• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 23:27
CET 05:27
KST 13:27
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Team Liquid Map Contest #234[ASL22] Finals Preview: Sweet Victory!12[ASL22] Ro4 Preview: Mirror Mirror6[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: Within Reach5[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: In A Tizzy11
Community News
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over1Dark completes military service, returns to SC215[BSL23] RO16 Group Stage20Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?2Weekly Cups (Oct 26 - Nov 1): MaxPax, herO, Solar win0
StarCraft 2
General
Team Liquid Map Contest #23 Dark completes military service, returns to SC2 Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over StarCraft open world shooter announced at BlizzCon No more SC2 streamers on team liquid?
Tourneys
Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament RSL goes to London! 2026 Offline Finals Nov 21-22 Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) Dark returns! GSL CK #7 4v4 Team Battle (Nov 19) soO & FanTaSy return! SC2 Kevin Scrim 4v4 (Nov 16)
Strategy
[H] ZvP Mid-Late Game: Stalkers Collossi HT
Custom Maps
[G] How to playtest arcade maps Starcraft 2 Advance [D] the control group Simple Questions/Answers
External Content
Mutation # 552 Secret Storm The PondCast: SC2 News & Results Mutation # 551 Robotic Revival Mutation # 550 Graveyard Shift
Brood War
General
BW General Discussion List of top players active on ShieldBattery NaDa's Body Shield Battery Server New Patch BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/
Tourneys
SC1 Kevin Scrim hosted by SOOP (Nov 18-19) [IPSL] Winter 26-27 Round of 16! [Megathread] Daily Proleagues 2v2v2v2 Tournament Stage 2: Players
Strategy
Pluto's TvP 5Marine 2Medic Push Simple Questions, Simple Answers Infested Terran strategies in 2026 Nuke strategy worked in K-League 2026-11-09
Other Games
General Games
Nintendo Switch Thread Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Free Space RTS Game, optimised f. Phone/Tablet etc List of Game Threads The PlayStation 5
Dota 2
League of Legends
[TL LoL EUW IHs] Teemo shall perish
Heroes of the Storm
Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Trading/Investing Thread Artificial Intelligence Thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine
Fan Clubs
Fan Club Resource Thread Reynor Fan Club The Flash Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
Football (Soccer) Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Recent Gifted Posts
Blogs
The time I organised my…
AssyrianKing
Why I built Repalyzer (1.1.…
BlueStar
Innovate or Game Over?
TrAiDoS
ShieldBattery on Mac
Kraekkling
Can Bots Beat Pros?? Starcr…
namkraft
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Socialism Anyone?
GreenHorizons
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 10389 users

Why Nansha Islands (Spratlys) belongs to China - Page 4

Forum Index > Closed
Post a Reply
Prev 1 2 3 4 5 6 9 10 11 Next All
Kupon3ss
Profile Joined May 2008
時の回廊10066 Posts
June 18 2011 18:39 GMT
#61
On June 19 2011 03:33 Fontong wrote:
So what do undeniable historical claims have to do with anything? I would say both Mexico and Britain have an undeniable historical claim over parts of the US. The difference is that the US is filled with Americans who have been living there for hundreds of years. From your historical timeline, the Nansha Islands have little to no Chinese population, and the Chinese have allowed foreigners to settle there are build strategic bases there for about a hundred years.

On one hand, people shouldn't build things(especially militarily significant things) on land someone else claims. However, I see this as only China's fault if they made no effort to prevent this occurrence, despite the fact that they a great deal of time to do so. Geographically, it looks as though the Philippines have a very logical claim over the area, as well as a national security interest in preventing China from claim islands right of their coast. You should know well that China already puts extreme military pressure on the nations around it, simply by existing.


The Mexican and British claims were both legally accepted and dealt with in the following way
Post the War of Independence, the main disputed lands lay in the Northwestern US, namely Oregon and in Northeastern US, namely Maine. In both cases both nations had laid claims over the same tracts of land at near simultaneous times with little cartography or mapping (in the case of the western part) or with statehood/provincial disputes (in the eastern part), both of the issues were resolved by treaties worked out by the parties

Mexican claims over land that is currently "American" were lost either during the Texan Revolution that made the settlers revolt, claim statehood, and join the United States, and by invasion of the US Army during the American Mexican war, at the end of which the lands were ceded to the United States for a sum of money

When in doubt, just believe in yourself and press buttons
Mordiford
Profile Joined April 2011
4448 Posts
June 18 2011 18:39 GMT
#62
On June 19 2011 03:36 Qi wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 19 2011 03:30 Mordiford wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:28 Qi wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:22 Sufficiency wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:17 Qi wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:12 Sufficiency wrote:
The issue remains that the other South-asian countries have the rights to claim these territories. For example, Vietnam has been part of China for hundreds of years. Once it achieved independence from China, however, it has the rights to make claims of Chinese territories which it believes to be part of Vietnam.

The same already applied to Falkland Island.

Basically, this is not an simple issue to resolve, especially with the consideration of the resources there. I think it's going to be a war there eventually.

