|
On March 30 2013 00:55 Hapahauli wrote:Show nested quote +On March 30 2013 00:50 Oatsmaster wrote: I saw that, thought it was really scummy, didnt bring it up cause it was so scummy.
Think for a bit, does this change in playstyle relay information about marv's alignment? Or are you just mad that he is fucking useless.
And... what the fuck?
I did refer everyone back to SnB's opening of day 2, and the lack of anything useful.
Also context. I read the nightkills and a bit after that earlier today, saw that, thought that was so scummy. Left. Returned. Posted that SnB is scum. Also he completely fails to address those USELESS FUCKING SCUMMY POSTS. and continues to do bullshit in his latest post.
|
okay now that it's out in the thread I am a one-shot medic more specifically, I am a "vanilla townie who is also a one-shot medic."
I targeted Hapa last night. I knew from asking Kurumi that I would not get notified if Hapa was saved, but Hapa would get notified, hence the post I put up right after the deadline when I saw that only one person was dead. I thought there was a decent chance that I had guessed correctly. That's why I asked Hapa specifically if he had taken a shot, before there was any indication of missing KP.
(I posted that even though Palmar died because I was already expecting scum would have 2KP; in my experience it's pretty common in 16-player games for scum to have more than 1 KP (either from factional KP or some from factional and some from roles, but since 1KP is "balanced" for 9player games, 16player games usually have more than 1).)
Now that that's out in the open, I can explain a few things. (1) The part of my post that Marv was confused about was a direct reference to this. There's no way that Marv misses this stuff in my filter if he actually is trying to analyze me and determine my alignment. I intentionally made it kind of oblique but clear enough to anyone who thinks about it for a second and is decently intelligent, because I was planning to claim anyway but wanted to see who was actually paying attention and who wasn't. So yeah that's what I mean when I talk about Marv calling me scum but not actually paying attention to or thinking about my filter.
(2) (I was planning on claiming regardless because I can't use my power again and having two confirmed townies on day 2 is worth more than making scum wifom over whether their shot was blocked by a medic and whether that medic could go again). (3) I can also explain the stuff with Acrofales's claim earlier. When Grack flipped, he flipped a role with no powers, but with a specific rolename written in blue. I am a "vanilla townie", my rolename is written in black, but I do have a power. (before someone jumps on me, my role PM includes the sentence "you win with town" so I'm not accidentally claiming third party VE-style here). So I thought it seemed likely that all of the "powerless townies" had specific role names written in blue, and all of the "town power roles" were "vanilla townies who also have ____ power" with the role name written in black. Then when Palmar went after Acro for his claim of "vanilla townie" with the role name written in green, I thought it meant Palmar had a similar role to mine and had come to the same conclusion about how role names work in this game. Obviously when nisani flipped, it proved all of this completely wrong. But hopefully this explains some weirdness in my filter.
|
On March 30 2013 00:57 Oatsmaster wrote:Show nested quote +On March 30 2013 00:54 Hapahauli wrote: But see that is exactly how you read marv. Town marv is generally aggressive and absurdly pro-town. He'll pepper everyone with questions, call everyone terrible, and will lead the town for better or for worse (almost always the former). Scum-marv is much more passive, doesn't push his cases strongly, and "goes with the flow."
Explain the scum meta part please Town games: In MTG AFAIK, he was useless. In Chrono as far as my memory holds out, he was useless. Scum games: Trolled themed, didnt stop my mislynch, generally active and it took a vig shot to kill him. In Hero, again really active, abrasive, fuckton of useless 1 liners, survived to the end. I didnt read any of his other scum games, you mind telling me what this meta read comes from?
Mtg was a hydra game. Bad to draw conclusions. And he was far from useless in chrono and got killed first by scum. As far as those scum games go, there are variations in activity but the fundamental read is the same.
As far as SnB goes, that comment isn't necessarily scummy. It does strongly suggest he has extra info, but that's it.
|
I still want to lynch SnB.
What a clean claim.
No.
|
As for SnB's claim, I have my own thoughts on it but I want to hear what other players (NOT Kei cause u so townie) think of it
|
On March 30 2013 01:08 Hapahauli wrote:Show nested quote +On March 30 2013 00:57 Oatsmaster wrote:On March 30 2013 00:54 Hapahauli wrote: But see that is exactly how you read marv. Town marv is generally aggressive and absurdly pro-town. He'll pepper everyone with questions, call everyone terrible, and will lead the town for better or for worse (almost always the former). Scum-marv is much more passive, doesn't push his cases strongly, and "goes with the flow."
