|
This is a thread that is dedicated to discussing One Piece. Do not read this thread if you are not currently caught up as there are spoilers in here.
If an episode or a chapter has already been officially released, then it is not necessary to post using spoilers.
If you have knowledge on a chapter that has not been officially released yet, do NOT post it in this thread. Ignoring this public note will result in a mod action. |
On April 15 2014 00:52 Serejai wrote:Do you guys feel that Doflamingo is more or less honorable than Enel? Poll: Who is most honorable?Enel (15) 68% Doflamingo (7) 32% 22 total votes Your vote: Who is most honorable? (Vote): Doflamingo
(Vote): Enel
i think people are voting enel this poll not for the question of the poll but rather since enel is in the poll.
|
I disagree and how dare you try to tarnish the results of my scientifically accurate poll.
|
On April 15 2014 01:33 Forikorder wrote:Show nested quote +On April 15 2014 01:09 BlackMagister wrote:
You can still be honorable to enemies. A swordsman challenges another swordsman to a duel. The second swordsman agrees to the duel, but says "I get to choose the time and place" the first agrees and turns around to leave and is struck down by the second swordsman.
Honorable right? There can still be honor between enemies, it's just when you're trying to kill each other it creates a huge incentive not to be honorable to win. Law was planning to give Caesar back that was honorable even though he could have just killed Caesar after DD appeared to resign. except the switch was jsut Law trying to buy time...
Law was still planning to uphold his end of the bargain while DD will break promises. Why are you even trying to argue with this? It's one thing in a list of shit DD has done. Let's not forget how DD lied to the entire country to make them hate King Riku when they loved him previously and refused to let Riku try to buy back his kingdom when he attempted to accept the deal DD made.
|
On April 15 2014 00:51 Raneth wrote:Show nested quote +On April 15 2014 00:46 Incognoto wrote:
DD shits on everyone except for his crew. which is better than someone like crocodile or buggy It still doesnt make him honourable, it might make him compassionate to his crew, it might make him protective, it might make him lots of things, what it does not make him, is honourable
never said he was honorable. just said things as they were.
people i would consider honorable in one piece are jinbei, whitebeard, shanks, all the straw hats, etc.
|
On April 15 2014 01:58 BlackMagister wrote:Show nested quote +On April 15 2014 01:33 Forikorder wrote:On April 15 2014 01:09 BlackMagister wrote:
You can still be honorable to enemies. A swordsman challenges another swordsman to a duel. The second swordsman agrees to the duel, but says "I get to choose the time and place" the first agrees and turns around to leave and is struck down by the second swordsman.
Honorable right? There can still be honor between enemies, it's just when you're trying to kill each other it creates a huge incentive not to be honorable to win. Law was planning to give Caesar back that was honorable even though he could have just killed Caesar after DD appeared to resign. except the switch was jsut Law trying to buy time... Law was still planning to uphold his end of the bargain while DD will break promises. Why are you even trying to argue with this? It's one thing in a list of shit DD has done. Let's not forget how DD lied to the entire country to make them hate King Riku when they loved him previously and refused to let Riku try to buy back his kingdom when he attempted to accept the deal DD made.
if DD "upheld" his end of the "bargain" (which is your term for Law blackmailing DD) then DD would have lost everything
|
On April 15 2014 02:18 Forikorder wrote:Show nested quote +On April 15 2014 01:58 BlackMagister wrote:On April 15 2014 01:33 Forikorder wrote:On April 15 2014 01:09 BlackMagister wrote:
You can still be honorable to enemies. A swordsman challenges another swordsman to a duel. The second swordsman agrees to the duel, but says "I get to choose the time and place" the first agrees and turns around to leave and is struck down by the second swordsman.
Honorable right? There can still be honor between enemies, it's just when you're trying to kill each other it creates a huge incentive not to be honorable to win. Law was planning to give Caesar back that was honorable even though he could have just killed Caesar after DD appeared to resign. except the switch was jsut Law trying to buy time... Law was still planning to uphold his end of the bargain while DD will break promises. Why are you even trying to argue with this? It's one thing in a list of shit DD has done. Let's not forget how DD lied to the entire country to make them hate King Riku when they loved him previously and refused to let Riku try to buy back his kingdom when he attempted to accept the deal DD made. if DD "upheld" his end of the "bargain" (which is your term for Law blackmailing DD) then DD would have lost everything
So he did a smart thing by tricking law, but he DIDNT do an HONOURABLE thing, you know that word you keep using? Honourable?
|
On April 15 2014 02:00 Incognoto wrote:Show nested quote +On April 15 2014 00:51 Raneth wrote:On April 15 2014 00:46 Incognoto wrote:
DD shits on everyone except for his crew. which is better than someone like crocodile or buggy It still doesnt make him honourable, it might make him compassionate to his crew, it might make him protective, it might make him lots of things, what it does not make him, is honourable never said he was honorable. just said things as they were. people i would consider honorable in one piece are jinbei, whitebeard, shanks, all the straw hats, etc.
