• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 17:27
CET 23:27
KST 07:27
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
[ASL22] Finals Preview: Sweet Victory!12[ASL22] Ro4 Preview: Mirror Mirror6[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: Within Reach5[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: In A Tizzy11[ASL22] Ro16 Preview: Holy Diver5
Community News
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over0Dark completes military service, returns to SC213[BSL23] RO16 Group Stage20Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?2Weekly Cups (Oct 26 - Nov 1): MaxPax, herO, Solar win0
StarCraft 2
General
TLMC 23 StarCraft open world shooter announced at BlizzCon Dark completes military service, returns to SC2 No more SC2 streamers on team liquid? Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over
Tourneys
RSL goes to London! 2026 Offline Finals Nov 21-22 Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) Dark returns! GSL CK #7 4v4 Team Battle (Nov 19) soO & FanTaSy return! SC2 Kevin Scrim 4v4 (Nov 16)
Strategy
[H] ZvP Mid-Late Game: Stalkers Collossi HT
Custom Maps
[G] How to playtest arcade maps Starcraft 2 Advance [D] the control group Simple Questions/Answers
External Content
Mutation # 552 Secret Storm The PondCast: SC2 News & Results Mutation # 551 Robotic Revival Mutation # 550 Graveyard Shift
Brood War
General
BW General Discussion NaDa's Body List of top players active on ShieldBattery Shield Battery Server New Patch BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/
Tourneys
SC1 Kevin Scrim hosted by SOOP (Nov 18-19) [IPSL] Winter 26-27 Round of 16! [Megathread] Daily Proleagues 2v2v2v2 Tournament Stage 2: Players
Strategy
Pluto's TvP 5Marine 2Medic Push Simple Questions, Simple Answers Infested Terran strategies in 2026 Nuke strategy worked in K-League 2026-11-09
Other Games
General Games
Nintendo Switch Thread Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Free Space RTS Game, optimised f. Phone/Tablet etc List of Game Threads The PlayStation 5
Dota 2
League of Legends
[TL LoL EUW IHs] Teemo shall perish
Heroes of the Storm
Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine Artificial Intelligence Thread Trading/Investing Thread
Fan Clubs
Fan Club Resource Thread Reynor Fan Club The Flash Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
Football (Soccer) Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Recent Gifted Posts
Blogs
The time I organised my…
AssyrianKing
Why I built Repalyzer (1.1.…
BlueStar
Innovate or Game Over?
TrAiDoS
ShieldBattery on Mac
Kraekkling
Can Bots Beat Pros?? Starcr…
namkraft
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Socialism Anyone?
GreenHorizons
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 10337 users

WCS 2013 Format, Players, Prizes and Point Details - Page 23

Forum Index > SC2 General
474 CommentsPost a Reply
Prev 1 21 22 23 24 Next All
Branman
Profile Joined March 2013
United States203 Posts
Last Edited: 2013-04-17 20:25:27
April 17 2013 20:22 GMT
#441
On April 18 2013 05:13 blackone wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 18 2013 05:07 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 04:59 blackone wrote:
On April 18 2013 04:58 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 04:05 sitromit wrote:
On April 18 2013 03:54 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 03:44 Canucklehead wrote:
This is like tennis paying out the same prize pool for winning a random tennis tournament and winning wimbledon or golf paying the same for a lesser golf tourney and the masters. Makes no sense, other than affirmative action for foreigners and giving them charity money.


There's not affirmative action for foreigners. Everyone is free to enter whatever system they want. Koreans are entering both the NA and EU leagues. In fact, the entire point of this (as said by Blizzard in interviews) is to have the Koreans actually enter the foreign scene and take their infrastructure with them as they move abroad.


There is affirmative action. Koreans aren't free to go where they want, only those on foreigner teams can afford to for the most part.

Not to mention 24 players were seeded directly into the premiere leagues, and the majority of seeds were given to non-koreans. People like hellokitty and maker got seeds over much much better Korean players. If that isn't affirmative action, I don't know what is.


The community has said that foreigners should just buck up and move to Korea if they want to be relevant. This is said with little regard to the actual costs of doing that or the culture shock. Suddenly there's an incentive for Koreans to move to NA/EU and there's outrage over that? The answer as to why lots of foreigners don't live in Seoul and participate in the Code A qualifiers is that it's freakin' expensive to do, yet no one seemed to care about cost and feasibility while shouting down seeds given to foreign major tournament winners (an actual incentive to get people to move to Korea).

Seriously, it's a double standard. The community was all about the old system which demanded that people move to Korea, and now they are upset about a system that encourages Koreans to move to a different continent? Why should Koreans have the privilege of not having to move to a foreign country and culture to make a living in SC2 when that's exactly what the community demanded of foreign progamers?

Because they're better. Just like it's okay to "force" the best soccer players to move to Europe but it would be stupid to force European leagues to have the same prize pool as African leagues and now some of the best soccer players have to play in Botswana.



The problem with your example is that many soccer players in Europe aren't from Europe, and European clubs don't have the highest level of skill. All of the world-class Africans travel to Europe, but we don't complain that they are forced to go to where the money is. Brazilian teams are equal in skill (they've won more club world cups), but they make far less money than European clubs.

That's bullshit, European clubs have the highest level of skill by a gigantic margin. The club world cup is about as important as the official baseball world championship.

Show nested quote +
On April 18 2013 05:07 Branman wrote:
Hypothetical example: if the MLS made NFL-like money, then they would be able to pay their players salaries competitive with EU teams. Would you be very upset if EU players moved to the US to play in this league?


If it happened naturally? No. If FIFA just decided to remove a third of European Leagues, cut their prize pool in half and slap a huge prize on the MLS to make players leave Europe, then yes, of course I'd be upset.

Show nested quote +
On April 18 2013 05:07 Branman wrote:
The fact is that for SC2, the money is in the Western scene. That's where the sponsors are. That's where the audience is. It's not the job of the Western audience to subsidize the Korean scene. If Koreans want to make more money playing Starcraft, they might want to move to the West.

This has absolutely nothing to do with sponsors. This is not GOM trying to adapt or Korean team sponsors wanting their teams to go to the USA. This was Blizzards decision.


You don't get to look at the results of an official FIFA sanctioned event and claim that it's bullshit. It's literally designed to determine what the best club team is. Even discounting that, South American players are far more skillful than their European counterparts. Why should they have to move to Europe when their continent has all of the talent for soccer?

This has EVERYTHING to do with exposure. More people will buy SC2 in NA and EU than in Korea. It's pretty simple. If blizzard wants to sell commercials on their streams, then the audience will matter. You're going to get bigger audiences for NA/EU primetime than KR primetime. More than that: it's about the longevity of the scene. If the SC2 scene stays Korea-centric, then it fails as a global esport, and Western audiences and money will evaporate. The whole point of this is to break the Korea-centricity of the current scene.
blackone
Profile Joined November 2010
Germany1314 Posts
Last Edited: 2013-04-17 20:27:03
April 17 2013 20:26 GMT
#442
On April 18 2013 05:22 Branman wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 18 2013 05:13 blackone wrote:
On April 18 2013 05:07 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 04:59 blackone wrote:
On April 18 2013 04:58 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 04:05 sitromit wrote:
On April 18 2013 03:54 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 03:44 Canucklehead wrote:
This is like tennis paying out the same prize pool for winning a random tennis tournament and winning wimbledon or golf paying the same for a lesser golf tourney and the masters. Makes no sense, other than affirmative action for foreigners and giving them charity money.


There's not affirmative action for foreigners. Everyone is free to enter whatever system they want. Koreans are entering both the NA and EU leagues. In fact, the entire point of this (as said by Blizzard in interviews) is to have the Koreans actually enter the foreign scene and take their infrastructure with them as they move abroad.


