybody is just dumb and hypocritical. They will most likely put pressure on lower wage - which is exactly what has been happening in europe in the schenghen area through the introduction of some of eastern countries (and what has happened historically in the US through immigration).


Many countries with absolutely atrocious economic situations in Europe have net emigration for years, it hasn't helped the labour market a bit. Is there any data at all that supports the claim that immigration drives wages down significantly? You're a big proponent of demand oriented policies and immigrants buy stuff and create jobs, too.

https://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/110th-congress-2007-2008/reports/12-6-immigration.pdf

Here's a meta-study from the US that details a negative impact on the economy by illegal immigrants. This one is probably more pertinent than the other ones stating that people who managed to get through a highly competitive selection process have a net positive impact on an economy.

That report doesn't' address wages being driven down or the economy. Only the drain on local government due to the US's total inability to have a realistic immigration police. Immigration isn't bad on its own, only that being an illegal immigrant is bad for the immigrant and the local government.

There's a direct correlation between how much income tax you pay and your economic impact. z_z

Yes, but that all related to the immigrants being illegal, not always paying taxes and not being paid as much because they were illegal. It doesn’t address legal immigration, which is what the poster above was asking about.

Oh sorry, maybe I didn't express my point clearly. It's more about comparing the different sectors, so to speak, of all migrants. Asylum seekers and illegals will fall into a much more similar category than those allowed in by the strict Canadian/British/German migration laws. There are many factors that disadvantage these groups on the labour market when compared to highly skilled migrants who came in in an ordered fashion with a job offer already on the table.
Failure to improve posting standards will result in a lengthy ban. I <crms_> !dumb <GeoffAnderson> crmsdota <crms_> damnit
Acrofales
Profile Joined August 2010
Spain18503 Posts
September 16 2015 19:02 GMT
#5830
On September 17 2015 03:45 dismiss wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 17 2015 03:36 Plansix wrote:
On September 17 2015 03:32 dismiss wrote:
On September 17 2015 02:47 Plansix wrote:
On September 17 2015 02:40 dismiss wrote:
On September 17 2015 02:31 Nyxisto wrote:
On September 17 2015 02:17 WhiteDog wrote:
In a place where there are already 25 million people unemployed (europe) saying that immigration will instantly have a positive economical impact for everybody is just dumb and hypocritical. They will most likely put pressure on lower wage - which is exactly what has been happening in europe in the schenghen area through the introduction of some of eastern countries (and what has happened historically in the US through immigration).


Many countries with absolutely atrocious economic situations in Europe have net emigration for years, it hasn't helped the labour market a bit. Is there any data at all that supports the claim that immigration drives wages down significantly? You're a big proponent of demand oriented policies and immigrants buy stuff and create jobs, too.

https://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/110th-congress-2007-2008/reports/12-6-immigration.pdf

Here's a meta-study from the US that details a negative impact on the economy by illegal immigrants. This one is probably more pertinent than the other ones stating that people who managed to get through a highly competitive selection process have a net positive impact on an economy.

That report doesn't' address wages being driven down or the economy. Only the drain on local government due to the US's total inability to have a realistic immigration police. Immigration isn't bad on its own, only that being an illegal immigrant is bad for the immigrant and the local government.

There's a direct correlation between how much income tax you pay and your economic impact. z_z

Yes, but that all related to the immigrants being illegal, not always paying taxes and not being paid as much because they were illegal. It doesn’t address legal immigration, which is what the poster above was asking about.

Oh sorry, maybe I didn't express my point clearly. It's more about comparing the different sectors, so to speak, of all migrants. Asylum seekers and illegals will fall into a much more similar category than those allowed in by the strict Canadian/British/German migration laws. There are many factors that disadvantage these groups on the labour market when compared to highly skilled migrants who came in in an ordered fashion with a job offer already on the table.

