EPTMy logic for wanting to shoot Vivax was that I was playing under the assumption that BTDT was scum. BDTD scumread Vivax, and Viv was super against the initial Grack lynch, keeping to his second wagon. Granted you can WIFOM the "mafia will split the wagons" theory to your heart's content, but in a world where BDTD is scum, it seemed likely that Viv would be too. I think there were a few other reasons I cooked up at the time but it's not terribly important.
Newbie Student Mafia XXV - Page 68
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Kmatt
United States1019 Posts
My logic for wanting to shoot Vivax was that I was playing under the assumption that BTDT was scum. BDTD scumread Vivax, and Viv was super against the initial Grack lynch, keeping to his second wagon. Granted you can WIFOM the "mafia will split the wagons" theory to your heart's content, but in a world where BDTD is scum, it seemed likely that Viv would be too. I think there were a few other reasons I cooked up at the time but it's not terribly important. | ||
|
Kmatt
United States1019 Posts
| ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
| ||
|
Calix
3379 Posts
lol | ||
|
ika42
260 Posts
On January 12 2017 09:29 darthfoley wrote: I think it's more likely that SW was killed because literally 0 people scum read her and she was active And that would not apply to the vig or me because? | ||
|
Mutaller
United States1036 Posts
On January 12 2017 09:26 Damdred wrote: Would you really want to risk the game killing onegu today and him being town? Like I understand frustration with someone not really playing that much. But i'm not sure if him not necessarily playing in this situation is super indicative. I don't know anyone's meta so... He only targets people who target him so he is too defensive. So maybe this vote could get something out. | ||
|
Mutaller
United States1036 Posts
On January 12 2017 09:31 Kmatt wrote: Wow I'm not even worth killing. I figured I was DoA with day3 because of my claim so I just rolled with it but they saw fit to roleblock me. That would have been pretty clever though, to make my claim with a double tap while still holding my shot. My logic for wanting to shoot Vivax was that I was playing under the assumption that BTDT was scum. BDTD scumread Vivax, and Viv was super against the initial Grack lynch, keeping to his second wagon. Granted you can WIFOM the "mafia will split the wagons" theory to your heart's content, but in a world where BDTD is scum, it seemed likely that Viv would be too. I think there were a few other reasons I cooked up at the time but it's not terribly important. I would have had to buy some doritos and mountain dew, I fucking love it. | ||
|
ika42
260 Posts
On January 12 2017 09:26 Damdred wrote: Would you really want to risk the game killing onegu today and him being town? Like I understand frustration with someone not really playing that much. But i'm not sure if him not necessarily playing in this situation is super indicative. even so viv suspected him and then he died... SW suspected him and then he died.... | ||
|
Calix
3379 Posts
On January 12 2017 09:41 ika42 wrote: even so viv suspected him and then he died... SW suspected him and then he died.... Where does Vivax suspect Onegu? | ||
|
darthfoley
United States8001 Posts
On January 12 2017 09:41 ika42 wrote: even so viv suspected him and then he died... SW suspected him and then he died.... This is actually not a bad point lol. Fool me once... | ||
|
darthfoley
United States8001 Posts
| ||
|
ika42
260 Posts
On January 12 2017 09:45 darthfoley wrote: wait Vivax never reads Onegu as scum. He town leans him I though he read him as scum? I'll have to run a filther later | ||
|
darthfoley
United States8001 Posts
Except SW has town read ika from d1 into oblivion... so i'm pretty sure my tin foil falls apart lol | ||
|
Calix
3379 Posts
On January 12 2017 09:49 darthfoley wrote: On the other hand, SW knows ika the best and is most likely to correctly scum read him. SW dies. Except SW has town read ika from d1 into oblivion... so i'm pretty sure my tin foil falls apart lol I don't need to be an expert on NKA to assume that SW didn't die because scum!ika was terrified that she would turn on him, lol. | ||
|
Calix
3379 Posts
On January 12 2017 09:51 Calix wrote: I don't need to be an expert on NKA to assume that SW didn't die because scum!ika was terrified that she would turn on him, lol. Like it is possible that ika is scum given that he's just limped into the thread with shitty NKA and no backing but SW dying is definitely not a reason that factors into that. | ||
|
ika42
260 Posts
On January 12 2017 09:52 Calix wrote: Like it is possible that ika is scum given that he's just limped into the thread with shitty NKA and no backing but SW dying is definitely not a reason that factors into that. You really don't know us then. In a world where I she is town and I am scum I would of left her alive or killed her n1. If she's town reading me I would not kill her nor would she kill me. | ||
|
ika42
260 Posts
I mean your reason applies to you as well | ||
|
Calix
3379 Posts
On January 12 2017 09:58 ika42 wrote: You really don't know us then. In a world where I she is town and I am scum I would of left her alive or killed her n1. If she's town reading me I would not kill her nor would she kill me. Don't worry, I don't care to. Your post is WIFOM since it basically says "I wouldn't have done XYZ as scum" which cannot be proven one way or the other. Kindly weigh in on the rest of the discussion if you don't mind. | ||
|
Calix
3379 Posts
On January 12 2017 10:00 ika42 wrote: Hell why couldnt you of killed sw calix? I mean your reason applies to you as well The levels of logical fallacy in this post are extremely high. My previous post stands and I'm not getting dragged into a discussion about NKA with a player who has yet to talk about anything substantial today. | ||
|
ika42
260 Posts
On January 12 2017 10:01 Calix wrote: Don't worry, I don't care to. Your post is WIFOM since it basically says "I wouldn't have done XYZ as scum" which cannot be proven one way or the other. Kindly weigh in on the rest of the discussion if you don't mind. about what? im going with silverwolfs reads | ||
| ||