Vietnam has no claim to any land outside its mainland. It barely had enough civilization in its mainland when China was already exploring the South China Sea. We hope it doesn't reach war. We want peace. But we also want our rightful claim to these islands. The problem is that other countries are aggressively claiming it without talking to China and respecting history.


Pretty sure that's false. China had minimal presence over these islands.

If you argue this way, then China also had very good claim over Korea and Japan because back then (say 1000-2000 years ago), they were once in some sense Chinese territory or Chinese satellite states, and they weren't "as civilized" as the Chinese then.

You are false. China has been trading with present-day Philippines, Malaysia, Indonesia, and Vietnam way before they even explored outside their immediate waters.
On your second paragraph, the answer is simple. China is not making any claims about Korea or Japan. So it's irrelevant to talk about it, right?


This goes back to my earlier statement though, if China made a claim to Korea or Japan, should we all get behind them since they have historical claim there? I feel this is kind of strange.

If the Island's went undisputed, good for China, but since they are being disputed, I think their claim to Islands based on historical precedent is somewhat irrelevant.

I do not understand why you think it is irrelevant. So I will try to illustrate. China has for more then 2000 years has record and claim of these islands. These records go all the way back even before some countries now are countries at all. Suddenly, one country claims that these islands are theirs simply because it's closer to them.
I understand that this issue is not easy. But my logic tells me that between the two, I'd believe someone who has a (longer) record of being there and it being officially part of its geography.


I don't think historical claim is very relevant to this situation, I feel Fontong aptly elaborates on my feelings in this regard.
semantics
Profile Blog Joined November 2009
10040 Posts
June 18 2011 18:42 GMT
#63
On June 19 2011 03:08 seaofsaturn wrote:
The only thing your Historical Records show is that the islands have always been contested by various countries (including Europeans) and that the only reason that China has maintained them is through its sheer power.

The difference from the Alaska example is that it hasn't been continuously contested. It was sold and obtained amicably, all sides were in agreement.

edit:
Also, how does the fact that Britain and other European countries still have territories everywhere make it right? The territories with any power at all(India, USA) have claimed their independence.

I am not taking either side, I am just pointing to the flaw in your logic in certain points.

This is always the problem with water lines, land that people live on becomes a bit simpler as they seeker their own independence or not. But countries always drew lines in the water to how ever they see fit. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_territorial_disputes
Qi
Profile Joined June 2011
China31 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-06-18 18:44:50
June 18 2011 18:44 GMT
#64
On June 19 2011 03:37 Sufficiency wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 19 2011 03:28 Qi wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:22 Sufficiency wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:17 Qi wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:12 Sufficiency wrote:
The issue remains that the other South-asian countries have the rights to claim these territories. For example, Vietnam has been part of China for hundreds of years. Once it achieved independence from China, however, it has the rights to make claims of Chinese territories which it believes to be part of Vietnam.

The same already applied to Falkland Island.

Basically, this is not an simple issue to resolve, especially with the consideration of the resources there. I think it's going to be a war there eventually.

Vietnam has no claim to any land outside its mainland. It barely had enough civilization in its mainland when China was already exploring the South China Sea. We hope it doesn't reach war. We want peace. But we also want our rightful claim to these islands. The problem is that other countries are aggressively claiming it without talking to China and respecting history.


Pretty sure that's false. China had minimal presence over these islands.

If you argue this way, then China also had very good claim over Korea and Japan because back then (say 1000-2000 years ago), they were once in some sense Chinese territory or Chinese satellite states, and they weren't "as civilized" as the Chinese then.

You are false. China has been trading with present-day Philippines, Malaysia, Indonesia, and Vietnam way before they even explored outside their immediate waters.
On your second paragraph, the answer is simple. China is not making any claims about Korea or Japan. So it's irrelevant to talk about it, right?


I am sorry, but I don't see how trading with a country has anything to do with that country not exploring its nearby islands.

As for your second paragraph, Tibet DOES claim sovereign of the the so-called Autonomic Tibet Territory. Their presence over Tibet has been around before 1600AD, and China did trade with it and interacted with it.

So yea, there is no way to solve it unless there is a war. Your claim that China wants to revolve this peacefully is complete bogus.

Let me simplify for you then. If Vietnam did not even explore more that 10 meters off its coast when China was already on mercantile relationship with most of the South East Asian countries, how could YOU claim that Vietnam has claims over these islands? It didn't even know they existed when China was already mapping them as part of its territory.
On your Tibet argument, it is true, but there is a bigger truth, Tibet is China. Officially. Recognized even by the UN. Until Tibet becomes a separate country, all so-called Tibet territories remain China's. When Tibet does become separate, it will be my honor to post it here.
On your third paragraph, I do not understand why you'd say that. Are you privy to the Chinese government that you know their plans?
Sufficiency
Profile Blog Joined October 2010
Canada23833 Posts
June 18 2011 18:48 GMT
#65
On June 19 2011 03:44 Qi wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 19 2011 03:37 Sufficiency wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:28 Qi wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:22 Sufficiency wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:17 Qi wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:12 Sufficiency wrote:
The issue remains that the other South-asian countries have the rights to claim these territories. For example, Vietnam has been part of China for hundreds of years. Once it achieved independence from China, however, it has the rights to make claims of Chinese territories which it believes to be part of Vietnam.

