EPTWill SC2 survive DOTA 2? - Page 4
| Blogs > dacthehork |
|
marttorn
Norway5211 Posts
| ||
|
zeru
8156 Posts
| ||
|
Grettin
42383 Posts
On September 02 2011 18:43 zeru wrote: I think you are talking about tobi-wan, almost a bit korean style casting, where you can actually hear the real excitement in his voice. I agree. First time ever i had the feeling that i have when i'm watching broodwar with korean commentators. To some it might be irritating but i like it. But no, DOTA 2 won't "kill" SC2. Two totally different games. I love both games though, and i will be following both. | ||
|
lozarian
United Kingdom1043 Posts
On September 02 2011 10:41 jimbob615 wrote: dota is so boring to watch as a neutral... it is already dead. its like cs 1.6. i'll admit i loved watching cs 1.6 back in the day, but its because i played. to a neutral its boring as hell. same as this game. sc2 has potential to be big because even a complete noob can relate to big armies colliding with eachother and watching huge battles. its like watching a war. dota is just fantasy crap which people cannot relate to at all without being a hardcore player. sc is so boring to watch as a neutral.. i'll admit i loved watching sc back in the day, but its because i played. to a neutral its boring as hell. same as this game. dota2 has potential to be big because even a complete noob can relate to heroes colliding with each other and watching one on one combat. its like watching wrestling. sc is just sci-fi crap which people cannot relate to at all without being a hardcore player None of what you said is actually relevant to dota. Maybe if you cited difficulty in understanding what's going on, what heroes do, why people are or aren't pushing, I'd get behind it. I find starcraft boring as hell to watch, because I don't understand it well enough. I can appreciate the clever maneouvers, but I don't get any of the bigger issues. Watch a stream and ask questions, or an actually decent commentator. | ||
|
KlaCkoN
Sweden1661 Posts
From personal experience, the acquaintancies that normally play wow or consoles or portal etc that picked up starcraft 2 because it was the newest blizzard game (the types of people that are making s2 so massive at the moment) they are all planning on switching to dota2 the second it´s released. But sc2 was never going to sustain the huge mainstream following it has right now anyway, bw too was huuge for a year or three after it´s release before it started to die down a bit as people moved on to different games, the same will happen to sc2 and dota2 will speed up that process. The people remaining will be the slightly more competetive people who really like the game for the game itself and not because it´s a shiny new blizzard game. | ||
|
Denzil
United Kingdom4193 Posts
If so I doubt it'll hurt SC too much maybe the growing China community takes a hit. | ||
|
Thrill
2599 Posts
| ||
|
CBNMystery
Canada25 Posts
| ||
|
ssi.bal-listic
United States568 Posts
| ||
|
Tomfour
United States173 Posts
The thing about Dota 2 vs SC2 is that Dota2, I'm assuming will be like the original Dota. What I mean by that is that it will still be very difficult to play, and will in a certain degree be like how if SC2 was harder to play like BW, which SC2 isn't. So the thing that's nice about SC2 is it's extremely easy to follow and play from a casual standpoint. I've watched some of the Dota2 tournaments, and I've been very impressed. The only thing I can say is that it's kind of hard to follow, and the games are much much longer. I know people have done analysis of BW game length vs SC2, but an hour game length for Dota2 is very common. I'm not sure that's very good for a competitive scene because people just straight up can't and won't devote that much time to it on as regular of a basis as they do for SC2, where an entire series will probably be over in that time. Just the length of games makes it so hard for it to be a competitive game. Although I didn't watch the LoL stream at the past MLG, I imagine live tournaments won't be able to be much bigger(4 teams I think it was) than that just do to how long games are. So people will definitely play it, myself included, but the people who are into SC2 right now aren't going to stop watching and give up SC2 for it. | ||
| ||