There is affirmative action. Koreans aren't free to go where they want, only those on foreigner teams can afford to for the most part.

Not to mention 24 players were seeded directly into the premiere leagues, and the majority of seeds were given to non-koreans. People like hellokitty and maker got seeds over much much better Korean players. If that isn't affirmative action, I don't know what is.


The community has said that foreigners should just buck up and move to Korea if they want to be relevant. This is said with little regard to the actual costs of doing that or the culture shock. Suddenly there's an incentive for Koreans to move to NA/EU and there's outrage over that? The answer as to why lots of foreigners don't live in Seoul and participate in the Code A qualifiers is that it's freakin' expensive to do, yet no one seemed to care about cost and feasibility while shouting down seeds given to foreign major tournament winners (an actual incentive to get people to move to Korea).

Seriously, it's a double standard. The community was all about the old system which demanded that people move to Korea, and now they are upset about a system that encourages Koreans to move to a different continent? Why should Koreans have the privilege of not having to move to a foreign country and culture to make a living in SC2 when that's exactly what the community demanded of foreign progamers?

Because they're better. Just like it's okay to "force" the best soccer players to move to Europe but it would be stupid to force European leagues to have the same prize pool as African leagues and now some of the best soccer players have to play in Botswana.



The problem with your example is that many soccer players in Europe aren't from Europe, and European clubs don't have the highest level of skill. All of the world-class Africans travel to Europe, but we don't complain that they are forced to go to where the money is. Brazilian teams are equal in skill (they've won more club world cups), but they make far less money than European clubs.

That's bullshit, European clubs have the highest level of skill by a gigantic margin. The club world cup is about as important as the official baseball world championship.

On April 18 2013 05:07 Branman wrote:
Hypothetical example: if the MLS made NFL-like money, then they would be able to pay their players salaries competitive with EU teams. Would you be very upset if EU players moved to the US to play in this league?


If it happened naturally? No. If FIFA just decided to remove a third of European Leagues, cut their prize pool in half and slap a huge prize on the MLS to make players leave Europe, then yes, of course I'd be upset.

On April 18 2013 05:07 Branman wrote:
The fact is that for SC2, the money is in the Western scene. That's where the sponsors are. That's where the audience is. It's not the job of the Western audience to subsidize the Korean scene. If Koreans want to make more money playing Starcraft, they might want to move to the West.

This has absolutely nothing to do with sponsors. This is not GOM trying to adapt or Korean team sponsors wanting their teams to go to the USA. This was Blizzards decision.


You don't get to look at the results of an official FIFA sanctioned event and claim that it's bullshit. It's literally designed to determine what the best club team is. Even discounting that, South American players are far more skillful than their European counterparts. Why should they have to move to Europe when their continent has all of the talent for soccer?


A) Yes, I do. No (and I mean absolutely no) soccer fan takes the Club WC seriously. It's like the NBA All Star Game. It's fun, but nobody cares about the results. More than that, a casual soccer fan wouldn't even know it existed.

B) South America doesn't have all of the talent.
Plansix
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
United States60190 Posts
April 17 2013 20:31 GMT
#443
On April 18 2013 05:22 Branman wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 18 2013 05:13 blackone wrote:
On April 18 2013 05:07 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 04:59 blackone wrote:
On April 18 2013 04:58 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 04:05 sitromit wrote:
On April 18 2013 03:54 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 03:44 Canucklehead wrote:
This is like tennis paying out the same prize pool for winning a random tennis tournament and winning wimbledon or golf paying the same for a lesser golf tourney and the masters. Makes no sense, other than affirmative action for foreigners and giving them charity money.


There's not affirmative action for foreigners. Everyone is free to enter whatever system they want. Koreans are entering both the NA and EU leagues. In fact, the entire point of this (as said by Blizzard in interviews) is to have the Koreans actually enter the foreign scene and take their infrastructure with them as they move abroad.


There is affirmative action. Koreans aren't free to go where they want, only those on foreigner teams can afford to for the most part.

Not to mention 24 players were seeded directly into the premiere leagues, and the majority of seeds were given to non-koreans. People like hellokitty and maker got seeds over much much better Korean players. If that isn't affirmative action, I don't know what is.


The community has said that foreigners should just buck up and move to Korea if they want to be relevant. This is said with little regard to the actual costs of doing that or the culture shock. Suddenly there's an incentive for Koreans to move to NA/EU and there's outrage over that? The answer as to why lots of foreigners don't live in Seoul and participate in the Code A qualifiers is that it's freakin' expensive to do, yet no one seemed to care about cost and feasibility while shouting down seeds given to foreign major tournament winners (an actual incentive to get people to move to Korea).

Seriously, it's a double standard. The community was all about the old system which demanded that people move to Korea, and now they are upset about a system that encourages Koreans to move to a different continent? Why should Koreans have the privilege of not having to move to a foreign country and culture to make a living in SC2 when that's exactly what the community demanded of foreign progamers?

Because they're better. Just like it's okay to "force" the best soccer players to move to Europe but it would be stupid to force European leagues to have the same prize pool as African leagues and now some of the best soccer players have to play in Botswana.



The problem with your example is that many soccer players in Europe aren't from Europe, and European clubs don't have the highest level of skill. All of the world-class Africans travel to Europe, but we don't complain that they are forced to go to where the money is. Brazilian teams are equal in skill (they've won more club world cups), but they make far less money than European clubs.

That's bullshit, European clubs have the highest level of skill by a gigantic margin. The club world cup is about as important as the official baseball world championship.

On April 18 2013 05:07 Branman wrote:
Hypothetical example: if the MLS made NFL-like money, then they would be able to pay their players salaries competitive with EU teams. Would you be very upset if EU players moved to the US to play in this league?


If it happened naturally? No. If FIFA just decided to remove a third of European Leagues, cut their prize pool in half and slap a huge prize on the MLS to make players leave Europe, then yes, of course I'd be upset.

On April 18 2013 05:07 Branman wrote:
The fact is that for SC2, the money is in the Western scene. That's where the sponsors are. That's where the audience is. It's not the job of the Western audience to subsidize the Korean scene. If Koreans want to make more money playing Starcraft, they might want to move to the West.

This has absolutely nothing to do with sponsors. This is not GOM trying to adapt or Korean team sponsors wanting their teams to go to the USA. This was Blizzards decision.


You don't get to look at the results of an official FIFA sanctioned event and claim that it's bullshit. It's literally designed to determine what the best club team is. Even discounting that, South American players are far more skillful than their European counterparts. Why should they have to move to Europe when their continent has all of the talent for soccer?

This has EVERYTHING to do with exposure. More people will buy SC2 in NA and EU than in Korea. It's pretty simple. If blizzard wants to sell commercials on their streams, then the audience will matter. You're going to get bigger audiences for NA/EU primetime than KR primetime. More than that: it's about the longevity of the scene. If the SC2 scene stays Korea-centric, then it fails as a global esport, and Western audiences and money will evaporate. The whole point of this is to break the Korea-centricity of the current scene.


Wait..your telling me that the reason that everyone is doing this is to sell ads and make money off of those ads? You mean Blizzard isn't doing trying to kill Esports in Korea, but tying to make money by marketing it to the largest group of people who bought SC2.

Thats, like, crazy man. Just crazy. Why would people want to move where the money is?
I have the Honor to be your Obedient Servant, P.6
TL+ Member
Branman
Profile Joined March 2013
United States203 Posts
April 17 2013 20:36 GMT
#444
On April 18 2013 05:26 blackone wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 18 2013 05:22 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 05:13 blackone wrote:
On April 18 2013 05:07 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 04:59 blackone wrote:
On April 18 2013 04:58 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 04:05 sitromit wrote:
On April 18 2013 03:54 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 03:44 Canucklehead wrote:
This is like tennis paying out the same prize pool for winning a random tennis tournament and winning wimbledon or golf paying the same for a lesser golf tourney and the masters. Makes no sense, other than affirmative action for foreigners and giving them charity money.


