EPT[T] Cell (Mini?) Mafia III - Page 33
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Blazinghand
United States25550 Posts
| ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31494 Posts
Why is thread so dead? | ||
|
Amiko
United States1725 Posts
In comparing B to C I said this earlier regarding Mysterymeat- On August 29 2014 03:41 Amiko wrote: I don't have a ton of experience with Wave or HF, and I don't feel MysteryMeat1 is an easy scum pick. To explain, he was mislynched as town in three of his five games in the database and I felt there were decent arguments for his play as scummy in those games. I'm not sure the best way to read him right now, but I'm fine with the idea that I don't have to. Given that, why did you put cell B as fourth instead of fifth? I'll put up some thoughts on Cell A in a bit | ||
|
Amiko
United States1725 Posts
Pregame: On August 08 2014 05:08 Blazinghand wrote: isn't the best way to order groups literally the opposite of this This suggests that Blazinghand thinks the best way to order the groups is with the highest activity first. Ingame: On August 28 2014 10:36 Blazinghand wrote: don't listen to any of this lunkheads. vote me. here's the order I'll use: D E A B C This is because we want put off C and B, which contain high activity players, to the end. . . . This suggests that BH wants to put players with high activity at the end. :| | ||
|
Amiko
United States1725 Posts
@Anyone else who said Cell C was an easy cell to read - this was at least NotReallyHolyflare and I think also Apathy Why do you feel this is the case? I have never been scum on forum mafia, so I don't see why it would be easy to read me as town/scum. Even if marv is easy to read, do you feel that confident about reading Oats? Give some basis on this | ||
|
Amiko
United States1725 Posts
On August 29 2014 07:12 Professor Apathy wrote: I tend do agree. batsnacks and ritoky come off as misguided, yet townish people. BH on the other hand hasn't made me think he's town. So from a process of elimination point of view it's BH right now. What about batsnacks seems misguided? Practically the only thing of substance I see from him is that he voted Blazinghand, who you also voted for. How is it misguided if you agree with him? | ||
|
Not really holyflare
Japan56 Posts
On August 29 2014 10:30 Amiko wrote: Oh sidethought I wanted to ask @Anyone else who said Cell C was an easy cell to read - this was at least NotReallyHolyflare and I think also Apathy Why do you feel this is the case? I have never been scum on forum mafia, so I don't see why it would be easy to read me as town/scum. Even if marv is easy to read, do you feel that confident about reading Oats? Give some basis on this Yes. Oats is like 99.9999% scum now because I think you're town. Because I trust that you may be 99.9999% town, ill sheep you for catching a mistake that bh shouldn't have done. Bat posted. Not scum. Ritoky MIGHT be scum because his town was analytical. This is bullshit ritoky. Anyway, scratch that. Ritoky is scum. ##Vote: ritoky | ||
|
Amiko
United States1725 Posts
| ||
|
27ninjabunnies
United States2486 Posts
(Side note: does anyone know how to fix a bike tire? XD) On August 29 2014 07:21 marvellosity wrote: what exactly are you getting at bunnies? I was getting at that I didn't think it was a ninja vote. Seemed as if it had progression. | ||
|
Amiko
United States1725 Posts
What do you think of batsnacks? | ||
|
27ninjabunnies
United States2486 Posts
On August 29 2014 07:33 ritoky wrote: well this ordering makes my life easy, just gotta find out which of these two is scum and not worry about the rest. This is not towny ritoky. Towny ritoky would be like "Let me find scum in my group, and let me tell you who else is scum". | ||
|
27ninjabunnies
United States2486 Posts
Nothing really interests me. The BH "slip"? might be something to look at, but is that a slip or just a change of mind? I tend to find town more slip like that than mafia in their way of thinking. Mafia are more calculated. Amiko is pretty much town for me atm as well. Like, I'm not sure if I've actually played an amiko mafia game, but I wouldn't lynch him this game. | ||
|
Amiko
United States1725 Posts
batsnacks, marvellosity, WaveofShadow, and Professor Apathy all voted for Blazinghand without really making an argument or noting the (what I think was fairly obvious) slip. Does this mean anything to you on their alignment? | ||
|
Amiko
United States1725 Posts
Can you talk a little more about ritoky? I don't have a great sense of the cell yet, but I think ritoky's posts (talking to/about Holyflare mostly) more than batsnacks' posts. I don't really have a sense of batsnacks from reading him yet. Is the idea that serious ritoky = town, silly ritoky = scum? Or just that serious ritoky = town? | ||
|
Amiko
United States1725 Posts
I think I like ritoky's posts (Talking to/about Holyflare mostly) more than batsnacks' posts. (I don't feel that strongly about it though, I feel like neither has given much of substance to read through yet) | ||
