• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EDT 05:25
CEST 11:25
KST 18:25
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
RSL Season 1 - Final Week1[ASL19] Finals Recap: Standing Tall10HomeStory Cup 27 - Info & Preview18Classic wins Code S Season 2 (2025)16Code S RO4 & Finals Preview: herO, Rogue, Classic, GuMiho0
Community News
Firefly given lifetime ban by ESIC following match-fixing investigation14$25,000 Streamerzone StarCraft Pro Series announced6Weekly Cups (June 30 - July 6): Classic Doubles6[BSL20] Non-Korean Championship 4x BSL + 4x China9Flash Announces Hiatus From ASL67
StarCraft 2
General
RSL Season 1 - Final Week Firefly given lifetime ban by ESIC following match-fixing investigation The SCII GOAT: A statistical Evaluation TL Team Map Contest #4: Winners Weekly Cups (June 30 - July 6): Classic Doubles
Tourneys
$25,000 Streamerzone StarCraft Pro Series announced FEL Cracov 2025 (July 27) - $8000 live event Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament RSL: Revival, a new crowdfunded tournament series WardiTV Mondays
Strategy
How did i lose this ZvP, whats the proper response Simple Questions Simple Answers
Custom Maps
[UMS] Zillion Zerglings
External Content
Mutation # 481 Fear and Lava Mutation # 480 Moths to the Flame Mutation # 479 Worn Out Welcome Mutation # 478 Instant Karma
Brood War
General
Flash Announces Hiatus From ASL BW General Discussion BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/ [G] Progamer Settings ASL20 Preliminary Maps
Tourneys
[Megathread] Daily Proleagues [BSL20] Non-Korean Championship 4x BSL + 4x China [BSL20] Grand Finals - Sunday 20:00 CET CSL Xiamen International Invitational
Strategy
Simple Questions, Simple Answers I am doing this better than progamers do.
Other Games
General Games
Nintendo Switch Thread Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Path of Exile What do you want from future RTS games? Beyond All Reason
Dota 2
Official 'what is Dota anymore' discussion
League of Legends
Positive Thoughts on Setting Up a Dual-Caliber FX
Heroes of the Storm
Simple Questions, Simple Answers Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Heroes of StarCraft mini-set
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread Vanilla Mini Mafia
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Stop Killing Games - European Citizens Initiative Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine Summer Games Done Quick 2025! Russo-Ukrainian War Thread
Fan Clubs
SKT1 Classic Fan Club! Maru Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece [\m/] Heavy Metal Thread
Sports
Formula 1 Discussion 2024 - 2025 Football Thread NBA General Discussion TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023 NHL Playoffs 2024
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List
Blogs
Men Take Risks, Women Win Ga…
TrAiDoS
momentary artworks from des…
tankgirl
from making sc maps to makin…
Husyelt
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 657 users

[Philosophy] Profound prisoner's dilemma. - Page 2

Forum Index > General Forum
Post a Reply
Prev 1 2 3 4 5 16 17 18 Next All
GGTeMpLaR
Profile Blog Joined June 2009
United States7226 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-07-18 22:42:35
July 18 2010 22:40 GMT
#21
On July 19 2010 07:35 kzn wrote:
You pull that lever in 0.1 seconds flat.

How is this even a dilemma?


well in the Game Theory version, both parties act rationally but doing so they produce an irrational/undesirable result, which might be considered a paradox I guess

as for his dilemma, I guess it might be considered an ethical issue to some - personal benefit at the expense of others (although it's debatable)
RhaegarBeast
Profile Joined July 2010
Bulgaria113 Posts
July 18 2010 22:40 GMT
#22
I'm updating the problem.
Never understimate a rabbit on a mission!
Win.win
Profile Joined March 2010
United States230 Posts
July 18 2010 22:42 GMT
#23
what do you mean by identical prisoner? he's a clone of you with the same life experiences?
SC2 Team Inflow: http://inflowgaming.net/
ZERG_RUSSIAN
Profile Blog Joined November 2008
10417 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-07-18 22:46:15
July 18 2010 22:45 GMT
#24
On July 19 2010 07:15 RhaegarBeast wrote:
This is a riddle that has plagued me for about 10 years and I think I finally found a satisfying solution; I believe I finally understood it.