There's not affirmative action for foreigners. Everyone is free to enter whatever system they want. Koreans are entering both the NA and EU leagues. In fact, the entire point of this (as said by Blizzard in interviews) is to have the Koreans actually enter the foreign scene and take their infrastructure with them as they move abroad.


There is affirmative action. Koreans aren't free to go where they want, only those on foreigner teams can afford to for the most part.

Not to mention 24 players were seeded directly into the premiere leagues, and the majority of seeds were given to non-koreans. People like hellokitty and maker got seeds over much much better Korean players. If that isn't affirmative action, I don't know what is.


The community has said that foreigners should just buck up and move to Korea if they want to be relevant. This is said with little regard to the actual costs of doing that or the culture shock. Suddenly there's an incentive for Koreans to move to NA/EU and there's outrage over that? The answer as to why lots of foreigners don't live in Seoul and participate in the Code A qualifiers is that it's freakin' expensive to do, yet no one seemed to care about cost and feasibility while shouting down seeds given to foreign major tournament winners (an actual incentive to get people to move to Korea).

Seriously, it's a double standard. The community was all about the old system which demanded that people move to Korea, and now they are upset about a system that encourages Koreans to move to a different continent? Why should Koreans have the privilege of not having to move to a foreign country and culture to make a living in SC2 when that's exactly what the community demanded of foreign progamers?

Because they're better. Just like it's okay to "force" the best soccer players to move to Europe but it would be stupid to force European leagues to have the same prize pool as African leagues and now some of the best soccer players have to play in Botswana.



The problem with your example is that many soccer players in Europe aren't from Europe, and European clubs don't have the highest level of skill. All of the world-class Africans travel to Europe, but we don't complain that they are forced to go to where the money is. Brazilian teams are equal in skill (they've won more club world cups), but they make far less money than European clubs.

That's bullshit, European clubs have the highest level of skill by a gigantic margin. The club world cup is about as important as the official baseball world championship.

On April 18 2013 05:07 Branman wrote:
Hypothetical example: if the MLS made NFL-like money, then they would be able to pay their players salaries competitive with EU teams. Would you be very upset if EU players moved to the US to play in this league?


If it happened naturally? No. If FIFA just decided to remove a third of European Leagues, cut their prize pool in half and slap a huge prize on the MLS to make players leave Europe, then yes, of course I'd be upset.

On April 18 2013 05:07 Branman wrote:
The fact is that for SC2, the money is in the Western scene. That's where the sponsors are. That's where the audience is. It's not the job of the Western audience to subsidize the Korean scene. If Koreans want to make more money playing Starcraft, they might want to move to the West.

This has absolutely nothing to do with sponsors. This is not GOM trying to adapt or Korean team sponsors wanting their teams to go to the USA. This was Blizzards decision.


You don't get to look at the results of an official FIFA sanctioned event and claim that it's bullshit. It's literally designed to determine what the best club team is. Even discounting that, South American players are far more skillful than their European counterparts. Why should they have to move to Europe when their continent has all of the talent for soccer?


A) Yes, I do. No (and I mean absolutely no) soccer fan takes the Club WC seriously. It's like the NBA All Star Game. It's fun, but nobody cares about the results. More than that, a casual soccer fan wouldn't even know it existed.

B) South America doesn't have all of the talent.


Anyway, my point still stands. South America has a large preponderance of talent, but soccer fans aren't upset that they are forced to move to Europe to make more money than they could if they stayed home. We should see the same thing here. Koreans can make money in Korea, but they can also travel outside of Korea to make money where there is more exposure and money.
Plansix
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
United States60190 Posts
April 17 2013 20:44 GMT
#445
On April 18 2013 05:36 Branman wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 18 2013 05:26 blackone wrote:
On April 18 2013 05:22 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 05:13 blackone wrote:
On April 18 2013 05:07 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 04:59 blackone wrote:
On April 18 2013 04:58 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 04:05 sitromit wrote:
On April 18 2013 03:54 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 03:44 Canucklehead wrote:
This is like tennis paying out the same prize pool for winning a random tennis tournament and winning wimbledon or golf paying the same for a lesser golf tourney and the masters. Makes no sense, other than affirmative action for foreigners and giving them charity money.


There's not affirmative action for foreigners. Everyone is free to enter whatever system they want. Koreans are entering both the NA and EU leagues. In fact, the entire point of this (as said by Blizzard in interviews) is to have the Koreans actually enter the foreign scene and take their infrastructure with them as they move abroad.


There is affirmative action. Koreans aren't free to go where they want, only those on foreigner teams can afford to for the most part.

Not to mention 24 players were seeded directly into the premiere leagues, and the majority of seeds were given to non-koreans. People like hellokitty and maker got seeds over much much better Korean players. If that isn't affirmative action, I don't know what is.


The community has said that foreigners should just buck up and move to Korea if they want to be relevant. This is said with little regard to the actual costs of doing that or the culture shock. Suddenly there's an incentive for Koreans to move to NA/EU and there's outrage over that? The answer as to why lots of foreigners don't live in Seoul and participate in the Code A qualifiers is that it's freakin' expensive to do, yet no one seemed to care about cost and feasibility while shouting down seeds given to foreign major tournament winners (an actual incentive to get people to move to Korea).

Seriously, it's a double standard. The community was all about the old system which demanded that people move to Korea, and now they are upset about a system that encourages Koreans to move to a different continent? Why should Koreans have the privilege of not having to move to a foreign country and culture to make a living in SC2 when that's exactly what the community demanded of foreign progamers?

Because they're better. Just like it's okay to "force" the best soccer players to move to Europe but it would be stupid to force European leagues to have the same prize pool as African leagues and now some of the best soccer players have to play in Botswana.



The problem with your example is that many soccer players in Europe aren't from Europe, and European clubs don't have the highest level of skill. All of the world-class Africans travel to Europe, but we don't complain that they are forced to go to where the money is. Brazilian teams are equal in skill (they've won more club world cups), but they make far less money than European clubs.

That's bullshit, European clubs have the highest level of skill by a gigantic margin. The club world cup is about as important as the official baseball world championship.

On April 18 2013 05:07 Branman wrote:
Hypothetical example: if the MLS made NFL-like money, then they would be able to pay their players salaries competitive with EU teams. Would you be very upset if EU players moved to the US to play in this league?


If it happened naturally? No. If FIFA just decided to remove a third of European Leagues, cut their prize pool in half and slap a huge prize on the MLS to make players leave Europe, then yes, of course I'd be upset.

On April 18 2013 05:07 Branman wrote:
The fact is that for SC2, the money is in the Western scene. That's where the sponsors are. That's where the audience is. It's not the job of the Western audience to subsidize the Korean scene. If Koreans want to make more money playing Starcraft, they might want to move to the West.

This has absolutely nothing to do with sponsors. This is not GOM trying to adapt or Korean team sponsors wanting their teams to go to the USA. This was Blizzards decision.


You don't get to look at the results of an official FIFA sanctioned event and claim that it's bullshit. It's literally designed to determine what the best club team is. Even discounting that, South American players are far more skillful than their European counterparts. Why should they have to move to Europe when their continent has all of the talent for soccer?


A) Yes, I do. No (and I mean absolutely no) soccer fan takes the Club WC seriously. It's like the NBA All Star Game. It's fun, but nobody cares about the results. More than that, a casual soccer fan wouldn't even know it existed.

B) South America doesn't have all of the talent.


Anyway, my point still stands. South America has a large preponderance of talent, but soccer fans aren't upset that they are forced to move to Europe to make more money than they could if they stayed home. We should see the same thing here. Koreans can make money in Korea, but they can also travel outside of Korea to make money where there is more exposure and money.


