• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 03:14
CET 09:14
KST 17:14
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Team Liquid Map Contest #235[ASL22] Finals Preview: Sweet Victory!12[ASL22] Ro4 Preview: Mirror Mirror6[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: Within Reach5[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: In A Tizzy11
Community News
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over1Dark completes military service, returns to SC215[BSL23] RO16 Group Stage20Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?2Weekly Cups (Oct 26 - Nov 1): MaxPax, herO, Solar win0
StarCraft 2
General
Team Liquid Map Contest #23 Dark completes military service, returns to SC2 Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over StarCraft open world shooter announced at BlizzCon No more SC2 streamers on team liquid?
Tourneys
Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament RSL goes to London! 2026 Offline Finals Nov 21-22 Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) Dark returns! GSL CK #7 4v4 Team Battle (Nov 19) soO & FanTaSy return! SC2 Kevin Scrim 4v4 (Nov 16)
Strategy
[H] ZvP Mid-Late Game: Stalkers Collossi HT
Custom Maps
[G] How to playtest arcade maps Starcraft 2 Advance [D] the control group Simple Questions/Answers
External Content
Mutation # 552 Secret Storm The PondCast: SC2 News & Results Mutation # 551 Robotic Revival Mutation # 550 Graveyard Shift
Brood War
General
List of top players active on ShieldBattery BW General Discussion NaDa's Body Shield Battery Server New Patch BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/
Tourneys
SC1 Kevin Scrim hosted by SOOP (Nov 18-19) [IPSL] Winter 26-27 Round of 16! [Megathread] Daily Proleagues 2v2v2v2 Tournament Stage 2: Players
Strategy
Pluto's TvP 5Marine 2Medic Push Simple Questions, Simple Answers Infested Terran strategies in 2026 Nuke strategy worked in K-League 2026-11-09
Other Games
General Games
Nintendo Switch Thread Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Free Space RTS Game, optimised f. Phone/Tablet etc List of Game Threads The PlayStation 5
Dota 2
League of Legends
[TL LoL EUW IHs] Teemo shall perish
Heroes of the Storm
Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Trading/Investing Thread Artificial Intelligence Thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine
Fan Clubs
Fan Club Resource Thread Reynor Fan Club The Flash Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
Football (Soccer) Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Recent Gifted Posts
Blogs
The time I organised my…
AssyrianKing
Why I built Repalyzer (1.1.…
BlueStar
Innovate or Game Over?
TrAiDoS
ShieldBattery on Mac
Kraekkling
Can Bots Beat Pros?? Starcr…
namkraft
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Socialism Anyone?
GreenHorizons
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 15027 users

[TV] HBO Game of Thrones - Page 1753

Forum Index > Media & Entertainment
Post a Reply
Prev 1 1751 1752 1753 1754 1755 1836 Next
All book discussion in this thread is now allowed.
bertolo
Profile Joined June 2010
United States133 Posts
Last Edited: 2019-04-30 19:05:40
April 30 2019 19:04 GMT
#35041
I know a lot of us are confused or upset about this last episode (myself included). Overall after watching it twice I want to say I liked it a lot, maybe more so the second time. I'm really only upset that some people didn't die and mostly about Bran's story and what his role to play was, I agree I think there needs to be some more explanation.

I think before you get mad over it or say its bad we should wait for the conclusion of the season.

It is not much time, but I feel there is a chance that some explanation will be made for Bran that is somewhat satisfying and won't waste him or his potential powers. It may be hoping for too much, but why not.
-Archangel-
Profile Joined May 2010
Croatia7457 Posts
Last Edited: 2019-04-30 19:06:54
April 30 2019 19:06 GMT
#35042
On May 01 2019 02:15 Gorsameth wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 01 2019 02:04 -Archangel- wrote:
On May 01 2019 01:41 Gorsameth wrote:
On May 01 2019 01:38 Requizen wrote:
On May 01 2019 01:23 VHbb wrote:
Well why warging into a dragon if you can warg into anyone?
Just warg into Cersei or someone else and end the war, no?

I don't buy it, I hope they don't have him warging into one of the remaining dragon to do something badass.
I don't think Bran has to *do* something epic to justify his character, though I hope the crows in last episode have some meaning.

He doesn't have to do anything "epic", but he really should do something to justify following this character for 8 seasons. What has his role been? Telling us how the White Walkers came to be? Not really overall important (especially since it had no bearing on defeating them). Warning of the Night King? Jon already knew about him from Hardhome and other places.

If the only point of his character was to tell everyone about the Phantom Menace trick and to be bait... I might honestly frickin scream.
He didn't even need to be bait really. Arya could have sneak attack stabbed the Night king anywhere else.
At this point the entire Brann storyline has basically been useless.

Well Arya could not backstab NK anywhere as NK would not come there in person if Bran was not bait.
Unless you wanted the show to have an even more ridiculous scene where Arya jumps from Jon's dragon to NK and stabs him there..
Not unreasonable he would have walked in just like now when the battle was won.
And to be fair. Arya divebombing off of a dragon would have made about as much sense as her teleporting from off screen now and certainly looked cooler.

Why would he need to walk in? There is nothing of import in Winterfell for him if Bran is not there. Zombies and other WW murder everyone and raise new dead and they move on to South. It is not like he needs Winterfell to spend a night there or pray at its Heart tree. If they would just have him randomly walk in so Arya can backstab him that would be even more stupid.
Logo
Profile Blog Joined April 2010
United States7542 Posts
April 30 2019 19:07 GMT
#35043
On May 01 2019 04:04 bertolo wrote:
I know a lot of us are confused or upset about this last episode (myself included). Overall after watching it twice I want to say I liked it a lot, maybe more so the second time. I'm really only upset that some people didn't die and mostly about Bran's story and what his role to play was, I agree I think there needs to be some more explanation.

I think before you get mad over it or say its bad we should wait for the conclusion of the season.

