Hogwarts Mafia - Page 79

StorrZerg

United States13910 Posts

October 19 2013 19:47 GMT

#1561

any reason to the ordering? idk kinda bothers me you don't have them organized by house. but thats minor and really doesn't matter i guess

Onegu

United States9695 Posts

October 19 2013 19:50 GMT

#1562

On October 20 2013 04:30 Mattchew wrote:

Why is ET and hopeless blank? You write "nothing" on others but those two are blank... Since I have scum reads on you and ET at this point I find this interesting.

I-be-Pro

Azerbaijan97 Posts

October 19 2013 19:52 GMT

#1563

On October 20 2013 04:46 justanothertownie wrote:

Show nested quote +

On October 20 2013 04:44 I-be-Pro wrote:

On October 20 2013 04:39 raynpelikonoshi wrote:
Who's sayin i am playing to my scum meta? This is important.

-rayn

I remember people saying that some would instalynch you if it was one or the other part of you posting from d1, so that's why I left you out as neutral despite having a townread on you.

On October 20 2013 04:39 justanothertownie wrote:

On October 20 2013 04:35 I-be-Pro wrote:

On October 20 2013 02:36 I-be-Pro wrote:
Honestly I've reread a coupld of things and I'm really not sure about a strong mafiaread right now. I've got a couple ones where I'd be "yeah could be mafia" but nothing to strong. The one on ET could be easily wrong imo, as I've been cherrypicking when writing about him, I'm still somewhat confused about Mocsta despite the green flip on Palmar, which completly busted my theory and reason to be wary of him but I'm not getting anything where I'd say "KILL IT WITH FIRE"...

I'm probably going to post my trademark picture during deadline. Keep Syllo alive at all cost please.

ET is the guy I'm buddied with or someone in my QT lied. It could be possible that my buddy is mafia, a thought that crossed my mind is that maybe my buddy isn't in the game but that'd be kind of a bitch-move from hosts so I'm pretty sure that's not the case, also the fact that noone is crying or raging about my claim makes it somewhat more likely it's a mafia imo.

I'd say ET has the best chance of flipping red.
Not sure if my read on superssoft is correct, I'd say that's the most likely to be wrong out of the vets.
Mocsta is neutral because I still don't like the SAM claim, his inthread presence is a slight townread which cancels that out.
BH is hard because I think he's trolling and lying all the time, maybe it's him being my buddy and he just lied, idk.
Ceph green solely because of the notes, otherwise he'd be yellow/orange.
I'd put Vayne and rayn as slight townreads if I knew them a little better, which you guys seem to do, so I left them white because it's my first game with them and you seem to be saying they're playing to their mafiameta. I'd put them down as slightly townish without knowing them.

Interesting. So yellow means scummy, yes?
If so - why is ET the only scumread you are giving reasons for while discussing your townier reads more indepht?

yellow is labeled as "somewhat scummy". Cephiro was the only one that got to orange so far and back to greenish-later on...
Because like I said above, I'm really not feeling sure about those reads, it's what I think so far but I haven't found anything outstanding without cherrypicking, which is what I earlier today when going through ET's filter imo, which is also the reason he's only yellow despite being the one I'd be most confident about.

Still there have to be reasons for you to paint those cells yellow, no? You discusses "hard" reads in this post anyways - why leave out your scumreads?

I discussed those that were recently changed or I have multiple points of view on:
Ceph from orange to green.
BH from green to neutral
Mocsta from green to neutral and for town inthread despite my ideas about his SAM.
Vayne and rayn for being town imo but still being labeled as neutral because of what some other people said.

snow would be yellow because he's looking out to much for "bonus points" by explaining shit all the time and being nice and all that.
ET has got a post himself from me so read that
Stutters because I'm underwhelmed by him
storr, youe and hopeless had some edgy stuff that rubbed me the wrong way while

Onegu

United States9695 Posts

October 19 2013 19:52 GMT

#1564

Oh Ive said in QT but not here, koshi would never make that case as scum on n1. I am very confident he is town.

I-be-Pro

Azerbaijan97 Posts

October 19 2013 19:53 GMT

#1565

On October 20 2013 04:47 StorrZerg wrote:
any reason to the ordering? idk kinda bothers me you don't have them organized by house. but thats minor and really doesn't matter i guess

they're ordered by numbers... copy & pasted from op

raynpelikonoshi

Cayman Islands1087 Posts

October 19 2013 19:56 GMT

#1566

On October 20 2013 04:39 syllogism wrote:
Rayn is one of the easiest town reads to make in this game and should never be lynched

This is correct and Toad, who else? yamato was confused because he did not read that i sign my posts and Koshi does not.
Who else? I have not been reading closely, so i dunno if there is someone else -- but you said "people" which indicates there is more than yamato.