The Boston Bruins has a single American player. The rest are not from the US and we are currently importing another Swedish player. Players move to new regions to make money in all competitive anything. There isn't some hockey mecca where all players reside and the US just dumps money into the region to promote the best players in the world. The players move to entertain the fans, not the other way around.
I have the Honor to be your Obedient Servant, P.6
TL+ Member
Benjamin99
Profile Joined April 2012
4176 Posts
April 17 2013 20:47 GMT
#446
On April 18 2013 05:36 Branman wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 18 2013 05:26 blackone wrote:
On April 18 2013 05:22 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 05:13 blackone wrote:
On April 18 2013 05:07 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 04:59 blackone wrote:
On April 18 2013 04:58 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 04:05 sitromit wrote:
On April 18 2013 03:54 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 03:44 Canucklehead wrote:
This is like tennis paying out the same prize pool for winning a random tennis tournament and winning wimbledon or golf paying the same for a lesser golf tourney and the masters. Makes no sense, other than affirmative action for foreigners and giving them charity money.


There's not affirmative action for foreigners. Everyone is free to enter whatever system they want. Koreans are entering both the NA and EU leagues. In fact, the entire point of this (as said by Blizzard in interviews) is to have the Koreans actually enter the foreign scene and take their infrastructure with them as they move abroad.


There is affirmative action. Koreans aren't free to go where they want, only those on foreigner teams can afford to for the most part.

Not to mention 24 players were seeded directly into the premiere leagues, and the majority of seeds were given to non-koreans. People like hellokitty and maker got seeds over much much better Korean players. If that isn't affirmative action, I don't know what is.


The community has said that foreigners should just buck up and move to Korea if they want to be relevant. This is said with little regard to the actual costs of doing that or the culture shock. Suddenly there's an incentive for Koreans to move to NA/EU and there's outrage over that? The answer as to why lots of foreigners don't live in Seoul and participate in the Code A qualifiers is that it's freakin' expensive to do, yet no one seemed to care about cost and feasibility while shouting down seeds given to foreign major tournament winners (an actual incentive to get people to move to Korea).

Seriously, it's a double standard. The community was all about the old system which demanded that people move to Korea, and now they are upset about a system that encourages Koreans to move to a different continent? Why should Koreans have the privilege of not having to move to a foreign country and culture to make a living in SC2 when that's exactly what the community demanded of foreign progamers?

Because they're better. Just like it's okay to "force" the best soccer players to move to Europe but it would be stupid to force European leagues to have the same prize pool as African leagues and now some of the best soccer players have to play in Botswana.



The problem with your example is that many soccer players in Europe aren't from Europe, and European clubs don't have the highest level of skill. All of the world-class Africans travel to Europe, but we don't complain that they are forced to go to where the money is. Brazilian teams are equal in skill (they've won more club world cups), but they make far less money than European clubs.

That's bullshit, European clubs have the highest level of skill by a gigantic margin. The club world cup is about as important as the official baseball world championship.

On April 18 2013 05:07 Branman wrote:
Hypothetical example: if the MLS made NFL-like money, then they would be able to pay their players salaries competitive with EU teams. Would you be very upset if EU players moved to the US to play in this league?


If it happened naturally? No. If FIFA just decided to remove a third of European Leagues, cut their prize pool in half and slap a huge prize on the MLS to make players leave Europe, then yes, of course I'd be upset.

On April 18 2013 05:07 Branman wrote:
The fact is that for SC2, the money is in the Western scene. That's where the sponsors are. That's where the audience is. It's not the job of the Western audience to subsidize the Korean scene. If Koreans want to make more money playing Starcraft, they might want to move to the West.

This has absolutely nothing to do with sponsors. This is not GOM trying to adapt or Korean team sponsors wanting their teams to go to the USA. This was Blizzards decision.


You don't get to look at the results of an official FIFA sanctioned event and claim that it's bullshit. It's literally designed to determine what the best club team is. Even discounting that, South American players are far more skillful than their European counterparts. Why should they have to move to Europe when their continent has all of the talent for soccer?


A) Yes, I do. No (and I mean absolutely no) soccer fan takes the Club WC seriously. It's like the NBA All Star Game. It's fun, but nobody cares about the results. More than that, a casual soccer fan wouldn't even know it existed.

B) South America doesn't have all of the talent.


Anyway, my point still stands. South America has a large preponderance of talent, but soccer fans aren't upset that they are forced to move to Europe to make more money than they could if they stayed home. We should see the same thing here. Koreans can make money in Korea, but they can also travel outside of Korea to make money where there is more exposure and money.


You are very wrong. South America got a large talent pool but nothing compared to the European talent pool. If you were right there will only be SA players in the biggest league in EU and that is not the case. French/Italien/Spanish/english/german players are the main influx of players in the biggest leagues. Only the very best of of SA is coming to EU same with Asia and Africa.

Btw I also find it ironic that an American having a discussion about football/soccer with Europeans:D
Stephano & Jaedong <-- The Pain Train. Polt and Innovation to EG plz
Plansix
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
United States60190 Posts
April 17 2013 20:55 GMT
#447
On April 18 2013 05:47 Benjamin99 wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 18 2013 05:36 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 05:26 blackone wrote:
On April 18 2013 05:22 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 05:13 blackone wrote:
On April 18 2013 05:07 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 04:59 blackone wrote:
On April 18 2013 04:58 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 04:05 sitromit wrote:
On April 18 2013 03:54 Branman wrote:
[quote]

There's not affirmative action for foreigners. Everyone is free to enter whatever system they want. Koreans are entering both the NA and EU leagues. In fact, the entire point of this (as said by Blizzard in interviews) is to have the Koreans actually enter the foreign scene and take their infrastructure with them as they move abroad.


There is affirmative action. Koreans aren't free to go where they want, only those on foreigner teams can afford to for the most part.

Not to mention 24 players were seeded directly into the premiere leagues, and the majority of seeds were given to non-koreans. People like hellokitty and maker got seeds over much much better Korean players. If that isn't affirmative action, I don't know what is.


The community has said that foreigners should just buck up and move to Korea if they want to be relevant. This is said with little regard to the actual costs of doing that or the culture shock. Suddenly there's an incentive for Koreans to move to NA/EU and there's outrage over that? The answer as to why lots of foreigners don't live in Seoul and participate in the Code A qualifiers is that it's freakin' expensive to do, yet no one seemed to care about cost and feasibility while shouting down seeds given to foreign major tournament winners (an actual incentive to get people to move to Korea).

Seriously, it's a double standard. The community was all about the old system which demanded that people move to Korea, and now they are upset about a system that encourages Koreans to move to a different continent? Why should Koreans have the privilege of not having to move to a foreign country and culture to make a living in SC2 when that's exactly what the community demanded of foreign progamers?

Because they're better. Just like it's okay to "force" the best soccer players to move to Europe but it would be stupid to force European leagues to have the same prize pool as African leagues and now some of the best soccer players have to play in Botswana.



The problem with your example is that many soccer players in Europe aren't from Europe, and European clubs don't have the highest level of skill. All of the world-class Africans travel to Europe, but we don't complain that they are forced to go to where the money is. Brazilian teams are equal in skill (they've won more club world cups), but they make far less money than European clubs.

That's bullshit, European clubs have the highest level of skill by a gigantic margin. The club world cup is about as important as the official baseball world championship.

On April 18 2013 05:07 Branman wrote:
Hypothetical example: if the MLS made NFL-like money, then they would be able to pay their players salaries competitive with EU teams. Would you be very upset if EU players moved to the US to play in this league?


If it happened naturally? No. If FIFA just decided to remove a third of European Leagues, cut their prize pool in half and slap a huge prize on the MLS to make players leave Europe, then yes, of course I'd be upset.