The same already applied to Falkland Island.

Basically, this is not an simple issue to resolve, especially with the consideration of the resources there. I think it's going to be a war there eventually.

Vietnam has no claim to any land outside its mainland. It barely had enough civilization in its mainland when China was already exploring the South China Sea. We hope it doesn't reach war. We want peace. But we also want our rightful claim to these islands. The problem is that other countries are aggressively claiming it without talking to China and respecting history.


Pretty sure that's false. China had minimal presence over these islands.

If you argue this way, then China also had very good claim over Korea and Japan because back then (say 1000-2000 years ago), they were once in some sense Chinese territory or Chinese satellite states, and they weren't "as civilized" as the Chinese then.

You are false. China has been trading with present-day Philippines, Malaysia, Indonesia, and Vietnam way before they even explored outside their immediate waters.
On your second paragraph, the answer is simple. China is not making any claims about Korea or Japan. So it's irrelevant to talk about it, right?


I am sorry, but I don't see how trading with a country has anything to do with that country not exploring its nearby islands.

As for your second paragraph, Tibet DOES claim sovereign of the the so-called Autonomic Tibet Territory. Their presence over Tibet has been around before 1600AD, and China did trade with it and interacted with it.

So yea, there is no way to solve it unless there is a war. Your claim that China wants to revolve this peacefully is complete bogus.

Let me simplify for you then. If Vietnam did not even explore more that 10 meters off its coast when China was already on mercantile relationship with most of the South East Asian countries, how could YOU claim that Vietnam has claims over these islands? It didn't even know they existed when China was already mapping them as part of its territory.
On your Tibet argument, it is true, but there is a bigger truth, Tibet is China. Officially. Recognized even by the UN. Until Tibet becomes a separate country, all so-called Tibet territories remain China's. When Tibet does become separate, it will be my honor to post it here.
On your third paragraph, I do not understand why you'd say that. Are you privy to the Chinese government that you know their plans?


You have not shown us, or probably never bothered, to research any Vietnamese records. Are you but merely automatically assuming that they were so barbaric that they never bothered to check out the islands 10 meters off its coast?

https://twitter.com/SufficientStats
Kupon3ss
Profile Joined May 2008
時の回廊10066 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-06-18 18:51:15
June 18 2011 18:50 GMT
#66
On June 19 2011 03:48 Sufficiency wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 19 2011 03:44 Qi wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:37 Sufficiency wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:28 Qi wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:22 Sufficiency wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:17 Qi wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:12 Sufficiency wrote:
The issue remains that the other South-asian countries have the rights to claim these territories. For example, Vietnam has been part of China for hundreds of years. Once it achieved independence from China, however, it has the rights to make claims of Chinese territories which it believes to be part of Vietnam.

The same already applied to Falkland Island.

Basically, this is not an simple issue to resolve, especially with the consideration of the resources there. I think it's going to be a war there eventually.

Vietnam has no claim to any land outside its mainland. It barely had enough civilization in its mainland when China was already exploring the South China Sea. We hope it doesn't reach war. We want peace. But we also want our rightful claim to these islands. The problem is that other countries are aggressively claiming it without talking to China and respecting history.


Pretty sure that's false. China had minimal presence over these islands.

If you argue this way, then China also had very good claim over Korea and Japan because back then (say 1000-2000 years ago), they were once in some sense Chinese territory or Chinese satellite states, and they weren't "as civilized" as the Chinese then.

You are false. China has been trading with present-day Philippines, Malaysia, Indonesia, and Vietnam way before they even explored outside their immediate waters.
On your second paragraph, the answer is simple. China is not making any claims about Korea or Japan. So it's irrelevant to talk about it, right?


I am sorry, but I don't see how trading with a country has anything to do with that country not exploring its nearby islands.

As for your second paragraph, Tibet DOES claim sovereign of the the so-called Autonomic Tibet Territory. Their presence over Tibet has been around before 1600AD, and China did trade with it and interacted with it.

So yea, there is no way to solve it unless there is a war. Your claim that China wants to revolve this peacefully is complete bogus.

Let me simplify for you then. If Vietnam did not even explore more that 10 meters off its coast when China was already on mercantile relationship with most of the South East Asian countries, how could YOU claim that Vietnam has claims over these islands? It didn't even know they existed when China was already mapping them as part of its territory.
On your Tibet argument, it is true, but there is a bigger truth, Tibet is China. Officially. Recognized even by the UN. Until Tibet becomes a separate country, all so-called Tibet territories remain China's. When Tibet does become separate, it will be my honor to post it here.
On your third paragraph, I do not understand why you'd say that. Are you privy to the Chinese government that you know their plans?


You have not shown us, or probably never bothered, to research any Vietnamese records. Are you but merely automatically assuming that they were so barbaric that they never bothered to check out the islands 10 meters off its coast?



