As a note, neither I nor sandroba can be around for the deadline tonight as we both have commitments off the forum. When I get off work (sometime between 10 and 11:30 i hope) I will return with the day post. Voting will still end at 9pm est but the unfortunately the flip will not take place till after.

Sevryn

698 Posts

July 28 2011 20:16 GMT

#2133

so are there any more cases? against people to lynch 2morrow?

Palmar

Iceland22630 Posts

July 28 2011 20:18 GMT

#2134

let's just wait till tomorrow?

Sevryn

698 Posts

July 28 2011 20:21 GMT

#2135

i suppose

RebirthOfLeGenD

USA5860 Posts

July 28 2011 20:32 GMT

#2136

On July 28 2011 19:56 Lucidity wrote:
I've been having trouble with RoL still being alive. After he claimed Day 2 I was convinced that SKs would target him. He was basically a confirmed 3rd party.

Here are the different scenarios where he could stay alive:

RoL is Batman:
He got hit night 1 by the Mafia/Joker/Vigi.
Decon was an idiot and didn't target him on Night 2.
Seeing as Palmar is claiming Batman too, I don't think this scenario is plausible.

RoL is Joker:
He got hit night 1 by Mafia/Ra'as/Vigi.
Batman was an idiot and didn't target him on Night 2 or 3.
Is Batman that bad?

RoL is Vet:
He got hit night 1 by Mafia/3rd Party/Vigi
Basically the Mafia and Vigis would leave him alone at this point, in case he's 3rd party and they waste a bullet.
This leaves us with 2 or 3 3rd parties who would be interested in killing him. Only 1 of them would have to act to kill RoL.
I find it hard to believe that not one of them tried their luck.

RoL lied about being hit:
In this case all 3 3rd parties would be expected to take a hit on him. He should be dead.

What does this leave us with? Incompetent 3rd party players I guess. I can't see how else he's alive. His biggest chance of still being alive is as either Joker or Batman, with deconduo messing up and not targeting him. Or due to mass medics protecting him. If so, well done on protecting someone who was considered 3rd party...

Pretty useless in the end, but it was bugging me.

-_-, I will still respond to your other posts but this entire reasoning is silly when all my actions combined with counter claims, etc prove me to be a veteran. On that note, you basically just made it so that me not wanting to lynch you just got finitely smaller.

RebirthOfLeGenD

USA5860 Posts

July 28 2011 20:34 GMT

#2137

On July 28 2011 22:03 Lucidity wrote:
Can you provide an alternative explanation for RoL still being alive?

Actually, I don't see why yesterday's logic has changed. Keeping SKs around only help scum to even out the teams at this point. We need to reduce the overall KP. Last night is a good example of what happens when we keep SKs around. They kill townies. This will happen even if they're looking for scum (which they're not), simply because there are mass amounts of townies left.

##vote Palmar for being confirmed 3rd party.

To respond to this, the enemy of my enemy is my friend.
Our win conditions don't conflict with batman, and we have a mutual goal: The death of joker. Ra'as was beneficial to get rid of because he is NOT working towards our goal and is another KP aimed at batman, once batman died the joker is still alive with one less threat going at him.

So no, I don't agree with trying to kill batman at this point. I can deduce who the joker must be then publicly post who it probably is.

hiro protagonist

1294 Posts

July 28 2011 20:46 GMT

#2138

well, that makes things easy:

##Vote: Lucidity

another day, another scum gone

RebirthOfLeGenD

USA5860 Posts

July 28 2011 21:59 GMT

#2139

I am sorry to be so candid right now, but I promise I will have more information in a few minutes.
Currently I need everyone to switch votes over to Pyo, I will have an explanation out very shortly but it is important we get this switch going right now.

I am really sorry, I meant to do this a bit earlier but I had overslept