|
On April 06 2015 04:53 FHDH wrote:Show nested quote +On April 06 2015 04:49 govie wrote: If AB would join secret they will kick rtz instead, because he is the weakest link on secret and zai like kky can play any role. Just because he managed to lose as Troll with a magnus --
I guess his transitition from carry mid to standard carry in a more versatile teamsetup is more difficult then expected. I didnt state they are gonna replace him, because in the old line up secet also needed 2/3 months to get in a state of mind where which resulted in 2 back to back tournament wins and more stable results in general.
|
He did play a bit of standard carry on EG when fear started playing puck and all that stuff. I think this is really much more of the teams picks and playstyle rather than rtz's inability to play safelane cause you know puppey picks the same shit every game.
(seriously secret is getting too uninteresting for me as a viewer they pick almost the same heroes majority of the time and they play the same playstyle like 90% of the time .. at least other teams try to mix and match there picks)
|
well they need to be slapped in the face a couple times more than once by Alliance recently and let's see
|
On April 06 2015 08:33 Nikto wrote: well they need to be slapped in the face a couple times more than once by Alliance recently and let's see
I don't think there is a team out there that has more potential than Secret. Like if they can just get their shit together and get Arteezy to care about the game there is no stopping this team. The team consists of only absolute beasts. I know having star players on every position doesn't necessarily mean success but honestly look at these players and what they have done and what they can do. They showed it in DAC group stage with 13-0, like wtf.
No matter how many times Alliance beats secret there still will be no team with the potential of this Team Secret line up.
|
its always funny to see people overreact from a meangningless group stage loss
|
On April 06 2015 10:02 GiveMeYourtTots wrote:Show nested quote +On April 06 2015 08:33 Nikto wrote: well they need to be slapped in the face a couple times more than once by Alliance recently and let's see I don't think there is a team out there that has more potential than Secret. Like if they can just get their shit together and get Arteezy to care about the game there is no stopping this team. The team consists of only absolute beasts. I know having star players on every position doesn't necessarily mean success but honestly look at these players and what they have done and what they can do. They showed it in DAC group stage with 13-0, like wtf. No matter how many times Alliance beats secret there still will be no team with the potential of this Team Secret line up.
Arteezy has stated that he has been motivated ever since joining Secret so I don't think that's the problem.
Although they did well at the DAC group stage, cracks began to appear soon afterward. Make no mistake, Secret is still a very strong team. But unless they develop more strategies, I don't see them winning TI5. Top 6 at most.
|
Arteezy says a lot of stuff.
|
c9 is gonna wins guys accept the fate
(obv some chinese team is gonna own everybody again if we count DAC as TI so the iteration of TI winner this time goes to an eastern team)
|
On April 06 2015 11:40 Nagamundo wrote:Show nested quote +On April 06 2015 10:02 GiveMeYourtTots wrote:On April 06 2015 08:33 Nikto wrote: well they need to be slapped in the face a couple times more than once by Alliance recently and let's see I don't think there is a team out there that has more potential than Secret. Like if they can just get their shit together and get Arteezy to care about the game there is no stopping this team. The team consists of only absolute beasts. I know having star players on every position doesn't necessarily mean success but honestly look at these players and what they have done and what they can do. They showed it in DAC group stage with 13-0, like wtf. No matter how many times Alliance beats secret there still will be no team with the potential of this Team Secret line up. Arteezy has stated that he has been motivated ever since joining Secret so I don't think that's the problem. Although they did well at the DAC group stage, cracks began to appear soon afterward. Make no mistake, Secret is still a very strong team. But unless they develop more strategies, I don't see them winning TI5. Top 6 at most. TOP4 with EG VG IG should be a pretty secure bet?
|
United States13143 Posts
On April 06 2015 21:28 LemOn wrote:Show nested quote +On April 06 2015 11:40 Nagamundo wrote:On April 06 2015 10:02 GiveMeYourtTots wrote:On April 06 2015 08:33 Nikto wrote: well they need to be slapped in the face a couple times more than once by Alliance recently and let's see I don't think there is a team out there that has more potential than Secret. Like if they can just get their shit together and get Arteezy to care about the game there is no stopping this team. The team consists of only absolute beasts. I know having star players on every position doesn't necessarily mean success but honestly look at these players and what they have done and what they can do. They showed it in DAC group stage with 13-0, like wtf. No matter how many times Alliance beats secret there still will be no team with the potential of this Team Secret line up. Arteezy has stated that he has been motivated ever since joining Secret so I don't think that's the problem. Although they did well at the DAC group stage, cracks began to appear soon afterward. Make no mistake, Secret is still a very strong team. But unless they develop more strategies, I don't see them winning TI5. Top 6 at most. TOP4 with EG VG IG should be a pretty secure bet? There's still 4 months to go before TI, a lot can change.