Wikipedia summary
+ Show Spoiler +
Ancient Chinese maps record the "Thousand Li Stretch of Sands"; Qianli Changsha (千里長沙) and the "Ten-Thousand Li of Stone Pools"; Wanli Shitang (萬里石塘),[7] which China today claims refers to the Spratly Islands. The Wanli Shitang have been explored by the Chinese since the Yuan Dynasty and may have been considered by them to have been within their national boundaries. [8][9] They are also referenced in the 13th century,[10] followed by the Ming Dynasty.[11] When the Ming Dynasty collapsed, the Qing Dynasty continued to include the territory in maps compiled in 1724,[12] 1755,[13] 1767,[14] 1810,[15] and 1817.[16] A Vietnamese map from 1834 also includes the Spratly Islands clumped in with the Paracels (a common occurrence on maps of that time) labeled as "Wanli Changsha".[17]
According to Hanoi, old Vietnamese maps record Bãi Cát Vàng (Golden Sandbanks, referring to both Paracels and the Spratly Islands) which lay near the Coast of the central Vietnam as early as 1838.[18] In Phủ Biên Tạp Lục (Frontier Chronicles) by the scholar Le Quy Don, Hoàng Sa and Trường Sa were defined as belonging to Quảng Ngãi District. He described it as where sea products and shipwrecked cargoes were available to be collected. Vietnamese text written in the 17th century referenced government-sponsored economic activities during the Le Dynasty, 200 years earlier. The Vietnamese government conducted several geographical surveys of the islands in the 18th century.[18]


From wikipedia
Basically, the islands were mapped and claimed by China since at least 1000 AD while any comparable Vietnamese claim occurs post 1800 at the earliest
When in doubt, just believe in yourself and press buttons
Mordiford
Profile Joined April 2011
4448 Posts
June 18 2011 18:53 GMT
#67
On June 19 2011 03:50 Kupon3ss wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 19 2011 03:48 Sufficiency wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:44 Qi wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:37 Sufficiency wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:28 Qi wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:22 Sufficiency wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:17 Qi wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:12 Sufficiency wrote:
The issue remains that the other South-asian countries have the rights to claim these territories. For example, Vietnam has been part of China for hundreds of years. Once it achieved independence from China, however, it has the rights to make claims of Chinese territories which it believes to be part of Vietnam.

The same already applied to Falkland Island.

Basically, this is not an simple issue to resolve, especially with the consideration of the resources there. I think it's going to be a war there eventually.

Vietnam has no claim to any land outside its mainland. It barely had enough civilization in its mainland when China was already exploring the South China Sea. We hope it doesn't reach war. We want peace. But we also want our rightful claim to these islands. The problem is that other countries are aggressively claiming it without talking to China and respecting history.


Pretty sure that's false. China had minimal presence over these islands.

If you argue this way, then China also had very good claim over Korea and Japan because back then (say 1000-2000 years ago), they were once in some sense Chinese territory or Chinese satellite states, and they weren't "as civilized" as the Chinese then.

You are false. China has been trading with present-day Philippines, Malaysia, Indonesia, and Vietnam way before they even explored outside their immediate waters.
On your second paragraph, the answer is simple. China is not making any claims about Korea or Japan. So it's irrelevant to talk about it, right?


I am sorry, but I don't see how trading with a country has anything to do with that country not exploring its nearby islands.

As for your second paragraph, Tibet DOES claim sovereign of the the so-called Autonomic Tibet Territory. Their presence over Tibet has been around before 1600AD, and China did trade with it and interacted with it.

So yea, there is no way to solve it unless there is a war. Your claim that China wants to revolve this peacefully is complete bogus.

Let me simplify for you then. If Vietnam did not even explore more that 10 meters off its coast when China was already on mercantile relationship with most of the South East Asian countries, how could YOU claim that Vietnam has claims over these islands? It didn't even know they existed when China was already mapping them as part of its territory.
On your Tibet argument, it is true, but there is a bigger truth, Tibet is China. Officially. Recognized even by the UN. Until Tibet becomes a separate country, all so-called Tibet territories remain China's. When Tibet does become separate, it will be my honor to post it here.
On your third paragraph, I do not understand why you'd say that. Are you privy to the Chinese government that you know their plans?


You have not shown us, or probably never bothered, to research any Vietnamese records. Are you but merely automatically assuming that they were so barbaric that they never bothered to check out the islands 10 meters off its coast?