On April 18 2013 05:07 Branman wrote:
The fact is that for SC2, the money is in the Western scene. That's where the sponsors are. That's where the audience is. It's not the job of the Western audience to subsidize the Korean scene. If Koreans want to make more money playing Starcraft, they might want to move to the West.

This has absolutely nothing to do with sponsors. This is not GOM trying to adapt or Korean team sponsors wanting their teams to go to the USA. This was Blizzards decision.


You don't get to look at the results of an official FIFA sanctioned event and claim that it's bullshit. It's literally designed to determine what the best club team is. Even discounting that, South American players are far more skillful than their European counterparts. Why should they have to move to Europe when their continent has all of the talent for soccer?


A) Yes, I do. No (and I mean absolutely no) soccer fan takes the Club WC seriously. It's like the NBA All Star Game. It's fun, but nobody cares about the results. More than that, a casual soccer fan wouldn't even know it existed.

B) South America doesn't have all of the talent.


Anyway, my point still stands. South America has a large preponderance of talent, but soccer fans aren't upset that they are forced to move to Europe to make more money than they could if they stayed home. We should see the same thing here. Koreans can make money in Korea, but they can also travel outside of Korea to make money where there is more exposure and money.


You are very wrong. South America got a large talent pool but nothing compared to the European talent pool. If you were right there will only be SA players in the biggest league in EU and that is not the case. French/Italien/Spanish/english/german players are the main influx of players in the biggest leagues. Only the very best of of SA is coming to EU same with Asia and Africa.

Btw I also find it ironic that an American having a discussion about football/soccer with Europeans:D


I also find that pretty amusing. From the discussions I have determined that South America and European regions have the best talent pool for football depending on who you ask. Also, if you don't agree with the person on where the talent pool is, you clearly no nothing about football.

The part that I find super funny is when people are shocked that players are moving to where the most money is. The US has been important the best athletes for years. We are of the opinion that it doesn't matter where your from as long as you play hard when your on my local team. And this wouldn't be the first time that a league used money to try and evenly distribute the talent pool across several areas to prevent on region/team from crushing every other region/team.
I have the Honor to be your Obedient Servant, P.6
TL+ Member
Branman
Profile Joined March 2013
United States203 Posts
Last Edited: 2013-04-17 21:00:18
April 17 2013 20:59 GMT
#448
On April 18 2013 05:47 Benjamin99 wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 18 2013 05:36 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 05:26 blackone wrote:
On April 18 2013 05:22 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 05:13 blackone wrote:
On April 18 2013 05:07 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 04:59 blackone wrote:
On April 18 2013 04:58 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 04:05 sitromit wrote:
On April 18 2013 03:54 Branman wrote:
[quote]

There's not affirmative action for foreigners. Everyone is free to enter whatever system they want. Koreans are entering both the NA and EU leagues. In fact, the entire point of this (as said by Blizzard in interviews) is to have the Koreans actually enter the foreign scene and take their infrastructure with them as they move abroad.


There is affirmative action. Koreans aren't free to go where they want, only those on foreigner teams can afford to for the most part.

Not to mention 24 players were seeded directly into the premiere leagues, and the majority of seeds were given to non-koreans. People like hellokitty and maker got seeds over much much better Korean players. If that isn't affirmative action, I don't know what is.


The community has said that foreigners should just buck up and move to Korea if they want to be relevant. This is said with little regard to the actual costs of doing that or the culture shock. Suddenly there's an incentive for Koreans to move to NA/EU and there's outrage over that? The answer as to why lots of foreigners don't live in Seoul and participate in the Code A qualifiers is that it's freakin' expensive to do, yet no one seemed to care about cost and feasibility while shouting down seeds given to foreign major tournament winners (an actual incentive to get people to move to Korea).

Seriously, it's a double standard. The community was all about the old system which demanded that people move to Korea, and now they are upset about a system that encourages Koreans to move to a different continent? Why should Koreans have the privilege of not having to move to a foreign country and culture to make a living in SC2 when that's exactly what the community demanded of foreign progamers?

Because they're better. Just like it's okay to "force" the best soccer players to move to Europe but it would be stupid to force European leagues to have the same prize pool as African leagues and now some of the best soccer players have to play in Botswana.



The problem with your example is that many soccer players in Europe aren't from Europe, and European clubs don't have the highest level of skill. All of the world-class Africans travel to Europe, but we don't complain that they are forced to go to where the money is. Brazilian teams are equal in skill (they've won more club world cups), but they make far less money than European clubs.

That's bullshit, European clubs have the highest level of skill by a gigantic margin. The club world cup is about as important as the official baseball world championship.

On April 18 2013 05:07 Branman wrote:
Hypothetical example: if the MLS made NFL-like money, then they would be able to pay their players salaries competitive with EU teams. Would you be very upset if EU players moved to the US to play in this league?


If it happened naturally? No. If FIFA just decided to remove a third of European Leagues, cut their prize pool in half and slap a huge prize on the MLS to make players leave Europe, then yes, of course I'd be upset.

On April 18 2013 05:07 Branman wrote:
The fact is that for SC2, the money is in the Western scene. That's where the sponsors are. That's where the audience is. It's not the job of the Western audience to subsidize the Korean scene. If Koreans want to make more money playing Starcraft, they might want to move to the West.

This has absolutely nothing to do with sponsors. This is not GOM trying to adapt or Korean team sponsors wanting their teams to go to the USA. This was Blizzards decision.


You don't get to look at the results of an official FIFA sanctioned event and claim that it's bullshit. It's literally designed to determine what the best club team is. Even discounting that, South American players are far more skillful than their European counterparts. Why should they have to move to Europe when their continent has all of the talent for soccer?


A) Yes, I do. No (and I mean absolutely no) soccer fan takes the Club WC seriously. It's like the NBA All Star Game. It's fun, but nobody cares about the results. More than that, a casual soccer fan wouldn't even know it existed.

B) South America doesn't have all of the talent.


Anyway, my point still stands. South America has a large preponderance of talent, but soccer fans aren't upset that they are forced to move to Europe to make more money than they could if they stayed home. We should see the same thing here. Koreans can make money in Korea, but they can also travel outside of Korea to make money where there is more exposure and money.


You are very wrong. South America got a large talent pool but nothing compared to the European talent pool. If you were right there will only be SA players in the biggest league in EU and that is not the case. French/Italien/Spanish/english/german players are the main influx of players in the biggest leagues. Only the very best of of SA is coming to EU same with Asia and Africa.

Btw I also find it ironic that an American having a discussion about football/soccer with Europeans:D


I figured that you wouldn't know much about the NHL which is a better example as Plansix just said. Not a knock, but most Americans don't know much about the NHL either. Hockey is a 2nd rate sport these days.

I didn't say that it would only be SA players, but that there would be a large amount of them moving for monetary reasons. The point is that we don't get upset about athletes moving from their home countries for monetary reasons in any other sport, why are we suddenly upset about it for SC2? Don't think that these players are moving to Europe because "that's where the best skill is." They are moving because that's where the money and audience is.

Every single sport in history reaches the point where its homeland is no longer the center of that sport's world. Example: the center of football in America has migrated from the midwest to the southeast, and we have players from the midwest lining up to play in the southeastern league. This is also starting to happen in baseball where some of the best talent is coming from the Caribbean, and Japan has some really solid players.
Branman
Profile Joined March 2013
United States203 Posts
April 17 2013 21:01 GMT
#449
On April 18 2013 05:55 Plansix wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 18 2013 05:47 Benjamin99 wrote:
On April 18 2013 05:36 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 05:26 blackone wrote:
On April 18 2013 05:22 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 05:13 blackone wrote:
On April 18 2013 05:07 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 04:59 blackone wrote:
On April 18 2013 04:58 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 04:05 sitromit wrote:
[quote]

There is affirmative action. Koreans aren't free to go where they want, only those on foreigner teams can afford to for the most part.