-rayn

Mattchew

United States5684 Posts

October 19 2013 19:58 GMT

#1567

On October 20 2013 04:50 Onegu wrote:

Show nested quote +

Why is ET and hopeless blank? You write "nothing" on others but those two are blank... Since I have scum reads on you and ET at this point I find this interesting.

i have feelings of scum on them.. this is about my town reads not about my scum reads

StorrZerg

United States13910 Posts

October 19 2013 19:59 GMT

#1568

I-Be-Pro

i find it odd you wouldn't organize the players by house

like idk why its bothering me so much

You-Know-Who

Great Britain155 Posts

October 19 2013 20:00 GMT

#1569

No posting until the daypost please. Thanks!

<3

You-Know-Who

Great Britain155 Posts

October 19 2013 20:03 GMT

#1570

Day 2

RP in progress.

Pandain as Harry Potter was sent to St. Mungos!
+ Show Spoiler +

You are the Chosen One, Harry Potter. Each night you have the ability to cast spells. Each spell can only be cast twice.

Lumos (unlocked at start) - Allows you to see how many people (not specifically who) visited your house that night. PM the host with ##Lumos.
Diffindo (unlocked at start) - Inflicts 0.5 KP on your target. He will be aware that he lost 0.5 KP. PM the host with ##Diffindo: XY.
Expelliarmus (unlocked at N2) - Roleblocks one player. PM the host with ##Expelliarmus: XY.
Fidelius Charm (unlocked at N3) - Saves a player from 1 KP. PM the host with ##Fidelius Charm: XY.
Accio (unlocked at N4) - Switches you with another player. Anything that targets you will affect the other person and vice-versa. PM the host with ##Accio: XY.

You win with Scum. Scum QT: [REDACTED]

LastArgument as Padma Patil was sent to St. Mungos!
+ Show Spoiler +

You are Padma Patil. You are masoned with your twin sister Parvati Patil. QT: [REDACTED}

You win with Town.

LoneMeow as Roger Davies was sent to St. Mungos!
+ Show Spoiler +

You are Roger Davies. Intrigued by the masterly art of Legilimency, you have taught yourself the basics of identifying the roles of your fellow students. Each night, you may read the mind of another person. Unfortunately being an autodidact limits your skills in this field, you are therefore restricted to only identify one ability of your target. PM the host with ##Legilimency: XY.

You win with Scum. Scum QT: [REDACTED]

supersoft as Marietta Edgecomb was sent to St. Mungos!
+ Show Spoiler +

You are Marietta Edgecomb. Your parents sent you to Hogwarts to educate you into a proper witch but it turns out you are a Squib.

You win with Town.

EchelonTee as Vincent Crabbe was sent to St. Mungos!
+ Show Spoiler +

You are Vincent Crabbe. Being a beater of the Slytherin Quidditch team you are able to knock someone out with a Bludger. Your target will be hit for 0.5 KP. You have four Bludgers. Type ##Bludger: XY in the game to hit someone during day and PM the host with ##Bludger: XY to hit someone at night. You may hit two bludgers per cycle but only one per day and one per night at most. Also, you and Goyle are BFFs and therefore inseparable. If one of you dies, the other dies as well.
You win with Scum. Scum QT: [REDACTED]

I-Be-Pro as Gregory Goyle was sent to St. Mungos!
+ Show Spoiler +

You are Gregory Goyle. Your parents sent you to Hogwarts to educate you into a proper wizard but it turns out you are a Squib. You and Crabbe are BFFs and therefore inseparable. If one of you dies, the other dies as well.

You win with Town.

It is now Day 1. You have 48 hours to lynch someone.

This game uses Plurality Lynch. Voting is mandatory. Only votes in the voting thread are counted. Please vote here.

Sn0_Man

Tebellong44238 Posts

October 19 2013 20:04 GMT

#1571

Ladies and gentlemen 3 scum dead N1

justanothertownie

16309 Posts

October 19 2013 20:04 GMT

#1572

LOL

Grackaroni

United States9832 Posts

October 19 2013 20:04 GMT

#1573

Wow Pandain was mafia?

StorrZerg

United States13910 Posts

October 19 2013 20:05 GMT

#1574

WHAT THE HELL HAPPENED

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

October 19 2013 20:05 GMT

#1575

Good enough I guess, although I think I should have realized that Pandain was being too reasonable.

You-Know-Who

Great Britain155 Posts

October 19 2013 20:05 GMT

#1576

You may now post.

EDIT: Looks like everyone already got that memo...

Sn0_Man

Tebellong44238 Posts

October 19 2013 20:06 GMT

#1577

Well I hope it's now clear that Supersoft's theory is awful and also that flavour names don't make you town (rofl crabbe and goyle not being same alignment).