Wikipedia summary
+ Show Spoiler +
Ancient Chinese maps record the "Thousand Li Stretch of Sands"; Qianli Changsha (千里長沙) and the "Ten-Thousand Li of Stone Pools"; Wanli Shitang (萬里石塘),[7] which China today claims refers to the Spratly Islands. The Wanli Shitang have been explored by the Chinese since the Yuan Dynasty and may have been considered by them to have been within their national boundaries. [8][9] They are also referenced in the 13th century,[10] followed by the Ming Dynasty.[11] When the Ming Dynasty collapsed, the Qing Dynasty continued to include the territory in maps compiled in 1724,[12] 1755,[13] 1767,[14] 1810,[15] and 1817.[16] A Vietnamese map from 1834 also includes the Spratly Islands clumped in with the Paracels (a common occurrence on maps of that time) labeled as "Wanli Changsha".[17]
According to Hanoi, old Vietnamese maps record Bãi Cát Vàng (Golden Sandbanks, referring to both Paracels and the Spratly Islands) which lay near the Coast of the central Vietnam as early as 1838.[18] In Phủ Biên Tạp Lục (Frontier Chronicles) by the scholar Le Quy Don, Hoàng Sa and Trường Sa were defined as belonging to Quảng Ngãi District. He described it as where sea products and shipwrecked cargoes were available to be collected. Vietnamese text written in the 17th century referenced government-sponsored economic activities during the Le Dynasty, 200 years earlier. The Vietnamese government conducted several geographical surveys of the islands in the 18th century.[18]


From wikipedia
Basically, the islands were mapped and claimed by China since at least 1000 AD while any comparable Vietnamese claim occurs post 1800 at the earliest


Yeah, but as people have drawn comparisons, people explored quite a bit throughout history, I'm wondering what the actual populace of the Islands consists of. I don't think the historical claim is that substantial, nor is it really relevant.
Waxangel
Profile Blog Joined September 2002
United States33717 Posts
June 18 2011 18:55 GMT
#68
Ughh... I summon moltke!
AdministratorHey HP can you redo everything youve ever done because i have a small complaint?
Qi
Profile Joined June 2011
China31 Posts
June 18 2011 18:55 GMT
#69
On June 19 2011 03:48 Sufficiency wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 19 2011 03:44 Qi wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:37 Sufficiency wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:28 Qi wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:22 Sufficiency wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:17 Qi wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:12 Sufficiency wrote:
The issue remains that the other South-asian countries have the rights to claim these territories. For example, Vietnam has been part of China for hundreds of years. Once it achieved independence from China, however, it has the rights to make claims of Chinese territories which it believes to be part of Vietnam.

The same already applied to Falkland Island.

Basically, this is not an simple issue to resolve, especially with the consideration of the resources there. I think it's going to be a war there eventually.

Vietnam has no claim to any land outside its mainland. It barely had enough civilization in its mainland when China was already exploring the South China Sea. We hope it doesn't reach war. We want peace. But we also want our rightful claim to these islands. The problem is that other countries are aggressively claiming it without talking to China and respecting history.


Pretty sure that's false. China had minimal presence over these islands.

If you argue this way, then China also had very good claim over Korea and Japan because back then (say 1000-2000 years ago), they were once in some sense Chinese territory or Chinese satellite states, and they weren't "as civilized" as the Chinese then.

You are false. China has been trading with present-day Philippines, Malaysia, Indonesia, and Vietnam way before they even explored outside their immediate waters.
On your second paragraph, the answer is simple. China is not making any claims about Korea or Japan. So it's irrelevant to talk about it, right?


I am sorry, but I don't see how trading with a country has anything to do with that country not exploring its nearby islands.

As for your second paragraph, Tibet DOES claim sovereign of the the so-called Autonomic Tibet Territory. Their presence over Tibet has been around before 1600AD, and China did trade with it and interacted with it.

So yea, there is no way to solve it unless there is a war. Your claim that China wants to revolve this peacefully is complete bogus.

Let me simplify for you then. If Vietnam did not even explore more that 10 meters off its coast when China was already on mercantile relationship with most of the South East Asian countries, how could YOU claim that Vietnam has claims over these islands? It didn't even know they existed when China was already mapping them as part of its territory.
On your Tibet argument, it is true, but there is a bigger truth, Tibet is China. Officially. Recognized even by the UN. Until Tibet becomes a separate country, all so-called Tibet territories remain China's. When Tibet does become separate, it will be my honor to post it here.
On your third paragraph, I do not understand why you'd say that. Are you privy to the Chinese government that you know their plans?


You have not shown us, or probably never bothered, to research any Vietnamese records. Are you but merely automatically assuming that they were so barbaric that they never bothered to check out the islands 10 meters off its coast?


Please dont use "barbaric". It's loaded and not desired for our discussion. I am simply stating historical facts. Read the post by Kupon above for a start.
Fruscainte
Profile Blog Joined December 2009
4596 Posts
June 18 2011 18:55 GMT
#70
On June 19 2011 03:53 Mordiford wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 19 2011 03:50 Kupon3ss wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:48 Sufficiency wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:44 Qi wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:37 Sufficiency wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:28 Qi wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:22 Sufficiency wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:17 Qi wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:12 Sufficiency wrote:
The issue remains that the other South-asian countries have the rights to claim these territories. For example, Vietnam has been part of China for hundreds of years. Once it achieved independence from China, however, it has the rights to make claims of Chinese territories which it believes to be part of Vietnam.

The same already applied to Falkland Island.

Basically, this is not an simple issue to resolve, especially with the consideration of the resources there. I think it's going to be a war there eventually.

Vietnam has no claim to any land outside its mainland. It barely had enough civilization in its mainland when China was already exploring the South China Sea. We hope it doesn't reach war. We want peace. But we also want our rightful claim to these islands. The problem is that other countries are aggressively claiming it without talking to China and respecting history.