Not to mention 24 players were seeded directly into the premiere leagues, and the majority of seeds were given to non-koreans. People like hellokitty and maker got seeds over much much better Korean players. If that isn't affirmative action, I don't know what is.


The community has said that foreigners should just buck up and move to Korea if they want to be relevant. This is said with little regard to the actual costs of doing that or the culture shock. Suddenly there's an incentive for Koreans to move to NA/EU and there's outrage over that? The answer as to why lots of foreigners don't live in Seoul and participate in the Code A qualifiers is that it's freakin' expensive to do, yet no one seemed to care about cost and feasibility while shouting down seeds given to foreign major tournament winners (an actual incentive to get people to move to Korea).

Seriously, it's a double standard. The community was all about the old system which demanded that people move to Korea, and now they are upset about a system that encourages Koreans to move to a different continent? Why should Koreans have the privilege of not having to move to a foreign country and culture to make a living in SC2 when that's exactly what the community demanded of foreign progamers?

Because they're better. Just like it's okay to "force" the best soccer players to move to Europe but it would be stupid to force European leagues to have the same prize pool as African leagues and now some of the best soccer players have to play in Botswana.



The problem with your example is that many soccer players in Europe aren't from Europe, and European clubs don't have the highest level of skill. All of the world-class Africans travel to Europe, but we don't complain that they are forced to go to where the money is. Brazilian teams are equal in skill (they've won more club world cups), but they make far less money than European clubs.

That's bullshit, European clubs have the highest level of skill by a gigantic margin. The club world cup is about as important as the official baseball world championship.

On April 18 2013 05:07 Branman wrote:
Hypothetical example: if the MLS made NFL-like money, then they would be able to pay their players salaries competitive with EU teams. Would you be very upset if EU players moved to the US to play in this league?


If it happened naturally? No. If FIFA just decided to remove a third of European Leagues, cut their prize pool in half and slap a huge prize on the MLS to make players leave Europe, then yes, of course I'd be upset.

On April 18 2013 05:07 Branman wrote:
The fact is that for SC2, the money is in the Western scene. That's where the sponsors are. That's where the audience is. It's not the job of the Western audience to subsidize the Korean scene. If Koreans want to make more money playing Starcraft, they might want to move to the West.

This has absolutely nothing to do with sponsors. This is not GOM trying to adapt or Korean team sponsors wanting their teams to go to the USA. This was Blizzards decision.


You don't get to look at the results of an official FIFA sanctioned event and claim that it's bullshit. It's literally designed to determine what the best club team is. Even discounting that, South American players are far more skillful than their European counterparts. Why should they have to move to Europe when their continent has all of the talent for soccer?


A) Yes, I do. No (and I mean absolutely no) soccer fan takes the Club WC seriously. It's like the NBA All Star Game. It's fun, but nobody cares about the results. More than that, a casual soccer fan wouldn't even know it existed.

B) South America doesn't have all of the talent.


Anyway, my point still stands. South America has a large preponderance of talent, but soccer fans aren't upset that they are forced to move to Europe to make more money than they could if they stayed home. We should see the same thing here. Koreans can make money in Korea, but they can also travel outside of Korea to make money where there is more exposure and money.


You are very wrong. South America got a large talent pool but nothing compared to the European talent pool. If you were right there will only be SA players in the biggest league in EU and that is not the case. French/Italien/Spanish/english/german players are the main influx of players in the biggest leagues. Only the very best of of SA is coming to EU same with Asia and Africa.

Btw I also find it ironic that an American having a discussion about football/soccer with Europeans:D


I also find that pretty amusing. From the discussions I have determined that South America and European regions have the best talent pool for football depending on who you ask. Also, if you don't agree with the person on where the talent pool is, you clearly no nothing about football.

The part that I find super funny is when people are shocked that players are moving to where the most money is. The US has been important the best athletes for years. We are of the opinion that it doesn't matter where your from as long as you play hard when your on my local team. And this wouldn't be the first time that a league used money to try and evenly distribute the talent pool across several areas to prevent on region/team from crushing every other region/team.


Dude, you're an American, it's soccer :p

Better phrasing "European Football" because there are many types of football of which American and Australian are the best types. :p
Plansix
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
United States60190 Posts
April 17 2013 21:12 GMT
#450
On April 18 2013 06:01 Branman wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 18 2013 05:55 Plansix wrote:
On April 18 2013 05:47 Benjamin99 wrote:
On April 18 2013 05:36 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 05:26 blackone wrote:
On April 18 2013 05:22 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 05:13 blackone wrote:
On April 18 2013 05:07 Branman wrote:
On April 18 2013 04:59 blackone wrote:
On April 18 2013 04:58 Branman wrote:
[quote]

The community has said that foreigners should just buck up and move to Korea if they want to be relevant. This is said with little regard to the actual costs of doing that or the culture shock. Suddenly there's an incentive for Koreans to move to NA/EU and there's outrage over that? The answer as to why lots of foreigners don't live in Seoul and participate in the Code A qualifiers is that it's freakin' expensive to do, yet no one seemed to care about cost and feasibility while shouting down seeds given to foreign major tournament winners (an actual incentive to get people to move to Korea).

Seriously, it's a double standard. The community was all about the old system which demanded that people move to Korea, and now they are upset about a system that encourages Koreans to move to a different continent? Why should Koreans have the privilege of not having to move to a foreign country and culture to make a living in SC2 when that's exactly what the community demanded of foreign progamers?

Because they're better. Just like it's okay to "force" the best soccer players to move to Europe but it would be stupid to force European leagues to have the same prize pool as African leagues and now some of the best soccer players have to play in Botswana.



The problem with your example is that many soccer players in Europe aren't from Europe, and European clubs don't have the highest level of skill. All of the world-class Africans travel to Europe, but we don't complain that they are forced to go to where the money is. Brazilian teams are equal in skill (they've won more club world cups), but they make far less money than European clubs.

That's bullshit, European clubs have the highest level of skill by a gigantic margin. The club world cup is about as important as the official baseball world championship.

On April 18 2013 05:07 Branman wrote:
Hypothetical example: if the MLS made NFL-like money, then they would be able to pay their players salaries competitive with EU teams. Would you be very upset if EU players moved to the US to play in this league?


If it happened naturally? No. If FIFA just decided to remove a third of European Leagues, cut their prize pool in half and slap a huge prize on the MLS to make players leave Europe, then yes, of course I'd be upset.

On April 18 2013 05:07 Branman wrote:
The fact is that for SC2, the money is in the Western scene. That's where the sponsors are. That's where the audience is. It's not the job of the Western audience to subsidize the Korean scene. If Koreans want to make more money playing Starcraft, they might want to move to the West.

This has absolutely nothing to do with sponsors. This is not GOM trying to adapt or Korean team sponsors wanting their teams to go to the USA. This was Blizzards decision.


You don't get to look at the results of an official FIFA sanctioned event and claim that it's bullshit. It's literally designed to determine what the best club team is. Even discounting that, South American players are far more skillful than their European counterparts. Why should they have to move to Europe when their continent has all of the talent for soccer?


A) Yes, I do. No (and I mean absolutely no) soccer fan takes the Club WC seriously. It's like the NBA All Star Game. It's fun, but nobody cares about the results. More than that, a casual soccer fan wouldn't even know it existed.

B) South America doesn't have all of the talent.


Anyway, my point still stands. South America has a large preponderance of talent, but soccer fans aren't upset that they are forced to move to Europe to make more money than they could if they stayed home. We should see the same thing here. Koreans can make money in Korea, but they can also travel outside of Korea to make money where there is more exposure and money.


