EPT[TV] HBO Game of Thrones - Page 1546
| Forum Index > Media & Entertainment |
All book discussion in this thread is now allowed. | ||
|
Emnjay808
United States10641 Posts
| ||
|
shin_toss
Philippines2589 Posts
| ||
|
Hider
Denmark9342 Posts
As far as the battle goes, I don't blame Jon for charging , they are the attacking force so they needed to attack anyway, they have inferior number and utility (archers, long spears). There is in no way they can lure the Bolton army to charge first either . Well except that Ramsay charged into Stannis. | ||
|
MooMooMugi
United States10531 Posts
| ||
|
shin_toss
Philippines2589 Posts
because they outnumber them largely and they know Stannis army can barely walk Stannis has like 200-300 men, Jon had at least 2000+ | ||
|
Hider
Denmark9342 Posts
On June 20 2016 17:36 shin_toss wrote: because they outnumber them largely and they know Stannis army can barely walk Stannis has like 200-300 men, Jon had at least 2000+ No Stannis lost like half his army. He had 2-3K as well. | ||
|
shin_toss
Philippines2589 Posts
![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/qgvq3cs.jpg) Bolton outnumbered Stannis like this, not even half of his first column,Plus he knows 80%of Stannis has red hp bar. While' Jon's, even tho outnumbered too, they are at least battle-ready and somewhat organized. Ramsey based on his character, wouldn't risk midlessly charging to that | ||
|
FiWiFaKi
Canada9858 Posts
Sansa stormed off, and once she wasn't there, Ramsay said that he didn't feed his dogs in 7 days. Then, when she was feeding him to the hounds, she said "They were, but they haven't been in seven days, you said so yourself". | ||
|
zeross
France310 Posts
Seem like there is some huge difficultys to make such scenes | ||
|
shin_toss
Philippines2589 Posts
On June 20 2016 18:38 FiWiFaKi wrote: Did anyone notice the plothole? Sansa stormed off, and once she wasn't there, Ramsay said that he didn't feed his dogs in 7 days. Then, when she was feeding him to the hounds, she said "They were, but they haven't been in seven days, you said so yourself". Might do a second re watch! | ||
|
LennX
4522 Posts
On June 20 2016 18:38 FiWiFaKi wrote: Did anyone notice the plothole? Sansa stormed off, and once she wasn't there, Ramsay said that he didn't feed his dogs in 7 days. Then, when she was feeding him to the hounds, she said "They were, but they haven't been in seven days, you said so yourself". The "They were" part was in response to Ramsay saying that his hounds were loyal and will never hurt him. | ||
|
Amui
Canada10567 Posts
On June 20 2016 18:41 zeross wrote: I found this interview with this episode director and found it really interesting http://www.ew.com/article/2016/06/19/game-thrones-battle-director Seem like there is some huge difficultys to make such scenes For a TV show, that must've been some endeavor. To think that the scene where Jon is struggling to just breathe came out of just not being able to shoot. Really hammered the idea that the battle was pretty much lost home. I think the dragon's spent a little bit long torching the one ship. Kinda overkilled it by a ton, but I guess you aren't trying to burn the fleet, only convince everybody to surrender. | ||
Yhamm
France7248 Posts
but some many stupid stuff too... the pile of corpses (that was actually so bad), the terrible strategy, and the wildlings army surrounded in such a small area.. it looked so weird I hope Sansa won't act as a bitch with Jon. How she looked at the army when she arrived with Littlefinger and the fact that she never told Jon that the Vale could help, I really hated her at that moment and wished for a lost arrow. | ||
|
Daumen
Germany1073 Posts
I miss that beast  Hoped that Ghost would eat Ramsey | ||
|
Plansix
United States60190 Posts
On June 20 2016 20:07 Daumen wrote: So, what actually happened to Ghost? (Jon Snow's Direwolf). I can't seem to remember, he was there when Jon Snow came back to life, but did he(the wolf) have another appearance after that? I miss that beast Budget. They have enough going on in that episode. | ||
|
Gorsameth
Netherlands21377 Posts
A cavalry charge turning into literal mountains and walls of corpses 3 meters high, an army that quietly stands around while a phalanx completely out of formation encircles them. Yes the actual fighting ect was pretty good by the overall picture, wow that was shit. | ||
|
Plansix
United States60190 Posts
| ||
|
Redox
Germany24794 Posts
I did not like the ending though. That Ramsay death was way too gratuitous. They promote the notion that it is awesome when the bad guy gets tortured to death. And of course it made zero sense how Sansa waited to reveal her Arryn army until her brothers forces were almost wiped out and she could have been pretty certain her brother was dead by then. Would only make sense if she wanted him dead to have no competition for the throne. Unfortunately it was just done for the sake of "suspense" and had no plot reasons. | ||
|
Gorsameth
Netherlands21377 Posts
On June 20 2016 20:23 Redox wrote: Great cinematography this episode. A lot of shots that deserve to be rewatched multiple times to fully appreciate them. I did not like the ending though. That Ramsay death was way too gratuitous. They promote the notion that it is awesome when the bad guy gets tortured to death. And of course it made zero sense how Sansa waited to reveal her Arryn army until her brothers forces were almost wiped out and she could have been pretty certain her brother was dead by then. Would only make sense if she wanted him dead to have no competition for the throne. Unfortunately it was just done for the sake of "suspense" and had no plot reasons. I would guess Sansa's plan was to come in and save the day while the Boltons stormed into the prepared Wildling defenses like the original plan was, but then Sansa should have been horrified when she came onto the scene and saw the plan had gone wrong, instead she stands there with a smug face as she watches her step-brother probably be dead. She wanted to prove that she had value to the men and so didn't want to reveal her trump card. And Ramsay's death smells of fan service. On June 20 2016 20:23 Plansix wrote: The pile of corpses meters high happened in WW1 and other battles, but over a protracted period of time as they fought over a single area. It was a cool effect, but the battled didn't seem long enough for that to happen. Then again, its an hour long TV show. Well yeah if you have battles that last weeks/months where people charge eachother and no one clears the corpses out of no mans land that can happen but not after a single cavalry charge. The entire setup required to created the encircled wildling army is just so preposterous it really detracts from an otherwise great scene. Also bemusing was the Masters 'negotiation'. Their attack made sense, Daenarys was gone, the city was vulnerable but when she comes back surely they remember she has adolescent dragons and they have a fleet of wooden ship. They seemed rather surprised the Mother of Dragons has dragons. Overall a nice episode tho but just a shame of such rather dumb inconsistencies. | ||
|
RowdierBob
Australia12802 Posts
| ||
| ||