Pretty sure that's false. China had minimal presence over these islands.

If you argue this way, then China also had very good claim over Korea and Japan because back then (say 1000-2000 years ago), they were once in some sense Chinese territory or Chinese satellite states, and they weren't "as civilized" as the Chinese then.

You are false. China has been trading with present-day Philippines, Malaysia, Indonesia, and Vietnam way before they even explored outside their immediate waters.
On your second paragraph, the answer is simple. China is not making any claims about Korea or Japan. So it's irrelevant to talk about it, right?


I am sorry, but I don't see how trading with a country has anything to do with that country not exploring its nearby islands.

As for your second paragraph, Tibet DOES claim sovereign of the the so-called Autonomic Tibet Territory. Their presence over Tibet has been around before 1600AD, and China did trade with it and interacted with it.

So yea, there is no way to solve it unless there is a war. Your claim that China wants to revolve this peacefully is complete bogus.

Let me simplify for you then. If Vietnam did not even explore more that 10 meters off its coast when China was already on mercantile relationship with most of the South East Asian countries, how could YOU claim that Vietnam has claims over these islands? It didn't even know they existed when China was already mapping them as part of its territory.
On your Tibet argument, it is true, but there is a bigger truth, Tibet is China. Officially. Recognized even by the UN. Until Tibet becomes a separate country, all so-called Tibet territories remain China's. When Tibet does become separate, it will be my honor to post it here.
On your third paragraph, I do not understand why you'd say that. Are you privy to the Chinese government that you know their plans?


You have not shown us, or probably never bothered, to research any Vietnamese records. Are you but merely automatically assuming that they were so barbaric that they never bothered to check out the islands 10 meters off its coast?



Wikipedia summary
+ Show Spoiler +
Ancient Chinese maps record the "Thousand Li Stretch of Sands"; Qianli Changsha (千里長沙) and the "Ten-Thousand Li of Stone Pools"; Wanli Shitang (萬里石塘),[7] which China today claims refers to the Spratly Islands. The Wanli Shitang have been explored by the Chinese since the Yuan Dynasty and may have been considered by them to have been within their national boundaries. [8][9] They are also referenced in the 13th century,[10] followed by the Ming Dynasty.[11] When the Ming Dynasty collapsed, the Qing Dynasty continued to include the territory in maps compiled in 1724,[12] 1755,[13] 1767,[14] 1810,[15] and 1817.[16] A Vietnamese map from 1834 also includes the Spratly Islands clumped in with the Paracels (a common occurrence on maps of that time) labeled as "Wanli Changsha".[17]
According to Hanoi, old Vietnamese maps record Bãi Cát Vàng (Golden Sandbanks, referring to both Paracels and the Spratly Islands) which lay near the Coast of the central Vietnam as early as 1838.[18] In Phủ Biên Tạp Lục (Frontier Chronicles) by the scholar Le Quy Don, Hoàng Sa and Trường Sa were defined as belonging to Quảng Ngãi District. He described it as where sea products and shipwrecked cargoes were available to be collected. Vietnamese text written in the 17th century referenced government-sponsored economic activities during the Le Dynasty, 200 years earlier. The Vietnamese government conducted several geographical surveys of the islands in the 18th century.[18]


From wikipedia
Basically, the islands were mapped and claimed by China since at least 1000 AD while any comparable Vietnamese claim occurs post 1800 at the earliest


Yeah, but as people have drawn comparisons, people explored quite a bit throughout history, I'm wondering what the actual populace of the Islands consists of. I don't think the historical claim is that substantial, nor is it really relevant.


Way to completely fall back.

Someone questioned the legitimacy of the comment of Vietnam not exploring those islands before China. A source was given that says China explored them 800 years before Vietnam, and now you say "OH IT DOESNT MATTER"
pissingwildly
Profile Joined June 2011
12 Posts
June 18 2011 18:55 GMT
#71
The modern Chinese nation-state simply did not exist during the time period you are talking about. Furthermore these claims hinge on the definition of a "Chinese people" that has changed wildly over time. The arguments presented can be summarily dismissed.
derp
Mordiford
Profile Joined April 2011
4448 Posts
June 18 2011 18:57 GMT
#72
On June 19 2011 03:55 Fruscainte wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 19 2011 03:53 Mordiford wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:50 Kupon3ss wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:48 Sufficiency wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:44 Qi wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:37 Sufficiency wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:28 Qi wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:22 Sufficiency wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:17 Qi wrote:
On June 19 2011 03:12 Sufficiency wrote:
The issue remains that the other South-asian countries have the rights to claim these territories. For example, Vietnam has been part of China for hundreds of years. Once it achieved independence from China, however, it has the rights to make claims of Chinese territories which it believes to be part of Vietnam.

The same already applied to Falkland Island.

Basically, this is not an simple issue to resolve, especially with the consideration of the resources there. I think it's going to be a war there eventually.

