Hogwarts Mafia - Page 78

On October 20 2013 02:35 justanothertownie wrote:

My feeling on hopeless changed when I was reading his filter (I have no townread on him but I didn't find enough for a scumread). I stated that. There is nothing about Storrzerg but I don't like the idea he just presented.

On October 19 2013 02:57 I-be-Pro wrote:
okay I figured this shit out. Palmar is mafia and he's angry at everyone because he's indeed doing the right thing because Mocsta is mafia as well and they had it planned all along. But Palmar expected to get less flak so he's mad while knowing his target is mafia.

My gut is always right on these things.

On October 18 2013 20:06 Mattchew wrote:

In an attempt to answer your question i think i found my first scum read, storrzerg.

I'm phone posting so this case will not be well formated nor long winded

Storr has focused on sn0 since his very first post which was more of a joke then anything

Storr has be consistently seeking approval of our qt before posting here, this is probably to make sure that other townies agree with him

Palmar very early said he liked storr's idea to kill sn0, this is what really set off the influx of storr's push on sn0

Storr's case on sn0 is bad, like forced bad. It only brings up one game related post, which is a setup post by sn0 that concludes scum may want to have a hand in who wins the challenges. This is a reasonable point

Storr has continued to push this case on sn0 despite its holes and seems to ignore a lot of other happenings in the thread... I think this is to look like a tunnelling townie

Storr has said in this thread and multiple times in the qt that hufflepuff produce the least dark wizards

Storr is scum

##vote storrzerg

On October 20 2013 03:13 yamato77 wrote:

Catching up, but I wanted to note this post.

Matt, this is sketchy as fuck. No reason to think Storr is mafia IMO, and for this to basically be your only scum read of the game... I am disappoint.

On October 20 2013 03:18 Mattchew wrote:

yes.. my read on marv and you was really good day 1/2 last game too.. i start slow because I process of elimination scum hunt

right now i dont believe storr is scum... hes too willing to share his entire thought process

i dont have any direct scum read right now... just people im ok with dying

On October 20 2013 03:00 LastArgument wrote:
I'm not sure about Mocsta, some of his content looks ok, he's pushing and pulling and he seems to back down when it's reasonable to back down.

Cephiro promised his play would improve so what happened yesterday wouldn't happen again; he hasn't posted since.

LoneMeow isn't posting in our QT at all, in some ways I find this more damning than not posting in the thread - in Noir he claimed that he was intimidated by vets, so you think a QT would be the perfect place to get some thoughts down, but apparently not.

Stutters looks bad, his contributions, what little exist of them, are quite superficial. It doesn't necessarily mean he's mafia, but usually as town he has some quality of analysis that's lacking here.

I don't think EchelonTee looks very good; I don't like how he misrepresented Onegu (I posted about that on Day 1), also Palmar didn't like how ET looked, nor does syllogism I think. Maybe he seems to be commenting on the game, yet not participating?

Toad's roleclaim is rather odd and he's not attempted to insert himself into a kind of "vet circle" as he likes to do as town. He's capable of making earnest discussion as mafia; I've noted several people giving him townreads for things I consider quite null for Toad.

I simply don't believe this post; it doesn't look like a genuine 'crazy' theory to me, rather it looks like someone trying to invent a crazy theory so that he looks like a townie with a crazy theory.

I still have a lot of players who I'm struggling to lean much on either way, I won't list them here, although there's bound to be a couple of mafia in these people. I'm still somewhat town on Mattchew although I'm not sure about it, I'd like to see more of him.

On October 20 2013 03:28 LastArgument wrote:


I'm curious whether this post constitutes you playing better than Noir, which was your stated goal earlier in this game? It feels quite apathetic.

In Noir one of your early mafia-reads was correct (Stutters), was it not? You seem a bit less emotionally invested this game.

I do have a couple of reasons to think you may be town, but I'm not very confident in them.

On October 20 2013 02:36 I-be-Pro wrote:
Honestly I've reread a coupld of things and I'm really not sure about a strong mafiaread right now. I've got a couple ones where I'd be "yeah could be mafia" but nothing to strong. The one on ET could be easily wrong imo, as I've been cherrypicking when writing about him, I'm still somewhat confused about Mocsta despite the green flip on Palmar, which completly busted my theory and reason to be wary of him but I'm not getting anything where I'd say "KILL IT WITH FIRE"...

I'm probably going to post my trademark picture during deadline. Keep Syllo alive at all cost please.

On October 20 2013 04:35 I-be-Pro wrote:




ET is the guy I'm buddied with or someone in my QT lied. It could be possible that my buddy is mafia, a thought that crossed my mind is that maybe my buddy isn't in the game but that'd be kind of a bitch-move from hosts so I'm pretty sure that's not the case, also the fact that noone is crying or raging about my claim makes it somewhat more likely it's a mafia imo.

I'd say ET has the best chance of flipping red.
Not sure if my read on superssoft is correct, I'd say that's the most likely to be wrong out of the vets.
Mocsta is neutral because I still don't like the SAM claim, his inthread presence is a slight townread which cancels that out.
BH is hard because I think he's trolling and lying all the time, maybe it's him being my buddy and he just lied, idk.
Ceph green solely because of the notes, otherwise he'd be yellow/orange.
I'd put Vayne and rayn as slight townreads if I knew them a little better, which you guys seem to do, so I left them white because it's my first game with them and you seem to be saying they're playing to their mafiameta. I'd put them down as slightly townish without knowing them.

On October 20 2013 04:39 raynpelikonoshi wrote:
Who's sayin i am playing to my scum meta? This is important.

-rayn

On October 20 2013 04:39 justanothertownie wrote:

Interesting. So yellow means scummy, yes?
If so - why is ET the only scumread you are giving reasons for while discussing your townier reads more indepht?

On October 20 2013 04:44 I-be-Pro wrote:

I remember people saying that some would instalynch you if it was one or the other part of you posting from d1, so that's why I left you out as neutral despite having a townread on you.

yellow is labeled as "somewhat scummy". Cephiro was the only one that got to orange so far and back to greenish-later on...
Because like I said above, I'm really not feeling sure about those reads, it's what I think so far but I haven't found anything outstanding without cherrypicking, which is what I earlier today when going through ET's filter imo, which is also the reason he's only yellow despite being the one I'd be most confident about.