It is not much time, but I feel there is a chance that some explanation will be made for Bran that is somewhat satisfying and won't waste him or his potential powers. It may be hoping for too much, but why not.


Yeah I still have the stance that it's one of my favorite produced episodes of the series. As a standalone thing I really really enjoyed it, but in terms of writing and fitting into the series as a whole I think it had a ton of problems, but we'll see with the last few episodes.
Logo
solidbebe
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
Netherlands4921 Posts
April 30 2019 19:07 GMT
#35044
On May 01 2019 03:55 Plansix wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 01 2019 03:34 Requizen wrote:
On May 01 2019 03:27 Plansix wrote:
People should avoid using the word “objectively” when talking about personal enjoyment or critiquing any sort of art. It does not make your argument stronger and can imply a basic misunderstanding of critical theory and the purpose of critiquing art as a persuasive argument. The goal of critique is never to convince anyone that a particular reading is the “right” reading. If you read criticism of narrative in movies and books, they don’t talk about good or bad writing. Writing is effective or ineffective. Focused or scattered. Good or bad is insufficient to describe if the writing serves the work.

Alright, then the writing ineffectively brought conclusion to a storyline that was page 1 in 1996 and ineffectively utilized a character that has taken up hours of screentime by having him do nothing against the exact threat that he was built up to stand against. It made the entirety of Bran's arc effectively pointless by having him do nothing he was aiming to do in the only storyline in this web that he's connected to, and effectively left us with half a dozen story threads that will never be answered until GRRM writes the actual conclusion to them.

Objectively bad is quicker to write, though.

And wrong, since the quality of narrative and prose are subjective. In the world of critique of, the only incorrect take is that one point of view is the “true” point of view. The use of the word objectively is anathema to the discussion of art and applying critical theory to works of media.

You're being so pedantic here its insane. There is absolutely an objective component to quality of media. Just because it isn't a hard science doesnt mean that anything you can say about art is completely subjective.
That's the 2nd time in a week I've seen someone sig a quote from this GD and I have never witnessed a sig quote happen in my TL history ever before. -Najda
-Archangel-
Profile Joined May 2010
Croatia7457 Posts
April 30 2019 19:10 GMT
#35045
As for the whole episode I am mostly sad that they solved NK problem in one episode after WW finally started moving south. As I wrote earlier in this topic, I was mostly afraid that WW problem would be solved before last 2 episodes of this season. For something that the show/books opened with, it is a shame that it ended like this.

Also as much as people made fun of Snooke in new Star Wars movies that ended up as a stupid pointless bad guy, WW and NK are now worse in my eyes.
Plansix
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
United States60190 Posts
April 30 2019 19:22 GMT
#35046
On May 01 2019 04:07 solidbebe wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 01 2019 03:55 Plansix wrote:
On May 01 2019 03:34 Requizen wrote:
On May 01 2019 03:27 Plansix wrote:
People should avoid using the word “objectively” when talking about personal enjoyment or critiquing any sort of art. It does not make your argument stronger and can imply a basic misunderstanding of critical theory and the purpose of critiquing art as a persuasive argument. The goal of critique is never to convince anyone that a particular reading is the “right” reading. If you read criticism of narrative in movies and books, they don’t talk about good or bad writing. Writing is effective or ineffective. Focused or scattered. Good or bad is insufficient to describe if the writing serves the work.

Alright, then the writing ineffectively brought conclusion to a storyline that was page 1 in 1996 and ineffectively utilized a character that has taken up hours of screentime by having him do nothing against the exact threat that he was built up to stand against. It made the entirety of Bran's arc effectively pointless by having him do nothing he was aiming to do in the only storyline in this web that he's connected to, and effectively left us with half a dozen story threads that will never be answered until GRRM writes the actual conclusion to them.

Objectively bad is quicker to write, though.

And wrong, since the quality of narrative and prose are subjective. In the world of critique of, the only incorrect take is that one point of view is the “true” point of view. The use of the word objectively is anathema to the discussion of art and applying critical theory to works of media.

You're being so pedantic here its insane. There is absolutely an objective component to quality of media. Just because it isn't a hard science doesnt mean that anything you can say about art is completely subjective.

You are saying you can measure the quality of human experience like someone measure average rain fall? Can we do this with music and paintings too?

I am not really being pedantic at all. Saying something is “objectively good” makes your read on the quality of the work look weak and unsure. It is like saying “I think” in front of an argument that should be a declarative statement. We all know there is no such thing as objectively good or objectively bad media. Some people enjoy trash. Other people are very picky about the films they watch. All their experiences are valid. Removing the word objectively makes your reads on the work stronger, not weaker.
I have the Honor to be your Obedient Servant, P.6
TL+ Member
solidbebe
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
Netherlands4921 Posts
April 30 2019 19:27 GMT
#35047
On May 01 2019 04:22 Plansix wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 01 2019 04:07 solidbebe wrote:
On May 01 2019 03:55 Plansix wrote:
On May 01 2019 03:34 Requizen wrote:
On May 01 2019 03:27 Plansix wrote:
People should avoid using the word “objectively” when talking about personal enjoyment or critiquing any sort of art. It does not make your argument stronger and can imply a basic misunderstanding of critical theory and the purpose of critiquing art as a persuasive argument. The goal of critique is never to convince anyone that a particular reading is the “right” reading. If you read criticism of narrative in movies and books, they don’t talk about good or bad writing. Writing is effective or ineffective. Focused or scattered. Good or bad is insufficient to describe if the writing serves the work.

Alright, then the writing ineffectively brought conclusion to a storyline that was page 1 in 1996 and ineffectively utilized a character that has taken up hours of screentime by having him do nothing against the exact threat that he was built up to stand against. It made the entirety of Bran's arc effectively pointless by having him do nothing he was aiming to do in the only storyline in this web that he's connected to, and effectively left us with half a dozen story threads that will never be answered until GRRM writes the actual conclusion to them.