Actually no. Once asylum seekers are granted asylum, you can far rather compare them to legal (economic) immigrants in terms of what their economic impact is. They will have a work permit, and pay income taxes after all.
Nyxisto
Profile Joined August 2010
Germany6287 Posts
Last Edited: 2015-09-16 19:07:03
September 16 2015 19:06 GMT
#5831
It's really not comparable . Illegal workers probably work way below minimum wages, which makes a huge difference in addition to the fact that they pay taxes.
dismiss
Profile Blog Joined March 2009
United Kingdom3341 Posts
Last Edited: 2015-09-16 19:11:56
September 16 2015 19:10 GMT
#5832
So you wouldn't say their probable inability to speak the local language when they arrive, hardship to get their qualifications recognised, forced location by the immigration office and bias for the local populace on the labour market doesn't put them into a disadvantaged position?
Failure to improve posting standards will result in a lengthy ban. I <crms_> !dumb <GeoffAnderson> crmsdota <crms_> damnit
WhiteDog
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
France8650 Posts
September 16 2015 19:15 GMT
#5833
On September 17 2015 02:50 Nyxisto wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 17 2015 02:43 WhiteDog wrote:
As for the fact that immigration bring down wage, I don't have datas for you - there are tons of study on the case but no clear answers (basically the idea is that immigration has positive impact on wage above a certain degree of qualification and for specific people - native more than migrants - but negative impact on lower wage, but most studies are based on models and thus the results vastly change from one model to another). But it's an old fact that anybody knows ; competition bring price down.

Is it really competition though? We have over a hundred thousand apprenticeship positions open every year(I figure other European countries have similar problems) and there's a notorious lack of people in less paying service sector jobs like nurses, elderly care, maintenance and so on. These jobs simply never get filled and it's definitely not like people are fighting over them and already now many people working in these areas are working class immigrants.

1) I disagree with the argument that people don't want to do certain jobs (it's more a question of information / qualification / indirect costs for accepting the jobs that explain the lack of people in certain fields) ;
2) These jobs would get filled with the proper policies and wages. It just cost less for the state (and has more benefits for big business) to stay at the same wage level and to bring in fresh workers who accept those wages.

But, putting this aside, it's just untrue : migrants also works in very competitive field, like in the construction or in the industry. The idea that adding more people in a depressed labor market does not create any negative effect for the weakest people that compete in the market is just a fairy tail. Putting this aside is also the best way to misunderstand the resentment the people usually feel towards immigration (and to blame it all on an irrationnal racism).
"every time WhiteDog overuses the word "seriously" in a comment I can make an observation on his fragile emotional state." MoltkeWarding
Plansix
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
United States60190 Posts
September 16 2015 19:16 GMT
#5834
Yes, but they have legal protections and access to services that illegal immigrants lack. There are non-profits and other groups that assist refugees in finding jobs and stability. Illegal immigrants do not have that and often do not pay taxes.
I have the Honor to be your Obedient Servant, P.6
TL+ Member
kwizach
Profile Joined June 2011
3658 Posts
Last Edited: 2015-09-16 19:25:22
September 16 2015 19:24 GMT
#5835
On September 17 2015 03:32 dismiss wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 17 2015 02:47 Plansix wrote:
On September 17 2015 02:40 dismiss wrote:
On September 17 2015 02:31 Nyxisto wrote:
On September 17 2015 02:17 WhiteDog wrote:
In a place where there are already 25 million people unemployed (europe) saying that immigration will instantly have a positive economical impact for everybody is just dumb and hypocritical. They will most likely put pressure on lower wage - which is exactly what has been happening in europe in the schenghen area through the introduction of some of eastern countries (and what has happened historically in the US through immigration).


Many countries with absolutely atrocious economic situations in Europe have net emigration for years, it hasn't helped the labour market a bit. Is there any data at all that supports the claim that immigration drives wages down significantly? You're a big proponent of demand oriented policies and immigrants buy stuff and create jobs, too.

https://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/110th-congress-2007-2008/reports/12-6-immigration.pdf

Here's a meta-study from the US that details a negative impact on the economy by illegal immigrants. This one is probably more pertinent than the other ones stating that people who managed to get through a highly competitive selection process have a net positive impact on an economy.

That report doesn't' address wages being driven down or the economy. Only the drain on local government due to the US's total inability to have a realistic immigration police. Immigration isn't bad on its own, only that being an illegal immigrant is bad for the immigrant and the local government.

