|
On July 09 2015 10:07 Half the Sky wrote:Show nested quote +On July 09 2015 08:48 Clarity_nl wrote: That's making the assumption marv was getting hit and palmar saved him That is my world as well. As for the milo/ritoky RB claims...
I think it COULD be possible that there is two mafia rb's. It feels like the RB's arn't that strong because the stuff is refunded. But i don't know if this is true because that might seem nerfed but having like a 1 shot role seems like it would even that out.
I'll probably be all for killing milo if damdred flips scum.
|
i was actively deflecting off scott on a hunch that no longer appears to be true, so i'll look at what you have on him, hts
|
On July 09 2015 09:49 Breshke wrote: So if damdred is mafia does that mean milo is mafia?
Or could there be two mafia RB with this many roles I'm not sure
In a world where all claims are true....
we have tracker (geript), 1shot dt (rit), 2shot dt (milo), 2-shot JK (Damdred), 2-shot banisher (Palmar)
ehhhhhh.....
Honestly, I would say town are OP here even with 2 RBs now that I think of it. Even if Damdred is scum, and the rest of the claims are true, I'd say town are OP.
I mean 3 investigative roles?
|
On July 09 2015 10:19 rsoultin wrote: i was actively deflecting off scott on a hunch that no longer appears to be true, so i'll look at what you have on him, hts You could also give some reads in general and adress the elephant in the room.
|
On July 09 2015 10:20 Harkon wrote:Show nested quote +On July 09 2015 10:19 rsoultin wrote: i was actively deflecting off scott on a hunch that no longer appears to be true, so i'll look at what you have on him, hts You could also give some reads in general and adress the elephant in the room.
my vote addresses the elephant in the room xP
or are you referring to a different elephant?
and no, not really interested
|
Also Breshke, I responded to a concern later N1 you had on scott, let me know what you think.
|
2:20am, I'm sorry but I really need to go to bed. Any questions I will return mid-day.
|
On July 09 2015 10:19 rsoultin wrote: i was actively deflecting off scott on a hunch that no longer appears to be true, so i'll look at what you have on him, hts
Don't even try it now - What would you like me to answer for you?
|
On July 09 2015 10:19 rsoultin wrote: i was actively deflecting off scott on a hunch that no longer appears to be true, so i'll look at what you have on him, hts
I knew you roleread him haha
WOS, HTS and rsoul and anyone else that is around whats your reads on EBH
He named 3 people (KSC, OWS and myself) before and asked people opinions on them. I assume this is because he scumleans on us or w/e which i find odd because those two are some of my top townreads. He also complains about people not putting effort into the game when he does nothing himself which isn't alignment indicative just irritating.
|
On July 09 2015 10:23 scott31337 wrote:Show nested quote +On July 09 2015 10:19 rsoultin wrote: i was actively deflecting off scott on a hunch that no longer appears to be true, so i'll look at what you have on him, hts Don't even try it now - What would you like me to answer for you?
don't even try what? trying to read you? lol >< oooookay
nothing
i haven't read...like probably half this game by now...and frankly have like no desire to do it at the moment
when and if i have questions i'll address them to you and/or anyone else
|
On July 09 2015 10:25 Breshke wrote:Show nested quote +On July 09 2015 10:19 rsoultin wrote: i was actively deflecting off scott on a hunch that no longer appears to be true, so i'll look at what you have on him, hts I knew you roleread him haha WOS, HTS and rsoul and anyone else that is around whats your reads on EBH He named 3 people (KSC, OWS and myself) before and asked people opinions on them. I assume this is because he scumleans on us or w/e which i find odd because those two are some of my top townreads. He also complains about people not putting effort into the game when he does nothing himself which isn't alignment indicative just irritating.
lol bresh >< i love that we think on the same wavelength. it's always the best sign that you're town ^^ and yeah. it was that or really stupid scum, and i just don't favor the stupid over smart argument unless there's a good reason to think a player would play stupid xP
mmmm ebh really whiny about the lynch was the main thought that popped into my head about him, which on principle i'm not a fan of from players that i don't remember being active during the lynch
beyond that i really only remember his bluehunting post lol which kinda dismissed as just...weird...and not definitively alignment-indicative
|
On July 09 2015 10:25 Breshke wrote:Show nested quote +On July 09 2015 10:19 rsoultin wrote: i was actively deflecting off scott on a hunch that no longer appears to be true, so i'll look at what you have on him, hts I knew you roleread him haha WOS, HTS and rsoul and anyone else that is around whats your reads on EBH He named 3 people (KSC, OWS and myself) before and asked people opinions on them. I assume this is because he scumleans on us or w/e which i find odd because those two are some of my top townreads. He also complains about people not putting effort into the game when he does nothing himself which isn't alignment indicative just irritating. I mean I've been skating (u gotta sk8) but for him to assume he's done anything but is silly.
