|
On November 27 2009 22:10 SuperArc wrote:Show nested quote +On November 27 2009 21:59 pripple wrote: can't imagine Stork being more skilled than JD, maybe it's my fanboyism getting in the way of seeing things objectively. he isn't, JD will soon have more golds than Stork has silvers :p
According to TLPD, Jaedong currently already has 8 golds to Stork's 7 silvers... of course those aren't all "major" leagues but still.
|
On November 28 2009 00:23 Musoeun wrote:Show nested quote +On November 27 2009 22:10 SuperArc wrote:On November 27 2009 21:59 pripple wrote: can't imagine Stork being more skilled than JD, maybe it's my fanboyism getting in the way of seeing things objectively. he isn't, JD will soon have more golds than Stork has silvers :p According to TLPD, Jaedong currently already has 8 golds to Stork's 7 silvers... of course those aren't all "major" leagues but still.
Jaedong has more major league golds than Stork has major league silvers, too...
Gold GSL1 > Silver GSI Gold 3 OSL/1 MSL/(1 WCG) >= Silver 1 MSL/2 OSL/(2 WCG)
|
Doesn't matter if jaedong has more major league golds than stork has in silver.
PR is more of like how well players are doing currently than how they did before, or else nada would be #1 every single time with like 6 golds and like gazillion silver. flash #1 stork #2 JD #3
|
im a rabid bisu fanboy and even i think he doesnt deserve top5 this month so sad
|
On November 28 2009 02:43 Djabanete wrote:Show nested quote +On November 28 2009 00:23 Musoeun wrote:On November 27 2009 22:10 SuperArc wrote:On November 27 2009 21:59 pripple wrote: can't imagine Stork being more skilled than JD, maybe it's my fanboyism getting in the way of seeing things objectively. he isn't, JD will soon have more golds than Stork has silvers :p According to TLPD, Jaedong currently already has 8 golds to Stork's 7 silvers... of course those aren't all "major" leagues but still. Jaedong has more major league golds than Stork has major league silvers, too... Gold GSL1 > Silver GSI Gold 3 OSL/1 MSL/(1 WCG) >= Silver 2 MSL/1 OSL/(2 WCG)
Stork has 2 OSL silvers (Vs Flash at Bacchus and Jaedong at Ever 07) and one MSL silver (vs Bisu at GomTV season 2 MSL). >:[
|
I have absolutely no intention of arguing that Stork is a better SC player than JD if we look at the big picture (the only one able to put up a fight in such a discussion would be Flash IMO). But I do indeed think Stork has looked hotter recently.
|
On November 28 2009 03:46 TwoToneTerran wrote:Show nested quote +On November 28 2009 02:43 Djabanete wrote:On November 28 2009 00:23 Musoeun wrote:On November 27 2009 22:10 SuperArc wrote:On November 27 2009 21:59 pripple wrote: can't imagine Stork being more skilled than JD, maybe it's my fanboyism getting in the way of seeing things objectively. he isn't, JD will soon have more golds than Stork has silvers :p According to TLPD, Jaedong currently already has 8 golds to Stork's 7 silvers... of course those aren't all "major" leagues but still. Jaedong has more major league golds than Stork has major league silvers, too... Gold GSL1 > Silver GSI Gold 3 OSL/1 MSL/(1 WCG) >= Silver 2 MSL/1 OSL/(2 WCG) Stork has 2 OSL Golds (Vs Flash at Bacchus and Jaedong at Ever 07) and one MSL silver (vs Bisu at GomTV season 2 MSL). >:[
I assume you mean 2 OSL silvers, and yeah, I goofed.
And in response to someone else, I wasn't trying to use medal count as an argument applicable to the PR. I was just responding to an off-topic train of thought and I'll shut up now.
|
Stork and Flash should take some combination of 1 and 2. if it were up to me, I would put Stork at number one. Flash's TvP is great but questionable to some extent, while Stork looks incredible in all 3 matchups.
|
I'd like to see Movie somewhere in the ranks.
Top should be like... Either Stork or Flash, then Jaedong. I don't think Bisu should move up or down, so I'm not sure why people think he should go down. I mean, he lost to Shine, but him losing to Shine was the reason he dropped to #5 in the first place. Other than that, he has only lost 1 game since, so I don't see any reason to drop him further.
|
It's hard to make a theoretical "How would Flash fare against Jaedong?" scenario when Flash just rolls over every Zerg he plays against in under 10 minutes.
|
On November 28 2009 14:29 Hinanawi wrote: It's hard to make a theoretical "How would Flash fare against Jaedong?" scenario when Flash just rolls over every Zerg he plays against in under 10 minutes. True. Stop being so fucking good, Flash. In a way it's disappointing that he's raping so hard, I would love to see him in a longer TvZ.
|
On November 28 2009 11:07 DoctorHelvetica wrote: Stork and Flash should take some combination of 1 and 2. if it were up to me, I would put Stork at number one. Flash's TvP is great but questionable to some extent, while Stork looks incredible in all 3 matchups.
I'm sure they will just wait until the 2nd so it can be settled in the clearest way possible.
|
On November 28 2009 14:29 Hinanawi wrote: It's hard to make a theoretical "How would Flash fare against Jaedong?" scenario when Flash just rolls over every Zerg he plays against in under 10 minutes.
+ Show Spoiler [KT vs hite spoiler] +So true --- I was looking forward to Flash vs Yarnc and the whole thing was over in the blink of an eye. The kid's really going back to his roots.
|
last season, he just kept on getting raped by 2 hatch builds, and now, he rolls 2 hatch builds
|
Flash 15-1 since the start of the new season :D Edit: Also now ahead of JD in ELO Peak and 2 points away from surpassing Bisu
|
If he manages to revamp his TvP he will be truly unstoppable. That's why I am really looking to his game vs Stork. Too bad it is on Heartbreak Ridge which is really gay map for TvP...
|
Ehem, I would like to propose that Calm be lowered for next month's PR. Thank you.
|
On November 28 2009 15:37 Avidkeystamper wrote: Ehem, I would like to propose that Calm be lowered for next month's PR. Thank you. Fuck yeah. That last game against Fantasy was extremely horrible.
|
On November 28 2009 11:07 DoctorHelvetica wrote: Stork and Flash should take some combination of 1 and 2. if it were up to me, I would put Stork at number one. Flash's TvP is great but questionable to some extent, while Stork looks incredible in all 3 matchups.
The only reason I would mind Stork being #1 on the PR is that Stork can only be #1 once. He was #1 in WCG once, #1 in OSL once, and #1 in PR once!
WE CAN'T HAVE IT AGAIN
He can be second plenty of times though!
|
yeah stork should never be above #2, it's the rulez
|
|
|
|