| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
Aerox
Malaysia1213 Posts
This "IS BEING REVEALED" feature is a good addition but not done right. I should think around 3-4 minutes should be given before the reveal. Timer before the reveal can be displayed but only for the revealee. We should let the opposing player scout for the enemy for a little while. There is still the misinformation of "another nexus/hatch/cc" in effect. Otherwise, I foresee nexus/hatch/cc sniping tactics in the future which would be a really stupid idea/logic for a win in a game. | ||
|
TBO
Germany1350 Posts
| ||
|
Exteray
United States1094 Posts
On April 13 2010 01:30 Spaylz wrote: well, this was in RoC and TFT. and it makes complete sense to me. one lousy player shouldn't prevent you from winning the game by building one pylon in an annoying part of the map. either way, I can assure you this will never EVER get removed. lol? It's actually quite interesting how you speak with such certainty (and by interesting I mean absurd). | ||
Arbiter[frolix]
United Kingdom2674 Posts
| ||
|
JInxy
Denmark5 Posts
| ||
|
peidongyang
Canada2084 Posts
I think, for most part, that it's a fair mechanic and should be kept into the game, but like you said, they should make the time a bit more. | ||
Falling
Canada11261 Posts
On April 13 2010 05:02 Carnivorous Sheep wrote: I think it's fine... I appreciate why it's there and I think maybe you should stop getting into elimination races so often if this is such a big deal... Again, watch some replays where this happens- it makes for some very exciting games. (And Day9's 50th cast the most epic BGH comeback would have been completely impossible.) I think we can agree that: 1) BM players hiding buildings sucks 2) The current reveal is no good. Personally I wouldn't mind if the reveal stayed, but increase the time to 3-5 minutes. Units move so fast in SC2, so if they are actually rebuilding a base you should be able to find it by scouting in that time. If in that time they are just hiding pylons, you'll get your reveal. Definitely get rid of the "is being revealed." A countdown for the player who lost their Nexus, etc would be good for commentating purposes if they can also see the countdown- could increase the excitement. This definitely needs to be changed for any form of 2v2 or 3v3, 2v2v2v2, 4v4 etc. An ally can be down and out for a bit and make a strong recovery to win the game. | ||
|
Bear4188
United States1797 Posts
| ||
|
fantomex
United States313 Posts
A healthy increase in the time it takes before you're revealed would be fine. | ||
|
iceeSC
United States17 Posts
| ||
|
Klockan3
Sweden2866 Posts
On April 13 2010 01:53 Ideas wrote: oh come on! it's such a stupid fucking reason to keep it in the game. "oh sometimes some assholes hide pylons all over the map and it could 5 minutes to kill them!" totally not worth keeping in the game. Building elim races happen SO MUCH MORE OFTEN. I've had like 10 games in beta so far where it's been building elim, and ZERO where someone plays hide the farm. That game was such a waste of 5 minutes, the terran was really worthy of winning that and if the toss did actually win it he would win it all based on luck! A reveal mechanic will make elimination games much fairer, the one with the better army left and with better micro will win instead of the guy finding the other guys hidden pylon first wins. The fun part of elimination races is the actual competition of how long it takes to raze all of the other guys structures and trying to win with a limited amount of units, not looking at them trying to find the other players last structure. But I agree that the current reveal mechanic is sloppily done and should get changed, but a reveal mechanic will be a good addition both for casual and competitive play in my opinion. | ||
|
Xyik
Canada728 Posts
A power rating can be attributed to each unit, such as 5 to a collossus, 4 to an immortal and 2 to a zealot, while giving unique ratings to air units as well and then comparing it to the enemy's power rating is an example of a crude way of at least TRYING to fix this stupid feature. | ||
|
faction123
Australia949 Posts
| ||
|
WarChimp
Australia943 Posts
So before all you WarCraftors want this mechanic in, play more StarCraft and see for yourself why it just doesn't work in this game. | ||
|
Klockan3
Sweden2866 Posts