Objectively bad is quicker to write, though.

And wrong, since the quality of narrative and prose are subjective. In the world of critique of, the only incorrect take is that one point of view is the “true” point of view. The use of the word objectively is anathema to the discussion of art and applying critical theory to works of media.

You're being so pedantic here its insane. There is absolutely an objective component to quality of media. Just because it isn't a hard science doesnt mean that anything you can say about art is completely subjective.

You are saying you can measure the quality of human experience like someone measure average rain fall? Can we do this with music and paintings too?

I am not really being pedantic at all. Saying something is “objectively good” makes your read on the quality of the work look weak and unsure. It is like saying “I think” in front of an argument that should be a declarative statement. We all know there is no such thing as objectively good or objectively bad media. Some people enjoy trash. Other people are very picky about the films they watch. All their experiences are valid. Removing the word objectively makes your reads on the work stronger, not weaker.

The fact that you say "some people enjoy trash" already indicates that there is some form of objective criteria that makes something trash. No, quality is not directly measurable. But a notion of quality clearly exists.
That's the 2nd time in a week I've seen someone sig a quote from this GD and I have never witnessed a sig quote happen in my TL history ever before. -Najda
Requizen
Profile Blog Joined March 2011
United States33802 Posts
April 30 2019 19:38 GMT
#35048
On May 01 2019 04:22 Plansix wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 01 2019 04:07 solidbebe wrote:
On May 01 2019 03:55 Plansix wrote:
On May 01 2019 03:34 Requizen wrote:
On May 01 2019 03:27 Plansix wrote:
People should avoid using the word “objectively” when talking about personal enjoyment or critiquing any sort of art. It does not make your argument stronger and can imply a basic misunderstanding of critical theory and the purpose of critiquing art as a persuasive argument. The goal of critique is never to convince anyone that a particular reading is the “right” reading. If you read criticism of narrative in movies and books, they don’t talk about good or bad writing. Writing is effective or ineffective. Focused or scattered. Good or bad is insufficient to describe if the writing serves the work.

Alright, then the writing ineffectively brought conclusion to a storyline that was page 1 in 1996 and ineffectively utilized a character that has taken up hours of screentime by having him do nothing against the exact threat that he was built up to stand against. It made the entirety of Bran's arc effectively pointless by having him do nothing he was aiming to do in the only storyline in this web that he's connected to, and effectively left us with half a dozen story threads that will never be answered until GRRM writes the actual conclusion to them.

Objectively bad is quicker to write, though.

And wrong, since the quality of narrative and prose are subjective. In the world of critique of, the only incorrect take is that one point of view is the “true” point of view. The use of the word objectively is anathema to the discussion of art and applying critical theory to works of media.

You're being so pedantic here its insane. There is absolutely an objective component to quality of media. Just because it isn't a hard science doesnt mean that anything you can say about art is completely subjective.

You are saying you can measure the quality of human experience like someone measure average rain fall?


Sure! It's a simple calculation.

First, calculate the number of screentime hours dedicated to the plotline. Add in the number of characters directly tied to this plotline who have no other direct purpose in the story other than this particular plotline. Add .5 * any character who is mainly tied to this plotline but has some relevance elsewhere in the story. Add to that the amount of money that was put into marketing this plotline as something important.

Then, calculate all the actual points of resolution that came from this plotline. In this case, that would be 0 since we have no more information about anything related to the Night King, no conclusion to the 3ER storyline, no major character developments that wouldn't have happened in a different sequence (Theon and Jorah would have sacrificed themselves if enemy was the NK or Cersei), and apparently no direct impact on the world whatsoever despite the fact that this was supposed to be the end times.

Now, multiply those two numbers together. You'll note that 0 times anything is often 0, so the narrative quality of the ending of the Long Night storyline was 0.
It's your boy Guzma!
Plansix
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
United States60190 Posts
April 30 2019 19:41 GMT
#35049
On May 01 2019 04:27 solidbebe wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 01 2019 04:22 Plansix wrote:
On May 01 2019 04:07 solidbebe wrote:
On May 01 2019 03:55 Plansix wrote:
On May 01 2019 03:34 Requizen wrote:
On May 01 2019 03:27 Plansix wrote:
People should avoid using the word “objectively” when talking about personal enjoyment or critiquing any sort of art. It does not make your argument stronger and can imply a basic misunderstanding of critical theory and the purpose of critiquing art as a persuasive argument. The goal of critique is never to convince anyone that a particular reading is the “right” reading. If you read criticism of narrative in movies and books, they don’t talk about good or bad writing. Writing is effective or ineffective. Focused or scattered. Good or bad is insufficient to describe if the writing serves the work.

Alright, then the writing ineffectively brought conclusion to a storyline that was page 1 in 1996 and ineffectively utilized a character that has taken up hours of screentime by having him do nothing against the exact threat that he was built up to stand against. It made the entirety of Bran's arc effectively pointless by having him do nothing he was aiming to do in the only storyline in this web that he's connected to, and effectively left us with half a dozen story threads that will never be answered until GRRM writes the actual conclusion to them.

Objectively bad is quicker to write, though.

And wrong, since the quality of narrative and prose are subjective. In the world of critique of, the only incorrect take is that one point of view is the “true” point of view. The use of the word objectively is anathema to the discussion of art and applying critical theory to works of media.

You're being so pedantic here its insane. There is absolutely an objective component to quality of media. Just because it isn't a hard science doesnt mean that anything you can say about art is completely subjective.

You are saying you can measure the quality of human experience like someone measure average rain fall? Can we do this with music and paintings too?