There's some odd stuff in his filter to be sure (open 'bluehunting,' trying to steer active and useful conversation, his most recent 'KP-carrying' post) but I can't be certain it's mafia indicative necessarily. The worst thing about what you mentioned Breshke is that he asks for opinions without giving any concrete thoughts himself which reeks of fishing for thread sentiment. Could be scum I suppose.
|
Oh also I remember not feeling rsoul this game for whatever reason. Doesn't feel like same rsoul who I pocketed via arguments in whatever game that as.
Also maybe HF 'cause HF
|
On July 09 2015 02:44 Half the Sky wrote:Reading Scott's filter. I don't like the beginning of game mindmeld concept but I remembered he also brought up a good point on BF that initially made me wonder if the latter is is flying under the radar. What gives me pause (is this the same thing you mean Breshke) is Scott's answer to Damdred's question: Show nested quote +On July 08 2015 07:48 scott31337 wrote:On July 08 2015 07:36 Damdred wrote: Scott why were you so sure he was town based on an easy to make claim? It makes sense - His first and basically only post was wanderer. No else claimed wanderer(which they should have if they were D1, like Miller). I see it was a stupid remark like my drunk post the last game and I need to refrain from posting with emotion. It's not a bad lynch if he was going to be useless anyway I find it funny I started to believe Ziphh when he was mentioning different pages he was going thru in the thread and to give him a chance - and that has somehow stopped The key words here being "first and basically only post" - I know when he gave me a townlean he also took either a listpost or something else that he considered me towny on. Would he have given me the same read if I did jack all d1? Somehow I doubt it. Show nested quote +On July 07 2015 05:15 scott31337 wrote:On July 07 2015 04:46 boxerfred wrote: I don't like the Miller claim that HtS spewed out, like he doesn't give a fuck. Reads more like a backup (which is sadly NAI), claiming Miller makes sense as scum and as town. He's threwing out cases and opinions without going too hard for someone. He did the same in the Himalaya game after he got in via replacement, he was scum in there.
I just want to say that before people start sheeping him. Her, BTW. Usually it's a decent strategy to claim self-aware miller/wanderer in day 1 - if you try it later when you're already checked or being pressured no body will believe it. No body else has claimed miller as of yet (and BM claimed wanderer). I mean don't give her a confirmed town 100%, just look more into her thoughts and agenda - and at the moment they seem okay. HF had a good point though. Why did you "hardclaim" cop while Rsoul was being pressured? Why did you time it then? Why did you say it at all? What do you think of Palmar so far? I guess for now I go with the believe ritoky on his claim for today. (see bolded in second quote) So why did he believe BM? BM did jack all after the wanderer post. He tells others to look into MY thoughts and agenda. Why didn't he do the same with BM or even think that the fact there was no thoughts or agenda could be problematic? I don't know. But I don't think this is adding up. TMI? Breshke or anyone else - comments?
Nah this isn't what i meant HTS what i was talking about was his reads list seeming genuine even if it was just like short notes on what seemed surface level stuff.
But about your post IDK. I don't think it is that weird. . First of all I think reason he specifically seems to mention you is because he is replying to BF about you. I think it is plausible he brings up the BM claim aswell but doesn't mention him in the next sentence because he is kind of showing BM that you have both claimed but then goes back to focus on what BM was actually talking about. I don't really see how it would be TMI either.
Basically yeah it is KINDA weird. But i can understand why he doesn't say look into BM and his agenda because the post he was replying to is specifically about you
|
On July 09 2015 10:33 WaveofShadow wrote: Oh also I remember not feeling rsoul this game for whatever reason. Doesn't feel like same rsoul who I pocketed via arguments in whatever game that as.
