|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
On January 21 2015 23:21 Koshi wrote:Show nested quote +On January 21 2015 23:14 Holyflare wrote:
Filter size means nothing when it's 4, he's not actively solving the game, he returns and is out of the loop like I said previously. He only comments on irrelevant crap most of the time.
If you scum read hts for asking shit questions and not pushing anything damdred is the same. This is not the towny i voted for most improved player. Except for the fact that there are 2 really good cases on HTS. Why are you soft pushing this Damdred lynch? Explain to me why Damdred has a bigger chance to flip mafia over HTS? The good cases in this thread disagree with you. Why can't Damdred be a townie that is overwhelmed by playing 2 games at once and can't get into the flow of this game? There are posts in Damdred his filter that support this possibility. Happened to me when I tried to play 2 games at the same time. That's why I never do it anymore.
I'm not disagreeing with the other cases since you know I agreed they were good before you even joined the game.
A++ reading.
If you're going to be a cocky know it all dick instead of attacking my post saying it has a mafia agenda when it quite clearly doesn't how about elaborating on why he's not mafia instead because when I read his posts he's about 10 hours behind each time and saying things that people have already said which is why reading filters is shit and maybe you should spend actual time reading the game first.
|
On January 21 2015 23:21 Koshi wrote:
Can you then explain to me why lian is mafia for saying Vivax is town while not reading what Vivax wrote. I don't get that point at all.
It's not that point alone. It's the aggregate, when you consider that he's not reading the thread for his scumreads. When he first enters, Lian says "did SL even post" when SL posted on three pages. That's another instance. Him throwing Vivax's name the way he had for the others further supports the fact that he's not reading the thread.
|
On January 21 2015 23:27 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On January 21 2015 23:21 Koshi wrote:On January 21 2015 23:14 Holyflare wrote:
Filter size means nothing when it's 4, he's not actively solving the game, he returns and is out of the loop like I said previously. He only comments on irrelevant crap most of the time.
If you scum read hts for asking shit questions and not pushing anything damdred is the same. This is not the towny i voted for most improved player. Except for the fact that there are 2 really good cases on HTS. Why are you soft pushing this Damdred lynch? Explain to me why Damdred has a bigger chance to flip mafia over HTS? The good cases in this thread disagree with you. Why can't Damdred be a townie that is overwhelmed by playing 2 games at once and can't get into the flow of this game? There are posts in Damdred his filter that support this possibility. Happened to me when I tried to play 2 games at the same time. That's why I never do it anymore. I'm not disagreeing with the other cases since you know I agreed they were good before you even joined the game. A++ reading. If you're going to be a cocky know it all dick instead of attacking my post saying it has a mafia agenda when it quite clearly doesn't how about elaborating on why he's not mafia instead because when I read his posts he's about 10 hours behind each time and saying things that people have already said which is why reading filters is shit and maybe you should spend actual time reading the game first.
No that would be boring
|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
Then go away and stop being irritating, I don't need you to lynch damdred.
|
On January 21 2015 23:29 Half the Sky wrote:Show nested quote +On January 21 2015 23:21 Koshi wrote:
Can you then explain to me why lian is mafia for saying Vivax is town while not reading what Vivax wrote. I don't get that point at all. It's not that point alone. It's the aggregate, when you consider that he's not reading the thread for his scumreads. When he first enters, Lian says "did SL even post" when SL posted on three pages. That's another instance. Him throwing Vivax's name the way he had for the others further supports the fact that he's not reading the thread.
Is it impossible that he thought Vivax was town? Vivax had 20 posts before lian made this post. Why can't lian have read those 20 posts and decided Vivax was town?
On January 20 2015 19:24 liancourt wrote:
At least we know vivax is town
I read those 20 posts and they aren't terrible.
|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
Damdred also never states that he can't keep up with 2 games. At all. Ever. Instead he just complains reallllyyyy out of the blue that he was demotivated and everyone immediately said "huh?" because it was so random/not characteristic.
Nothing he has done this game is progressive. It's all answering KelsierSC questions about marv and then saying sl was lying about some meta and then into demotivated speech.
|
Morning I started doing some filter diving this morning when I got power back, i'm looking at Wilie right now who I previously said ok without looking into his filter.
Some of his posts seem ok, but most of his filter is just one liners and almost no follow up can be seen with what he is doing. His biggest conversation points are when he is attacked by HF and hf ends up disengaging after a bit. After that he has some questions but as I said earlier the follow up just isn't there overall. What little follow up with hts doesn't seem to be in the vein of solving the game. Most of everything is one liners with little to no insight and I see no conclussions that have been drawn, just that the thread sentiments are good lynches today. While I said he was ok early on this guy is a good possible scum.
|
Scum never gives and hides behind excuses to not play a game...
|
Oats is another good scum suspect for me, just looking at random posts he looks so/so in the thread but when you look into his filter, he has a ton of one liners. He sits on the side line and he sometimes like with the SL comments throws a bit more gas on the fire. His biggest contribution during the game is jumping on me for what he thinks is not a way to scum hunt basically. Hes picked at people who are generally being scum read by the thread and get pressure, besides his sudden lets lynch bats he really hasn't contributed anything note worthy to the thread.