There's a direct correlation between how much income tax you pay and your economic impact. z_z

Mette Foged, Giovanni Per (2014), Immigrants and Native Workers: New Analysis Using Longitudinal Employer-Employee Data:
We focus on a largely unexplored inflow of non-European (EU) immigrants to Denmark, beginning in 1995 and driven by a sequence of international political crises, the Bosnian, Somalian and Iraqi one and economic crises, the Turkey depression of 1994-95. We find that the increased supply of non-EU immigrants in a Danish municipality pushed the less educated native workers to pursue more complex and less manual-intensive occupations. This reallocation took place mainly through movement of individuals across firms and resulted in higher or unchanged wages. Immigration increased mobility of natives across firms but it did not increase their probability of unemployment." (emphasis mine)
Source.

The study you cited did not cover the impact on wages, and it conveniently left out the positive impact on federal finances. Overall, the net fiscal impact of immigration is positive in most countries, and the effect on wages is negligible (it can have a slightly negative impact for the lower-skilled workers, but not necessarily -- as evidenced in the paper I just posted). This is not to say that we support immigration first and foremost for economic reasons, as WhiteDog falsely implied, but simply that economic arguments against immigration, and in this case against welcoming the refugees who reach Europe, are largely baseless.
"Oedipus ruined a great sex life by asking too many questions." -- Stephen Colbert
dismiss
Profile Blog Joined March 2009
United Kingdom3341 Posts
September 16 2015 19:31 GMT
#5836
On September 17 2015 04:16 Plansix wrote:
Yes, but they have legal protections and access to services that illegal immigrants lack. There are non-profits and other groups that assist refugees in finding jobs and stability. Illegal immigrants do not have that and often do not pay taxes.

The problem in Germany for example is the incredibly poor integration policy by the state though. I had a quick look around what you'd need to get an approbation. You need to be able to speak German at at least the B2 level, realistically more like C1. A mandatory German language course will get you nowhere near that, I'd guess it'd probably take you somewhere between 1-2 years to get there if you do nothing but learn to speak the language. Then you need to find a hospital that'll want to employ you, which is going to be hard because they don't even know if you qualify. Then you have to take some tests/get your qualification reviewed. It's quite common for them to tell simply tell you to fuck off if it's not from a Western country. All in all that'll take years. Gotta eat somehow during that time. Without having real qualification, they'll be hard pressed to find anything but the shittiest of jobs.
Failure to improve posting standards will result in a lengthy ban. I <crms_> !dumb <GeoffAnderson> crmsdota <crms_> damnit
Banaora
Profile Joined May 2013
Germany234 Posts
Last Edited: 2015-09-16 19:36:37
September 16 2015 19:33 GMT
#5837
On September 17 2015 03:21 Toadesstern wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 17 2015 03:12 Banaora wrote:
On September 17 2015 02:23 Toadesstern wrote:
On September 17 2015 02:17 WhiteDog wrote:
On September 17 2015 01:56 Sermokala wrote:
Economically all of them are desirable. Look at America it only takes a generation or so for indoctrination to set in with the kids and then suddenly they're good working citizens. Poor people are going to work hard to feed their kids and take shitty jobs to support them. You can't look at them like they're people you have to look at them like cogs in your economic machine.

The point is that the men are trying to earn money to get somewhere were they can bring the rest of their family over. USAs illegals are treated like shit and we still get them paying way more in taxes then they take out in services. That's having your cake and eating it too.

The thing is that people, when they take that "economical" argument, put aside the fact that the society is divided by different interests and groups. Immigration profit certain people, that's it. In a place where there are already 25 million people unemployed (europe) saying that immigration will instantly have a positive economical impact for everybody is just dumb and hypocritical. They will most likely put pressure on lower wage - which is exactly what has been happening in europe in the schenghen area through the introduction of some of eastern countries (and what has happened historically in the US through immigration).

The left in europe right now is constantly using that economical argument to support their desire to welcome refugees (E. Balibar even wrote a piece saying it will force europe into changing their economical policies ! who seriously believe that ?) shows very well how the current left is liberal to its core.

well from a german point of view, as the country that recently even "surpassed" Japan when it comes to having the lowest birthrate, you'd be pretty hard pressed to find negative things about it.

We just flat out won't have the people to pay for pensions for people who can't work anymore come 20 or 30 more years right now.