I am not really being pedantic at all. Saying something is “objectively good” makes your read on the quality of the work look weak and unsure. It is like saying “I think” in front of an argument that should be a declarative statement. We all know there is no such thing as objectively good or objectively bad media. Some people enjoy trash. Other people are very picky about the films they watch. All their experiences are valid. Removing the word objectively makes your reads on the work stronger, not weaker.

The fact that you say "some people enjoy trash" already indicates that there is some form of objective criteria that makes something trash. No, quality is not directly measurable. But a notion of quality clearly exists.

How can it be objective if some people enjoy it and other so not? Some of those people think “trash” is good and meritorious. They would like more of the “trash” to be made so they can enjoy more of it. If it was “Objective” it would mean that there is one true perspective that is correct and all others are wrong. It is binary, devoid of nuance.
I have the Honor to be your Obedient Servant, P.6
TL+ Member
Requizen
Profile Blog Joined March 2011
United States33802 Posts
April 30 2019 19:42 GMT
#35050
On May 01 2019 04:41 Plansix wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 01 2019 04:27 solidbebe wrote:
On May 01 2019 04:22 Plansix wrote:
On May 01 2019 04:07 solidbebe wrote:
On May 01 2019 03:55 Plansix wrote:
On May 01 2019 03:34 Requizen wrote:
On May 01 2019 03:27 Plansix wrote:
People should avoid using the word “objectively” when talking about personal enjoyment or critiquing any sort of art. It does not make your argument stronger and can imply a basic misunderstanding of critical theory and the purpose of critiquing art as a persuasive argument. The goal of critique is never to convince anyone that a particular reading is the “right” reading. If you read criticism of narrative in movies and books, they don’t talk about good or bad writing. Writing is effective or ineffective. Focused or scattered. Good or bad is insufficient to describe if the writing serves the work.

Alright, then the writing ineffectively brought conclusion to a storyline that was page 1 in 1996 and ineffectively utilized a character that has taken up hours of screentime by having him do nothing against the exact threat that he was built up to stand against. It made the entirety of Bran's arc effectively pointless by having him do nothing he was aiming to do in the only storyline in this web that he's connected to, and effectively left us with half a dozen story threads that will never be answered until GRRM writes the actual conclusion to them.

Objectively bad is quicker to write, though.

And wrong, since the quality of narrative and prose are subjective. In the world of critique of, the only incorrect take is that one point of view is the “true” point of view. The use of the word objectively is anathema to the discussion of art and applying critical theory to works of media.

You're being so pedantic here its insane. There is absolutely an objective component to quality of media. Just because it isn't a hard science doesnt mean that anything you can say about art is completely subjective.

You are saying you can measure the quality of human experience like someone measure average rain fall? Can we do this with music and paintings too?

I am not really being pedantic at all. Saying something is “objectively good” makes your read on the quality of the work look weak and unsure. It is like saying “I think” in front of an argument that should be a declarative statement. We all know there is no such thing as objectively good or objectively bad media. Some people enjoy trash. Other people are very picky about the films they watch. All their experiences are valid. Removing the word objectively makes your reads on the work stronger, not weaker.

The fact that you say "some people enjoy trash" already indicates that there is some form of objective criteria that makes something trash. No, quality is not directly measurable. But a notion of quality clearly exists.

How can it be objective if some people enjoy it and other so not? Some of those people think “trash” is good and meritorious. They would like more of the “trash” to be made so they can enjoy more of it. If it was “Objective” it would mean that there is one true perspective that is correct and all others are wrong. It is binary, devoid of nuance.

I think his point is that if you call one trash and the other one not trash.... you've kind of answered your own question.
It's your boy Guzma!
Plansix
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
United States60190 Posts
April 30 2019 19:47 GMT
#35051
On May 01 2019 04:42 Requizen wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 01 2019 04:41 Plansix wrote:
On May 01 2019 04:27 solidbebe wrote:
On May 01 2019 04:22 Plansix wrote:
On May 01 2019 04:07 solidbebe wrote:
On May 01 2019 03:55 Plansix wrote:
On May 01 2019 03:34 Requizen wrote:
On May 01 2019 03:27 Plansix wrote:
People should avoid using the word “objectively” when talking about personal enjoyment or critiquing any sort of art. It does not make your argument stronger and can imply a basic misunderstanding of critical theory and the purpose of critiquing art as a persuasive argument. The goal of critique is never to convince anyone that a particular reading is the “right” reading. If you read criticism of narrative in movies and books, they don’t talk about good or bad writing. Writing is effective or ineffective. Focused or scattered. Good or bad is insufficient to describe if the writing serves the work.

Alright, then the writing ineffectively brought conclusion to a storyline that was page 1 in 1996 and ineffectively utilized a character that has taken up hours of screentime by having him do nothing against the exact threat that he was built up to stand against. It made the entirety of Bran's arc effectively pointless by having him do nothing he was aiming to do in the only storyline in this web that he's connected to, and effectively left us with half a dozen story threads that will never be answered until GRRM writes the actual conclusion to them.

Objectively bad is quicker to write, though.

And wrong, since the quality of narrative and prose are subjective. In the world of critique of, the only incorrect take is that one point of view is the “true” point of view. The use of the word objectively is anathema to the discussion of art and applying critical theory to works of media.

You're being so pedantic here its insane. There is absolutely an objective component to quality of media. Just because it isn't a hard science doesnt mean that anything you can say about art is completely subjective.

You are saying you can measure the quality of human experience like someone measure average rain fall? Can we do this with music and paintings too?

I am not really being pedantic at all. Saying something is “objectively good” makes your read on the quality of the work look weak and unsure. It is like saying “I think” in front of an argument that should be a declarative statement. We all know there is no such thing as objectively good or objectively bad media. Some people enjoy trash. Other people are very picky about the films they watch. All their experiences are valid. Removing the word objectively makes your reads on the work stronger, not weaker.

The fact that you say "some people enjoy trash" already indicates that there is some form of objective criteria that makes something trash. No, quality is not directly measurable. But a notion of quality clearly exists.