On April 13 2010 06:27 WarChimp wrote: I think all you WarCraftors are forgetting, this is the sequel to StarCraft, not a new WarCraft 3, why should we add a mechanic that sucks to StarCraft 2 that wasn't in StarCraft 1, you guys have to remember, a lot of WarCraft 3 was 1 base play and sometimes 2 but not till later game so it didn't matter, but StarCraft, you end up with 3-5 bases in a normal game sometimes more. The fact that you kill your opponents main doesn't mean he is dead, like in WarCraft 3. So before all you WarCraftors want this mechanic in, play more StarCraft and see for yourself why it just doesn't work in this game. You obviously have no idea of what you are talking about, killing the main do not mean that someone is revealed. | ||
|
WarChimp
Australia943 Posts
On April 13 2010 06:30 Klockan3 wrote: You obviously have no idea of what you are talking about, killing the main do not mean that someone is revealed. However in WarCraft 3 it did. | ||
|
Zack1900
United States211 Posts
It might also be a good Idea to revel the opponent when they no longer have any units that can do damage. So if I have a supply depot and a raven with Hunter seeker missile(HSM) and you have a turret and a banshee. Neither of us are reveled. Lets say I screw up and fly into your turret, and louse my raven. Now I can't attack so I am reveled. If you had lost your banshee to my HSM then neither of us can attack (assuming HSM doesn't hurt buildings) so we will both be revealed. (This is where a draw should kick in, but that's for another thread) If a scv were to fall from the sky for you and build a CC then start mining at the end of 3 minutes of mining I would be reviled. In either of games posted above the neither player would not have been revealed.In a team game these rules should be applied across the entire team. If you do come back and build a main building your opponent shouldn't see anything to let him know it happened. Your revealed building would still be one the mini map, but they wouldn't know be able to tell that you had a new main. While not perfect (you can't set up defenses before you commit to the expansion) it would likely never affect a game. | ||
|
TwilightStar
United States649 Posts
On April 13 2010 02:42 Alexc26 wrote: Many people will still stay in the game even though they have GGed and they know they have lost, they just like to be awkward and stay in the game till you have destroyed every single thing of theirs. I do agree that it is annoying when someone lingers in a lost game, however the solution they've implemented can totally ruin a legitimate game... I'd much rather look around for a floating barracks every other game than have the "is being revealed" thing kept around. It completely ruins elim races, which are EXTREMELY exciting to watch. People rely on sacrifices to win games, and this can ruin it. I hope blizzard makes the right choice and removes this before SC2 launch, this is StarCraft not WarCraft! | ||
|
Ideas
United States8055 Posts
On April 13 2010 06:24 Klockan3 wrote: That game was such a waste of 5 minutes, the terran was really worthy of winning that and if the toss did actually win it he would win it all based on luck! A reveal mechanic will make elimination games much fairer, the one with the better army left and with better micro will win instead of the guy finding the other guys hidden pylon first wins. The fun part of elimination races is the actual competition of how long it takes to raze all of the other guys structures and trying to win with a limited amount of units, not looking at them trying to find the other players last structure. But I agree that the current reveal mechanic is sloppily done and should get changed, but a reveal mechanic will be a good addition both for casual and competitive play in my opinion. there's totally something to be said for the strategy of hiding buildings to make sure you can eliminate the other guy first, just like in Savior vs nal_ra | ||
|
dudeman001
United States2412 Posts
| ||
| ||
StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War Dota 2 League of Legends Counter-Strike Heroes of the Storm Other Games Organizations StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War |
|
Sparkling Tuna Cup
WardiTV Invitational
Spirit vs SHIN
Clem vs SKillous
herO vs TBD
TBD vs GuMiho
AI Arena 2025 Tournament
Replay Cast
Clem vs Zoun
Wardi Open
Monday Night Weeklies
PiGosaur Monday
Replay Cast
SOOP
SKillous vs Spirit
Tenacious Turtle Tussle
[ Show More ] |
|
|
EPT