Right you are, was just making sure that wasnt an unwritten implication of your post 
|
Hitler was evil and not a honorable person.. and more then one country followed him!
he had millions of followers and thousands that would die for him, many were forced or had no chance in the matter but many of them would die for him..
Same with Stalin, Mao Tse Tung, etc..
Are they honorable? don't think so dude..
DD is evil and a piece a shit person, does his word mean something? depends on the situation.. if it's to fuck up a enemy? no it doesn't.. if it's to maitain his life and his reputation?? you can bet his words mean something!
That's why i also believe he wouldn't have messed with the fruit.. the winner would grab it but they probably wouldn't walk out of his island with the prize
|
On April 15 2014 02:35 Raneth wrote:Show nested quote +On April 15 2014 02:18 Forikorder wrote:On April 15 2014 01:58 BlackMagister wrote:On April 15 2014 01:33 Forikorder wrote:On April 15 2014 01:09 BlackMagister wrote:
You can still be honorable to enemies. A swordsman challenges another swordsman to a duel. The second swordsman agrees to the duel, but says "I get to choose the time and place" the first agrees and turns around to leave and is struck down by the second swordsman.
Honorable right? There can still be honor between enemies, it's just when you're trying to kill each other it creates a huge incentive not to be honorable to win. Law was planning to give Caesar back that was honorable even though he could have just killed Caesar after DD appeared to resign. except the switch was jsut Law trying to buy time... Law was still planning to uphold his end of the bargain while DD will break promises. Why are you even trying to argue with this? It's one thing in a list of shit DD has done. Let's not forget how DD lied to the entire country to make them hate King Riku when they loved him previously and refused to let Riku try to buy back his kingdom when he attempted to accept the deal DD made. if DD "upheld" his end of the "bargain" (which is your term for Law blackmailing DD) then DD would have lost everything So he did a smart thing by tricking law, but he DIDNT do an HONOURABLE thing, you know that word you keep using? Honourable?
it doesnt make someone un-honourable to lie to someone when its either lie or die
|
On April 15 2014 02:42 shell wrote:
Hitler was evil and not a honorable person.. and more then one country followed him!
he had millions of followers and thousands that would die for him, many were forced or had no chance in the matter but many of them would die for him..
Same with Stalin, Mao Tse Tung, etc..
Are they honorable? don't think so dude..
DD is evil and a piece a shit person, does his word mean something? depends on the situation.. if it's to fuck up a enemy? no it doesn't.. if it's to maitain his life and his reputation?? you can bet his words mean something!
That's why i also believe he wouldn't have messed with the fruit.. the winner would grab it but they probably wouldn't walk out of his island with the prize
I think DD isn't as bad as hitler though.
|
FREEAGLELAND26781 Posts
|
On April 15 2014 02:46 Forikorder wrote:Show nested quote +On April 15 2014 02:35 Raneth wrote:On April 15 2014 02:18 Forikorder wrote:On April 15 2014 01:58 BlackMagister wrote:On April 15 2014 01:33 Forikorder wrote:On April 15 2014 01:09 BlackMagister wrote:
You can still be honorable to enemies. A swordsman challenges another swordsman to a duel. The second swordsman agrees to the duel, but says "I get to choose the time and place" the first agrees and turns around to leave and is struck down by the second swordsman.
Honorable right? There can still be honor between enemies, it's just when you're trying to kill each other it creates a huge incentive not to be honorable to win. Law was planning to give Caesar back that was honorable even though he could have just killed Caesar after DD appeared to resign. except the switch was jsut Law trying to buy time... Law was still planning to uphold his end of the bargain while DD will break promises. Why are you even trying to argue with this? It's one thing in a list of shit DD has done. Let's not forget how DD lied to the entire country to make them hate King Riku when they loved him previously and refused to let Riku try to buy back his kingdom when he attempted to accept the deal DD made. if DD "upheld" his end of the "bargain" (which is your term for Law blackmailing DD) then DD would have lost everything So he did a smart thing by tricking law, but he DIDNT do an HONOURABLE thing, you know that word you keep using? Honourable? it doesnt make someone un-honourable to lie to someone when its either lie or die
Good thing it wasn't lie or die then.
