|
[QUOTE]On October 03 2011 12:35 chaoser wrote:
Ok, so here's what everyone should know. Drazerk said he got hit on Day 4. He also got motivation and used it on Night 3 to protect prplhz and me. This is confirmed by Curu. He later protected me from a hit on Night 4.
This means that syllo must have given him motivation on Night 2. But Syllo died on Day 3. That makes it impossible for him to protect Drazerk for day 4 since he wasn't around on Night 3 to do it. That means the only way Drazerk could have survived a hit was if there was another medic. This confirms heist as the other medic.
At the same time, it explains why mafia didn't shoot Drazerk since they knew he was being protected but not by who.
That leaves:
27. heist
22. Cyber_Cheese
5. kitaman27
30. TranceStorm
6. GGQ
Mafia would obviously all pile onto heist since I just said I'm willing to lynch him. There's a 3/5 chance to hit mafia here, and 3/4 if you think kita is town tracker.
I feel however, Cyber_Cheese is 100% mafia.
[quote]On wherebugsgo, I get the distinct impression he's just a townie who wanted to have the ring and decided acting as Smeagol and demanding the ring until people got bored of it was better than trying to defend himself actively. I'm willing to bet there is no posting restriction, in fact I think it was explicitly stated somewhere that there wasn't.
That said, I'd be comfortable with a lynch on him on the off-chance he is telling the truth about being third party, purely because that seems to make him a safer bet than most others.[/quote]
He's ok with lynching third-party.
He then says iGrok is suspicious but is "giving hi a break".
[quote]IGrok seems a little bit suspicious, but since I'm giving archon_toilet a break I guess I'll be doing the same here.[/quote]
He then goes on to defend iGrok when iGrok claims third-party.
[quote]Go back and look at the claims of chaoser and igrok, if we must kill a neutral party, chaoser is the optimal choice.[/quote]
but he wants to lynch me over iGrok if I'm third-party.
[quote]LOL WHAT
I collapse in my bed with a few hours to go, and out of nowhere someone who hadn't even been considered previously was lynched.
Bad call on Errandor, I really didn't see that happening, and I guess I'm not the only one[quote]
He also pulls exactly what people have said about mafia leaving their vote on prp and then going WHAT STUPID TOWNIES when Errandor gets lynched.
##vote: Cyber_cheese[/QUOTE]
I was hoping to keep avoiding role-claiming in full so mafia could waste hits on me, but that doesn't help me if I die.
I am Meriadoc Brandybuck, Hobbit of the Fellowship, Hider.
I have the ability to hide behind people at night, with a 50% chance to die if my target is mafia.
So far, I've hidden behind:
iGrok - Night 1
iGrok - Night 2
Greymist - Night 3
Raynpelikoneet - Night 4
Chaoser - Night 5
You who claimed multiple kp were a better choice than someone who claimed one if it had to be third party.
The Errandor thing genuinely surprised me, it was an overreaction.
I changed my stance on third parties after I made that WBG quote, when I realised lynching someone that might be mafia would be better for information.
|
On October 03 2011 12:55 heist wrote:
Why would 3 mafia have 2 KP? Doesn't it round down? But anyways, irrelevant. I'll be keeping my vote on cyber_cheese.
It rounds up. Never in a game has it rounded down.
|
EBWOP - Fixed the failed quote
On October 03 2011 12:35 chaoser wrote:Ok, so here's what everyone should know. Drazerk said he got hit on Day 4. He also got motivation and used it on Night 3 to protect prplhz and me. This is confirmed by Curu. He later protected me from a hit on Night 4. This means that syllo must have given him motivation on Night 2. But Syllo died on Day 3. That makes it impossible for him to protect Drazerk for day 4 since he wasn't around on Night 3 to do it. That means the only way Drazerk could have survived a hit was if there was another medic. This confirms heist as the other medic. At the same time, it explains why mafia didn't shoot Drazerk since they knew he was being protected but not by who. That leaves: 27. heist 22. Cyber_Cheese 5. kitaman27 30. TranceStorm 6. GGQ Mafia would obviously all pile onto heist since I just said I'm willing to lynch him. There's a 3/5 chance to hit mafia here, and 3/4 if you think kita is town tracker. I feel however, Cyber_Cheese is 100% mafia. Show nested quote +On wherebugsgo, I get the distinct impression he's just a townie who wanted to have the ring and decided acting as Smeagol and demanding the ring until people got bored of it was better than trying to defend himself actively. I'm willing to bet there is no posting restriction, in fact I think it was explicitly stated somewhere that there wasn't.