I personally think there is something wrong in our country that we as Germans have such a low birth rate especially compared to France and I would rather prefer we changed our policy in this regard than using the low birth rate as an "excuse" why we need immigration.

The current immigration of 1 Mio seekers of refugee status will in my opinion change our country in the long term and nobody was really asked if he wants that. Let's assume 50% get accepted, then they are allowed to take their family to Germany so I'm just guessing now we would have maybe 1 Mio new immigrants that can get residence status after some years or if they have to go later usually get tolerated to stay as most will not get deported if they are successfully integrated into our society. And this is just for 2015 and will probably continue.

Yes we are solving our ageing population problem this way but no one can know at what costs. Will the integration be a success?

There are resources bound to that that could have gone into other projects maybe to show solidarity with poor families in Germany or projects in southern Europe to create jobs.

Sure you can argue you are playing out refugees against other issues on the other side money can only be spent once and maybe it's a better idea not to advertise to everybody to come to Germany with their cultures to seek safety here.

Do you want to force people to have babies? Because I'm pretty sure there are efforts to make germans want more babies... it's just that they don't seem to work. If you want it or not, we need more young people if we want to keep our pension system alive

In the end it's a problem people brought upon themselves, so I really couldn't care less about people whining about that sort of thing.

People don't want to have babies, people don't want to have immigrants, people don't want to have cuts in pensions... Maybe we should have invested more money into cloning research rather than anything else.
+ Show Spoiler +
I might not be 100% serious with my last paragraph

Sure you can't force people to make babies. But you can have a proper policy so people feel good about having more children. You can read what France does here (in German): http://www.dw.com/de/frankreichs-erfolgreiche-familienpolitik/a-16872434
(hope it's still correct)

I'll try to summarise from the article:
- Child care starting early on and available everywhere
- No child benefit for the first child. Child benefits starting from the second child with an additional reward for the third.
- A tax system that rewards especially the third child. Starting from the fourth child average income families rarely pay any taxes.
dismiss
Profile Blog Joined March 2009
United Kingdom3341 Posts
Last Edited: 2015-09-16 19:42:19
September 16 2015 19:37 GMT
#5838
On September 17 2015 04:24 kwizach wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 17 2015 03:32 dismiss wrote:
On September 17 2015 02:47 Plansix wrote:
On September 17 2015 02:40 dismiss wrote:
On September 17 2015 02:31 Nyxisto wrote:
On September 17 2015 02:17 WhiteDog wrote:
In a place where there are already 25 million people unemployed (europe) saying that immigration will instantly have a positive economical impact for everybody is just dumb and hypocritical. They will most likely put pressure on lower wage - which is exactly what has been happening in europe in the schenghen area through the introduction of some of eastern countries (and what has happened historically in the US through immigration).


Many countries with absolutely atrocious economic situations in Europe have net emigration for years, it hasn't helped the labour market a bit. Is there any data at all that supports the claim that immigration drives wages down significantly? You're a big proponent of demand oriented policies and immigrants buy stuff and create jobs, too.

https://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/110th-congress-2007-2008/reports/12-6-immigration.pdf

Here's a meta-study from the US that details a negative impact on the economy by illegal immigrants. This one is probably more pertinent than the other ones stating that people who managed to get through a highly competitive selection process have a net positive impact on an economy.

That report doesn't' address wages being driven down or the economy. Only the drain on local government due to the US's total inability to have a realistic immigration police. Immigration isn't bad on its own, only that being an illegal immigrant is bad for the immigrant and the local government.

There's a direct correlation between how much income tax you pay and your economic impact. z_z

Mette Foged, Giovanni Per (2014), Immigrants and Native Workers: New Analysis Using Longitudinal Employer-Employee Data:
Show nested quote +
We focus on a largely unexplored inflow of non-European (EU) immigrants to Denmark, beginning in 1995 and driven by a sequence of international political crises, the Bosnian, Somalian and Iraqi one and economic crises, the Turkey depression of 1994-95. We find that the increased supply of non-EU immigrants in a Danish municipality pushed the less educated native workers to pursue more complex and less manual-intensive occupations. This reallocation took place mainly through movement of individuals across firms and resulted in higher or unchanged wages. Immigration increased mobility of natives across firms but it did not increase their probability of unemployment." (emphasis mine)
Source.