|
On April 06 2015 11:26 Churrass wrote: its always funny to see people overreact from a meangningless group stage loss
It happens in each and every sport
You win: best team in the world You lose: WE SUCK, WE SHOULD DISBAND OMG [insert player name here] SO BAD, RETIRE PLZ
You arent the best for winning a game nor the worst for losing one, chill out...
|
On April 06 2015 11:40 Nagamundo wrote:Show nested quote +On April 06 2015 10:02 GiveMeYourtTots wrote:On April 06 2015 08:33 Nikto wrote: well they need to be slapped in the face a couple times more than once by Alliance recently and let's see I don't think there is a team out there that has more potential than Secret. Like if they can just get their shit together and get Arteezy to care about the game there is no stopping this team. The team consists of only absolute beasts. I know having star players on every position doesn't necessarily mean success but honestly look at these players and what they have done and what they can do. They showed it in DAC group stage with 13-0, like wtf. No matter how many times Alliance beats secret there still will be no team with the potential of this Team Secret line up. Arteezy has stated that he has been motivated ever since joining Secret so I don't think that's the problem. Although they did well at the DAC group stage, cracks began to appear soon afterward. Make no mistake, Secret is still a very strong team. But unless they develop more strategies, I don't see them winning TI5. Top 6 at most.
Yeah, "he stated"... Just look at him when he plays, he doesnt give a fuck about dota.
|
How can you tell that from watching him play lol
|
Problem with secret is that they are playing without a position 1 player, rtz is a mid core(2) and s4 keeps playing utility champs on a safe lane, thus making the team without a hard carry. The time of mid pucks and "million dollar coils" is over and watching s4 play carries(like now against SFZ) is just sad... Either they let zai play that safe lane hard carry and switch s4 to offlane where he can play those utility cores that he was always famous for, or s4 gets booted for someone who can play carries on 1/2 position. For example look at the duos of 1/2 from empire/asus/tinker/IG and many others where both of their 1/2 can play any carry role on any lane.
edit: also add on top of that their draft stage, puppys drafts seem rather poor(he basically lost game 2 vs alliance on draft alone) and as someone mentioned their diversity, they keep playing same heroes every game.
|
On April 07 2015 04:21 Super_Style wrote: Problem with secret is that they are playing without a position 1 player, rtz is a mid core(2) and s4 keeps playing utility champs on a safe lane, thus making the team without a hard carry. The time of mid pucks and "million dollar coils" is over and watching s4 play carries(like now against SFZ) is just sad... Either they let zai play that safe lane hard carry and switch s4 to offlane where he can play those utility cores that he was always famous for, or s4 gets booted for someone who can play carries on 1/2 position. For example look at the duos of 1/2 from empire/asus/tinker/IG and many others where both of their 1/2 can play any carry role on any lane. I agree with part of this but the position 1 mid is a real thing with a successful track record, so your assertion that RTZ is pos 2 because he is mid is just incorrect.
|
On April 07 2015 04:23 FHDH wrote:Show nested quote +On April 07 2015 04:21 Super_Style wrote: Problem with secret is that they are playing without a position 1 player, rtz is a mid core(2) and s4 keeps playing utility champs on a safe lane, thus making the team without a hard carry. The time of mid pucks and "million dollar coils" is over and watching s4 play carries(like now against SFZ) is just sad... Either they let zai play that safe lane hard carry and switch s4 to offlane where he can play those utility cores that he was always famous for, or s4 gets booted for someone who can play carries on 1/2 position. For example look at the duos of 1/2 from empire/asus/tinker/IG and many others where both of their 1/2 can play any carry role on any lane. I agree with part of this but the position 1 mid is a real thing with a successful track record, so your assertion that RTZ is pos 2 because he is mid is just incorrect. Position 1 mid is a real thing if you are for example tinker and have qojqva play medusa mid while black plays troll safe lane or some other carry. Its not secrets playstyle and even if you count rtz as position 1 player, s4 still doesnt even fill the role of position 2 player, he is offlane player who gets safe lane farm at best. Reminds me of navi that forces dendi mid on magnus and plays single carry core setup, havent seen them won a game on that. Just doesnt work.
edit: my point is that there is no position 1 and position 2, its the same role now in this meta, its not even restricted to a specific lane anymore, and im sorry but s4 fills neither.