How can it be objective if some people enjoy it and other so not? Some of those people think “trash” is good and meritorious. They would like more of the “trash” to be made so they can enjoy more of it. If it was “Objective” it would mean that there is one true perspective that is correct and all others are wrong. It is binary, devoid of nuance.

I think his point is that if you call one trash and the other one not trash.... you've kind of answered your own question.

I never said that my assessment of something being trash was objective. I have asserted that it is subjective. The thing that people enjoy can be both trash and not be trash at the same time. To go even further, I can could hold the viewpoint that the art in question is trash and worthy of being shown to the public at the same time. I, personally, could have two conflicting views of a piece of art and both of them could be completely valid and true at the same time.
I have the Honor to be your Obedient Servant, P.6
TL+ Member
Requizen
Profile Blog Joined March 2011
United States33802 Posts
April 30 2019 19:50 GMT
#35052
On May 01 2019 04:47 Plansix wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 01 2019 04:42 Requizen wrote:
On May 01 2019 04:41 Plansix wrote:
On May 01 2019 04:27 solidbebe wrote:
On May 01 2019 04:22 Plansix wrote:
On May 01 2019 04:07 solidbebe wrote:
On May 01 2019 03:55 Plansix wrote:
On May 01 2019 03:34 Requizen wrote:
On May 01 2019 03:27 Plansix wrote:
People should avoid using the word “objectively” when talking about personal enjoyment or critiquing any sort of art. It does not make your argument stronger and can imply a basic misunderstanding of critical theory and the purpose of critiquing art as a persuasive argument. The goal of critique is never to convince anyone that a particular reading is the “right” reading. If you read criticism of narrative in movies and books, they don’t talk about good or bad writing. Writing is effective or ineffective. Focused or scattered. Good or bad is insufficient to describe if the writing serves the work.

Alright, then the writing ineffectively brought conclusion to a storyline that was page 1 in 1996 and ineffectively utilized a character that has taken up hours of screentime by having him do nothing against the exact threat that he was built up to stand against. It made the entirety of Bran's arc effectively pointless by having him do nothing he was aiming to do in the only storyline in this web that he's connected to, and effectively left us with half a dozen story threads that will never be answered until GRRM writes the actual conclusion to them.

Objectively bad is quicker to write, though.

And wrong, since the quality of narrative and prose are subjective. In the world of critique of, the only incorrect take is that one point of view is the “true” point of view. The use of the word objectively is anathema to the discussion of art and applying critical theory to works of media.

You're being so pedantic here its insane. There is absolutely an objective component to quality of media. Just because it isn't a hard science doesnt mean that anything you can say about art is completely subjective.

You are saying you can measure the quality of human experience like someone measure average rain fall? Can we do this with music and paintings too?

I am not really being pedantic at all. Saying something is “objectively good” makes your read on the quality of the work look weak and unsure. It is like saying “I think” in front of an argument that should be a declarative statement. We all know there is no such thing as objectively good or objectively bad media. Some people enjoy trash. Other people are very picky about the films they watch. All their experiences are valid. Removing the word objectively makes your reads on the work stronger, not weaker.

The fact that you say "some people enjoy trash" already indicates that there is some form of objective criteria that makes something trash. No, quality is not directly measurable. But a notion of quality clearly exists.

How can it be objective if some people enjoy it and other so not? Some of those people think “trash” is good and meritorious. They would like more of the “trash” to be made so they can enjoy more of it. If it was “Objective” it would mean that there is one true perspective that is correct and all others are wrong. It is binary, devoid of nuance.

I think his point is that if you call one trash and the other one not trash.... you've kind of answered your own question.

I never said that my assessment of something being trash was objective. I have asserted that it is subjective. The thing that people enjoy can be both trash and not be trash at the same time. To go even further, I can could hold the viewpoint that the art in question is trash and worthy of being shown to the public at the same time. I, personally, could have two conflicting views of a piece of art and both of them could be completely valid and true at the same time.

"This is trash."
"Yeah it is bad, I agree."
"WOAH NOW I DIDN'T SAY IT WAS BAD ONLY THAT IT WAS TRASH."

I'm honestly not sure what it is you're trying to say. That subjective is subjective? Sure. But there's also plenty of things objective about storytelling. The former does not preclude the latter.
It's your boy Guzma!
The_Red_Viper
Profile Blog Joined August 2013
19533 Posts
April 30 2019 19:53 GMT
#35053
Well if you only talk about "good and bad" then yeah, it is binary. In truth the quality of a work is on a spectrum, people use "bad" and "good" for convenience.
Why any sort of 'objectivity' in art exists? Because humans studied art and through that academic and popular discourse we figured out what works and what doesn't work (and everything in between). No there are no 100% rules, but there are techniques and an understanding of what these techniques will create in the audience for the most part.
Appreciating art is a skill in itself as well, kids will like basically anything which isn't too slowly paced, only with more experience that will change, people learn about it in school, they consume more and more different things, and thus a better understanding of it builds.

So yeah, it is not inherently objective, but that isn't required either for having a qualitative assessment of it.
IU | Sohyang || There is no God and we are his prophets | For if ‘Thou mayest’—it is also true that ‘Thou mayest not.” | Ignorance is the parent of fear |
VHbb
Profile Joined October 2014
692 Posts
April 30 2019 19:55 GMT
#35054
Simply that a story can

- be enjoyable for someone (subjective)
- respect some rules / canon (objective)

and the two are not necessarily correlated


And repeating "bad writing" and "lazy writing" seem to imply a subjective opinion on the story based on some objective rules, which is a bit misleading.


