Newbie Student Mafia XXX

On September 17 2019 16:26 Blazinghand wrote:
/obs

On September 26 2019 10:24 Fecalfeast wrote:

Lol ok I'll ignore the read on me but why have 2 people said vivax is scummy when he has actually posted more than once? Vivax has a very easy meta to read and by the end of this day or the next he will be an obvious lock read.


I also wonder if I have that pic of me in the bear mask from long ago

On September 26 2019 11:05 Eywa- wrote:
I think I have a winning PoE guys, let me know when you're ready to sheep me.

On September 26 2019 20:20 boxerfred wrote:
I don't think FF's reaction to the mod thingy was being offended.

It felt more like an official "bro, stop right there, this kind of shade is not part of the game" kind of statement. Given that you're the one throwing the shade, Vivax, that "offended" interpretation of yours doesn't make it better.

I mean, you set it up earlier with the pinoccio joke. Now you say "I never suggested he actually did it" but you actually did - your post strongly implies FF would use his mod powers to determine a smurf's identity which would pretty clearly be cheating.

Does not compute, Vivax goes to the scum pile.

On September 26 2019 21:09 Eywa- wrote:
vote:Branch.AUT

If you guys are really nice, I might even give you his partner before I get night killed.

On September 27 2019 02:53 Eywa- wrote:

It's not a huge distinction, but it is a significant one. Your post makes it seem like I was looking for arguments to justify why he was Mafia, but I'm not doing that at all. He is mafia, I'm telling you, if my track record is not enough to justify that, then I guess I would say... Sounds like you want to lose.

On September 27 2019 02:29 CopCake wrote:
I wouldnt touch Ewya this early tho GB

On September 27 2019 06:43 Eywa- wrote:
I'm a bit nervous because I think my PoE is quite narrow for this stage of the game, but I am eager to flip Branch to see if I'm right.

On September 27 2019 03:39 CopCake wrote:
Because I cant read him correctly and he was right about rayn last game.

And if you poke him he will be like “whatever” because he doesnt care nor engage a convo.

I would say that GB is town.
FF seems town.
Vivax smells mafia.
Shockey smells a little bit as mafia, just a little bit.

I am curious about one thing with you.

And Ewya is null.

On September 27 2019 06:27 CopCake wrote:
Ewya is town in my eyes now btw.

On September 27 2019 13:06 FreezingFoot wrote:
Ok, I've re-read the game and I think Eywa- is right about Branch.

##Unvote
##Vote: Branch.AUT

On September 27 2019 05:06 Vivax wrote:




This is ridiculous? You vote him out of nowhere and complain that hes dismissing you because youre supposedly good at the game.

Why should he think that if youre wrong and hes town? And if hes mafia why shouldnt he dismiss you?
In abstraction, you have delivered a prime example of damned if I do, damned if I dont.

If you dont acknowledge that this is plain BS with a backtrack and a formal apology to the god of logic Im voting you and never unvoting.

On September 27 2019 07:46 Fecalfeast wrote:

Uneasy feelings. I'm on a houseboat lmao


My friends rented a houseboat for 4 days for my bachelor party. I'll have service but lmao. I've not read since the post I quoted

On September 29 2019 01:07 CopCake wrote:
phone posting is shitty, but I don't get why Branch didnt fight when he said he likes his games with discussions.

On September 29 2019 04:24 CopCake wrote:


If this is true then

Ewya is mafia
Boxer mafia
Cake mafia
GB mafia
Tube mafia
FF/Hf mafia

Idk if I am missing someone.

Idk how you can clear Branch as town tho, not gonna deny Ewyas read lacked arguments but to clear someone with that little content...

On September 29 2019 06:32 Holyflare wrote:


because I'm starting to think cop is probably town and so the sum total of your filter is piggy backing shockeyy suspicion on cake and afking while saying you're here to contribute now

On September 29 2019 06:32 Holyflare wrote:


because I'm starting to think cop is probably town and so the sum total of your filter is piggy backing shockeyy suspicion on cake and afking while saying you're here to contribute now

On September 29 2019 06:35 CopCake wrote:


That is not true, I believe shockey is more mafia. That is why I didnt vote you.

On September 29 2019 06:42 Holyflare wrote:


I literally wrote a giant wall of text about it dude. Please read the thread or pretend to have?