|
On April 07 2015 04:36 Super_Style wrote:Show nested quote +On April 07 2015 04:23 FHDH wrote:On April 07 2015 04:21 Super_Style wrote: Problem with secret is that they are playing without a position 1 player, rtz is a mid core(2) and s4 keeps playing utility champs on a safe lane, thus making the team without a hard carry. The time of mid pucks and "million dollar coils" is over and watching s4 play carries(like now against SFZ) is just sad... Either they let zai play that safe lane hard carry and switch s4 to offlane where he can play those utility cores that he was always famous for, or s4 gets booted for someone who can play carries on 1/2 position. For example look at the duos of 1/2 from empire/asus/tinker/IG and many others where both of their 1/2 can play any carry role on any lane. I agree with part of this but the position 1 mid is a real thing with a successful track record, so your assertion that RTZ is pos 2 because he is mid is just incorrect. Position 1 mid is a real thing if you are for example tinker and have qojqva play medusa mid while black plays troll safe lane or some other carry. Its not secrets playstyle and even if you count rtz as position 1 player, s4 still doesnt even fill the role of position 2 player, he is offlane player who gets safe lane farm at best. Reminds me of navi that forces dendi mid on magnus and plays single carry core setup, havent seen them won a game on that. Just doesnt work. I think you're confusing terminology. "Position 1" just means it is the hero with top farm priority. This is what Arteezy has played in most of his professional games.
What I believe you're expressing dissatisfaction with is the fact that since Arteezy has taken over position 1 on Secret they have not been running a lot of late game carries. Like Tinker was before the nerf (I mean he still kinda is but the nerfs were fuckin' real). And when they have deviated from this they have shown mixed results.
I don't disagree with this. But you have to be clear about what you mean.
|
On April 07 2015 04:52 FHDH wrote:Show nested quote +On April 07 2015 04:36 Super_Style wrote:On April 07 2015 04:23 FHDH wrote:On April 07 2015 04:21 Super_Style wrote: Problem with secret is that they are playing without a position 1 player, rtz is a mid core(2) and s4 keeps playing utility champs on a safe lane, thus making the team without a hard carry. The time of mid pucks and "million dollar coils" is over and watching s4 play carries(like now against SFZ) is just sad... Either they let zai play that safe lane hard carry and switch s4 to offlane where he can play those utility cores that he was always famous for, or s4 gets booted for someone who can play carries on 1/2 position. For example look at the duos of 1/2 from empire/asus/tinker/IG and many others where both of their 1/2 can play any carry role on any lane. I agree with part of this but the position 1 mid is a real thing with a successful track record, so your assertion that RTZ is pos 2 because he is mid is just incorrect. Position 1 mid is a real thing if you are for example tinker and have qojqva play medusa mid while black plays troll safe lane or some other carry. Its not secrets playstyle and even if you count rtz as position 1 player, s4 still doesnt even fill the role of position 2 player, he is offlane player who gets safe lane farm at best. Reminds me of navi that forces dendi mid on magnus and plays single carry core setup, havent seen them won a game on that. Just doesnt work. I think you're confusing terminology. "Position 1" just means it is the hero with top farm priority. This is what Arteezy has played in most of his professional games. What I believe you're expressing dissatisfaction with is the fact that since Arteezy has taken over position 1 on Secret they have not been running a lot of late game carries. Like Tinker was before the nerf (I mean he still kinda is but the nerfs were fuckin' real). And when they have deviated from this they have shown mixed results. I don't disagree with this. But you have to be clear about what you mean. I guess you are correct, sorry i have trouble expressing my thoughts exactly. However how would you then explain teams like IG, tinker or mostly EG where sumail fills same role as rtz while fear is doing what s4 should be doing. I wouldnt say that either fear or burning have farm priority over ferrari or sumail.