That said, I'd be comfortable with a lynch on him on the off-chance he is telling the truth about being third party, purely because that seems to make him a safer bet than most others. He's ok with lynching third-party. He then says iGrok is suspicious but is "giving hi a break". Show nested quote +IGrok seems a little bit suspicious, but since I'm giving archon_toilet a break I guess I'll be doing the same here. He then goes on to defend iGrok when iGrok claims third-party. Show nested quote +Go back and look at the claims of chaoser and igrok, if we must kill a neutral party, chaoser is the optimal choice. but he wants to lynch me over iGrok if I'm third-party. Show nested quote +LOL WHAT
I collapse in my bed with a few hours to go, and out of nowhere someone who hadn't even been considered previously was lynched.
Bad call on Errandor, I really didn't see that happening, and I guess I'm not the only one He also pulls exactly what people have said about mafia leaving their vote on prp and then going WHAT STUPID TOWNIES when Errandor gets lynched. ##vote: Cyber_cheese
I was hoping to keep avoiding role-claiming in full so mafia could waste hits on me, but that doesn't help me if I die.
I am Meriadoc Brandybuck, Hobbit of the Fellowship, Hider.
I have the ability to hide behind people at night, with a 50% chance to die if my target is mafia.
So far, I've hidden behind:
iGrok - Night 1
iGrok - Night 2
Greymist - Night 3
Raynpelikoneet - Night 4
Chaoser - Night 5
You who claimed multiple kp were a better choice than someone who claimed one if it had to be third party.
The Errandor thing genuinely surprised me, it was an overreaction.
I changed my stance on third parties after I made that WBG quote, when I realised lynching someone that might be mafia would be better for information.
|
I was hoping to keep avoiding role-claiming in full so mafia could waste hits on me, but that doesn't help me if I die.
Why would mafia hit you if you're fucking suspected of being mafia? And this fear is only contingent on IF we are able to lynch mafia today.
It's between you, who looks scummy as fuck with all your contradictions and scumminess and GGQ, who has been fingered by Radfield as scummy and someone that should be shot and also pushed for iGrok's lynch at the very beginning. He looks so damn clean it's kinda suspicious. You on the other hand look so fucking scummy. We can skip over this debate by lynching TS who is 100% mafia and try to buy another day, hoping that mafia doesn't kill anyone tonight since we got two medics if everyone is willing.
|
I have the ability to hide behind people at night, with a 50% chance to die if my target is mafia.
So far, I've hidden behind:
iGrok - Night 1
iGrok - Night 2
Greymist - Night 3
Raynpelikoneet - Night 4
Chaoser - Night 5
You hid behind iGrok twice and didn't die with a 50% chance to die if you hid behind mafia? What a shitty claim.
|
On October 03 2011 13:04 chaoser wrote:Show nested quote +I was hoping to keep avoiding role-claiming in full so mafia could waste hits on me, but that doesn't help me if I die. Why would mafia hit you if you're fucking suspected of being mafia? And this fear is only contingent on IF we are able to lynch mafia today. It's between you, who looks scummy as fuck with all your contradictions and scumminess and GGQ, who has been fingered by Radfield as scummy and someone that should be shot and also pushed for iGrok's lynch at the very beginning. He looks so damn clean it's kinda suspicious. You on the other hand look so fucking scummy. We can skip over this debate by lynching TS who is 100% mafia and try to buy another day, hoping that mafia doesn't kill anyone tonight since we got two medics if everyone is willing.
Yeah they might not attack me, but they definitely wouldn't once I claimed in full, I figured some chance was better than none.
|
United States720 Posts
Let's assume you have this power. Why the hell have you been using it every night? I'm not gonna lie, this is a terrible power you revealed.
Either you have a 50% chance to die for nothing if you hide behind mafia
or
You throw someone else in front of you (someone who could actually have blue powers) just to save yourself.
|
On October 03 2011 13:10 heist wrote:
Let's assume you have this power. Why the hell have you been using it every night? I'm not gonna lie, this is a terrible power you revealed.
Either you have a 50% chance to die for nothing if you hide behind mafia
or
You throw someone else in front of you (someone who could actually have blue powers) just to save yourself.
Because then if I survive I can protect the person I was behind.
|
On October 03 2011 13:16 Cyber_Cheese wrote:Show nested quote +On October 03 2011 13:10 heist wrote:
Let's assume you have this power. Why the hell have you been using it every night? I'm not gonna lie, this is a terrible power you revealed.