You are very wrong. South America got a large talent pool but nothing compared to the European talent pool. If you were right there will only be SA players in the biggest league in EU and that is not the case. French/Italien/Spanish/english/german players are the main influx of players in the biggest leagues. Only the very best of of SA is coming to EU same with Asia and Africa.

Btw I also find it ironic that an American having a discussion about football/soccer with Europeans:D


I also find that pretty amusing. From the discussions I have determined that South America and European regions have the best talent pool for football depending on who you ask. Also, if you don't agree with the person on where the talent pool is, you clearly no nothing about football.

The part that I find super funny is when people are shocked that players are moving to where the most money is. The US has been important the best athletes for years. We are of the opinion that it doesn't matter where your from as long as you play hard when your on my local team. And this wouldn't be the first time that a league used money to try and evenly distribute the talent pool across several areas to prevent on region/team from crushing every other region/team.


Dude, you're an American, it's soccer :p

Better phrasing "European Football" because there are many types of football of which American and Australian are the best types. :p


Quite, you blow my cover! I am trying to speak to them about soccerball and the massive conflict as to which region has the larger number of talented players compared to the other regions with another amount of talent players. From my careful study, either one or both regions has a metric butt ton of talent players, while other other region has just a single ass load. Also, apparently their systems both support and discourage diversity while also supporting the best teams and the worst teams with and without welfare.
I have the Honor to be your Obedient Servant, P.6
TL+ Member
MasterOfPuppets
Profile Blog Joined March 2011
Romania6942 Posts
April 17 2013 21:21 GMT
#451
On April 18 2013 05:59 Branman wrote:
The point is that we don't get upset about athletes moving from their home countries for monetary reasons in any other sport, why are we suddenly upset about it for SC2?


I assume that in most other sports the teams that these players move to from their home countries have the means to provide them with a great practice environment. I don't know how fair the comparison to sports like football really is, since all football teams practice together under the supervision of a coach. That's the thing. Not all teams have that kind of infrastructure in SC2, in fact do you know which ones do? The Korean ones.

It's really not a matter of "omg sellout", although it's very true that their motivation behind this *is* the money, but that's understandable. It's a matter of "by moving to NA/EU, their training will suffer greatly" which eventually leads to their skill stagnating or even dropping considerably (see Rain, PuMa etc)
"my shaft scares me too" - strenx 2014
Shiori
Profile Blog Joined July 2011
3815 Posts
April 17 2013 21:23 GMT
#452
On April 18 2013 06:21 MasterOfPuppets wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 18 2013 05:59 Branman wrote:
The point is that we don't get upset about athletes moving from their home countries for monetary reasons in any other sport, why are we suddenly upset about it for SC2?


I assume that in most other sports the teams that these players move to from their home countries have the means to provide them with a great practice environment. I don't know how fair the comparison to sports like football really is, since all football teams practice together under the supervision of a coach. That's the thing. Not all teams have that kind of infrastructure in SC2, in fact do you know which ones do? The Korean ones.

It's really not a matter of "omg sellout", although it's very true that their motivation behind this *is* the money, but that's understandable. It's a matter of "by moving to NA/EU, their training will suffer greatly" which eventually leads to their skill stagnating or even dropping considerably (see Rain, PuMa etc)

This. There's also the fact that the Korean leagues were crippled somewhat by this announcement, which is a little different than just providing opportunities outside of Korea.
Plansix
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
United States60190 Posts
Last Edited: 2013-04-17 21:35:01
April 17 2013 21:33 GMT
#453
On April 18 2013 06:23 Shiori wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 18 2013 06:21 MasterOfPuppets wrote:
On April 18 2013 05:59 Branman wrote:
The point is that we don't get upset about athletes moving from their home countries for monetary reasons in any other sport, why are we suddenly upset about it for SC2?


I assume that in most other sports the teams that these players move to from their home countries have the means to provide them with a great practice environment. I don't know how fair the comparison to sports like football really is, since all football teams practice together under the supervision of a coach. That's the thing. Not all teams have that kind of infrastructure in SC2, in fact do you know which ones do? The Korean ones.

It's really not a matter of "omg sellout", although it's very true that their motivation behind this *is* the money, but that's understandable. It's a matter of "by moving to NA/EU, their training will suffer greatly" which eventually leads to their skill stagnating or even dropping considerably (see Rain, PuMa etc)

This. There's also the fact that the Korean leagues were crippled somewhat by this announcement, which is a little different than just providing opportunities outside of Korea.

Well the teams will learn to deal with it and overcome the problem of living in NA and keeping you skill up through practice. Polt has been able to remain competitive and Violet is pretty impressive as well, while both living in NA.

The simple fact is that there the NA scene is where a lot of the money is when it comes to sponsors and ad revenue. Blizzard has started a league in NA and give the Korean players and team the option to compete in that region. The Korean players and teams can either A: Come to the NA region, compete and figure out how to keep their practice up while they do it. Or B: let the NA players have the prize money and exposure. And the only reason Korean players and team are going to figure out that problem is if they would be stupid not to(ie, like the current WCS system). And they will figure it out, because it is in their best interest to do so.

Also, in response to Master's questions. NHL players move because of the money. They can practice anywhere there are good players and a hockey rink. Sometimes, they move because of the money and they like the fans or team. But mostly because of the money.
I have the Honor to be your Obedient Servant, P.6
TL+ Member
fuzzylogic44
Profile Joined December 2011
Canada2633 Posts
April 17 2013 21:49 GMT
#454
So if I understand correctly, the difference in format is that NA/EU Code A has less players, top 8 advance like GSL, but the losers of the first matches are not elimintated. Then, in the Up and Downs, the bottom 8 are eliminated there. This makes it less luck based so you don't get eliminated facing a korean in round 1 while someone else get's to face Hellokitty. Makes sense. However only changing 8 players every seasons makes it hard to break into.

As for the Korean chart, there's something there I don't get that I think is new.... it looks like there's a direct qualification into the Up and Down matches? "Top 2" from an open qualifier? Does that mean you can seed directly into Code S in a given season (albeit not easily)?
ffadicted
Profile Joined January 2011
United States3545 Posts
April 18 2013 00:41 GMT
#455
On April 17 2013 00:46 LighT. wrote:
Biggest complaint:
Theres no bias towards Korea although there should be a little bit of leverage towards them.


Exactly this, in both prize pool, but more importantly in qualification points and seasonal finals spots

Really should be top 8 korea, top 4 na, top 4 europe for seasonal and at least a 1.7x Kr 1.3x Eu 1.0x NA point bias or something.. Looking at the WCS Kr lineup makes the NA lineup look pathetic, it's sad these tournaments are held in equal weight, extremely poor design lol IDK what's the big deal about weighing regions when UEFA does the same for Champions League, the biggest "joint-league" tournament in the world for any sport ever.

I'd love to see Kr netizens reaction
SooYoung-Noona!
Shinta)
Profile Joined July 2010
United States1716 Posts
April 18 2013 16:30 GMT
#456
On April 18 2013 03:44 Canucklehead wrote:
This is like tennis paying out the same prize pool for winning a random tennis tournament and winning wimbledon or golf paying the same for a lesser golf tourney and the masters. Makes no sense, other than affirmative action for foreigners and giving them charity money.

lol what? Actually it's more like tennis paying out the same prize pool for Wimbledon, Rolland Garros, the US Open and the Aus Open, which would make a lot of sense.
Also, it's like having other, smaller tournaments pay out less money, while giving points to qualify for those few major tournaments.

lol, that's how tennis works, that's how this WCS system works.
There are minor kinks, but the prize money is not bad, and the points system is good enough for the first season.
Suteki Da Ne 素敵だね Isn't it Wonderful
Canucklehead
Profile Joined March 2011
Canada5074 Posts
Last Edited: 2013-04-18 17:33:30
April 18 2013 17:30 GMT
#457
On April 19 2013 01:30 Shinta) wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 18 2013 03:44 Canucklehead wrote:
This is like tennis paying out the same prize pool for winning a random tennis tournament and winning wimbledon or golf paying the same for a lesser golf tourney and the masters. Makes no sense, other than affirmative action for foreigners and giving them charity money.

lol what? Actually it's more like tennis paying out the same prize pool for Wimbledon, Rolland Garros, the US Open and the Aus Open, which would make a lot of sense.
Also, it's like having other, smaller tournaments pay out less money, while giving points to qualify for those few major tournaments.