E.g. I enjoy Bran's character even if apparently he violates some basic rules of storytelling (to be discussed more, but let's give it for true), does it mean that is character is badly written?
To me, no, it means that he does not respect some rules that might help in writing out a character, but he ended up interesting anyway.
To you, yes, because you don't find his character story compelling or good enough.
My life for Aiur !
Plansix
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
United States60190 Posts
April 30 2019 20:02 GMT
#35055
On May 01 2019 04:50 Requizen wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 01 2019 04:47 Plansix wrote:
On May 01 2019 04:42 Requizen wrote:
On May 01 2019 04:41 Plansix wrote:
On May 01 2019 04:27 solidbebe wrote:
On May 01 2019 04:22 Plansix wrote:
On May 01 2019 04:07 solidbebe wrote:
On May 01 2019 03:55 Plansix wrote:
On May 01 2019 03:34 Requizen wrote:
On May 01 2019 03:27 Plansix wrote:
People should avoid using the word “objectively” when talking about personal enjoyment or critiquing any sort of art. It does not make your argument stronger and can imply a basic misunderstanding of critical theory and the purpose of critiquing art as a persuasive argument. The goal of critique is never to convince anyone that a particular reading is the “right” reading. If you read criticism of narrative in movies and books, they don’t talk about good or bad writing. Writing is effective or ineffective. Focused or scattered. Good or bad is insufficient to describe if the writing serves the work.

Alright, then the writing ineffectively brought conclusion to a storyline that was page 1 in 1996 and ineffectively utilized a character that has taken up hours of screentime by having him do nothing against the exact threat that he was built up to stand against. It made the entirety of Bran's arc effectively pointless by having him do nothing he was aiming to do in the only storyline in this web that he's connected to, and effectively left us with half a dozen story threads that will never be answered until GRRM writes the actual conclusion to them.

Objectively bad is quicker to write, though.

And wrong, since the quality of narrative and prose are subjective. In the world of critique of, the only incorrect take is that one point of view is the “true” point of view. The use of the word objectively is anathema to the discussion of art and applying critical theory to works of media.

You're being so pedantic here its insane. There is absolutely an objective component to quality of media. Just because it isn't a hard science doesnt mean that anything you can say about art is completely subjective.

You are saying you can measure the quality of human experience like someone measure average rain fall? Can we do this with music and paintings too?

I am not really being pedantic at all. Saying something is “objectively good” makes your read on the quality of the work look weak and unsure. It is like saying “I think” in front of an argument that should be a declarative statement. We all know there is no such thing as objectively good or objectively bad media. Some people enjoy trash. Other people are very picky about the films they watch. All their experiences are valid. Removing the word objectively makes your reads on the work stronger, not weaker.

The fact that you say "some people enjoy trash" already indicates that there is some form of objective criteria that makes something trash. No, quality is not directly measurable. But a notion of quality clearly exists.

How can it be objective if some people enjoy it and other so not? Some of those people think “trash” is good and meritorious. They would like more of the “trash” to be made so they can enjoy more of it. If it was “Objective” it would mean that there is one true perspective that is correct and all others are wrong. It is binary, devoid of nuance.

I think his point is that if you call one trash and the other one not trash.... you've kind of answered your own question.

I never said that my assessment of something being trash was objective. I have asserted that it is subjective. The thing that people enjoy can be both trash and not be trash at the same time. To go even further, I can could hold the viewpoint that the art in question is trash and worthy of being shown to the public at the same time. I, personally, could have two conflicting views of a piece of art and both of them could be completely valid and true at the same time.

"This is trash."
"Yeah it is bad, I agree."
"WOAH NOW I DIDN'T SAY IT WAS BAD ONLY THAT IT WAS TRASH."

I'm honestly not sure what it is you're trying to say. That subjective is subjective? Sure. But there's also plenty of things objective about storytelling. The former does not preclude the latter.

Because I don't use trash to describe things that are bad when I talk about movies, shows and music I like. Trash is a descriptor to describe the type of enjoyment I derive from the thing. Stranger Things is trash, for instance. But its really wholesome trash that I love. But its fucking trash. If the art were food, icecream and sweet tarts are trash.

So I know you were trying to be funny, but the reality is the meaning of the word trash in this context is subjective.
I have the Honor to be your Obedient Servant, P.6
TL+ Member
Requizen
Profile Blog Joined March 2011
United States33802 Posts
April 30 2019 20:04 GMT
#35056
On May 01 2019 04:55 VHbb wrote:
Simply that a story can

- be enjoyable for someone (subjective)
- respect some rules / canon (objective)

and the two are not necessarily correlated


And repeating "bad writing" and "lazy writing" seem to imply a subjective opinion on the story based on some objective rules, which is a bit misleading.


E.g. I enjoy Bran's character even if apparently he violates some basic rules of storytelling (to be discussed more, but let's give it for true), does it mean that is character is badly written?
To me, no, it means that he does not respect some rules that might help in writing out a character, but he ended up interesting anyway.
To you, yes, because you don't find his character story compelling or good enough.

I don't see how you could claim that something can violate basic rules and not be bad. If one goes to a marathon and bikes the whole thing, you could say subjectively they are smart for going faster and easier, but they are objectively not following basic rules.

In storytelling, when you break the rules you basically either end up with storylines that don't make sense or ones that don't go anywhere. And it can be an amusing journey, but if it was pointless in the long scheme of things, then all you were doing was padding your word count in order to make something seem more voluminous than it really was. And ASoIAF is not that.
It's your boy Guzma!
VHbb
Profile Joined October 2014
692 Posts
April 30 2019 20:08 GMT
#35057
What does a marathon have to do with telling a story? It's a comparison that makes little sense
Of course you can violate basic rules and not be bad!