The study you cited did not cover the impact on wages, and it conveniently left out the positive impact on federal finances. Overall, the net fiscal impact of immigration is positive in most countries, and the effect on wages is negligible (it can have a slightly negative impact for the lower-skilled workers, but not necessarily -- as evidenced in the paper I just posted). This is not to say that we support immigration first and foremost for economic reasons, as WhiteDog falsely implied, but simply that economic arguments against immigration, and in this case against welcoming the refugees who reach Europe, are largely baseless.

Don't have time to read the whole thing right now but that sounds like the pressure on the low wage jobs increased and some of the people managed to better their lot by gaining more qualifications? I'd be interested how well this scales on a large basis. Read, how likely is this effect to occur in a country with low unemployment and primary demand for highly qualified people.
Failure to improve posting standards will result in a lengthy ban. I <crms_> !dumb <GeoffAnderson> crmsdota <crms_> damnit
Rassy
Profile Joined August 2010
Netherlands2308 Posts
Last Edited: 2015-09-16 21:13:21
September 16 2015 21:11 GMT
#5839
Just heard the numbers from the Netherlands. 700 refuges a day atm, wich would make 250k/year on a population of 16m... that's almost twice as much as Germany and Germany is very high already.
How these people come in? Rules are to ask asylum in the first safe country that you enter,well that obviously is not the case.

It is unbelievable what is happening now. The consequences will be very bad.
Will see that with the next elections.


o nvm,i see you guys are already passed this subject.
Ghostcom
Profile Joined March 2010
Denmark4783 Posts
Last Edited: 2015-09-16 22:47:27
September 16 2015 22:43 GMT
#5840
Nevermind, I had promised myself to not re-enter this discussion.
Prev 1 290 291 292 293 294 1432 Next
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
Next event in 1h 41m
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
ProTech128
StarCraft: Brood War
Jaedong 180
Zeus 147
Larva 142
Leta 83
actioN 75
Shine 27
ToSsGirL 24
EffOrt 21
Sharp 19
ajuk12(nOOB) 17
[ Show more ]
Aegong 17
Sacsri 16
Noble 10
Light 9
scan(afreeca) 8
sOs 6
Force[name] 4
Dota 2
Fuzer 52
Other Games
summit1g9372
JimRising 402
Mew2King76
Trikslyr17
[ Show 10 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Dota 2
• lizZardDota2399
League of Legends
• Rush1435
Upcoming Events
KCM Race Survival
1h 41m
Ultimate Battle
3h 41m
ZerO vs Bisu
Big Brain Bouts
8h 41m
FoxeR vs Bly
LetaleX vs MilkiCow
Reynor vs Lambo
RSL Revival
1d 2h
AI Arena Tournament
1d 8h
BSL
1d 11h
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
2 days
IPSL
2 days
Ret vs ggnore13
nOmaD vs Aether
BSL
2 days
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
2 days
[ Show More ]
WardiTV Weekly
3 days
Kung Fu Cup
4 days
Solar vs Classic
ByuN vs SHIN
PiGosaur Cup
4 days
The PondCast
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Proleague 2026-11-17
Blizzard Classic Cup 2026
HCC Season 3

Ongoing

Acropolis #5
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4
International ShieldBattery League
BSL Season 23
IPSL Winter 2026-27
Calamity Cup Div. A Season 8
Underdog Cup 2026 Div 2-3
Stake Ranked Episode 6
BLAST Rivals Fall 2026
IEM Beijing 2026
PGL Masters Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 5
1win Private Club #2
Thunderpick World Champ. '26
ESL Pro League Season 24
Stake Ranked Episode 4
1win Private Club #1
Logitech G Play Connect 2026
SL StarSeries Fall 2026
FISSURE Playground #3

Upcoming

Sector 591
YSL S4
SC4ALL II: Brood War
NBSL 2026 Xiamen LAN
BSL 23: Non-Korean Championship
HSC XXX
Stellar Fest 2: Lunar Cup
StarCraft2 Weekly Open Tournament 2026 Grand Finals
SC4ALL II: StarCraft II
Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals
RSL Offline Finals
IEM Kraków 2027
PGL Bucharest 2027
BLAST Bounty Winter 2027
PGL Major Singapore 2026
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.