Vietnam has no claim to any land outside its mainland. It barely had enough civilization in its mainland when China was already exploring the South China Sea. We hope it doesn't reach war. We want peace. But we also want our rightful claim to these islands. The problem is that other countries are aggressively claiming it without talking to China and respecting history.


Pretty sure that's false. China had minimal presence over these islands.

If you argue this way, then China also had very good claim over Korea and Japan because back then (say 1000-2000 years ago), they were once in some sense Chinese territory or Chinese satellite states, and they weren't "as civilized" as the Chinese then.

You are false. China has been trading with present-day Philippines, Malaysia, Indonesia, and Vietnam way before they even explored outside their immediate waters.
On your second paragraph, the answer is simple. China is not making any claims about Korea or Japan. So it's irrelevant to talk about it, right?


I am sorry, but I don't see how trading with a country has anything to do with that country not exploring its nearby islands.

As for your second paragraph, Tibet DOES claim sovereign of the the so-called Autonomic Tibet Territory. Their presence over Tibet has been around before 1600AD, and China did trade with it and interacted with it.

So yea, there is no way to solve it unless there is a war. Your claim that China wants to revolve this peacefully is complete bogus.

Let me simplify for you then. If Vietnam did not even explore more that 10 meters off its coast when China was already on mercantile relationship with most of the South East Asian countries, how could YOU claim that Vietnam has claims over these islands? It didn't even know they existed when China was already mapping them as part of its territory.
On your Tibet argument, it is true, but there is a bigger truth, Tibet is China. Officially. Recognized even by the UN. Until Tibet becomes a separate country, all so-called Tibet territories remain China's. When Tibet does become separate, it will be my honor to post it here.
On your third paragraph, I do not understand why you'd say that. Are you privy to the Chinese government that you know their plans?


You have not shown us, or probably never bothered, to research any Vietnamese records. Are you but merely automatically assuming that they were so barbaric that they never bothered to check out the islands 10 meters off its coast?



Wikipedia summary
+ Show Spoiler +
Ancient Chinese maps record the "Thousand Li Stretch of Sands"; Qianli Changsha (千里長沙) and the "Ten-Thousand Li of Stone Pools"; Wanli Shitang (萬里石塘),[7] which China today claims refers to the Spratly Islands. The Wanli Shitang have been explored by the Chinese since the Yuan Dynasty and may have been considered by them to have been within their national boundaries. [8][9] They are also referenced in the 13th century,[10] followed by the Ming Dynasty.[11] When the Ming Dynasty collapsed, the Qing Dynasty continued to include the territory in maps compiled in 1724,[12] 1755,[13] 1767,[14] 1810,[15] and 1817.[16] A Vietnamese map from 1834 also includes the Spratly Islands clumped in with the Paracels (a common occurrence on maps of that time) labeled as "Wanli Changsha".[17]
According to Hanoi, old Vietnamese maps record Bãi Cát Vàng (Golden Sandbanks, referring to both Paracels and the Spratly Islands) which lay near the Coast of the central Vietnam as early as 1838.[18] In Phủ Biên Tạp Lục (Frontier Chronicles) by the scholar Le Quy Don, Hoàng Sa and Trường Sa were defined as belonging to Quảng Ngãi District. He described it as where sea products and shipwrecked cargoes were available to be collected. Vietnamese text written in the 17th century referenced government-sponsored economic activities during the Le Dynasty, 200 years earlier. The Vietnamese government conducted several geographical surveys of the islands in the 18th century.[18]


From wikipedia
Basically, the islands were mapped and claimed by China since at least 1000 AD while any comparable Vietnamese claim occurs post 1800 at the earliest


Yeah, but as people have drawn comparisons, people explored quite a bit throughout history, I'm wondering what the actual populace of the Islands consists of. I don't think the historical claim is that substantial, nor is it really relevant.


Way to completely fall back.

Someone questioned the legitimacy of the comment of Vietnam not exploring those islands before China. A source was given that says China explored them 800 years before Vietnam, and now you say "OH IT DOESNT MATTER"


I'm not "falling back" anywhere, go look at some of my first posts in this thread, I specifically mentioned that China had mapped out those regions hundreds of years prior, and mentioned I didn't think it was relevant. Nice try though.
TALegion
Profile Joined October 2010
United States1187 Posts
June 18 2011 18:59 GMT
#73
How will this get settled, if not with violence?
All involved seem to have some rational and justification for the islands belonging to them, and don't seem to want to easily surrender their claim. I don't see how this issue can get resolved peacefully if no one will simply give up the islands.
A person willing to die for a cause is a hero. A person willing to kill for a cause is a madman
Kupon3ss
Profile Joined May 2008
時の回廊10066 Posts
June 18 2011 19:02 GMT
#74
On June 19 2011 03:59 TALegion wrote:
How will this get settled, if not with violence?
All involved seem to have some rational and justification for the islands belonging to them, and don't seem to want to easily surrender their claim. I don't see how this issue can get resolved peacefully if no one will simply give up the islands.