Explain the scum meta part please Town games: In MTG AFAIK, he was useless. In Chrono as far as my memory holds out, he was useless. Scum games: Trolled themed, didnt stop my mislynch, generally active and it took a vig shot to kill him. In Hero, again really active, abrasive, fuckton of useless 1 liners, survived to the end. I didnt read any of his other scum games, you mind telling me what this meta read comes from? Mtg was a hydra game. Bad to draw conclusions. And he was far from useless in chrono and got killed first by scum. As far as those scum games go, there are variations in activity but the fundamental read is the same. As far as SnB goes, that comment isn't necessarily scummy. It does strongly suggest he has extra info, but that's it.
What.
Tell me more about how scum marv is passive and how he is passive in this game?
Tell me more considering marv claims that if he is suspected day 1(he didnt claim that here though) he is never scum and what that means.
|
I believe his claim because I think he's not (not the other way around).
|
EDBOP: I believe his claim because I think he's town (not the other way around).
|
...and very strong feelings in one way I might add. Correctly state my opinion and rationale and you too could earn townie points.
|
On March 30 2013 01:13 Oatsmaster wrote:Show nested quote +On March 30 2013 01:08 Hapahauli wrote:On March 30 2013 00:57 Oatsmaster wrote:On March 30 2013 00:54 Hapahauli wrote: But see that is exactly how you read marv. Town marv is generally aggressive and absurdly pro-town. He'll pepper everyone with questions, call everyone terrible, and will lead the town for better or for worse (almost always the former). Scum-marv is much more passive, doesn't push his cases strongly, and "goes with the flow."
Explain the scum meta part please Town games: In MTG AFAIK, he was useless. In Chrono as far as my memory holds out, he was useless. Scum games: Trolled themed, didnt stop my mislynch, generally active and it took a vig shot to kill him. In Hero, again really active, abrasive, fuckton of useless 1 liners, survived to the end. I didnt read any of his other scum games, you mind telling me what this meta read comes from? That'll take a while. On phone right now, but I'll get back to ya. Mtg was a hydra game. Bad to draw conclusions. And he was far from useless in chrono and got killed first by scum. As far as those scum games go, there are variations in activity but the fundamental read is the same. As far as SnB goes, that comment isn't necessarily scummy. It does strongly suggest he has extra info, but that's it. What. Tell me more about how scum marv is passive and how he is passive in this game? Tell me more considering marv claims that if he is suspected day 1(he didnt claim that here though) he is never scum and what that means.
|
On March 30 2013 01:15 Hapahauli wrote: ...and very strong feelings in one way I might add. Correctly state my opinion and rationale and you too could earn townie points.
Can they be exchanged with GreyMist points? If not, I dont want them
|
Failpost. On phone. Will get back to ya about Marv, cause it'll take a while
|
On March 30 2013 01:16 Oatsmaster wrote:Show nested quote +On March 30 2013 01:15 Hapahauli wrote: ...and very strong feelings in one way I might add. Correctly state my opinion and rationale and you too could earn townie points. Can they be exchanged with GreyMist points? If not, I dont want them
I am a well connected man.
|
Wait did acro role claim?
|
United Kingdom36156 Posts
The claim is probably legit if my own role PM is anything to go by.
I can't pick out 4 mafia now for the life of me.
|
On March 30 2013 01:19 Hapahauli wrote: Wait did acro role claim? Vanilla townie in his first post.
|
On March 30 2013 01:21 marvellosity wrote: The claim is probably legit if my own role PM is anything to go by.
I can't pick out 4 mafia now for the life of me.
Do you have reasons to believe it to be true beyond aesthetics?
|
SnB, why did you choose to save Hapa?
|
On March 30 2013 01:21 marvellosity wrote: The claim is probably legit if my own role PM is anything to go by.
I can't pick out 4 mafia now for the life of me.
There have been 3 flips.
Are you claiming 1 shot blue too?
|
On March 30 2013 01:21 prplhz wrote:Vanilla townie in his first post. with a green name
|
|
|
|