EPTShould we be nice to Protoss and give em number 3 at least? ; D
Who's the THIRD best Brood War player of all time?
| Forum Index > BW General |
|
LUCKY_NOOB
Bulgaria1466 Posts
Should we be nice to Protoss and give em number 3 at least? ; D | ||
|
M3t4PhYzX
Poland4208 Posts
maybe iloveoov | ||
|
XenOsky
Chile2277 Posts
#1 protoss (aka bisu) is arround 6 or 7 imo. | ||
|
TMNT
2842 Posts
 | ||
|
LUCKY_NOOB
Bulgaria1466 Posts
On December 18 2022 22:41 TMNT wrote: How can we decide this when we haven't been able to decide who's the second yet So true! I mean I think it's clearly Flash. First place would be the eventual AI takeover. | ||
Peeano
Netherlands5132 Posts
On December 18 2022 22:41 TMNT wrote: How can we decide this when we haven't been able to decide who's the second yet ![[image loading]](https://i.imgur.com/73b2sy9.png) The poll result very clearly shows JD as favorite for 2nd best. I counted/gauged the votes in the thread of people who bothered enough about the poll to write in the thread and there JD is also the favorite (by 1 over Nada) with Boxer/Savior as tied 3rd (if I recall correctly). I counted about a week ago and didn't feel like bumping the thread again, but it was like 19 JD vs 18 Nada. From those people that bothered to post in previous thread it is clear Nada should be 3rd, but if you look at the poll this should be about Boxer vs Nada? Since the original poll was on TL's main page, one can argue SC2 fans with little to no knowledge about BW skewed the poll in favor of JD... This all calls for a new poll to vote 3rd best, but OP rather be clowning  | ||
|
CHEONSOYUN
536 Posts
| ||
|
Qikz
United Kingdom12022 Posts
2. FlaSh 3. Jaedong Don't @ me | ||
|
hiro protagonist
1294 Posts
Only other players I would give a slot to here are effort and Julyzerg | ||
|
prosatan
Romania8292 Posts
I have 3 pick for 3rd place: Bisu , Fantasy and Effort.. I rank Nada and Rain very high in terms of pure talent. | ||
|
prosatan
Romania8292 Posts
Here it is: wraiths: Leta reavers: Snow dts: Bisu carriers: Stork macro: Best and OOV vulture harassing: Fantasy Muta control: JD  lings control: JD and Kwanro early game: Mini (probably the best ever at early game) game plan and execution: Flash defiler: savior m&m micro: Boxer (he still has it!) good effective APM: soulkey Very high APM(unfortunately not so effcient): Hyuk Nice building placemen: Horang2 the most handsome: JD the best chef: JD the most talented at singing and dancing: JD | ||
|
LUCKY_NOOB
Bulgaria1466 Posts
On December 19 2022 01:41 Peeano wrote: The poll result very clearly shows JD as favorite for 2nd best. I counted/gauged the votes in the thread of people who bothered enough about the poll to write in the thread and there JD is also the favorite (by 1 over Nada) with Boxer/Savior as tied 3rd (if I recall correctly). I counted about a week ago and didn't feel like bumping the thread again, but it was like 19 JD vs 18 Nada. From those people that bothered to post in previous thread it is clear Nada should be 3rd, but if you look at the poll this should be about Boxer vs Nada? Since the original poll was on TL's main page, one can argue SC2 fans with little to no knowledge about BW skewed the poll in favor of JD... This all calls for a new poll to vote 3rd best, but OP rather be clowning Polls restrict options thus shaping and constraining people's opinions unless ALL possible options are included in the poll (and all answers are presented equally which is impossible). Since there are no criteria we've agreed to judge by threads are a much better way to express one's opinion. If people want to say Artosis is greatest BW player they have the right to do so! | ||
|
LUCKY_NOOB
Bulgaria1466 Posts
On December 19 2022 03:32 prosatan wrote: I thought about which players are good at a specific thing, like early game , micro , macro or one unit control Here it is: wraiths: Leta reavers: Snow dts: Bisu carriers: Stork macro: Best and OOV vulture harassing: Fantasy Muta control: JD lings control: JD and Kwanro early game: Mini (probably the best ever at early game) game plan and execution: Flash defiler: savior m&m micro: Boxer (he still has it!) good effective APM: soulkey Very high APM(unfortunately not so effcient): Hyuk Nice building placemen: Horang2 the most handsome: JD the best chef: JD the most talented at singing and dancing: JD Now THIS comment is much closer to the truth! You sure you are Protoss? kek | ||
|
LUCKY_NOOB
Bulgaria1466 Posts
On December 18 2022 22:02 XenOsky wrote: jaedong/savior #1 protoss (aka bisu) is arround 6 or 7 imo. Harsh! | ||
|
VGhost
United States3615 Posts
Or it's an intimidation factor list, and you could make a strong argument for any of half a dozen players - Bisu, July, Nada, oov, Boxer, and savior. | ||
|
prosatan
Romania8292 Posts
On December 19 2022 05:19 LUCKY_NOOB wrote: Now THIS comment is much closer to the truth! You sure you are Protoss? kek yesss ! Protoss FTW!  | ||
|
outscar
2832 Posts
https://tl.net/forum/brood-war/46384-boxers-biography-crazy-as-me https://tl.net/forum/starcraft-2/288614-boxers-autobio-crazy-as-mepdf-for-kindle-3 https://www.reddit.com/r/starcraft/comments/1urw5e/lim_yohwans_boxer_autobiography_crazy_as_me/ (download here book if links are broken) | ||
|
L_Master
United States8017 Posts
3rd best peak skill? 3rd best in terms of accomplishments? 3rd best in terms of accomplishments weighted based on estimated depth of talent? etc. The answers to each question are quite different. | ||
|
Marl
United States692 Posts
On December 19 2022 03:32 prosatan wrote: I thought about which players are good at a specific thing, like early game , micro , macro or one unit control Here it is: wraiths: Leta reavers: Snow dts: Bisu carriers: Stork macro: Best and OOV vulture harassing: Fantasy Muta control: JD lings control: JD and Kwanro early game: Mini (probably the best ever at early game) game plan and execution: Flash defiler: savior m&m micro: Boxer (he still has it!) good effective APM: soulkey Very high APM(unfortunately not so effcient): Hyuk Nice building placemen: Horang2 the most handsome: JD the best chef: JD the most talented at singing and dancing: JD storms: jangbi | ||
|
PhilGood2DaY
Germany7424 Posts
2. NaDa 3. Jeadong (truth) | ||
| ||