Huh you just named 4 tennis majors? Majors have all the top players going to them, whether it be tennis or golf. Tiger woods, federer etc don't go to all tournaments, but always go to the majors.

I don't consider WCS NA and WCS EU to be majors in terms of skill. It's artificially made into a "major" by blizzard with their prize pool. I think you're confusing prize pool in a tournament with skill. Last year WCS finals gave out 100k to the winner. Are you going to try to tell me that was the most skillful tournament because it had the highest prize pool for the year? The competition there was a farce and parting won it by beating only 1 kr.
Top 10 favourite pros: MKP, MVP, MC, Nestea, DRG, Jaedong, Flash, Life, Creator, Leenock
Plansix
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
United States60190 Posts
April 18 2013 18:04 GMT
#458
On April 19 2013 02:30 Canucklehead wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 19 2013 01:30 Shinta) wrote:
On April 18 2013 03:44 Canucklehead wrote:
This is like tennis paying out the same prize pool for winning a random tennis tournament and winning wimbledon or golf paying the same for a lesser golf tourney and the masters. Makes no sense, other than affirmative action for foreigners and giving them charity money.

lol what? Actually it's more like tennis paying out the same prize pool for Wimbledon, Rolland Garros, the US Open and the Aus Open, which would make a lot of sense.
Also, it's like having other, smaller tournaments pay out less money, while giving points to qualify for those few major tournaments.


Huh you just named 4 tennis majors? Majors have all the top players going to them, whether it be tennis or golf. Tiger woods, federer etc don't go to all tournaments, but always go to the majors.

I don't consider WCS NA and WCS EU to be majors in terms of skill. It's artificially made into a "major" by blizzard with their prize pool. I think you're confusing prize pool in a tournament with skill. Last year WCS finals gave out 100k to the winner. Are you going to try to tell me that was the most skillful tournament because it had the highest prize pool for the year? The competition there was a farce and parting won it by beating only 1 kr.


Who cares? Sadly Blizzard as not invented teleportation or cloning to solve your problem. All three leagues are happening in different regions, in different time zones. The best players cannot be three places at once to scoop up all the prize money. Because some of the matches will be held while they are sleeping, other players who might be less skills can win that tournament. So unless Flash, Life and Innovation learn to pull the trick from the Man of Steel, they will have to play in Korea.

I guess all events could change their rules where their prize pool was based directly on the number of Koreans that signed up if that would make you happy.
I have the Honor to be your Obedient Servant, P.6
TL+ Member
Canucklehead
Profile Joined March 2011
Canada5074 Posts
Last Edited: 2013-04-18 18:23:56
April 18 2013 18:23 GMT
#459
On April 19 2013 03:04 Plansix wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 19 2013 02:30 Canucklehead wrote:
On April 19 2013 01:30 Shinta) wrote:
On April 18 2013 03:44 Canucklehead wrote:
This is like tennis paying out the same prize pool for winning a random tennis tournament and winning wimbledon or golf paying the same for a lesser golf tourney and the masters. Makes no sense, other than affirmative action for foreigners and giving them charity money.

lol what? Actually it's more like tennis paying out the same prize pool for Wimbledon, Rolland Garros, the US Open and the Aus Open, which would make a lot of sense.
Also, it's like having other, smaller tournaments pay out less money, while giving points to qualify for those few major tournaments.


Huh you just named 4 tennis majors? Majors have all the top players going to them, whether it be tennis or golf. Tiger woods, federer etc don't go to all tournaments, but always go to the majors.

I don't consider WCS NA and WCS EU to be majors in terms of skill. It's artificially made into a "major" by blizzard with their prize pool. I think you're confusing prize pool in a tournament with skill. Last year WCS finals gave out 100k to the winner. Are you going to try to tell me that was the most skillful tournament because it had the highest prize pool for the year? The competition there was a farce and parting won it by beating only 1 kr.



I guess all events could change their rules where their prize pool was based directly on the number of Koreans that signed up if that would make you happy.


Yes, it would as I've already pointed out before, I would be completely fine with a hard region lock if the NA/EU prizepool was 33% of the KR one. Then the prizepool would reflect more appropriately on the skill level in it. That is how it works in other sports.
Top 10 favourite pros: MKP, MVP, MC, Nestea, DRG, Jaedong, Flash, Life, Creator, Leenock
neoghaleon55
Profile Blog Joined August 2010
United States7435 Posts
Last Edited: 2013-04-18 18:24:30
April 18 2013 18:24 GMT
#460
Has anything been announced about WCS EU challenger league?
or qualifier league?
moo...for DRG
Prev 1 21 22 23 24 Next All
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
Next event in 2h 33m
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
PiGStarcraft231
SteadfastSC 168
Nathanias 83
CosmosSc2 13
Super Smash Bros
PPMD78
Heroes of the Storm
Liquid`Hasu625
Trikslyr61
Other Games
tarik_tv5611
Grubby2993
FrodaN2279
shahzam408
ToD234
C9.Mang0198
B2W.Neo160
Pyrionflax157
Organizations
Other Games
BasetradeTV131
[ Show 11 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• Hinosc 56
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• HerbMon 7
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Other Games
• imaqtpie1095
Upcoming Events
PiGosaur Cup
2h 33m
The PondCast
11h 33m
University League
11h 33m
LiuLi Cup
12h 33m
Rogue vs TBD
Maru vs TBD
OSC
17h 33m
Replay Cast
1d
GSL
1d 13h
Maru vs Dark
Patches Events
1d 15h
OSC
1d 17h
Replay Cast
2 days
[ Show More ]
KCM Race Survival
2 days
Ultimate Battle
2 days
ZerO vs Bisu
RSL Revival
3 days
BSL
3 days
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
4 days
IPSL
4 days
Ret vs ggnore13
nOmaD vs Aether
BSL
4 days
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
5 days
WardiTV Weekly
5 days
Kung Fu Cup
6 days
Solar vs Classic
ByuN vs SHIN
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Proleague 2026-11-16
Blizzard Classic Cup 2026
HCC Season 3

Ongoing

Acropolis #5
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4
International ShieldBattery League
BSL Season 23
IPSL Winter 2026-27
Calamity Cup Div. A Season 8
Underdog Cup 2026 Div 2-3
Stake Ranked Episode 6
BLAST Rivals Fall 2026
IEM Beijing 2026
PGL Masters Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 5
1win Private Club #2
Thunderpick World Champ. '26
ESL Pro League Season 24
Stake Ranked Episode 4
1win Private Club #1
Logitech G Play Connect 2026
SL StarSeries Fall 2026
FISSURE Playground #3
BLAST Open Fall 2026

Upcoming

Sector 591
YSL S4
SC4ALL II: Brood War
NBSL 2026 Xiamen LAN
BSL 23: Non-Korean Championship
HSC XXX
Stellar Fest 2: Lunar Cup
StarCraft2 Weekly Open Tournament 2026 Grand Finals
SC4ALL II: StarCraft II
Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals
RSL Offline Finals
IEM Kraków 2027
PGL Bucharest 2027
BLAST Bounty Winter 2027
PGL Major Singapore 2026
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.