On September 29 2019 06:35 CopCake wrote:


That is not true, I believe shockey is more mafia. That is why I didnt vote you.

On September 29 2019 07:10 CopCake wrote:


My first vote was Shockey, changed to try to save Ewya.

Woooooooooooo

On September 29 2019 07:16 Holyflare wrote:


because branch has said shit all

eywa dies and you conveniently say his circular logic points are now valid so you can lynch branch? the fuck do I know what your master plan is?

you use all these points to conveniently do nothing but type in capital letters and say I'm mafia when I've hinted that I can prove I was shot multiple times, essentially trying to get information on what happened to me

you afk and only return to make comments ever since I entered the game

not once have you commented on a single case that I've written this entire game other than one on yourself where you said nothing in response but instead you just ad hom me and say "oh he's playing bad with bad logic" but never explain it

you either became really really bad at this game or are obviously just mafia and I am much more inclined to think the latter

On September 29 2019 19:03 Vivax wrote:
Good thing branch has posted. Bad thing he appeara really salty about being scumread.

Could use a few reads instead of a frothing mouth.

On September 29 2019 13:30 CopCake wrote:


Fair question HF

Let's say GB is mafia

If that is true that would make Brach town, correct?

I mean look at the times of the votes.

It was a tie between Brach and Ewya



Why wouldn't mafia save his mafia partner?

I mean, he has thrown his mafia partner to the lynch pile before so he gets towncred, but it is stupid to do it here, at least now considering how many players we have and more importantly, how we are playing.

If I was mafia GB I would have just stuck my vote on Ewya since "town" read her as mafia. If he didn't care who he voted for because he is mafia then that makes Branch also town.

Also it is strange that Branch didnt vote for Ewya to save himself.

On September 29 2019 21:03 Vivax wrote:


I think you are too easy on HF here, what he has done so far isnt outside the range of what tìhe is capable of as scum. Id give him a freepass today and start being inquisitive around tomorrow.

I dont expect that both of the mafia team are high profile players after a night without bloodshed.

Going to take a look at GB but he seemed townie to me so far except for the fact he didnt notice how faulty eywas reasoning was when he voted you. Turning a blind eye there is possibly the only reason he can be mafia to me.

On September 30 2019 00:27 CopCake wrote:
No, I am just saying that “pushing someone to make him talk” is dumb considering the levels of activity.

And I know I am good but I wont share because if by “actions” and “results” is how people will clear themselves I wont give all the scenarios so they pick one. My work is to debunk the actions.

There was a drawing game and my yelling and annoying ass helped.

On September 30 2019 00:51 Tubesock wrote:
I’m here for a little bit.

I don’t think we should kill any of the actives. HF, Cop, GB are likely all town. CopCakes seems to misread nearly everything, just look at what she just said to Vivax concerning me. GB has always said inconsistent things and been a bit wild when he’s town. As HF said, he always thinks he’s mafia.

As this is a 20 page game on D2, I think the odds of mafia being afk and forgetting to submit the nk are not insignificant. And further being such a low activity game, it’s even more likely mafia is lurking. So, why are we trying to kill the actives?

On September 30 2019 12:20 FreezingFoot wrote:
@HF

I didn't realise Eywa didn't really believe in his points. I know he wrote he was mocking cases, but I didn't take it literally. I mean, he was scumreading Branch for reasons outside the game? I didn't see a post where he said that. I scumread him because I kept pushing him and he kept being evasive. I thought he was tunneled and that his tunnel was fake. That's an easy option for mafia IMO. Selecting a player, nitpicking his posts and keep being tunneled. So I thought he was mafia.

The thread wasn't moving on. There wasn't much to work with and he wasn't answering me. He just kept being sarcastic. I thought "Am I actually missing something?". Then I decided to re read the thread. What made me think Branch was mafia was the way he reacted to Eywa every time, and this read got stronger when he actually started posting only when I was pushing him too. It looked like he felt he was in danger and had to defend himself or he would get lynched.

I said that I could see why Eywa could be town because it appeared to me that he truly believed Branch slipped, and his reactions of being overly defensive and discrediting Eywa's ability to play the game was a strong indicative. I could see a townie so certain of his reads that every questioning of his reasons would be stupid.

On September 30 2019 08:22 CopCake wrote:
This quote bothered me a lot.



So I decided to filter you.







You think HF made an excellent work on GB which is your top mafia read but he is not town enough to be on your list.