|
On April 07 2015 05:01 Super_Style wrote:Show nested quote +On April 07 2015 04:52 FHDH wrote:On April 07 2015 04:36 Super_Style wrote:On April 07 2015 04:23 FHDH wrote:On April 07 2015 04:21 Super_Style wrote: Problem with secret is that they are playing without a position 1 player, rtz is a mid core(2) and s4 keeps playing utility champs on a safe lane, thus making the team without a hard carry. The time of mid pucks and "million dollar coils" is over and watching s4 play carries(like now against SFZ) is just sad... Either they let zai play that safe lane hard carry and switch s4 to offlane where he can play those utility cores that he was always famous for, or s4 gets booted for someone who can play carries on 1/2 position. For example look at the duos of 1/2 from empire/asus/tinker/IG and many others where both of their 1/2 can play any carry role on any lane. I agree with part of this but the position 1 mid is a real thing with a successful track record, so your assertion that RTZ is pos 2 because he is mid is just incorrect. Position 1 mid is a real thing if you are for example tinker and have qojqva play medusa mid while black plays troll safe lane or some other carry. Its not secrets playstyle and even if you count rtz as position 1 player, s4 still doesnt even fill the role of position 2 player, he is offlane player who gets safe lane farm at best. Reminds me of navi that forces dendi mid on magnus and plays single carry core setup, havent seen them won a game on that. Just doesnt work. I think you're confusing terminology. "Position 1" just means it is the hero with top farm priority. This is what Arteezy has played in most of his professional games. What I believe you're expressing dissatisfaction with is the fact that since Arteezy has taken over position 1 on Secret they have not been running a lot of late game carries. Like Tinker was before the nerf (I mean he still kinda is but the nerfs were fuckin' real). And when they have deviated from this they have shown mixed results. I don't disagree with this. But you have to be clear about what you mean. I guess you are correct, sorry i have trouble expressing my thoughts exactly. However how would you then explain teams like IG, tinker or mostly EG where sumail fills same role as rtz while fear is doing what s4 should be doing. I wouldnt say that either fear or burning have farm priority over ferrari or sumail. I don't watch enough IG to say anything about their current drafting patterns but EG is running similar to Secret. The big difference is they have a farming carry in Fear and, as you say, S4 has been usually running a utility hero from the safelane. When EG is on their game, on the back of SumaiL's play, the enemy team is often on their heels by the time a Fear hero really comes online. In the same time period S4 will be expected to be fighting.
Essentially, Secret has been drafting to win during the mid game, typically speaking. EG has been drafting to have more security late game because their safelane hero is a true carry.
|
On April 07 2015 05:08 FHDH wrote:Show nested quote +On April 07 2015 05:01 Super_Style wrote:On April 07 2015 04:52 FHDH wrote:On April 07 2015 04:36 Super_Style wrote:On April 07 2015 04:23 FHDH wrote:On April 07 2015 04:21 Super_Style wrote: Problem with secret is that they are playing without a position 1 player, rtz is a mid core(2) and s4 keeps playing utility champs on a safe lane, thus making the team without a hard carry. The time of mid pucks and "million dollar coils" is over and watching s4 play carries(like now against SFZ) is just sad... Either they let zai play that safe lane hard carry and switch s4 to offlane where he can play those utility cores that he was always famous for, or s4 gets booted for someone who can play carries on 1/2 position. For example look at the duos of 1/2 from empire/asus/tinker/IG and many others where both of their 1/2 can play any carry role on any lane. I agree with part of this but the position 1 mid is a real thing with a successful track record, so your assertion that RTZ is pos 2 because he is mid is just incorrect. Position 1 mid is a real thing if you are for example tinker and have qojqva play medusa mid while black plays troll safe lane or some other carry. Its not secrets playstyle and even if you count rtz as position 1 player, s4 still doesnt even fill the role of position 2 player, he is offlane player who gets safe lane farm at best. Reminds me of navi that forces dendi mid on magnus and plays single carry core setup, havent seen them won a game on that. Just doesnt work. I think you're confusing terminology. "Position 1" just means it is the hero with top farm priority. This is what Arteezy has played in most of his professional games. What I believe you're expressing dissatisfaction with is the fact that since Arteezy has taken over position 1 on Secret they have not been running a lot of late game carries. Like Tinker was before the nerf (I mean he still kinda is but the nerfs were fuckin' real). And when they have deviated from this they have shown mixed results. I don't disagree with this. But you have to be clear about what you mean. I guess you are correct, sorry i have trouble expressing my thoughts exactly. However how would you then explain teams like IG, tinker or mostly EG where sumail fills same role as rtz while fear is doing what s4 should be doing. I wouldnt say that either fear or burning have farm priority over ferrari or sumail. I don't watch enough IG to say anything about their current drafting patterns but EG is running similar to Secret. The big difference is they have a farming carry in Fear and, as you say, S4 has been usually running a utility hero from the safelane. When EG is on their game, on the back of SumaiL's play, the enemy team is often on their heels by the time a Fear hero really comes online. In the same time period S4 will be expected to be fighting. Essentially, Secret has been drafting to win during the mid game, typically speaking. EG has been drafting to have more security late game because their safelane hero is a true carry. This, i couldnt have said it better so im kinda mind blown how well you put it. Thats exactly how IG also plays, and what secret should play/are trying to play but s4 just doesnt play those heroes on safe lane, and when he does, he performs rather poorly... Look its no secret(no pun intended) that im not a fan of s4, i think hes the most overhyped player atm in dota based on the fact that he won an international and well he is playing on secret. But in the current meta he just has no place in that positon and in this team, that puck and batrider he is most famous for zai plays way better now. Dunno, if we look at like top 8 western teams i dont think any one of those would take him in to replace one of their 1/2 if he wasnt on secret.
|
|
|
|