"You are a total prisoner of an unknown mage. You slowly realize that there is absolutely no escape and then the mage gives you a lever and tells you that it is connected to an identical one in an identical prison with an identical prisoner. He says that as long as the lever remains unpressed you both remain in the prison. But when someone actually decides to press it then the other prisoner dies and the remaining one goes free. The prison is rather tormenting and both prisoners really want to get out. What will eventually happen? It actually depends on the person that you ask. What is your solution to the problem? What would you do? What would the average person do? What happens? Does the end justify the means? THINK ABOUT IT!" The solution gets more awesome the more I think about it.


Btw, I first saw a version of this riddle in Baldur's Gate II.

Edit: The other prisoner learns this at the same time as you do. The mage can make you really "know" that everything that is written is true.

Is this a trick? Because there's absolutely no reason not to pull the lever as soon as possible in your version. Usually there's some sort of "if both players don't pull it they can both _______" clause.
I'm on GOLD CHAIN
GGTeMpLaR
Profile Blog Joined June 2009
United States7226 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-07-18 22:48:08
July 18 2010 22:47 GMT
#25
+ Show Spoiler +
On July 19 2010 07:45 ZERG_RUSSIAN wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 19 2010 07:15 RhaegarBeast wrote:
This is a riddle that has plagued me for about 10 years and I think I finally found a satisfying solution; I believe I finally understood it.

"You are a total prisoner of an unknown mage. You slowly realize that there is absolutely no escape and then the mage gives you a lever and tells you that it is connected to an identical one in an identical prison with an identical prisoner. He says that as long as the lever remains unpressed you both remain in the prison. But when someone actually decides to press it then the other prisoner dies and the remaining one goes free. The prison is rather tormenting and both prisoners really want to get out. What will eventually happen? It actually depends on the person that you ask. What is your solution to the problem? What would you do? What would the average person do? What happens? Does the end justify the means? THINK ABOUT IT!" The solution gets more awesome the more I think about it.


Btw, I first saw a version of this riddle in Baldur's Gate II.

Edit: The other prisoner learns this at the same time as you do. The mage can make you really "know" that everything that is written is true.

Is this a trick? Because there's absolutely no reason not to pull the lever as soon as possible in your version. Usually there's some sort of "if both players don't pull it they can both _______" clause.


yea, like if one pulls it and the other doesn't, they get the greatest benefit, if both pull it they get benefit but less than if neither pull it. however if you don't pull it and the other person does, you lose it all.
RhaegarBeast
Profile Joined July 2010
Bulgaria113 Posts
July 18 2010 22:48 GMT
#26
Oops, I intended to give another version first. This one is too complicated.

Version 1.0 - The more you stand in the prison the more you suffer. If you press the lever you die and the other one goes free.

Version 2.0 will be the one I posted, but keep in mind it's also meaningful.
Never understimate a rabbit on a mission!
danl9rm
Profile Blog Joined July 2009
United States3111 Posts
July 18 2010 22:48 GMT
#27
I would not pull the lever. And I'm fairly certain I could sustain torture for longer than the other guy. Yes, that means I would die.
"Science has so well established that the preborn baby in the womb is a living human being that most pro-choice activists have conceded the point. ..since the abortion proponents have lost the science argument, they are now advocating an existential one."
NonY
Profile Blog Joined June 2007
8748 Posts
July 18 2010 22:49 GMT
#28
On July 19 2010 07:42 Win.win wrote:
what do you mean by identical prisoner? he's a clone of you with the same life experiences?

'Prisoner' is a role. It's not a proper noun...
"Fucking up is part of it. If you can't fail, you have to always win. And I don't think you can always win." Elliott Smith ---------- Yet no sudden rage darkened his face, and his eyes were calm as they studied her. Then he smiled. 'Witness.'
StRyKeR
Profile Blog Joined January 2006
United States1739 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-07-18 22:52:26
July 18 2010 22:51 GMT
#29
Hmm, interesting. The new Version 1.0 is interesting...

If you decide to just endure the torture assuming that the other prisoner will eventually cave in, you both might end up being tortured indefinitely (probably till both die).

So the question is, do you act to save the other person? You might as well, since if both of you keep enduring, you'll both die. But there's a chance that the other will cave in first, so maybe not?

I'd probably try to endure it as much as possible.
Ars longa, vita brevis, principia aeturna.
RhaegarBeast
Profile Joined July 2010
Bulgaria113 Posts
July 18 2010 22:53 GMT
#30
On July 19 2010 07:42 Win.win wrote:
what do you mean by identical prisoner? he's a clone of you with the same life experiences?