This is pretty much true, given China's current economical and political position, it would be hard to see the US actually actively intervening on the behalf of say, the Philippines, barring that, any war that breaks out will be pretty similar to
Falklands_War
(maybe not as one sided)
When in doubt, just believe in yourself and press buttons
Anomandaris
Profile Joined July 2010
Afghanistan440 Posts
June 18 2011 19:02 GMT
#75
OP working for chinese governement.
Dagobert
Profile Blog Joined July 2009
Netherlands1858 Posts
June 18 2011 19:04 GMT
#76
Even if his information was accurate, it's just a long post building on the genetic fallacy.
Qi
Profile Joined June 2011
China31 Posts
June 18 2011 19:04 GMT
#77
On June 19 2011 03:59 TALegion wrote:
How will this get settled, if not with violence?
All involved seem to have some rational and justification for the islands belonging to them, and don't seem to want to easily surrender their claim. I don't see how this issue can get resolved peacefully if no one will simply give up the islands.

Let's just hope US doesn't intervene. China and the ASEAN seem respectful for now. They have to talk though.
GertHeart
Profile Blog Joined February 2011
United States631 Posts
June 18 2011 19:04 GMT
#78
For those who didn't study Chinese history, you have to understand china should not be able to get these islands, or anymore resources. Sadly the Chinese government is always fragile as has been for 1000's of years, a simple new leader can simply cause havoc to the rest of the world.

I have no problems with Chinese people, but I do have a problem with their leaders. There will probably be a WWIII and China will be the primary antagonist. Leaders cause wars nor individuals. If people had their way they wouldn't go to war.
He who conquers the past rules the future, He who conquers the future rules the past. - C&C Red Alert
stork4ever
Profile Joined April 2010
United States1036 Posts
June 18 2011 19:07 GMT
#79
That map is pretty ridiculous, poor Brunei, they must be feeling claustrophobic. With such vital sea lanes being claimed by China, noone is going to allow China to exercise such a huge chunk of sea. For Japan/Korea, if they want to import oil from the Mideast they will have to send their ships through "Chinese claimed" sea or go the long way around. That can't be good for their economy.

Chinese Taipei? This isnt the Olympics!
archonOOid
Profile Blog Joined March 2011
1983 Posts
June 18 2011 19:08 GMT
#80
I agree with OP but the thing is why is this under discussion and not listed as fact? Taiwan also claims those islands which makes this case bullet proof. Vietnam, Philippines and Indonesia surrender the islands or surrender in war.
I'm Quotable (IQ)
Prev 1 2 3 4 5 6 9 10 11 Next All
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
PiGosaur Cup
10:00
#108
PiGStarcraft594
CranKy Ducklings72
Liquipedia
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
PiGStarcraft594
RuFF_SC2 200
StarCraft: Brood War
ZergMaN 23
ToSsGirL 10
Icarus 9
Force[name] 8
League of Legends
JimRising 575
Counter-Strike
summit1g13673
SPUNJ500
taco 381
Heroes of the Storm
Trikslyr84
Other Games
C9.Mang0406
WinterStarcraft392
ViBE121
trigger6
Organizations
Other Games
gamesdonequick1039
[ Show 12 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• EnkiAlexander 61
• CranKy Ducklings SOOP24
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• Azhi_Dahaki170
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
League of Legends
• Rush359
Upcoming Events
The PondCast
5h 33m
University League
5h 33m
LiuLi Cup
6h 33m
Rogue vs TBD
Maru vs TBD
OSC
11h 33m
Replay Cast
18h 33m
GSL
1d 7h
Maru vs Dark
Patches Events
1d 9h
OSC
1d 11h
Replay Cast
1d 18h
KCM Race Survival
2 days
[ Show More ]
Ultimate Battle
2 days
ZerO vs Bisu
RSL Revival
3 days
BSL
3 days
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
4 days
IPSL
4 days
Ret vs ggnore13
nOmaD vs Aether
BSL
4 days
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
4 days
WardiTV Weekly
5 days
Kung Fu Cup
6 days
Solar vs Classic
ByuN vs SHIN
PiGosaur Cup
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Proleague 2026-11-16
Blizzard Classic Cup 2026
HCC Season 3

Ongoing

Acropolis #5
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4
International ShieldBattery League
BSL Season 23
IPSL Winter 2026-27
Calamity Cup Div. A Season 8
Underdog Cup 2026 Div 2-3
Stake Ranked Episode 6
BLAST Rivals Fall 2026
IEM Beijing 2026
PGL Masters Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 5
1win Private Club #2
Thunderpick World Champ. '26
ESL Pro League Season 24
Stake Ranked Episode 4
1win Private Club #1
Logitech G Play Connect 2026
SL StarSeries Fall 2026
FISSURE Playground #3
BLAST Open Fall 2026

Upcoming

Sector 591
YSL S4
SC4ALL II: Brood War
NBSL 2026 Xiamen LAN
BSL 23: Non-Korean Championship
HSC XXX
Stellar Fest 2: Lunar Cup
StarCraft2 Weekly Open Tournament 2026 Grand Finals
SC4ALL II: StarCraft II
Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals
RSL Offline Finals
IEM Kraków 2027
PGL Bucharest 2027
BLAST Bounty Winter 2027
PGL Major Singapore 2026
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.