I don't even know what the basic rules of writing a story are, and I can still tell if a show is enjoyable, I like it, or not, and for which reasons..
My life for Aiur !
Requizen
Profile Blog Joined March 2011
United States33802 Posts
April 30 2019 20:09 GMT
#35058
On May 01 2019 05:02 Plansix wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 01 2019 04:50 Requizen wrote:
On May 01 2019 04:47 Plansix wrote:
On May 01 2019 04:42 Requizen wrote:
On May 01 2019 04:41 Plansix wrote:
On May 01 2019 04:27 solidbebe wrote:
On May 01 2019 04:22 Plansix wrote:
On May 01 2019 04:07 solidbebe wrote:
On May 01 2019 03:55 Plansix wrote:
On May 01 2019 03:34 Requizen wrote:
[quote]
Alright, then the writing ineffectively brought conclusion to a storyline that was page 1 in 1996 and ineffectively utilized a character that has taken up hours of screentime by having him do nothing against the exact threat that he was built up to stand against. It made the entirety of Bran's arc effectively pointless by having him do nothing he was aiming to do in the only storyline in this web that he's connected to, and effectively left us with half a dozen story threads that will never be answered until GRRM writes the actual conclusion to them.

Objectively bad is quicker to write, though.

And wrong, since the quality of narrative and prose are subjective. In the world of critique of, the only incorrect take is that one point of view is the “true” point of view. The use of the word objectively is anathema to the discussion of art and applying critical theory to works of media.

You're being so pedantic here its insane. There is absolutely an objective component to quality of media. Just because it isn't a hard science doesnt mean that anything you can say about art is completely subjective.

You are saying you can measure the quality of human experience like someone measure average rain fall? Can we do this with music and paintings too?

I am not really being pedantic at all. Saying something is “objectively good” makes your read on the quality of the work look weak and unsure. It is like saying “I think” in front of an argument that should be a declarative statement. We all know there is no such thing as objectively good or objectively bad media. Some people enjoy trash. Other people are very picky about the films they watch. All their experiences are valid. Removing the word objectively makes your reads on the work stronger, not weaker.

The fact that you say "some people enjoy trash" already indicates that there is some form of objective criteria that makes something trash. No, quality is not directly measurable. But a notion of quality clearly exists.

How can it be objective if some people enjoy it and other so not? Some of those people think “trash” is good and meritorious. They would like more of the “trash” to be made so they can enjoy more of it. If it was “Objective” it would mean that there is one true perspective that is correct and all others are wrong. It is binary, devoid of nuance.

I think his point is that if you call one trash and the other one not trash.... you've kind of answered your own question.

I never said that my assessment of something being trash was objective. I have asserted that it is subjective. The thing that people enjoy can be both trash and not be trash at the same time. To go even further, I can could hold the viewpoint that the art in question is trash and worthy of being shown to the public at the same time. I, personally, could have two conflicting views of a piece of art and both of them could be completely valid and true at the same time.

"This is trash."
"Yeah it is bad, I agree."
"WOAH NOW I DIDN'T SAY IT WAS BAD ONLY THAT IT WAS TRASH."

I'm honestly not sure what it is you're trying to say. That subjective is subjective? Sure. But there's also plenty of things objective about storytelling. The former does not preclude the latter.

Because I don't use trash to describe things that are bad when I talk about movies, shows and music I like. Trash is a descriptor to describe the type of enjoyment I derive from the thing. Stranger Things is trash, for instance. But its really wholesome trash that I love. But its fucking trash. If the art were food, icecream and sweet tarts are trash.

So I know you were trying to be funny, but the reality is the meaning of the word trash in this context is subjective.

I can't actually tell if you're trying to honestly convince me that you were using the word trash with no negative connotation. Because... what?

Like yeah you can enjoy trash. Like you said, I enjoy ice cream. I also enjoy trashy pulp action. But they're objectively bad. It can't be trash without being bad in some way, because then we wouldn't call it trash. And there's plenty of things that are bad but enjoyable, but they're still bad.

It's ok to love trash, but calling it "trash you love" and then say it's not bad is so twisty that I think my eyes are pointed backwards in my skull.
It's your boy Guzma!
VHbb
Profile Joined October 2014
692 Posts
April 30 2019 20:10 GMT
#35059
Is it more acceptable if I say

to me Bran's character's arc is bad writing
but it's interesting, compelling and part of an organic story, which I find enjoyable, and fits well in the overall narrative

?
My life for Aiur !
Plansix
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
United States60190 Posts
Last Edited: 2019-04-30 20:20:43
April 30 2019 20:14 GMT
#35060
On May 01 2019 05:09 Requizen wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 01 2019 05:02 Plansix wrote:
On May 01 2019 04:50 Requizen wrote:
On May 01 2019 04:47 Plansix wrote:
On May 01 2019 04:42 Requizen wrote:
On May 01 2019 04:41 Plansix wrote:
On May 01 2019 04:27 solidbebe wrote:
On May 01 2019 04:22 Plansix wrote:
On May 01 2019 04:07 solidbebe wrote:
On May 01 2019 03:55 Plansix wrote:
[quote]
And wrong, since the quality of narrative and prose are subjective. In the world of critique of, the only incorrect take is that one point of view is the “true” point of view. The use of the word objectively is anathema to the discussion of art and applying critical theory to works of media.

You're being so pedantic here its insane. There is absolutely an objective component to quality of media. Just because it isn't a hard science doesnt mean that anything you can say about art is completely subjective.

You are saying you can measure the quality of human experience like someone measure average rain fall? Can we do this with music and paintings too?

I am not really being pedantic at all. Saying something is “objectively good” makes your read on the quality of the work look weak and unsure. It is like saying “I think” in front of an argument that should be a declarative statement. We all know there is no such thing as objectively good or objectively bad media. Some people enjoy trash. Other people are very picky about the films they watch. All their experiences are valid. Removing the word objectively makes your reads on the work stronger, not weaker.

The fact that you say "some people enjoy trash" already indicates that there is some form of objective criteria that makes something trash. No, quality is not directly measurable. But a notion of quality clearly exists.