Basically, yes. Smart guy.
Never understimate a rabbit on a mission!
Navi
Profile Joined November 2009
5286 Posts
July 18 2010 22:54 GMT
#31
If the prisoners are truly identical, they would "know" that if they pulled the lever, the other prisoner would do the same at the same time, and thus they would both die (unless the mage has some system in case they both pull at the same time). For instance, if the prisoners were both hotheads, they would immediately pull the lever while their counterpart would as well, and they would both die. If they thought it out, they would realize that this would occur regardless of how long they waited, and thus they would realize that the sooner they pulled the lever, the sooner that both could escape the torment inside of the prison.

So TL;DR: pull leverz n die for both parties
Hey! Listen!
GGTeMpLaR
Profile Blog Joined June 2009
United States7226 Posts
July 18 2010 22:54 GMT
#32
that makes a ton more sense than the original lol

it would probably come down to whoever has more to live for and can sustain more suffering
NonY
Profile Blog Joined June 2007
8748 Posts
July 18 2010 22:54 GMT
#33
Well then this is how I see it...

Freedom is good. Death is neutral. Prison is bad.

Going from prison to death is a good change. Going from prison to freedom is a good change. Pull the lever.

Or if I think the other guy might value a life in prison more than death, and I have a whim of altruism, I'll wait an hour to give him a chance to pull the lever. During that time, I expect him to decide if a guilty conscience is going to prevent him from getting the proper benefit out of his pulling the lever. If he doesn't pull it after an hour, I'll pull it, because I believe he'd be better off that way, and I know I'd be better off that way, and I'd be sure to not let a guilty conscience affect my happiness while free.
"Fucking up is part of it. If you can't fail, you have to always win. And I don't think you can always win." Elliott Smith ---------- Yet no sudden rage darkened his face, and his eyes were calm as they studied her. Then he smiled. 'Witness.'
RhaegarBeast
Profile Joined July 2010
Bulgaria113 Posts
July 18 2010 22:54 GMT
#34
Prisoner is a state of being in this case. It's like a type of animal - Prisoner.
Never understimate a rabbit on a mission!
RhaegarBeast
Profile Joined July 2010
Bulgaria113 Posts
July 18 2010 22:55 GMT
#35
Now, you gotta specify which version you're talking about or mayham will ensue.
Never understimate a rabbit on a mission!
nath
Profile Blog Joined May 2010
United States1788 Posts
July 18 2010 22:56 GMT
#36
On July 19 2010 07:51 StRyKeR wrote:
Hmm, interesting. The new Version 1.0 is interesting...

If you decide to just endure the torture assuming that the other prisoner will eventually cave in, you both might end up being tortured indefinitely (probably till both die).

So the question is, do you act to save the other person? You might as well, since if both of you keep enduring, you'll both die. But there's a chance that the other will cave in first, so maybe not?

I'd probably try to endure it as much as possible.

i'd just wait. he may cave! i might cave too lol, although we all like to think we're strong enough to handle torture.
Founder of Flow Enterprises, LLC http://flow-enterprises.com/
RhaegarBeast
Profile Joined July 2010
Bulgaria113 Posts
July 18 2010 22:58 GMT
#37
I'm not giving any more hints. I'm guessing many people will disagree with the whole idea, I like it a lot though.
Never understimate a rabbit on a mission!
Mohdoo
Profile Joined August 2007
United States15664 Posts
July 18 2010 22:58 GMT
#38
I'd immediately press it.
KwarK
Profile Blog Joined July 2006
United States42558 Posts
July 18 2010 22:59 GMT
#39
The main question is more interesting. At first your situation seems hopeless, a choice between torment or death, but then you realise the other can free you. You simply need to endure it for longer than he does. Then, no matter how hard it gets, you know he's suffering in the same way and that gives you hope because the worse it gets, the nearer they are to breaking. It's a self perpetuating system. If the torture gets worse then both would eventually break at the same time but if not then it may continue indefinitately.
ModeratorThe angels have the phone box
Win.win
Profile Joined March 2010
United States230 Posts
July 18 2010 22:59 GMT
#40
On July 19 2010 07:49 Liquid`Tyler wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 19 2010 07:42 Win.win wrote:
what do you mean by identical prisoner? he's a clone of you with the same life experiences?