Decent lynch for today.
|
On January 21 2015 23:39 Holyflare wrote:
Damdred also never states that he can't keep up with 2 games. At all. Ever. Instead he just complains reallllyyyy out of the blue that he was demotivated and everyone immediately said "huh?" because it was so random/not characteristic.
Nothing he has done this game is progressive. It's all answering KelsierSC questions about marv and then saying sl was lying about some meta and then into demotivated speech.
From scum POV. Would you:
either
a) complain that you got 2 games to read and hide behind the fact it is hard to keep up and pretend to be useful or will be useful in the future.
or
b) say you are demotivated to play.
|
On January 21 2015 23:39 Holyflare wrote:
Damdred also never states that he can't keep up with 2 games. At all. Ever. Instead he just complains reallllyyyy out of the blue that he was demotivated and everyone immediately said "huh?" because it was so random/not characteristic.
Nothing he has done this game is progressive. It's all answering KelsierSC questions about marv and then saying sl was lying about some meta and then into demotivated speech.
Its demotivating being in every persons scum list for doing something half of the game did? Everything I've done is being categorized as scummy, its like trying to dig your way out of the pit by digging down instead of just digging steps.
|
|
|
|
|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
On January 21 2015 23:50 Koshi wrote:Show nested quote +On January 21 2015 23:39 Holyflare wrote:
Damdred also never states that he can't keep up with 2 games. At all. Ever. Instead he just complains reallllyyyy out of the blue that he was demotivated and everyone immediately said "huh?" because it was so random/not characteristic.
Nothing he has done this game is progressive. It's all answering KelsierSC questions about marv and then saying sl was lying about some meta and then into demotivated speech. From scum POV. Would you: either a) complain that you got 2 games to read and hide behind the fact it is hard to keep up and pretend to be useful or will be useful in the future. or b) say you are demotivated to play.
He's made time excuses maybe you should read.
"i have not time everyone asked what i wanted to ask when I'm here"
"I've got to go, wife"
"I'm running out of time"
|
On January 21 2015 23:56 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On January 21 2015 23:50 Koshi wrote:On January 21 2015 23:39 Holyflare wrote:
Damdred also never states that he can't keep up with 2 games. At all. Ever. Instead he just complains reallllyyyy out of the blue that he was demotivated and everyone immediately said "huh?" because it was so random/not characteristic.
Nothing he has done this game is progressive. It's all answering KelsierSC questions about marv and then saying sl was lying about some meta and then into demotivated speech. From scum POV. Would you: either a) complain that you got 2 games to read and hide behind the fact it is hard to keep up and pretend to be useful or will be useful in the future. or b) say you are demotivated to play. He's made time excuses maybe you should read. "i have not time everyone asked what i wanted to ask when I'm here" "I've got to go, wife" "I'm running out of time"
Now we are getting somewhere.
|
HTS is probably town here, I looked at her filter here and at her filter in http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/474146-newbie-mini-mafia-lx?user=Half the Sky&page=3. She is a lot less inquisitive in the newbie game where she is scum and really bites on scummy things there and pushes that angle, a lot more aggressive in that regard as well.
Here she asks questions wants people to hold off on votes on marv for instance to see what he can do when it would be a good time to jump on. Is super inquisitive about peoples reasoning's behind things here. She does push scummy things here but she does it in a very different way than in the scum game, instead of latching onto things here she looks at them and questions before doing anything with it. She does not lack conclusions to my eyes and seems to have a pretty clear flowing line of thought.
Overall not a good lynch at all, I would town her.
|
United Kingdom10443 Posts
what conclusions has she drawn?
|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
On January 21 2015 23:58 Koshi wrote:Show nested quote +On January 21 2015 23:56 Holyflare wrote:On January 21 2015 23:50 Koshi wrote:On January 21 2015 23:39 Holyflare wrote:
Damdred also never states that he can't keep up with 2 games. At all. Ever. Instead he just complains reallllyyyy out of the blue that he was demotivated and everyone immediately said "huh?" because it was so random/not characteristic.
Nothing he has done this game is progressive. It's all answering KelsierSC questions about marv and then saying sl was lying about some meta and then into demotivated speech. From scum POV. Would you: either a) complain that you got 2 games to read and hide behind the fact it is hard to keep up and pretend to be useful or will be useful in the future. or b) say you are demotivated to play. He's made time excuses maybe you should read. "i have not time everyone asked what i wanted to ask when I'm here" "I've got to go, wife" "I'm running out of time" Now we are getting somewhere.
Not to mention in the game which i forgot the name of but obi was a cop and everyone was suspicious of damdred apart from me at one point damd didn't say he was demotivated or anything like that at all afaik. It's very uncharacteristic from someone who I had to shoot n1 in carol because he got the whole mafia team right.
|
Just off the top of my head without looing back that SL is scummy and takes a ton of stuff out of context, and lian is suspect for the way hes going after things
|
Slam is scum, hes not worried about being vet'd or fighting with anyone. Hes way to serious about things. I might be a novice at slam speak but this looks like titanic slam again.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