Yeah, no.

Posts like "which side are you on" are scummy, to me. It only invites people to take sides which you shouldn't if you are town, you look for the truth.

On September 30 2019 12:45 FreezingFoot wrote:
I'm sure we should lynch Branch today. He seems the perfect "newbie mafia" player, and his flip would help a lot to figure out the game.

If anyone other than me, Cop and HF gets lynched today, I can't be really arsed since I didn't read anything really memorable from the other players.

On September 30 2019 15:18 Vivax wrote:
Kill BF

On September 30 2019 08:22 CopCake wrote:
This quote bothered me a lot.



So I decided to filter you.







You think HF made an excellent work on GB which is your top mafia read but he is not town enough to be on your list.

Yeah, no.

Posts like "which side are you on" are scummy, to me. It only invites people to take sides which you shouldn't if you are town, you look for the truth.

On September 30 2019 18:37 Holyflare wrote:
I did read your case cop and I'll get back to it at some point

On September 30 2019 23:09 Holyflare wrote:
And I don't know what you're talking about "somehow piggybacked" if you read my first big catch up post you'd see exactly what I'm talking about. Did you not read it but say you did?

On September 30 2019 23:11 Holyflare wrote:
Just so you know, it's against the rules to talk about your coach in the thread so you're basically confirmed town. Don't waste a vote on me, especially if you like the content I've produced? I don't know who I'm supposed to be yelling at to lynch because I've been pretty vocal about lynching gb until his return.

On September 30 2019 23:20 Holyflare wrote:


ShoCkeyy came up with something on copcake and you essentially said the same post as him when you came back later to apply pressure on copcake. It was good pressure but not original thought.

On September 30 2019 23:21 ShoCkeyy wrote:


How is he confirmed town, we all knew he was getting a coach, he asked for it lol. I would expect mafia to be able to get a coach too, why just town?

On September 30 2019 21:02 Holyflare wrote:
Fuck it.

##unvote
##vote boxerfred

On September 30 2019 23:45 CopCake wrote:


Not at all.

The way I understood it is that his post was bad therefore he got yelled at.

And everyone can fake to have a coach or be a blue eole.

Stuff like this doesnt clear someone.

On October 01 2019 02:29 Tubesock wrote:


Some OMGUS, and how he pretty much only has me as his scumread but hasn’t done anything to push me or figure out my alignment at all. He simply omgus’ Copcake defensively and nothing else. He has t progressed the game forward in any way.

Branch is deliberately being uncooperative.

On October 02 2019 03:24 Holyflare wrote:
I'm still wondering why Branch knew my crumb contents and still tried to vote me off

On October 02 2019 03:25 CopCake wrote:
If he is Jailkeeper he could have blocked GB...

Why assume he is town and not a mafia thay got blocked?

On October 02 2019 03:58 CopCake wrote:


I have to read this several times to get it (the one letter thing)

Still it is strange that TownHF! didnt went and tried to get TS lynched asap but GB, and mafia knows who they targeted (GB) so... they know or assume that HF is either doc/jail

I am playing devils advocate here but as a “newbie”, how did you decipher that?

I believed it was him getting mad at me lol.

On October 02 2019 03:06 Holyflare wrote:
##vote tubesock

:D

what a fucking legend

On October 02 2019 04:25 ShoCkeyy wrote:
I also posted this in my profile section last night since ya know just in case HF died. And this is all entirely based on Cop being town.

On October 02 2019 04:44 Tubesock wrote:
HF what’s the rest of your crumb? And confirm you’re actually tracker/watcher.

On October 02 2019 04:47 Tubesock wrote:


The bit after TSVGB. That’s the only thing Branch seemed to see that I visited GB. Do the other letters mean anything? Are you hardclaiming watcher?

On October 02 2019 06:23 CopCake wrote:


Huh

How is Shockey confirmed town?

Explain to me like a 5 years older

On October 02 2019 06:24 Holyflare wrote:
You should offensively jk tonight of ts is mafia branch.

On October 02 2019 08:18 CopCake wrote:
I still want to know how Shockey is town according to Branch

On October 02 2019 21:16 Vivax wrote:
Sorry guys I'll play later I'm too busy trading. The DAX is about to lose 400 points in 2 days.

On October 02 2019 22:45 CopCake wrote:


Here you claim Shockey is town Branch and Idk how can you clear him????