'Prisoner' is a role. It's not a proper noun...

and if a 'prisoner' is a person confined in prison, then 'identical prisoner' would be an identical person confined in prison...
SC2 Team Inflow: http://inflowgaming.net/
Prev 1 2 3 4 5 16 17 18 Next All
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
Next event in 35m
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft: Brood War
Calm 9077
Sea 4527
Hyuk 470
Jaedong 453
Backho 294
actioN 241
Soulkey 94
Soma 92
Zeus 76
ToSsGirL 71
[ Show more ]
EffOrt 66
hero 60
Sharp 38
Noble 35
sSak 32
Hyun 29
JulyZerg 29
NaDa 25
yabsab 19
sorry 18
Sacsri 16
Free 15
Bale 14
Shinee 11
ajuk12(nOOB) 9
IntoTheRainbow 8
Hm[arnc] 7
Sexy 4
Dota 2
Gorgc2369
XaKoH 450
XcaliburYe374
League of Legends
JimRising 522
Counter-Strike
shoxiejesuss911
chrisJcsgo76
Heroes of the Storm
Khaldor148
Other Games
tarik_tv19578
shahzam701
Stewie2K655
ceh9605
crisheroes446
monkeys_forever219
Lowko139
Liquid`RaSZi126
SortOf81
Organizations
Other Games
gamesdonequick24416
StarCraft: Brood War
Kim Chul Min (afreeca) 401
StarCraft 2
Blizzard YouTube
StarCraft: Brood War
BSLTrovo
sctven
[ Show 16 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• Berry_CruncH364
• LUISG 13
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• LaughNgamezSOOP
• Migwel
• sooper7s
StarCraft: Brood War
• tankgirl 1
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Dota 2
• lizZardDota2162
League of Legends
• Lourlo1287
• Stunt494
Upcoming Events
RSL Revival
35m
ByuN vs SHIN
Clem vs Reynor
OSC
3h 35m
Replay Cast
14h 35m
RSL Revival
1d
Classic vs Cure
FEL
1d 6h
OSC
1d 10h
RSL Revival
2 days
FEL
2 days
FEL
2 days
CSO Cup
2 days
[ Show More ]
BSL20 Non-Korean Champi…
2 days
Bonyth vs QiaoGege
Dewalt vs Fengzi
Hawk vs Zhanhun
Sziky vs Mihu
Mihu vs QiaoGege
Zhanhun vs Sziky
Fengzi vs Hawk
Sparkling Tuna Cup
3 days
RSL Revival
3 days
FEL
3 days
BSL20 Non-Korean Champi…
3 days
Bonyth vs Dewalt
QiaoGege vs Dewalt
Hawk vs Bonyth
Sziky vs Fengzi
Mihu vs Zhanhun
QiaoGege vs Zhanhun
Fengzi vs Mihu
Replay Cast
5 days
Replay Cast
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Proleague 2025-07-07
HSC XXVII
Heroes 10 EU

Ongoing

JPL Season 2
BSL 2v2 Season 3
Acropolis #3
KCM Race Survival 2025 Season 2
CSL 17: 2025 SUMMER
Copa Latinoamericana 4
Jiahua Invitational
Championship of Russia 2025
RSL Revival: Season 1
Murky Cup #2
BLAST.tv Austin Major 2025
ESL Impact League Season 7
IEM Dallas 2025
PGL Astana 2025
Asian Champions League '25
BLAST Rivals Spring 2025
MESA Nomadic Masters
CCT Season 2 Global Finals
IEM Melbourne 2025

Upcoming

2025 ACS Season 2: Qualifier
CSLPRO Last Chance 2025
CSL Xiamen Invitational
CSL Xiamen Invitational: ShowMatche
2025 ACS Season 2
CSLPRO Chat StarLAN 3
K-Championship
uThermal 2v2 Main Event
SEL Season 2 Championship
FEL Cracov 2025
Esports World Cup 2025
Underdog Cup #2
StarSeries Fall 2025
FISSURE Playground #2
BLAST Open Fall 2025
BLAST Open Fall Qual
Esports World Cup 2025
BLAST Bounty Fall 2025
BLAST Bounty Fall Qual
IEM Cologne 2025
FISSURE Playground #1
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2025 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.