Also maybe HF 'cause HF
lol pocketed. selective memory
|
On July 09 2015 10:34 rsoultin wrote:Show nested quote +On July 09 2015 10:33 WaveofShadow wrote: Oh also I remember not feeling rsoul this game for whatever reason. Doesn't feel like same rsoul who I pocketed via arguments in whatever game that as.
Also maybe HF 'cause HF
lol pocketed. selective memory Totally would have won that game if I didn't let yamato convince me to shoot you
|
On July 09 2015 10:29 rsoultin wrote:Show nested quote +On July 09 2015 10:25 Breshke wrote:On July 09 2015 10:19 rsoultin wrote: i was actively deflecting off scott on a hunch that no longer appears to be true, so i'll look at what you have on him, hts I knew you roleread him haha WOS, HTS and rsoul and anyone else that is around whats your reads on EBH He named 3 people (KSC, OWS and myself) before and asked people opinions on them. I assume this is because he scumleans on us or w/e which i find odd because those two are some of my top townreads. He also complains about people not putting effort into the game when he does nothing himself which isn't alignment indicative just irritating. lol bresh >< i love that we think on the same wavelength. it's always the best sign that you're town ^^ and yeah. it was that or really stupid scum, and i just don't favor the stupid over smart argument unless there's a good reason to think a player would play stupid xP mmmm ebh really whiny about the lynch was the main thought that popped into my head about him, which on principle i'm not a fan of from players that i don't remember being active during the lynch beyond that i really only remember his bluehunting post lol which kinda dismissed as just...weird...and not definitively alignment-indicative
Too be fair I have no idea where you got the blue read from
I think the wos point that he asked about 3 people then didn't give any opinions himself is good and makes him look airly summy.
VEry possible this is OMGUS for me because I was grumpy last night and he said i wasn't giving a shit about the night phase when i was actually asleep
|
On July 09 2015 10:38 WaveofShadow wrote:Show nested quote +On July 09 2015 10:34 rsoultin wrote:On July 09 2015 10:33 WaveofShadow wrote: Oh also I remember not feeling rsoul this game for whatever reason. Doesn't feel like same rsoul who I pocketed via arguments in whatever game that as.
Also maybe HF 'cause HF
lol pocketed. selective memory Totally would have won that game if I didn't let yamato convince me to shoot you
I tried my hardest to help you
|
On July 09 2015 10:38 WaveofShadow wrote:Show nested quote +On July 09 2015 10:34 rsoultin wrote:On July 09 2015 10:33 WaveofShadow wrote: Oh also I remember not feeling rsoul this game for whatever reason. Doesn't feel like same rsoul who I pocketed via arguments in whatever game that as.
Also maybe HF 'cause HF
lol pocketed. selective memory Totally would have won that game if I didn't let yamato convince me to shoot you
lol yeeeeeaaah doubt it
i was scumreading you hard when you stopped making sense xP
|
On July 09 2015 10:42 Breshke wrote:Show nested quote +On July 09 2015 10:29 rsoultin wrote:On July 09 2015 10:25 Breshke wrote:On July 09 2015 10:19 rsoultin wrote: i was actively deflecting off scott on a hunch that no longer appears to be true, so i'll look at what you have on him, hts I knew you roleread him haha WOS, HTS and rsoul and anyone else that is around whats your reads on EBH He named 3 people (KSC, OWS and myself) before and asked people opinions on them. I assume this is because he scumleans on us or w/e which i find odd because those two are some of my top townreads. He also complains about people not putting effort into the game when he does nothing himself which isn't alignment indicative just irritating. lol bresh >< i love that we think on the same wavelength. it's always the best sign that you're town ^^ and yeah. it was that or really stupid scum, and i just don't favor the stupid over smart argument unless there's a good reason to think a player would play stupid xP mmmm ebh really whiny about the lynch was the main thought that popped into my head about him, which on principle i'm not a fan of from players that i don't remember being active during the lynch beyond that i really only remember his bluehunting post lol which kinda dismissed as just...weird...and not definitively alignment-indicative Too be fair I have no idea where you got the blue read from I think the wos point that he asked about 3 people then didn't give any opinions himself is good and makes him look airly summy. VEry possible this is OMGUS for me because I was grumpy last night and he said i wasn't giving a shit about the night phase when i was actually asleep
aussie time
i make that mistake occasionally, or did
oh, it's more how quickly he was willing to believe there were wanderers in the game?
|
|
|
|