On October 03 2019 05:49 FreezingFoot wrote:


I'm doing it right now

On October 03 2019 04:16 CopCake wrote:
This game is amazing

Thank you

On October 03 2019 06:22 ShoCkeyy wrote:
I’m not mafia, I got a great theory that proves other people are mafia. I’ll post when I get out of work in three hours

On October 03 2019 06:25 Tubesock wrote:


Probably for Shockeyy to do something towny. So far he’s “uh I’m town yo!”

On October 03 2019 06:28 Tubesock wrote:
Hmm. If Shockeyy and HF were mafia, then I can see Shockeyy not voting to save himself.

On October 03 2019 06:29 Tubesock wrote:


Where did he scum hunt?

On October 03 2019 06:24 CopCake wrote:


A good case why he is town.

Spoiler: no one has given me one.

On October 03 2019 06:39 Tubesock wrote:


Because you can’t because he fucking didn’t.

On October 03 2019 06:42 Tubesock wrote:


Actually you are wrong. She’s done a big case and brought up other points. She is not the 4 year old.

On October 03 2019 06:33 Holyflare wrote:
It's frustrating but yeah

On October 03 2019 22:20 FreezingFoot wrote:
And yes, HF’s track claim makes no sense and he wasted half of a cycle having us voting a guy we thought was confirmed mafia. I had to decide if this would make him Mafia or not.

There are some policies in this game which is “Lynch all liars”, if he was mafia trying to confuse town I would never forgive myself to have let him pass

On October 03 2019 22:12 FreezingFoot wrote:
Well, I’m town. And I thought this was obvious.

Vivax, I clearly scumread HF for OMGUSing and paranoia. I kept getting back from scumreading him because I decided to analyze things rationally. His claim was weird, and to be honest I think he is VT doing it.

Branch, I was scumreading Vivax because as far as I remember of him playing as town, he never was so disconnected from the game. I also believe he doesn’t have hard stances in the game, and I will always vote like this because I don’t truly know anyone’s alignment. Btw, you’re right that you should investigate Tubesock.

I will not fight my lynch, you guys already know who i think we should kill, and you either believe me and vote with me, or don’t and I have nothing else to do.

On October 03 2019 22:34 CopCake wrote:


GB read this plsss the whole post

On October 03 2019 22:32 CopCake wrote:
Like the reason could clear HF is because Branch visited GB.

But HF targeted me...

How did he know someone targeted GB?

:D

On October 03 2019 22:53 CopCake wrote:


Not if he is mafia with Shockey <_<

On October 04 2019 00:07 CopCake wrote:
- sighs -

Yeah because as mafia instead to blend in when I am a townread for almost everyone I would go and ruin my credibility.

On October 04 2019 00:36 CopCake wrote:
Do whatever you want Branch, You had been the best town with your night actions.

Never ask who to lynch like a sheep, make up your own decisions. If you think HF is town then go and solve the gane with him.

On October 04 2019 02:07 Holyflare wrote:
It actually feels like 2 people are playing on her account even because this is a stark difference from her relatively townie rest of the game.

On October 04 2019 02:05 Holyflare wrote:
Cop mafia. Thoughts? Reading her last few posts and shit flinging is really putting the tinfoil into me.

On October 04 2019 02:13 Vivax wrote:








^^^^

rayn

But tbh I don't care if it is.

On October 04 2019 03:04 Holyflare wrote:
I will do my best to sort it out tonight. I don't know if I'll live.

Branch please rng between saving me and offensively jailing someone.

On October 04 2019 04:17 Holyflare wrote:
You literally just said I'm mafia because I had no concrete points on GB but you don't even know what those points were to begin with. I'm mafia because I stopped us talking about reads for half a cycle but you don't even read the reads I post in the latter half of the cycle to know what I'm saying. You don't care about reads, all you did was sit on shockey the entire cycle!!!!

On October 04 2019 22:30 CopCake wrote:


Honest question Branch

How do you know HF’s claim is true?

Mafia knows who is town so it is easy to say “Oh I targeted you and you did nothing”

On October 05 2019 02:15 Holyflare wrote:


Your target of what?

I'll be announcing my track at deadline just in case.

On October 05 2019 02:25 Tubesock wrote:
There’s zero % chance CopCake is mafia.

On October 05 2019 02:25 Holyflare wrote:


About 35% chance.