|
Poll: Doflamingo is an honorable person?False (18) 90% True (2) 10% 20 total votes Your vote: Doflamingo is an honorable person? (Vote): True
(Vote): False
|
On April 15 2014 03:38 Dangermousecatdog wrote:Poll: Doflamingo is an honorable person?False (18) 90% True (2) 10% 20 total votes Your vote: Doflamingo is an honorable person? (Vote): True
(Vote): False
a much more accurate poll than the one Serejai made. 
|
On April 15 2014 03:03 GettingIt wrote:Show nested quote +On April 15 2014 02:46 Forikorder wrote:On April 15 2014 02:35 Raneth wrote:On April 15 2014 02:18 Forikorder wrote:On April 15 2014 01:58 BlackMagister wrote:On April 15 2014 01:33 Forikorder wrote:On April 15 2014 01:09 BlackMagister wrote:
You can still be honorable to enemies. A swordsman challenges another swordsman to a duel. The second swordsman agrees to the duel, but says "I get to choose the time and place" the first agrees and turns around to leave and is struck down by the second swordsman.
Honorable right? There can still be honor between enemies, it's just when you're trying to kill each other it creates a huge incentive not to be honorable to win. Law was planning to give Caesar back that was honorable even though he could have just killed Caesar after DD appeared to resign. except the switch was jsut Law trying to buy time... Law was still planning to uphold his end of the bargain while DD will break promises. Why are you even trying to argue with this? It's one thing in a list of shit DD has done. Let's not forget how DD lied to the entire country to make them hate King Riku when they loved him previously and refused to let Riku try to buy back his kingdom when he attempted to accept the deal DD made. if DD "upheld" his end of the "bargain" (which is your term for Law blackmailing DD) then DD would have lost everything So he did a smart thing by tricking law, but he DIDNT do an HONOURABLE thing, you know that word you keep using? Honourable? it doesnt make someone un-honourable to lie to someone when its either lie or die Good thing it wasn't lie or die then.
cause Law totally doest seem like he wants DD dead
at any rate there enemies only the most lawful stupid would refuse to lie to there enemy
|
Why the fuck are we even talking about Doflamingo being an honorable men ? Honorable is pretty subjective in some cases.In my opinion, we cannot say that Doffy is honorable, no fucking way. Is he loyal in regard to his crew and high-ranking officers ? So far it has been shown,that he is. However, I Doffla is ready to use any means necessary to win,even if it involves deceit,blackmailing, falsely accusing someone etc. etc.
|
The dudes a Pirate. He ain't following no rules that he can get away with not following.
|
On April 15 2014 03:55 shark. wrote:
The dudes a Pirate. He ain't following no rules that he can get away with not following.
here here!
Edit: To quote the great jack sparrow "Pirate..."
|
On April 15 2014 03:50 Forikorder wrote:Show nested quote +On April 15 2014 03:03 GettingIt wrote:On April 15 2014 02:46 Forikorder wrote:On April 15 2014 02:35 Raneth wrote:On April 15 2014 02:18 Forikorder wrote:On April 15 2014 01:58 BlackMagister wrote:On April 15 2014 01:33 Forikorder wrote:On April 15 2014 01:09 BlackMagister wrote:
You can still be honorable to enemies. A swordsman challenges another swordsman to a duel. The second swordsman agrees to the duel, but says "I get to choose the time and place" the first agrees and turns around to leave and is struck down by the second swordsman.
Honorable right? There can still be honor between enemies, it's just when you're trying to kill each other it creates a huge incentive not to be honorable to win. Law was planning to give Caesar back that was honorable even though he could have just killed Caesar after DD appeared to resign. except the switch was jsut Law trying to buy time... Law was still planning to uphold his end of the bargain while DD will break promises. Why are you even trying to argue with this? It's one thing in a list of shit DD has done. Let's not forget how DD lied to the entire country to make them hate King Riku when they loved him previously and refused to let Riku try to buy back his kingdom when he attempted to accept the deal DD made. if DD "upheld" his end of the "bargain" (which is your term for Law blackmailing DD) then DD would have lost everything So he did a smart thing by tricking law, but he DIDNT do an HONOURABLE thing, you know that word you keep using? Honourable? it doesnt make someone un-honourable to lie to someone when its either lie or die Good thing it wasn't lie or die then. cause Law totally doest seem like he wants DD dead at any rate there enemies only the most lawful stupid would refuse to lie to there enemy
Cause Law totally can kill DD
|
Doing the smart thing and the honorable thing are two different things. Just like it might be smart to break a treaty or a cease fire agreement, but it's not honorable. There can be honor between enemies that want to kill each other is that really so hard to understand?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
