|
This is a thread that is dedicated to discussing One Piece. Do not read this thread if you are not currently caught up as there are spoilers in here.
If an episode or a chapter has already been officially released, then it is not necessary to post using spoilers.
If you have knowledge on a chapter that has not been officially released yet, do NOT post it in this thread. Ignoring this public note will result in a mod action. |
On March 05 2016 18:54 Salteador Neo wrote:
While knowing 3 points you can find the place if you go from A to B, B to C then C to A in straight lines (it has to be somewhere between them).
Oh my 5k post being in the One Piece thread seems fitting :D
yeah but this is the grand line, going in a straight line isn't possible, remember?
........ of course that means that you can't get to raftel though, what the fuck >_<
are you right?
|
On March 05 2016 22:25 Incognoto wrote:Show nested quote +On March 05 2016 18:54 Salteador Neo wrote:
While knowing 3 points you can find the place if you go from A to B, B to C then C to A in straight lines (it has to be somewhere between them).
Oh my 5k post being in the One Piece thread seems fitting :D yeah but this is the grand line, going in a straight line isn't possible, remember? ........ of course that means that you can't get to raftel though, what the fuck >_< are you right?
just have Luffy stand on one island, feet firmly planted, grab his arm then sail to the opposite island and you have a straight line
|
|
|
drawing a straight line between 2 points in the surface of a sphere is different from drawing a straight line between 2 points through the sphere. The island could be under ocean or even under the sea floor depending on how far away the island's are located.
Because think about it, if the second picture in this http://imgur.com/nz9z4k8 is draw on the surface of the ocean, people would only need 2 points and the hidden island has to be somewhere along the line between the 2 points, people like aokiji or anyone that can fly like shiki would have already found it, there would be no need for all 4 islands.
|
On March 07 2016 03:52 rei wrote:drawing a straight line between 2 points in the surface of a sphere is different from drawing a straight line between 2 points through the sphere. The island could be under ocean or even under the sea floor depending on how far away the island's are located. Because think about it, if the second picture in this http://imgur.com/nz9z4k8 is draw on the surface of the ocean, people would only need 2 points and the hidden island has to be somewhere along the line between the 2 points, people like aokiji or anyone that can fly like shiki would have already found it, there would be no need for all 4 islands.
unless raftel is just surrounded by the most dangerous conditions ever that make the rest of the grand line look EZ and you have to follow a specific path and each island has the way to get to the next one and then finally raftel
or a shrine or some crap and all 4 need to be active to get past the barrier around raftel (lol)
|
On March 07 2016 03:52 rei wrote:drawing a straight line between 2 points in the surface of a sphere is different from drawing a straight line between 2 points through the sphere. The island could be under ocean or even under the sea floor depending on how far away the island's are located. Because think about it, if the second picture in this http://imgur.com/nz9z4k8 is draw on the surface of the ocean, people would only need 2 points and the hidden island has to be somewhere along the line between the 2 points, people like aokiji or anyone that can fly like shiki would have already found it, there would be no need for all 4 islands.
You'd need 2 points across from each other if it was 2D. If the two points are not they don't help you much. Either way it's probable that there's some reason why you need all four that we can't really infer from the details we were given.
|
2 points isn't enough, except if those two points are linked together. If not, you're going to search for nothing.
|
Even 4 points isn't enough.
It's going to form 2 circles on the sphere which will intersect at 2 points.
If you take all possible pairs of two points you get 2*4choose2
12 locations
|
There might be a reason to need 4 poneglyphs and it might be written there. Too bad, unless Robin explain to us before they get all clues its a mistery to be solved in the next decade D:
But really could be many things, the dog could be wrong about the drawing a cross thing, maybe its not that simple.
|
Robin's bounty should definitely higher. How many people can read poneglyphs just Robin? She holds the key to ancient weapons, true history and now possibly the only guide to One Piece. Maybe someone like Roger, aka Luffy, could magic sense to read the poneglyph, but other than that it's just Robin so far.
|
On March 07 2016 12:04 BlackMagister wrote:
Robin's bounty should definitely higher. How many people can read poneglyphs just Robin? She holds the key to ancient weapons, true history and now possibly the only guide to One Piece. Maybe someone like Roger, aka Luffy, could magic sense to read the poneglyph, but other than that it's just Robin so far.
Yea I never got why her bounty was so low for how high a priority she probably has with WG. Hell she is arguably a higher value target then even Luffy for the WG with the knowledge she has.
|
On March 07 2016 12:15 Slaughter wrote:Show nested quote +On March 07 2016 12:04 BlackMagister wrote:
Robin's bounty should definitely higher. How many people can read poneglyphs just Robin? She holds the key to ancient weapons, true history and now possibly the only guide to One Piece. Maybe someone like Roger, aka Luffy, could magic sense to read the poneglyph, but other than that it's just Robin so far. Yea I never got why her bounty was so low for how high a priority she probably has with WG. Hell she is arguably a higher value target then even Luffy for the WG with the knowledge she has.
Even though everyone and their mom seems to know that Robin can read poneglyphs, her bounty is still ostensibly because she is the demon child from Ohara that destroyed 6 marine ships. It's possible that they don't increase her bounty further, since they don't want to bring too much attention to her, and prefer to leave her arrest to the Cipher Pols.
It is pretty odd though.
|
On March 07 2016 12:04 BlackMagister wrote:
Robin's bounty should definitely higher. How many people can read poneglyphs just Robin? She holds the key to ancient weapons, true history and now possibly the only guide to One Piece. Maybe someone like Roger, aka Luffy, could magic sense to read the poneglyph, but other than that it's just Robin so far.
I think it has been mentioned somewhere in the manga that the WG did not want to draw so much attention to the poneglyph knowledge. Or I may just have remembered it wrongly
|
they dont give a fuck about Raftel though, her value is only the possibility of her activating an ancient weapon that may not even exist in a functional accesible state
|
|
|
wtf how u find this
the clothing looks very wano...
|
At the very least its probably someone who is relevant.
|
Thats a good find man. Very very plausible, don't forget the Kage hat, alot of Naruto mentions on this bigface ninja.
|
On March 05 2016 18:20 LennX wrote:Show nested quote +On March 05 2016 00:02 Shellshock wrote:On March 04 2016 17:47 LennX wrote:
They mentioned only kinemon family of stone masons were able to crave the rocks, so I'm assuming they taught Gol D Rogers how to crave it since he added some stuff into the glyphs during the skypeia arc
Will haki be a requirement for it and who else know how to do it? didn't he carve it into the gold around the ponyglyph and not the glyph itself? I cant remember, I just assumed it was on the glyph
Seems pretty likely that Lord Oden could have just carved it for Rogers.
|
There's a theory I read recently about that picture and in my opinion, it's going to be right.
That guy is Scopper Gaban, the third strongest member of the Roger Pirates. 
You read it here first. He will show up in Wano country.
+ Show Spoiler +
Gold Roger - Top 1
Silvers Rayleigh - Top 2
S copper Gaban - Top 3
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
