EPTFirst one will decide which maps are actually playable.
And second one will decide which is the best out of those.
The second vote can be done by the community but the for the first one you have to get some experienced players or so on board.
Map of the month competition - Page 4
| Forum Index > SC2 Maps & Custom Games |
|
MAPPoVe
86 Posts
First one will decide which maps are actually playable. And second one will decide which is the best out of those. The second vote can be done by the community but the for the first one you have to get some experienced players or so on board. | ||
|
Archivian
United Kingdom362 Posts
And Can maps that have already been posted in previous weeks in other threads on the TL site be entered? or a new map not previously posted anywhere on the site. Finally Do we post maps straight to this thread? Depending on the answers, I would be posting about 6 maps, 5 from previous threads and 1 that I am currently making for the competition. If the average map maker does the same, the first month competition might be flooded, less so in subsiquent months. | ||
|
Samro225am
Germany982 Posts
On November 19 2010 22:44 MAPPoVe wrote: Well I think there needs to be two votings. First one will decide which maps are actually playable. And second one will decide which is the best out of those. The second vote can be done by the community but the for the first one you have to get some experienced players or so on board. you cannot give such a workload to 'the judges'. nobody is interested in checking if something is playable... On November 20 2010 01:15 Archivian wrote: Is there a limit to how many can be sent in per person yet? And Can maps that have already been posted in previous weeks in other threads on the TL site be entered? or a new map not previously posted anywhere on the site. Finally Do we post maps straight to this thread? Depending on the answers, I would be posting about 6 maps, 5 from previous threads and 1 that I am currently making for the competition. If the average map maker does the same, the first month competition might be flooded, less so in subsiquent months. did you even bother to read more than the thread's title? | ||
|
Cyber_Cheese
Australia3615 Posts
On November 20 2010 02:17 Samro225am wrote: you cannot give such a workload to 'the judges'. nobody is interested in checking if something is playable... did you even bother to read more than the thread's title? moreover; quit bragging and FLOOD THE DAMN THREAD its more than about time it got one decent map :/ | ||
|
prodiG
Canada2016 Posts
On November 20 2010 07:26 Cyber_Cheese wrote: moreover; quit bragging and FLOOD THE DAMN THREAD its more than about time it got one decent map :/ Rules need to be decided before anything happens. As soon as one person posts a map, everyone will post maps and nobody will know wtf the plan is. | ||
|
EffectS
Belgium795 Posts
Looking forward to the maps and perhaps participating. | ||
|
WniO
United States2706 Posts
| ||
|
Imperfect1987
United States558 Posts
| ||
|
iGrok
United States5142 Posts
On November 21 2010 08:00 WniO wrote: got a sick map almost done. probably post it in a few days. btw has anyone figured out how voting should be done and should we just have another thread for the official list of maps entered? All I can say is, start working on maps and be patient (at least another week). Awesome things to come :D | ||
|
elkram
United States221 Posts
On November 21 2010 15:16 iGrok wrote: All I can say is, start working on maps and be patient (at least another week). Awesome things to come :D So does that mean we got awesomeness in terms of how we decide a winner, or what? This is a very intriguing post, can you explain somewhat? Or at least give a date? Did you and the OP collab and shit and make awesomeness? Or are you just talking about your own map? | ||
|
WniO
United States2706 Posts
On November 21 2010 15:16 iGrok wrote: All I can say is, start working on maps and be patient (at least another week). Awesome things to come :D dude its gonna be sick i just have to wait till the third of december to put it online... so ive been trickin out on the details. this thread isnt as popular as i thought it would be  anyone else been working on any maps? | ||
|
Randomaccount#77123
United States5003 Posts
| ||
|
G_Wen
Canada525 Posts
On November 27 2010 00:26 WniO wrote: Yes. Now go stir up some publicity in the general forums.dude its gonna be sick i just have to wait till the third of december to put it online... so ive been trickin out on the details. this thread isnt as popular as i thought it would be anyone else been working on any maps? | ||
|
Pax
United States175 Posts
To that end as well, it'd probably be helpful if you made a case for why this contest would be good for the community. I can think of several reasons myself, but I am tired and would rather see what you guys come up with. | ||
|
Nightmarjoo
United States3360 Posts
| ||
|
iGrok
United States5142 Posts
Myself and a few others have been working to make a huge map competition. As previously stated, it'll be announced "soon". Early december. The reason for the delay is simple: polish. We want this to be huge, great, and long-term. That takes weeks of planning. I promise you that it'll be worth the wait. In the meantime, go ahead and keep publishing maps. You'll be given ample time to create new ones once it starts. If you've got specific questions, pm me! I'm said when my inbox is empty  | ||
|
Jiiks
Finland487 Posts
![[image loading]](http://oi52.tinypic.com/2q9a0w0.jpg) | ||
|
Cyber_Cheese
Australia3615 Posts
On November 27 2010 21:24 Jiiks wrote: Boring day =/ added to op and credited you hmmm was going to wait for entries before deciding how this was judged, but theres still none so... anyone wishing to take part in the judging pm me with credentials, admins/pros will be auto accepted, others should include a section on why i should choose them should i allow people who enter a map to take part, such that they cant vote for their own map? that way its an extra judge w/ map making background | ||
|
forelmashi
421 Posts
Death Mountain by BoX & strOut: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=173363 we are having issues publishing to other servers atm we took elements from bw maps which bw players should immediately recognize but I think this counts as an original map?  | ||
|
Gofarman
Canada648 Posts
Also, is the voting going to be a 1v1 bracket set-up or a certain number of votes per contest etc. etc. I would also recommend that you make a rule that a map may not be submitted 2 contests in a row (although every second one is fine) so that you see some variation, as well to that end I would think there should be a 2 or 3 limit per account since we don't want to flood it at the start and the map-makers will be forced to pick their best maps. I would also support some show-matches on the winning map to be played by some pros/semi-pros if it could be arranged. (I would hope for each match-up but that might be hard to arrange) | ||
| ||
