I just realized that we would now be able to direct the actions of all the Detectives. Of course this is only the case if I am actually a Detective and the person who role claimed to me is actually a Detective.

So we can refer to the three of us as:

semioldguy, DT who claimed to semioldguy, and other DT not claimed to semioldguy.

semioldguy

United States7488 Posts

March 21 2009 20:34 GMT

#933

Yeah.... the town being able to direct the action of all the Detectives to make sure they don't overlap and such will also be a huge help for our double lynch tomorrow assuming that passes since not only we will have a bunch more clue and behavior analysis, but will will potentially have information from three DT abilities to help us decide.

semioldguy

United States7488 Posts

March 22 2009 07:52 GMT

#1005

The double lynch is NOT auto-passed at this point. People should still vote for it if they want it to pass since with each additional voter it increases the difficulty to pass the double lynch by another one-half of a vote. meaning if 14 people spam voted right now without also voting to double lynch, we would get no double lynch tomorrow since the 21 votes we have now would no longer be equat to half of the voters.

semioldguy

United States7488 Posts

March 23 2009 04:24 GMT

#1031

Who do we want the other two Detectives role-checking/clue checking tonight?

semioldguy

United States7488 Posts

March 23 2009 05:19 GMT

#1038

Also I need a clue from Day One to check for myself.

semioldguy

United States7488 Posts

March 23 2009 10:38 GMT

#1054

@ Pyrrhuloxia
Yeah... I got that PM... but I get a lot of PM's between this game of Mafia, WeMade shirt questions, Fanatsy Starcraft things and other random junk and its hard/time consuming to reply to everything, especially since my reply to that would have been something like "Okay, I'll make a note of that but don't know if I'll use it yet." I did get that message though, pretty much right after you sent it. I still haven't picked a clue to ask about, I'll probably do it in a few hours when I am at work and have some time to look through things with fresh mind.

Those posts were checked and nothing significant was there. I mostly auto check edited posts. To me it shows up kind of like a spoiler tag at the bottom of a post so I just click on it and read it in comparison to the current post. Whenever it has been something different I've posted about it.

semioldguy

United States7488 Posts

March 23 2009 10:40 GMT

#1055

That goes for everyone sending me PM's (I know there are at least one or two others who sent me a PM about this game that I didn't reply to because I didn't really have anything else to add or ask, but your message wasn't ignored)... I don't reply to a lot of things unless I have something significant to add to it or something further to ask about it, but I read everything and take it into account

edit: typos

semioldguy

United States7488 Posts

March 23 2009 18:17 GMT

#1063

I can't find anything to pin that bit onto though

semioldguy

United States7488 Posts

March 23 2009 22:36 GMT

#1076

I think I know who all three Detectives are.

PM'ing the third one now and I'll update in the morning. If there is a Detective out there reading this that I haven't said anything to, then we have a short list of suspects to find a Mafia.

Detectives:
(1) Myself
(2) DT who roleclaimed to me
(3) Role-checked by #2

I'm both astonished and suspicious that it has happened this way. If #3 is Detective, it prettymuch confirms #2's innocence. If #3 is Mafia (or anything not Detective), it basically confirms #2's guilt. If #3 is Godfather we can't be sure about #2 at all.

semioldguy

United States7488 Posts

March 23 2009 22:46 GMT

#1079

This would also be completely ridiculous for me to fabricate (I have no idea how it could successfully be pulled off). Reason being that if there are any Detectives out there thinking to themselves "Hey, I don't fit descriptions #2 or # 3" Then at minimum we have caught at least one Mafia.

semioldguy

United States7488 Posts

March 23 2009 23:10 GMT

#1082

Obviously the worst case scenario here is that if I am guilty, as it could potentially screw over ALL of the town's DT's.

I still think that if there are DT's out there that they should NOT Role claim to me yet regardless. It should become apparent whether this is all true or not before very long.

semioldguy

United States7488 Posts

March 23 2009 23:22 GMT

#1084

Because if we aren't DT's somewhere things are eventually not going to be accurate. I'm not saying they shouldn't out themselves to myself or publically eventually, just not immediately (and not necessarily to me).

Personally, I am very suspicious of all this.

semioldguy

United States7488 Posts

March 23 2009 23:36 GMT

#1087

If I am Mafia (which is a really, really big if) then I see the following as possible scenarios:

(1) I already know the identity of two Detectives, neither of which I should have known about in my opinion. In this case there is only one more Detective out there. Mafia have much less to gain from this as by not revealing this information I can instead try to misguide the two I do know about in my direction of their actions and mafia kills them when they are of no more use. There is little for mafia to gain in this scenario if only one other Detective is out, in my opinion that would not be worth the risk to essentially give myself up for a single Detective.

(2) I completely made everything up. This means there are three Detectives out there (none of which whom I know about). In this situation mafia may stand to gain intel of all three Detectives. There is more to still be gained by mafia from this scenario, which is why if the DT's need to come out, they shouldn't come out to me (though we will have to find someone else to trust... I should also not decide that person)

Neither of these are very likely in my opinion though. I am currently quite suspicious of the other two Detectives.

semioldguy

United States7488 Posts

March 23 2009 23:42 GMT

#1090

I definitely want to hear from others how we should handle this as a town.

semioldguy

United States7488 Posts

March 24 2009 00:07 GMT

#1098

Which is why I posted that none of them should be claiming to me should they happen to exist out there.

semioldguy

United States7488 Posts

March 24 2009 00:09 GMT

#1099

The clue I already sent in to be checked about 30 minutes ago was "He reached out his hand as if to help Chuiu up, Chuiu grabbed his hand with a puzzled look on his face and began to get up."

Which was one of the clues she mentioned.

semioldguy

United States7488 Posts

March 24 2009 00:49 GMT

#1110

On March 24 2009 09:31 malongo wrote:

Show nested quote +

Actually we cant do too much until next day. Medics should be catching hits this night and the rest of the blues should refrain to roleclaim you.

Role-claiming should not happen through me.

semioldguy

United States7488 Posts

March 24 2009 04:21 GMT

#1130

Well... although the Medics didn't stop anyone this night... we did get a successful Vigi hit though.

We have a double lynch today, let's make the most of it.

Detective #3 has role-checked on Scooter and told me that he checkout out as Mafia! I say that is most assuredly one of our two lynches.

Additionally the clue I checked for day one came back with no results. For reference I checked was:

He reached out his hand as if to help Chuiu up, Chuiu grabbed his hand with a puzzled look on his face and began to get up.

semioldguy

United States7488 Posts

March 24 2009 04:32 GMT

#1134

Just a block over Versatile was digging a hole in the ground looking for something.

seems suspicious in conjunction with Day One.

semioldguy

United States7488 Posts

March 24 2009 04:40 GMT

#1139

Camlito
Qatol
BloodyC0bbler
~~Ver~~
Caller
Bockit
~~iNfuNdiBuLuM~~
Ace
MrBabyHands
Versatile
Scaramanga
JL13

That's a list of twelve potential targets, for fun let's call them the The Zodiac Brave.

They seem to be picking off the people on this list with ease. Only Five of the Twelve remain, with two of them being safe for sure the coming night.