How can it be objective if some people enjoy it and other so not? Some of those people think “trash” is good and meritorious. They would like more of the “trash” to be made so they can enjoy more of it. If it was “Objective” it would mean that there is one true perspective that is correct and all others are wrong. It is binary, devoid of nuance.

I think his point is that if you call one trash and the other one not trash.... you've kind of answered your own question.

I never said that my assessment of something being trash was objective. I have asserted that it is subjective. The thing that people enjoy can be both trash and not be trash at the same time. To go even further, I can could hold the viewpoint that the art in question is trash and worthy of being shown to the public at the same time. I, personally, could have two conflicting views of a piece of art and both of them could be completely valid and true at the same time.

"This is trash."
"Yeah it is bad, I agree."
"WOAH NOW I DIDN'T SAY IT WAS BAD ONLY THAT IT WAS TRASH."

I'm honestly not sure what it is you're trying to say. That subjective is subjective? Sure. But there's also plenty of things objective about storytelling. The former does not preclude the latter.

Because I don't use trash to describe things that are bad when I talk about movies, shows and music I like. Trash is a descriptor to describe the type of enjoyment I derive from the thing. Stranger Things is trash, for instance. But its really wholesome trash that I love. But its fucking trash. If the art were food, icecream and sweet tarts are trash.

So I know you were trying to be funny, but the reality is the meaning of the word trash in this context is subjective.

I can't actually tell if you're trying to honestly convince me that you were using the word trash with no negative connotation. Because... what?

Like yeah you can enjoy trash. Like you said, I enjoy ice cream. I also enjoy trashy pulp action. But they're objectively bad. It can't be trash without being bad in some way, because then we wouldn't call it trash. And there's plenty of things that are bad but enjoyable, but they're still bad.

It's ok to love trash, but calling it "trash you love" and then say it's not bad is so twisty that I think my eyes are pointed backwards in my skull.

If you enjoy them, how they be objectively bad? What does that even mean? Are you saying your enjoyment doesn’t have value? How can trash be bad when I say it with such endearment and joy?

What you are trying to articulate is that trashy pulp has lacks substance beyond the entertainment you derive from it. It isn’t thought provoking. It doesn’t challenge you or expand your world view. It just entertains you, which has its own merit. Like icecream, which one should not eat all the time. Because it is trash. But sometimes trash is good.

On May 01 2019 05:10 VHbb wrote:
Is it more acceptable if I say

to me Bran's character's arc is bad writing
but it's interesting, compelling and part of an organic story, which I find enjoyable, and fits well in the overall narrative

?

“Bran’s story line didn’t work for me. The route they went with him was to generic and the actor did all the heavy lifting, while also being able to put in any sense of mystery behind his new powers. It was really frustrating because I can see a version of the story that I like, with that actor, but it just wasn’t there. Which only compounded how much it bothered me.”

For me, framing an argument like that is much stronger than using the word “objectively bad” because no one can dispute its validity. It isn’t persuasive, but no one can say it isn’t a thoughtful articulation of what didn’t work in the Bran story line.
I have the Honor to be your Obedient Servant, P.6
TL+ Member
Prev 1 1751 1752 1753 1754 1755 1836 Next
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
Next event in 1h 46m
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
ProTech160
SortOf 136
StarCraft: Brood War
Calm 3699
Bisu 518
ToSsGirL 259
Hyuk 247
Soulkey 125
actioN 94
Snow 79
Larva 40
ZergMaN 21
Barracks 20
[ Show more ]
JYJ 20
Killer 14
sOs 11
Sharp 8
Force[name] 6
League of Legends
JimRising 679
Counter-Strike
shoxiejesuss0
Super Smash Bros
Mew2King65
Heroes of the Storm
Trikslyr43
Other Games
summit1g13344
WinterStarcraft634
ceh9458
Happy248
ViBE56
Organizations
Other Games
gamesdonequick593
[ Show 11 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• iopq 1
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Dota 2
• lizZardDota2218
League of Legends
• Rush1314
Upcoming Events
The PondCast
1h 46m
University League
1h 46m
LiuLi Cup
2h 46m
Rogue vs TBD
Maru vs TBD
OSC
7h 46m
Replay Cast
14h 46m
GSL
1d 3h
Maru vs Dark
Patches Events
1d 5h
OSC
1d 7h
Replay Cast
1d 14h
KCM Race Survival
2 days
[ Show More ]
Ultimate Battle
2 days
ZerO vs Bisu
RSL Revival
3 days
BSL
3 days
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
4 days
IPSL
4 days
Ret vs ggnore13
nOmaD vs Aether
BSL
4 days
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
4 days
WardiTV Weekly
5 days
Kung Fu Cup
6 days
Solar vs Classic
ByuN vs SHIN
PiGosaur Cup
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Proleague 2026-11-16
Blizzard Classic Cup 2026
HCC Season 3

Ongoing

Acropolis #5
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4
International ShieldBattery League
BSL Season 23
IPSL Winter 2026-27
Calamity Cup Div. A Season 8
Underdog Cup 2026 Div 2-3
Stake Ranked Episode 6
BLAST Rivals Fall 2026
IEM Beijing 2026
PGL Masters Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 5
1win Private Club #2
Thunderpick World Champ. '26
ESL Pro League Season 24
Stake Ranked Episode 4
1win Private Club #1
Logitech G Play Connect 2026
SL StarSeries Fall 2026
FISSURE Playground #3
BLAST Open Fall 2026

Upcoming

Sector 591
YSL S4
SC4ALL II: Brood War
NBSL 2026 Xiamen LAN
BSL 23: Non-Korean Championship
HSC XXX
Stellar Fest 2: Lunar Cup
StarCraft2 Weekly Open Tournament 2026 Grand Finals
SC4ALL II: StarCraft II
Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals
RSL Offline Finals
IEM Kraków 2027
PGL Bucharest 2027
BLAST Bounty Winter 2027
PGL Major Singapore 2026
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.