|
ritoky
United States6851 Posts
On August 29 2014 11:04 Amiko wrote: Is the idea that serious ritoky = town, silly ritoky = scum? Or just that serious ritoky = town? All ritoky is town ritoky on TL. It is actually getting to the point of frustration lol. 10 games in on these forums and I have rolled jailkeeper once and townie 9x. | ||
|
ritoky
United States6851 Posts
On August 29 2014 10:36 Not really holyflare wrote: Yes. Oats is like 99.9999% scum now because I think you're town. Because I trust that you may be 99.9999% town, ill sheep you for catching a mistake that bh shouldn't have done. Bat posted. Not scum. Ritoky MIGHT be scum because his town was analytical. This is bullshit ritoky. Anyway, scratch that. Ritoky is scum. ##Vote: ritoky Why do you immediately dismiss BH as an option to be scum with 0 comments? Do you know something about him that I don't? | ||
|
Amiko
United States1725 Posts
What about batsnacks seems misguided? Practically the only thing of substance I see from him is that he voted Blazinghand, who you also voted for. How is it misguided if you agree with him? @WaveofShadow: Man you seem so down this game, every post makes me feel like you just lost to some hearthstone boss on heroic. I don't think your cell is solved (MM1 is not always towny when he's town, Blazinghand may be able to give some insight on this) but we can worry about it again a little later in the game. You talked a little on ritoky & blazinghand. Any thoughts on batsnacks? Thought on ritoky- I'm just going to say that although Not really holyflare's post is the kind of thing that would normally make me think he's scum, I feel like knowing the player makes it not the case. If I have to out who I am fairly sure he is a little later I will do so, but I do kinda like that ritoky picked up on that post (http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/463542-cell-mini-mafia-iii?page=33#657). I'm out for a bit :3 | ||
|
27ninjabunnies
United States2486 Posts
Let's chat. While you are at it, tell me how to take this tire off of my bike so I can figure out the tube size and how to change it. (I have no friends.) So your points: I remember Marv voting BH, tbh, the rest looked like sheep votes without reason. Does sheep votes mean they are mafia? eh, maybe. But not really. So I'd have to see more of each of their play. I am actually really curious as to WHY PA votes HF as mayor, and then puts him as mafia. He says mayor doesn't matter, but I think it does in a sense. Why would you want mafia to be mayor? Like I said, nothing else I read really interested me. I'm still salty towards BH for lynching me d1, so tbh, I'd totally sheep the BH vote for the hell of it, but I don't necessarily see anything based behind it. Then again, I've only played 1 BH game, and dont know how he acts really as either alignment. Most of my things on ritoky are silly and not actually anything. I like joking with ritoky mostly because 1. he always fake cop checks me, and 2. he watches me and a few others play video mafia. Though, my recent post, saying that town ritoky wouldn't say this is true. Ritoky is very much about figuring out the game, not just figuring out the cell and letting the rest pass by. So him saying that makes me think he's not town ritoky. But I do agree with you, his posts are better than batsnacks'. | ||
|
ritoky
United States6851 Posts
On August 29 2014 10:43 Amiko wrote: @ritoky What do you think of batsnacks? Still deciding. He is doing a lot of what myself and meapak did last cell game, which firstly makes me want to call him a copycat. However, he was a part of that game and saw what happened. So I haven't decided if his motivations are to try to emulate that line of play to project town because he is not and needs to fake it/pocket me; or if he is town having a wonderful time being tr0llzy like I was last time. I hope he will switch to a little bit of substance at some point, but one can only hope. Was really hoping BH would do something meaningful, but I have found him even more underwhelming. Like he started to get pissed off, but there was no follow-through, which makes me feel like it was not genuine frustration but just contrived BS. As for other people in the game if you want reads. I haven't really bothered too much outside of my really strong ones, since I won't be around. Lilwade - TOWN AS ALL GET OUT - seriously. i think this is his first full fledged game...and he enters the thread like that? Pure BALLS, guy is town; anyone who thinks otherwise is leaning scum immediately in my book. If he is mafia, he already fooled me and I applaud him. 27ninjabunnies - Mafia leaner - her play is just too similar to the last cell game at this point for me to ignore it, she would be the prime candidate in her cell. Holyflare - read my filter and find what i think of his scummy ass. | ||
| ||