Either you have a 50% chance to die for nothing if you hide behind mafia
or
You throw someone else in front of you (someone who could actually have blue powers) just to save yourself.
Because then if I survive I can protect the person I was behind.
That's also not how it works, things that target me miss, things that hit the other person hit us both.
|
United States720 Posts
So you choose someone to hide behind. You get targetted. And instead of that person taking the hit for you, you come out and save the two of you?
What's with this "if", won't you live regardless of being targeted if you are hiding?
|
United States720 Posts
|
On October 03 2011 13:19 heist wrote:
So you choose someone to hide behind. You get targetted. And instead of that person taking the hit for you, you come out and save the two of you?
What's with this "if", won't you live regardless of being targeted if you are hiding?
Erm what?
I hide behind someone.
Things aimed at that someone hit us both.
Things aimed at me miss entirely.
If that someone is mafia, I have a 50% chance to die.
|
United States720 Posts
Lemme get this straight:
1. Any attacks on you will miss.
2. The only way to kill you at night (assuming you target a townie) is if your target gets hit. The hit will apply to both of you.
3. Yet you can also protect your target?
wtf?
|
|
|
On October 03 2011 13:16 Cyber_Cheese wrote:Show nested quote +On October 03 2011 13:10 heist wrote:
Let's assume you have this power. Why the hell have you been using it every night? I'm not gonna lie, this is a terrible power you revealed.
Either you have a 50% chance to die for nothing if you hide behind mafia
or
You throw someone else in front of you (someone who could actually have blue powers) just to save yourself.
Because then if I survive I can protect the person I was behind.
How does this work again? You don't protect shit, you just survive. Also, please explain why you hid behind iGrok for two whole days when there's a 50% chance you would die and you didn't apparently?
|
On October 03 2011 13:25 heist wrote:
Lemme get this straight:
1. Any attacks on you will miss.
2. The only way to kill you at night (assuming you target a townie) is if your target gets hit. The hit will apply to both of you.
3. Yet you can also protect your target?
wtf?
I don't protect them...
|
United States720 Posts
On October 03 2011 13:16 Cyber_Cheese wrote:Show nested quote +On October 03 2011 13:10 heist wrote:
Let's assume you have this power. Why the hell have you been using it every night? I'm not gonna lie, this is a terrible power you revealed.
Either you have a 50% chance to die for nothing if you hide behind mafia
or
You throw someone else in front of you (someone who could actually have blue powers) just to save yourself.
Because then if I survive I can protect the person I was behind.
Explain.
|
Also, why the fuck would Merry be a hider? He fucking kills Nazgul. Not once in the books did he hide. This looks like you went into PYP mafia and stole the hider role from there.
|
On October 03 2011 13:28 chaoser wrote:Show nested quote +On October 03 2011 13:16 Cyber_Cheese wrote:On October 03 2011 13:10 heist wrote:
Let's assume you have this power. Why the hell have you been using it every night? I'm not gonna lie, this is a terrible power you revealed.
Either you have a 50% chance to die for nothing if you hide behind mafia
or
You throw someone else in front of you (someone who could actually have blue powers) just to save yourself.
Because then if I survive I can protect the person I was behind. How does this work again? You don't protect shit, you just survive. Also, please explain why you hid behind iGrok for two whole days when there's a 50% chance you would die and you didn't apparently?
iGrok the first night because I didn't think he'd get hit.
When I was alive day 2 I figured I should defend him because I survived.
I then decided to double check night 2 because it was only 50/50, and if I died he was very likely to get lynched day 3 anyway at that point.
As it turns out I wasn't able to save him despite getting lucky and surviving again.
On October 03 2011 13:31 chaoser wrote:
Also, why the fuck would Merry be a hider? He fucking kills Nazgul. Not once in the books did he hide. This looks like you went into PYP mafia and stole the hider role from there.
Why the fuck would Theon Greyjoy be in a Lotr themed game?
On October 03 2011 13:29 heist wrote:Show nested quote +On October 03 2011 13:16 Cyber_Cheese wrote:On October 03 2011 13:10 heist wrote:
Let's assume you have this power. Why the hell have you been using it every night? I'm not gonna lie, this is a terrible power you revealed.
Either you have a 50% chance to die for nothing if you hide behind mafia
or
You throw someone else in front of you (someone who could actually have blue powers) just to save yourself.
Because then if I survive I can protect the person I was behind. Explain.
Defend them from the people pushing to lynch them.
|
United States720 Posts
Well I'm done for the night. Your claim isn't really backed by anything. So either we believe you or we don't.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
